10 Massively Underrated War Movie Performances
"Not anxious to die sir, just anxious to matter."
Effortlessly immersing the viewer in the hellish conditions and life-or-death nature of armed conflict, war movies have provided a blank canvas for some of the most evocative and unforgettable performances in the cinematic medium.
Recent years have seen the likes of Hacksaw Ridge, Dunkirk and All Quiet on the Western Front act as award magnets, garnering rave reviews and a litany of accolades for the quality of the performances on display. With such a vast library of material to choose from in this category, however, it is hardly surprising that several exemplary case studies have sneaked under the radar like a stealth fighter trying to evade detection.
From supporting roles that stole the show to lesser-known actors providing a career-defining turn, the following entries somehow found themselves overshadowed by a movie's wider success or were simply lost in the tidal wave of acting credits for that year.
Whatever the reason for their obscurity, these award-worthy portrayals constitute some of the more overlooked war movie performances in film history.
10. Richard Burton As Allen Faulkner - The Wild Geese
Following a group of European mercenaries attempting to save a deposed African president from execution, Andrew V. McLaglen's The Wild Geese divided critical opinion upon the movie's release.
While the 1977 offering's ensemble cast, action sequences and tongue-in-cheek humour received praise, the dated nature of the movie and its depiction of black characters were justifiably lambasted by many reviewers. The fact that it was filmed in South Africa during apartheid didn't help matters either.
Despite this troubling context, The Wild Geese features a notably underrated bow in the form of Richard Burton's Colonel Allen Faulkner. One of the most gifted performers of his generation, the Welshman's natural sense of onscreen authority and slick aura made him the perfect fit for the charismatic leader of the film's rag-tag group of soldiers.
Despite being primarily known for his dramatic roles, the seven-time Academy Award nominee plays off established fellow cast members Roger Moore and Richard Harris with textbook ease, showcasing his versatility as an actor. In a career dominated by his bows in the likes of Cleopatra and Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? - Burton's 1977 foray into war movies remains a diamond in the rough of a performance.
9. Cillian Murphy As Jozef Gabčík - Anthropoid
A taut thriller concerning the true story of the eponymous WWII operation, 2016's "Anthropoid" depicts the assassination of Reinhard Heydrich - a key figure in the Holocaust - at the hands of the Czech resistance.
Highlighting the brutality of the Nazi reprisals that followed, Sean Ellis' picture is led by a pair of established Irish character actors in Jamie Dornan and Cillian Murphy. While Dornan is impressive in his turn as Jan Kubiš, it is the star of Oppenheimer and Peaky Blinders who blows the doors off in this darkly engrossing endeavour.
Taking on the role of Slovak soldier Jozef Gabčík, Murphy brings his charge to life in stunning fashion. Possessing a gaze capable of conveying a thousand emotions at once, the Irishman is one of his generation's most talented performers and he levies all of his gifts in Anthropoid.
In particular, the visual of Murphy before he commits suicide in the film's climactic sequence to avoid capture is indescribably haunting. It's a moment that leaves behind a stunned silence, exemplifying the strengths of Murphy's performance.
8. Burt Lancaster As Paul Labiche - The Train
One of Hollywood's original tough guys with a tender heart, Burt Lancaster is one of the more celebrated names in cinematic history.
As such, it's shocking that one of the four-time Academy Award nominee's finest performances amongst his extensive filmography often goes overlooked - particularly when one considers that the film in question was critically acclaimed at the time of its release.
1964's black-and-white epic The Train follows Lancaster's French resistance member, Paul Labiche. His character is tasked with intercepting a Nazi locomotive carrying stolen art masterpieces back to Germany, finding himself up against Paul Schofield's nefarious Colonel von Waldheim.
In a war film performance for the ages, Lancaster brings astounding depth and legitimacy to his reluctant hero. The Train sees Lancaster make the inspired choice to utilise subtle changes of expression and nuanced body language to convey a vast array of emotions as opposed to lengthy segments of dialogue.
