10 Mistakes Marvel Need To Avoid With Black Widow
It's been a long wait... don't mess it up!
The comic book movie-loving Internet has been all a-buzz recently about the long-rumored yet unannounced solo outing for Marvel's Black Widow. The fire of speculation has been stoked first by fans, then by Kevin Feige's semi-confirmation that it's on the way, and then by ScarJo's enthusiasm in recent interviews.
While Marvelites may well have spectacularly jumped the gun (there's no definitive proof it's gone beyond the consideration stages), it once again highlights how much eagerness exists to see Natasha Romanoff headline her own adventure. For Marvel, they should do it just to get the monkey off their back.
Despite being a second-tier Avenger in many eyes, there are a lot of possibilities with a Black Widow solo movie. She is such a complex character with so much rich history and her own adventure would give Marvel the opportunity to change things up a little. However, if the project is mishandled, the results could be a total disaster and make fans wish she stuck to the team-up movies.
With all the excitement, it's a perfect time to look at the big mistakes Marvel must avoid in order to make a great Black Widow film.
9. The Origin Story
The Mistake: Marvel has struggled with how to handle their origin stories in the past. While they wisely avoided retreading familiar grounds with heroes like Hulk and Spider-Man, with lesser known characters, they've felt the need to go the obvious route. Certain heroes like Doctor Strange certainly benefit from this approach, but giving us Black Widow: The Early Years would be a waste of a solo film.
That's not to say that Widow doesn't have an interesting origin; she has perhaps the darkest past of any Marvel hero with plenty of rich material to delve into. The problem is that we've been fed so much of her backstory over the course of her film appearances that giving a more in-depth telling of it would ultimately be redundant.
The Solution: There are still plenty of secrets about Natasha's past, but the best way to explore it would be with a new story. With The Avengers disbanded, have Natasha go rogue and return to her homeland of Russia on a personal mission to unpick more of the Winter Soldier story (since it's so close to her own).
There we could learn more about the Black Widow Program and the friends and enemies she left behind.
8. The Romance
The Mistake: After all the success the MCU has had, there is still one aspect of their movies that they often stumble on; the romantic subplot. There have been times where the romance has worked of course: Tony and Pepper have great back-and-forth and Steve's relationship with Peggy was genuinely touching.
It's just that there are also times where the romance feels tacked on (Ant-Man) or completely unconvincing (Thor).
Maybe worst of all, Black Widow herself was thrown into a pointless and, frankly, insulting romance with Bruce Banner in Avengers: Age of Ultron, so there very real concern they could make the same mistake twice.
The Solution: The truth is, not every summer action blockbuster needs to throw in a romance storyline, you just need a compelling and believable relationship at the core. While Starlord and Gamora do some flirting in Guardians Of The Galaxy, at the centre it was about misfits finding each other.
Captain America: The Winter Solider had maybe the most effective relationship at its centre and it was about two old friends. (No matter how much the Internet insisted they were more).
Give Black Widow a real relationship that we care about, but avoid the lazy and overused love interest. Go an unexpected route and have her attempting to save a young girl from the same Black Widow program that ruined her life.
7. The Scale
The mistake: Marvel is known for their big expensive tent-pole films, but as their success continues they seem to think each movie needs to be bigger than the other. But while a massive budget makes sense for The Avengers, or even Captain America films, not every entry into the universe needs to cost $200 million.
The big, globe-trotting spectacles are fun but there's a sense that audiences are looking for something fresh. The giant blockbusters can get tiresome and if Marvel doesn't recognize that they can give us movies of varying sizes than they will likely burn out.
The Solution: Black Widow is the perfect hero to explore through a smaller scale, personal story. Sure, we want some big set pieces but there's no need to through bags of money at the production.
And with a more sensible budget, it could give Marvel a little more faith in the project. The sad reality is that Hollywood believes that female-led films can't find a wide audience (despite a lot of examples to the contrary).
If Marvel has similar concerns, going with a smaller budget could ease them and get this thing into production.
6. The Villain
The Mistake: Even the most die hard "Marvel Zombies" will admit, the MCU has an issue when it comes to their villains.
We can all point at Loki as a paramount, but after that it gets harder to name a memorable and effective bad guy. Too many of these antagonists are just mirrored versions of our heroes and mere plot obstacles rather than real threats. Going forward, Marvel really needs to focus on giving audiences well-rounded villains with clear motivations.
The Solution: One way to achieve this is make the battle personal. Captain America: Civil War proved a film can be extremely compelling when its centred around a personal conflict. This is the approach the Black Widow film should take as well.
By sending Natasha back to Russia, it only makes sense that she would find herself facing off with people from her past. In the comics, Black Widow was often partnered with a fellow KGB agent, Boris Turgenev aka Crimson Dynamo.
