10 Major Problems With Zack Snyder’s Justice League

For every step the Snyder Cut seems to take forward, it takes an extra few backwards.

By James Wilson /

In February last year, Warner Bros announced they had given Zack Snyder $70 million to complete his version of the Justice League film and that it would be releasing on HBO Max. This news stunned many media outlets who had reported that a Snyder Cut of Justice League was highly unlikely, but was very well received by fans and cast members who had been petitioning for the Snyder Cut for years.

Advertisement

After much build up and anticipation, Zack Snyder's Justice League was released on March 18th and has been mostly well received by fans and critics as an improvement of the original film. But now that the Snyder Cut has had its chance to shine, it is time to acknowledge that, despite being perceived as an improvement, the film still has major problems.

There are many smaller issues, like how Snyder decided to cut meaningful moments from the original version in favour of his own additional scenes, but for this list we will be looking at the 10 biggest problems with Zack Synder’s Justice League; concerning issues around plot holes, characters and directorial decisions, while also making comparisons to the original film.

Spoiler warning if you have not seen the Snyder Cut.

10. Too Much Slow Motion And Extended Scenes

In a film where you have multiple characters that can move super fast, it is no surprise that a bit of slow motion is going to be used. But the Snyder Cut has a distractingly large amount of slow motion with the sole purpose of making scenes look cool. IGN even calculated that 10% of the film's 4 hour run time is in slow motion, which is just over 24 minutes.

But what is more egregious than the many instances of unnecessary slow motion are the unnecessary extended and additional scenes.

Advertisement

The multiple interrogation scenes. Steppenwolf’s conversations with Desaad and Darkseid. The weird yodeling from the fish town people, and the after credits scene where Lex breaks out of prison and reveals the identity of Batman to Deathstroke.

All of this, combined with cutting out meaningful character moments between members of the Justice League from the original version, adds to the bloated runtime of the film. It can also be argued that this is an example of Snyder prioritising precious time and resources to create impressive imagery in his own unique style, rather than add anything of meaningful substance to the story or the characters.

9. Cyborg Is Insanely Overpowered

To most viewers it would seem that Cyborg benefited immensely from the Snyder Cut. He got a lot more screen time that focused on his relationship with his father and how he was dealing with his powers. But on closer examination, what seems to be a step in the right direction only creates more problems for the character and his involvement in the film's story.

In a tape recording provided by his father Silas, we learn that Cyborg is connected to all machinery all over the world and that it will all bend without effort to his will. This raises insane ethical and moral questions about his powers, but the film never explores this problem. It should also be concerning that a confused and angry teenager who hates what he has become has access to this power at all times.

Advertisement

But what is more bizarre than Cyborg’s incredible powers is how little he makes use of them. In the final battle, he focuses on plugging into the Mother Boxes instead of using his powers to aid the team against Steppenwolf, like calling in a missle strike or signalling to the military that they could use some support.

8. Cyborg Let His Father Die

As mentioned in the previous entry, Cyborg’s powers, which allow him to be connected to all machinery all over the world, are explained to him and the audience through a tape recording of Silas. Unfortunately, this raises a very serious problem concerning Silas’ sacrifice.

When the reanimation of Superman results in the Mother Box landing near Silas, he takes it to his lab and prepares to fire a laser capable of reaching temperatures of 3.5 million kelvin at the Mother Box in what appears to be an attempt to destroy it. Cyborg then arrives outside the room his father is locked in but can only watch and scream in horror as the laser kills him and leaves the Mother Box unharmed.

Advertisement

The problem with this scene is that Cyborg, being connected to all machinery, does not turn the laser off and save his father. What is worse is that his scream gives away the fact that he knows what the machine can do and still does nothing to prevent it. An argument could be made that he was too panicked or emotional to react, but the fact of the matter is that he had the power to do more and did nothing.

7. Many Scenes Are Added To Tease Potential Sequels and Spin-off Films

Almost all promotional trailers of the Snyder Cut heavily featured new scenes shot specifically for the film. This appeased fans who wanted the Snyder Cut as it helped justify their campaign for the film, while also bolstering claims that it would help bring Snyder’s true vision of the film to life and undo the damage done by Warner Bros and the original version.

But now that the film has been released and audiences can look back on all the new scenes for themselves, it would appear that many of them were just acting as bait for DC fans and being used as a way of trying to garner hype for more Snyder films based on their favourite DC characters.

Advertisement

New elements like the Knightmare dream sequence, Martian Manhunter and Superman’s black suit, combined with hints at another Justice League film, Flash film and Ben Affleck Batman film are all attempts to jangle the keys in front of fans and get them excited for potentially more movies to come in this version of the DCEU.

Much like how fans came together to ask for the Snyder Cut, it seems like these additional scenes are trying to evoke the same support for future films.

6. The Mother Boxes Are Awakened By Superman’s Death

In the original version of Justice League, Superman’s death plunges the whole world into fear, thus awakening the Mother Boxes who call out to Steppenwolf and triggering the events of the film. In the Snyder Cut, there is a different reason for why the Mother Boxes awaken, which brings with it its own problems.

It is revealed that as Superman dies at the hands of Doomsday, he lets out a scream that travels the world and awakens the Mother Boxes. The Justice League concluded that the Mother Boxes must have feared Superman and saw his death as the perfect chance to call to Steppenwolf and conquer Earth.