Despite Lancaster's propensity for playing charismatic leads across a variety of genres, The Train undoubtedly remains his most underrated performance.
7. Tom Hardy As Farrier - Dunkirk
It speaks volumes to the ineffable quality of Tom Hardy's performance in Dunkirk that the Venom star has approximately 10 lines of dialogue throughout Christopher Nolan's 2017 war epic, but still turns in a magnificent turn as Farrier, a.k.a. Fortis One.
A Spitfire pilot lending invaluable air support in the skies over the British Channel and Dunkirk, Hardy's aviator manages to efficiently (and superbly) convey a cascade of feelings. Remarkably, he manages to do this despite having his facial features obscured by an oxygen mask for the vast majority of the film.
The segments depicting Farrier in aerial combat are nail-biting, and the climactic moment in which Farrier decides to sacrifice the remainder of his fuel also serves as a notable highlight for this criminally unappreciated role.
Eschewing a safe return home in order to protect the stranded Allied troops, the vast range of emotions as Farrier wrestles with his impossible choice and the subsequent realisation of the consequences of his actions are conveyed with no more than Hardy's eyes. Breathtaking stuff.
6. James Coburn As Rolf Steiner - Cross Of Iron
One of cinema's quintessential tough guys, James Coburn's illustrious career was littered with iconic character roles. Even in light of this fact, it remains a remarkable state of affairs that his turn in the critically acclaimed Cross of Iron retains status as one of his sleeper hits.
Sam Peckinpah's 1977 offering focuses on class conflict within the German ranks during WWII, with Coburn taking on the role of battle-hardened NCO Rolf Steiner. Set amidst the hellish conditions of the Eastern Front, the film sees Steiner find himself at odds with Maximilian Schell's Captain Stransky - a deluded aristocratic officer who desperately aspires to win the Iron Cross.
Sharing electric chemistry with his talented co-stars, Coburn's take on Steiner is one of the American's more complex characters. It's a nuanced role that he throws himself into, utilising an inspired blend of physicality, world-weariness and a reluctant sense of heroism to produce an Oscar-worthy bow against the backdrop of a first-rate war movie.
"Cross of Iron" somehow remains one of Coburn's more obscure roles to this day, further contributing to the underrated nature of his stellar performance.
5. Mark Wahlberg as Marcus Luttrell - Lone Survivor
Depicting the disastrous real-life events of Operation Red Wings, Peter Berg's "Lone Survivor" is decidedly not the most authentic war film out there when it comes to strict historical accuracy. With that said, the movie is still a gripping, visceral ride - due in large part to Mark Wahlberg's take on the titular character, Hospital Corpsman First Class Marcus Luttrell.
The only Navy SEAL from the initial reconnaissance force to make it out of the Afghan mountains alive, Wahlberg's imposing physical presence lends grounded legitimacy to the role of this elite soldier with ease. The Academy Award nominee also demonstrates his dramatic range flawlessly throughout. He's utterly believable as this hard-as-nails marksman when the bullets start flying, but the moments in which his iron exterior cracks to reveal a battered, terrified human being beneath are even more impressive.
Wahlberg's action star credentials marked him as a sure-fire casting success story long before "Lone Survivor" debuted in 2013, but the performance he gives here transcends the aura associated with his usual action roles and then some. Textbook stuff from Marky Mark, it's a crying shame that most critics were more concerned with the film's historical inaccuracies.
4. Lee Marvin As The Sergeant - The Big Red One
It should come as little surprise that Lee Marvin turns in one of the most authentic war movie performances of all time in Samuel Fuller's The Big Red One.
The American served as a Marine scout sniper in the Pacific Theatre during WWII, earning numerous medals for gallantry. He was discharged after being wounded in action during the Battle of Saipan, an engagement that wiped out most of his company.