Such a character would make a perfect villain for the film; rather than a madman aiming for world domination, apatriotic solider who feels betrayed by a former ally. To make things even better, cast Game of Thrones' Kristofer Hivju as Turgenev.
5. The Team-Ups
The Mistake: Marvel's roster is packed with so many likeable and established characters that they can pretty much throw anyone of them into any movie they like. That's sort of a good and bad thing.
While the overblown cast worked surprisingly well in Captain America: Civil War, there's danger of Marvel relying too much on team-ups and cameos. Already Hulk will join Thor in his third film, Tony Stark will show up in Spider-Man. and Bucky might feature into Black Panther.
Pretty soon solo movies won't be a thing.
The Solution: Leave the rest of the team at home. Have the courage to let one of your heroes stand on their own without an A-lister to add some name recognition.
This movie needs to be small and contained with personal stakes at the centre. As badass as Black Widow is, she wouldn't be the first one Nick Fury calls to save the world so this needs to be something that only she can handle.
Plus, no one is screaming for more Hawkeye.
4. The Action
The Mistake: Marvel does enjoy there big set-pieces and audiences tend to eat them up as well. They have an great talent for delivering energetic and fun action sequences, perhaps most successfully done with the airport brawl in Captain America: Civil War.
However, the studio has also added to the problematic trend of mass destruction in modern superhero films. It's hard to enjoy these light popcorn films when you consider how many innocent bystanders are killed in these massive battles.
Aside from that, watching heroes face-off against hordes of faceless of enemies is getting tiresome.
The Solution: Despite the fact that she doesn't fly or shoot laser-beams, Black Widow as a character offers the opportunity for some great action scenes. Her style of fighting is so kinetic and thrilling to watch it that you don't need to see skyscraper getting demolished.
Stick to what makes sense for the character. You can still have action set-pieces, but keep them grounded like shootouts and car chases. And above all, give us some great hand-to-hand combat.
Instead of having the climax involve a beam of energy shooting up in the sky, have Black Widow and Crimson Dynamo throw down with a brutal fight scene.
3. The Gender Issue
The Mistake: On an episode of Saturday Night Live that Scarlett Johansson, there was a skit that made light of the fact that Marvel might not know how to make a female superhero movie. The joke was that they made their Black Widow film into a typical rom-com you might see Katherine Heigl in.
While it's obviously a comedic take, there's probably some unfortunate truth to it.
Marvel have several female heroes on their roster now and Captain Marvel will mark their long journey to bringing a solo female outing. But they are still guilty of handling their female characters in the same cliched ways most studio action film.
They are love interests/damsels in distress who serve as motivations for the heroes. And while Black Widow is a strong character, Age of Ultron showed us even she isn't immune.
The Solution: Does this film need a female director to work? Or course not. Would a female director help to ensure a the character is handled with respect and not made into a stereotype? Most likely yes.
Find someone who will focus on character while giving us a well-rounded female protagonist. Susanne Bier, coming off the fantastic The Night Manager miniseries, would be a great fit for the material.
2. The Formula
The Mistake: Despite being the pinnacle of modern superhero movies, the MCU is not above certain criticisms. Chief among those criticisms is that there films tend to be a bit formulaic, which continues to be a problem based on early reactions to Doctor Strange.
Going into a Marvel film, you can pretty much guarantee there will be a likable hero, a straightforward plot, a mysterious MacGuffin, a light tone, a lot of quips, a bland villain and a happy ending.
It's hard to blame them really, they've found something that works and are hesitant to change things up too much. But playing it safe can only work for so long and audiences WILL tire.
The Solution: Take some risks with this one. We've mentioned the need to create a different kind of Marvel villain and there are a few other ways to break the mould with this film.
Go for a darker feel to things. This should have the bleak and tense feel of a Cold War thriller so there doesn't need to be constant jokes or a comic relief character. Give the plot a few twists and ditch the MacGuffin for the more personal approach.
1. The Stakes
The Mistake: Marvel movies are beginning to seem a bit cowardice recently. We're into Phase 3 of these films and despite plenty of opportunity, they have yet to kill off one of their main heroes. Sure, Quicksilver and Coulson bit the dust, but those seemed more like cop outs than anything.
No doubt it's hard to get rid of a cash cow but the every time these heroes are able to walk away from world-ending situation without any casualties, it gives the sense that there are no real stakes to the whole thing.
The Solution: Kill off Black Widow.
It may seem like a cruel joke to finally give the character her own film only to kill her off, but there is no better time. As fun as this character is, there is scarcely any room in this universe for a non-super-powered person. Thee threats are becoming too big and there are too many other more qualified heroes to take up the fight.
Really, what is she going to do against Thanos anyway?
Instead of making her the death used to rally the team together, give her a quieter, cathartic death. Let her die on her last mission, putting an end to the Black Widow program and saving a young girl from the horrors she herself faced. A fitting end to a character that truly deserves one.
Would you be keen to see a Black Widow movie? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.