10 Least Deserving Oscar Winners Ever

Can't get them all right.

By John Cunningham /

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences claims its main objective is to "recognise and uphold excellence in the motion picture arts and sciences, inspire imagination, and connect the world through the medium of motion pictures."

Advertisement

A noble intention that sadly falls through a lot of the time.

Year after year its selection of winners manage to dumbfound viewers, critics and performers alike. Mediocre, often sickly sweet, middlebrow dramas with supposedly inspirational plot points seem to be their favourite form of film. So much so that the term 'Oscar bait' has been prescribed to countless nominees everyone beyond the Academy were bored senseless by.

Another especially frustrating trait of the long-running ceremony is its penchant for snubbing great performers time and time again only to reward them for average work late into their careers. A bizarre habit that does the awards' prestige no favours, it has lead to a variety of questionable winners and unfair losses.

Conspiracies of studio meddling (especially from a certain disgraced, highly infamous producer) run afoot, as do questions of just how independent the voting really is. For all the times the Academy get it right, there's a boatload of questionable statue holders out there making them look like fools.

10. Avatar: Best Cinematography

By the rules of the Academy, a studio can submit a movie for animation nomination provided 75% or more of the film's run time is animated. By that logic, Fox really should've submitted James Cameron's Avatar as an animated feature. The film takes place in a world composed of CGI, where actors use motion-capture technology to become computed generated characters.

Advertisement

With this in mind, the feature's Best Cinematography win is highly debatable. The film's Best Visual Effects win was perfectly justifiable. Cameron spent years developing new filming techniques and cameras to create the film, providing a visual extravaganza unlike anything that had come before it.

The question remains, however, of why it bags cinematography when everything on screen was a digital creation. Nominees such as Inglourious Basterds and The White Ribbon were considerably more deserving of the award. Beautifully filmed in more traditional, less high tech, settings, these films embodied what the category is meant to acknowledge.

First time nominee Mauro Fiore was no doubt overjoyed by his victory. All the same, the film's win ultimately raised the question of what cinematography does and does not entail. A controversial win for a film that really didn't belong in the category to begin with.

9. The Golden Compass: Best Visual Effects

This deeply disappointing adaptation of Phillip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy was likely meant to replicate the success of the Lord of the Rings franchise for New Line Cinema. That might've worked had it not been for the poorly adapted storyline, less-than-stellar acting, anaemic character development and unconvincing special effects.

Advertisement

It is the special effects in particular that prove egregious here, inexplicably bagging an Oscar (and a BAFTA earlier that year) against the more impressive nominees Transformers and Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End. Both runner-ups had far more interesting, fully-realised visual palettes than the victor. The fact that director Chris Weitz considers the special effects as the main strength of his film is more of a testament to how bad everything else.

Rhythm and Hues Studios, Framestore CFC and Cinesite all played a hand in bringing the film's dæmons, bears, airships and icy landscapes to life. The bears in particular have not aged well. Lead creature feature character Iorek Byrnisson looks especially glaring around the live action characters, redeemed only by the fact the great Ian McKellen agreed to voice him.

8. Sandra Bullock: Best Actress

Sandra Bullock's performance as the suburban mum who takes in a homeless teen and sorts his whole life out for him didn't exactly set the world on fire. Based on a true story, the feel-good drama is more akin to a big budget television movie than a major motion picture.

Advertisement

While Bullock does a decent southern accent, there isn't a huge amount of depth to her take on Leigh Anne Tuohy. The performance is exceedingly bland and stereotypical, a criticism that can be applied to the film as a whole also. Bullock herself has admitted as much. Whilst promoting 2013's Gravity at the Toronto International Film Festival, she explained, "I didn't feel worthy of it when I got it, so I feel like, 'Okay, I'm going to spend the rest of my life hopefully earning it."

A household name in Hollywood, Bullock's win felt more like the Academy seizing the chance to award a star for their popularity rather than their performance. Newcomer nominees Carey Mulligan (An Education) and Gabourey Sidibe (Precious) both turned out stronger, more affecting performances. Sadly neither of them had big star name value like Bullock did.