Long story short, in terms of gritty authenticity and unwavering authority, Fuller - himself having served in the First Infantry Division in World War II - couldn't have hoped for a better actor to play the unnamed Sergeant in his 1980 epic. Marvin is magnificent in his role, somehow providing a restrained take on a character who has literally been sending young men to their deaths since WWI.
The Sergeant is the glue that holds the film's central squad together from the beaches of North Africa to the Falkenau concentration camp. Marvin's charge highlights the fact that true military camaraderie comes around as a result of competence, restraint and a weary resignation to the horrors that soldiers find themselves faced with, as opposed to lengthy speeches about heroism and duty.
3. Mélanie Laurent As Shosanna Dreyfus - Inglorious Basterds
"I have a message for Germany...that you are all going to die tonight. And I want you to look deep into the face of the Jew that is going to do it!"
Quentin Tarantino's Inglorious Basterds saw Christoph Waltz turn in one of the most critically acclaimed performances of the last two decades. With the German-Austrian actor earning the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for his portrayal of SS officer Hans Landa, one of the finest war film bows in recent memory often finds itself overshadowed.
Simply put, Mélanie Laurent is as mesmerising in her role as Shoshanna Dreyfus. A French Jewish cinema owner who saw her entire family executed by Landa when she was eighteen years old, Shoshanna embarks on a campaign of retribution against the "Jew Hunter" and the Nazi regime.
Laurent is utterly believable as a hardened survivor and perpetrator of sadistic vengeance, while simultaneously lending staggering levels of legitimacy to the moments where her mask slips to reveal a traumatised and petrified young woman.
Waltz may have swept the accolades for this offering, but to say that his in-film competition was stiff would be the understatement of the century.
2. Giovanni Ribisi As Irwin Wade - Saving Private Ryan
While the majority of accolades associated with individual performances within Saving Private Ryan are usually bestowed upon leading man Tom Hanks, special praise must be reserved for Giovanni Ribisi's evocative bow as Technician 4th Grade Irwin Wade. A medic who survives the initial landing at Omaha Beach, Wade is responsible for several of the movie's most emotionally charged flashpoints.
The segments in which Ribisi's soldier poignantly reflects on his relationship with his mother or his desperate attempts to rush to a mortally wounded Caparzo never fail to tug on even the most iron of heartstrings. Wade's undisguised trauma underlines in brutal clarity just how far the combatants are from the comforts of home.
That's without even mentioning the medic's demise. Ribisi is so convincing as a dying young man terrified of his own mortality that his death is arguably the most desolating fatality throughout Saving Private Ryan. Considering that 255 men bite the dust onscreen throughout the course of Steven Spielberg's epic war offering - typically in abjectly harrowing fashion - this is quite the morbid accomplishment.
It wouldn't have been possible without the exemplary - and criminally underrated - efforts of Ribisi in a career-highlight performance.
1. Christian Bale As Dieter Dengler - Rescue Dawn
Christian Bale possesses one of the most formidable résumés in modern Hollywood. The lauded actor is particularly recognised for his stunning versatility; Bale utterly throws himself into his roles, undergoing shocking physical transformations for his bows in the likes of The Machinist and Vice.
Bale's notoriously underappreciated bow in 2006's Rescue Dawn stands as a cinematic testament to this state of affairs. Taking on the role of real-life Vietnam War POW Dieter Dengler, Bale's dedication to his craft within Werner Herzog's offering is breathtaking.
Losing a significant amount of weight to lend authenticity to his portrayal of the emaciated Dengler, Bale produces a raw and emotionally charged performance of the highest calibre. The star of The Dark Knight trilogy is shockingly convincing, imbuing his charge with mesmerising realism whether he is in the darkest pit of despair or demonstrating the resilience that ultimately led to his escape.
Despite receiving widespread acclaim, Rescue Dawn was a box-office bomb. Bale's stunning performance was somehow completely overlooked by the critics, failing to garner a single major accolade during an awards season dominated by entries such as The Departed and Pan's Labyrinth.