10 More Films Hollywood Needs To Apologize For
If Joel Schumacher can apologize for Batman & Robin, anything's possible.
When Variety caught up with Joel Schumacher at the Hamptons Film Festival, the filmmaker was surprisingly candid about Batman & Robin. It’s not every director who celebrates a picture’s 20th anniversary by admitting that it was a sequel too far.
“I never did a sequel to any of my movies and sequels are only made for one reason: to make more money and sell more toys,” Schumacher said. “I did my job. But I never got my ass in the seat right.”
Released to theaters exactly two years after Batman Forever (with George Clooney as an eleventh hour replacement for Val Kilmer), Batman & Robin was described by The Austin Chronicle as “a limp, excruciatingly shallow knock off that leaves viewers cringing at the one-liners that make up the better part of the script.” Schumacher accepts the majority of the blame for the movie.
“I could have said, ‘I’m not going to do it’,” he says. “I just hope whenever I see a list of the worst movies ever made, we’re not on it. I didn’t do a good job. George did. Chris did. Uma is brilliant in it. Arnold is Arnold.”
Schumacher’s candour is refreshing, especially in the summer of Baywatch and Transformers: The Last Knight. Should his honesty inspire his colleagues to follow his example, there are several films for which an apology is long overdue.
10. Resident Evil: Apocalypse
After staging action sequences for XXX, Daredevil and Casino Royale, second unit director Alexander Witt made his helming debut with this sequel to 2002’s Resident Evil, and you can see why he never returned for the sequel
Apocalypse is slickly shot, well-staged and loaded with slam-bang set pieces, but Paul WS Anderson’s script is strictly on the level of a Saturday morning cartoon, with “cool” characters who spin their guns before holstering them or jump from a helicopter firing two weapons simultaneously if they’re really slick.
In other words, the kind of over-the-top shenanigans Robert Rodriguez serves up with his tongue firmly in his cheek are presented here without irony. When characters start wandering off alone, sneaking up on armed-to-the-teeth colleagues and hiding from zombies in a graveyard you have to wonder if the filmmakers set out to make a spoof of the first film with all the humour taken out.
9. Spice World
Bands like Rage Against The Machine, The Stone Roses and Cypress Hill (among others) meant the early 90s were a vibrant time for music fans, but that all came to an end when The Spice Girls released their debut album and ushered in the era of manufactured, crassly commercial pop sensations.
In 1997, they were busy selling their message of “Girl Power” in Spice World, a movie created for them by the men that controlled their careers. Attempting to do for the Fatuous Five what A Hard Days’ Night did for the Fab Four, the film tries to avoid looking like a glorified promotional video by being “hip” and “funny”. The results look suspiciously like what would happen if five Barbie dolls came to life and surrounded themselves with embarrassed looking guest stars.
An inexplicable hit, the movie lowered the bar for pop music, musicals, screen acting and film in general, leaving the door wide open for America’s Got Talent, Justin Bieber and other names on the CIA’s Severe Harsh Interrogation Techniques list.
8. Halloween: Resurrection
The early 2000s were the era of tacky reality television, so it must’ve made sense to the creatively bankrupt producers of this seventh sequel to incorporate it into the plot. The result is one of the dumbest, most unintentionally funny horror films you’ve ever seen.
After explaining how Michael Myers survived being decapitated at the end of Halloween H20 (“Ohmigod, she killed the wrong person!”) and doing away with the only other continuing character (RIP, Laurie), the movie sends Michael back to his childhood home, which is full of reality TV contestants getting high and sneaking off to have sex. Over the next eighty-nine minutes, prepare to see a once-proud horror icon being outsmarted by text-messaging teens, mocked for being mute and fought off by a kung fu fighting rapper.
You’ll hear Donald Pleasance turn over in his grave when Busta Rhymes, whose real name is Trevor Smith, kicks down a door with the zinger, “Trick or treat, Motherf**ker!” But before that he gets to fight Michael with mixed martial arts and before that he becomes the first person to tell Myers to “scoot, skedaddle, get the f**k outta Dodge” and walk away.