7. Suicide Squad: Best Make-Up

'Academy Award winner Suicide Squad' doesn't sound right and yet, here we are. Defeating A Man Called Ove and Star Trek Beyond, David Ayers' widely panned supervillain flick took on new life as a meme. "Suicide Squad has more Oscars than..." became a widely parroted gag at the expense of more celebrated (yet winless) films, actors and directors out there.

Advertisement

The make-up and hair in Suicide Squad is mostly among the film's stronger points. That being said, it doesn't hold up to the elite level use of prosthetics and appearance-altering goodness served up in Star Trek Beyond. The Joker's hideous tattoos turned Jared Leto into a laughing stock before release time and Killer Croc's head looks unhealthily large for his body. The incandescent colouring of several characters proves especially jarring against the film's muted colours landscape also.

Winners Alessandro Bertolazzi, Giorgio Gregorini and Christopher Nelson let their imaginations run wild for the DC disappointment. While they deserve an A for effort, the results were, at best, mixed with several characters looking more ridiculous than menacing. An odd choice of winner, it means the DCEU beat the MCU to its first Oscar, the first of few victories in its war against the Disney juggernaut.

6. Art Carney: Best Actor

Among the most bizarre upsets in the Best Actor category's history.

Advertisement

Dustin Hoffman, Al Pacino and Jack Nicholson turned in all time great performances in 1974 with Lenny, The Godfather Part II and Chinatown respectively. All 3 were unsurprisingly nominated and then very surprisingly upset by Art Carney's mellow turn in Harry and Tonto. The first time nominee's win was considered a jaw-dropper at the time. Sporting a fresh coat of unconvincing, old timer make-up, Carney portrays an elderly New Yorker enjoying a cross-country road trip with his trusty cat, Tonto.

Carney's performance is pleasant enough but unexciting. The then-55 year old's work is not the kind of game-changing, instantly iconic stuff his competitors were putting out. His win seemed like the Academy wanting to reward him for his popular and versatile work in comedies such as The Honeymooners.

Another key example of the Academy voting for the safe and the middlebrow over the dynamic and exciting, Harry and Tonto is not remembered as a seminal film or performance these days. Unsurprisingly, most of Carney's opponents are, making this win all the more of a head scratcher.

5. Crash: Best Picture

Easily the dirt worst Best Picture winner of the new millennium, 2004's Crash shocked the world when it upset Brokeback Mountain. While Brokeback was the favourite, it's worth noting every other nominee was also a better film than Crash: Capote, Munich and Good Night, and Good Luck were all top notch in their own right.

Advertisement

When asked about his film's inexplicable victory, director Paul Haggis said, "Was it the best film of the year? I don't think so."

A sappy melodrama about how racism is not a good thing, Crash also managed to steal Oscars for its humdrum screenplay and questionable editing.

Crash is by no means an abysmal film, it holds some excellent performances, particularly from Matt Dillion and Terence Howard. It simply was not on the level of its competitors at the time, making its win egregious at best.

In 2015, the Hollywood Reporter polled hundreds of Academy members, asking them to recast their ballots over the years. An interesting study of what winners have (and have not) stood the test of time, Crash was among several Best Picture winners to be switched. With the benefit of hindsight, voters anointed Brokeback Mountain the would've/should've/could've victor.

4. Shakespeare In Love: Best Picture

As if there weren't enough reasons to despise Harvey Weinstein already...

Advertisement

The disgraced producer essentially rigged everything in this humdrum flick's favour. Going up against the masterful Saving Private Ryan, the film appeared to be an unlikely underdog. Despite being nowhere near the level of other nominees that year, it did have a few things running in its favour. Historical dramas centred on famous folks tend to appeal to the Academy, even the lesser quality ones.

Prior to the film's release, Weinstein had a new ending shot that would ensure the film was more appealing to viewers. He also assembled an army of lobbyists to sell the film to voters in a desperate bid to make them vote it over Saving Private Ryan. As if that wasn't enough, he also launched a subtle, but effective, smear campaign against Steven Spielberg's WWII epic.