Advertisement

This raises questions as to how the Mother Boxes knew a Kryptonian on Earth would be a problem against Steppenwolf, how they knew Superman was on Earth in the first place and how they knew he was dead. It also raises questions as to why they never called out to Steppenwolf in the centuries prior to Superman’s arrival on Earth.

So what seems to be a small change in the film actually ends up becoming an unnecessary one that creates more plot holes in the film's story.

5. Cyborg’s Auto-Defence System Triggers The Fight With Superman

This scene is a problem in both versions of the Justice League, but is made worse in the Snyder Cut because it removes some important scenes from the original version.

After reviving Superman, all of the Justice League except Batman follow him to the Superman shrine. But before they can speak with him, Cyborg’s auto-defence identifies Superman as a threat and, against his will, Cyborg fires a rocket at Superman, starting a fight between him and the League.

Advertisement

The problem in both versions is that no member of the League tries to stop Cyborg from attacking Superman or immediately tries to apologise. It is as if the whole purpose of this scene was just to have Superman fight the League no matter what, and Cyborg’s auto-defence was just a means to making that happen.

But at least the original version of Justice League included scenes that introduced Cyborg’s auto-defence as a thing prior to Superman’s revival. In the Snyder Cut, these scenes are removed, meaning that the auto-defence comes out of nowhere and is never brought up again, even when it would have come in handy when Cyborg would later go on to fight Steppenwolf.

4. Atlantans And Amazons Do Not Help In The Fight Against Steppenwolf

One of the main themes both versions of the Justice League tries to push is that people are stronger together. That no matter what the odds are, when the time comes we must put our differences aside and work together to fight a common enemy.

Unfortunately, both versions fail in nailing this theme. This is because both films fail to address why the Atlanteans and the Amazons do not do more to help in the fight against Steppenwolf.

Advertisement

Both civilisations recognise that the Mother Boxes are dangerous relics that could lead to the end of the world and they both uphold their responsibilities to protect them for centuries after Darkseid first came to Earth. But when they lose them, they decide not to send their armies after them. Instead, they both hand the responsibility off to Aquaman and Wonder Woman and remain in hiding from humanity.

This completely goes against the main theme of the film while also not giving a valid reason as to why the Atlanteans and Amazons do not do more to help. It is also confusing as to why neither civilisation decides to contact humanity and warn them about the potential threat.

3. Martian Manhunter Did Nothing For Three Films

Near the end of the Snyder Cut, it is revealed that the Secretary of Defence for the US Government, Calvin Swanwick, is the Martian Manhunter. After Steppenwolf is defeated, Martian Manhunter makes contact with Bruce Wayne and tells him that he was inspired by what he and the League did and is now willing to be more directly involved in defending Earth.

As cool a reference as this must have been for fans of the character and the comics, the inclusion of Martian Manhunter in this way raises major concerns not just in the Snyder Cut, but in other films as well.

Advertisement

The character Calvin Swanwick is introduced for the first time in the Superman origin film, Man of Steel, and also appears in the Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice film. This means that the Martian Manhunter could have helped defend Earth from multiple apocalyptic events, but chose not to.

Instead of helping Superman or the other members of the Justice League fighting General Zod, Doomsday or Steppenwolf, he decided to protect his identity and let them fight by themselves. This makes Martian Manhunter look like a coward and once again goes against the main theme of the film.

2. The Flash Can Reverse Time With Zero Consequences

The Flash gets his big payoff during the final battle against Steppenwolf where in order to save the world he enters the Speed Force, rewinds time, and gets to Cyborg in time to prevent The Unity from happening. The visuals and music during this scene are stunning, but the whole thing breaks the movie and The Flash as a character.

For some reason, The Flash mentions he has a rule against entering the Speed Force but does not explain what it is. It was assumed that it was because doing so can have serious consequences on the timeline or on The Flash himself. However the Snyder Cut has him entering the Speed Force without any consequences whatsoever.

Advertisement

By allowing The Flash to do this with no negative side effects, it means that entering the Speed Force does not cost him anything or prove anything about his character. It just means that The Flash can access a power that destroys all tension and stakes in the film. This problem could be tackled in the upcoming Flash film, but if it is not, then it will fail to address another major hole in Zack Snyder’s Justice League.

1. Darkseid Forgot Where Earth Is

The worst problem of all in Zack Snyder’s Justice League is the fact that Darkseid forgot where Earth was. When Wonder Woman explains to Batman where the Mother Boxes came from and what they are, she tells him of the time Darkseid first came to Earth and was defeated by those defending it.

In this scene we learn that this was the first time Darkseid was beaten in battle, the time when he lost the Mother Boxes and discovered the only place in all of existence where the Anti-Life Equation was; something he has spent centuries looking for. A conversation between Steppenwolf and Desaad even mentions that the story about Darkseid’s defeat is well known by his followers.

Advertisement

It is already hard enough to believe the insane coincidence that all of these important things happened at the same time and on Earth. But what is more insane is that despite all of these things happening, Darkseid and his forces would forget what planet they took place on.

The fact that this happened to what is supposed to be the DC equivalent of Thanos just makes Darkseid’s first major film appearance a complete embarrassment and a waste of such an incredible comic book villain.

Advertisement