The film itself isn't anything remotely special. Light and harmless, it offers little interigue or entertainment value and has aged poorly. Considered the worst of the 90s decade's Best Picture winners, its legacy lies in being an example of how to engineer an award winning feature. For this, not only was it undeserving, it made the Academy as a whole look bad in the process, calling the ceremony's prestige into question.

3. Gwyneth Paltrow: Best Actress

Shakespeare in Love strikes again...

Advertisement

Gwyneth Paltrow turned in an unspectacular performance almost as unconvincing as her painful, overly-emotional acceptance speech. The Goop spokesperson benefited greatly from Harvey Weinstein's relentless campaign to make the film an award hog. Portraying Viola de Lesseps, a wealthy fan of Shakespeare's work, Paltrow poses as a male actor and romances the Bard, becoming his all important muse in the process.

Paltrow and Shakespeare-portrayer Joseph Fiennes have passable chemistry and it's all very polite, pleasant viewing but none of it screams award-worthy. Fellow nominee Cate Blanchett turned in an infinitely more rewarding turn as Queen Elizabeth I in the suitably titled, Elizabeth. In fact, all of the runner-ups were more deserving that year with Fernanda Montenegro (Central Station), Meryl Streep (One True Thing) and Emily Watson (Hilary and Jackie) turning in superior performances. In the years since, Paltrow's win has often come under fire as an extension of Weinstein's push to make Shakespeare in Love a much bigger deal than it deserved to be.

A poll hosted by MSN Movies voted Gwyneth Paltrow the least deserving recipient of the Best Actress award in history.

2. Driving Miss Daisy: Best Picture

When asked for his opinion on Bruce Beresford's 1989 stage play adaptation, Spike Lee said "When Driving Miss motherf-----g Daisy won Best Picture, that hurt- no one's talking about Driving Miss Daisy now."

Advertisement

Do the Right Thing, Lee's acclaimed drama centred on racial tensions in a Brooklyn neighbourhood, was among several considerably better films to be snubbed in favour of Driving Miss Daisy.

In a year of hard-hitting, interesting dramas such as Born on the Fourth of July, My Left Foot and Sex, Lies and Videotape, the Academy went for a middlebrow drama with a distastefully rose-tinted view of pre-civil rights movement America. While actors Jessica Tandy and Morgan Freeman do great work, the film itself was clearly not the cream of the crop, something the Academy themselves seemed to think given the director's lack of a nomination.

Throughout the 70s and 80s, the Academy was able to reward challenging, mature films such as The Godfather, The Deer Hunter and Platoon. By 1990, a gradual shift into lighter, feel-good movies with one note moral lessons was becoming apparent. It would continue throughout the decade with Dances of Wolves going over Goodfellas and Forrest Gump beating both Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption.

1. Roberto Benigni: Best Actor

Roberto Benigni ran a ferociously annoying campaign through the 1998-99 awards season, delivering bizarre, hyperactive victory speeches and antics throughout. His chair hopping lunacy at the Oscars was certainly memorable and as ridiculous as the film he was winning for. Life Is Beautiful is a treacly, tawdry hybrid of old-fashioned physical comedy and the horrors of the Holocaust. It's immediately off-putting to see one of the worst acts of bloodshed in human history be mentioned in the same sentence as 'comedy'. The 2 go together about as well as orange juice and toothpaste.

Advertisement

Benigni's clownish flick took Tinseltown by storm for a spell, leaving career best performances from Ian McKellen (Gods and Monsters), Nick Nolte (Affliction) and Edward Norton (American History X) in the rear view mirror. Jim Carrey's exceptional performance in The Truman Show wasn't even nominated.

Benigni's shenanigans at the SAG Awards might've swayed voters who were desperate for entertainment. Wholly unlike any other acceptance speech before or since, Benigni's win was a memorable narrative for that year's awards show and a break from more straight-laced, Hollywood leads thanking the Academy for 3 minutes.

Advertisement