Please come back, John Carpenter.
7. Hitman: Agent 47
Once mooted as a possible vehicle for Vin Diesel, Hitman gets an upgrade in this reboot of the 2007 movie. No longer a mere assassin and no longer played by Timothy Olyphant (Homeland’s does a good job of filling his shoes), Agent 47 is now a superhero Jason Bourne who engages in some astonishingly athletic gunplay when he isn’t taking out his opponents with bombs and helicopters.
Coming from the studio and screenwriter that brought you A Good Day To Die Hard, Agent 47 had the odds stacked against it before it even reached theaters but as long as you don’t approach it with the expectations of seeing a good movie you might enjoy it. In a dumb, senseless I-Can’t-Beileve-This-Got-Made kind of way.
When it comes to movies about killers with abnormal speed, intelligence and strength, Wanted did that whole yarn back in 2008 (with a naked Angelina Jolie, no less). Small world dept: Thomas Kretschmann, who played James McAvoy’s father in that film, also appears here as one of the villains. But that’s probably just a coincidence.
6. Planet Of The Apes
If you need convincing that blockbusters in the early 2000s were churned out for an audience of gurgling test subjects, look no further than Tim Burton’s “reimagining” of Planet Of The Apes. Judging by the level of wit and creativity on display here, a “reimagining” means a rushed and pointless film that throws out the original in favor of a third-rate Twilight Zone episode.
The 1968 original is incredibly subversive, with characters arguing that religious dogma (read “creationism”) should not be substituted for scientific fact, but this movie is having none of that. Instead, Mark Wahlberg runs around, there are some special effects, and Charlton Heston turns up to say “damn them all to hell” (as will you).
So incredibly slipshod in its storytelling that neither Burton nor his cast could explain the plot, Apes has the distinction of being the only movie in the franchise where nothing is satisfactorily explained, characters and plot points are introduced and discarded at random and the big ‘reveal’ at the climax still leaves viewers scratching their heads.
Does Ape-raham Lincoln have a monument in his honor because he emancipated the apes? Or did he free the human slaves? If you expect answers from Burton’s DVD commentary, you’ll be disappointed.
5. Independence Day: Resurgence
Say what you like about the original, but that shot of aliens destroying the White House made it a fixture of pop culture. Twenty years later, the most remarkable thing about this belated sequel is how much it looks like every other Roland Emmerich movie.
Following two flops (Anonymous and White House Down) Emmerich’s gone back to his biggest hit and this time it looks like he’s decided to turn it into a franchise, complete with an open-ended finale that sets up the sequel. He needn’t have bothered because even by the standards of the man who remade Godzilla very badly, Resurgence is pretty dour stuff, a coldly calculated Hollywood “product” that gives its audience no joy.
The film’s attitude to its audience is summed up by the introduction of Brent Spiner’s character, who we now learn wasn’t killed off in the original film but in a coma for exactly twenty years. His awakening coincides with a new alien invasion and faster than you can say “contrivance” it’s business as usual, only minus the fun.
4. The Day The Earth Stood Still
If you’re going to remake a classic, don’t give it to the director of Hellraiser: Inferno. Also, don’t cast John Cleese as a boffin, Jaden Smith as Jennifer Connelly’s stepson or Keanu Reeves as an alien named Klaatu. That’s just asking for trouble.
In the 1951 original, Klaatu was a surrogate Christ who adopted the name “Carpenter” before being killed and resurrected. The idea of Keanu playing Christ is good only for a few chuckles but the filmmakers seem to have retained it, hence the sequence where Klaatu appears to be walking on water.
It’s a shame that they didn’t retain the story: gone is the sequence where Klaatu neutralizes the electricity supply across the globe, causing the Earth to (you guessed it) stand still. It’s been replaced with some hogwash about how he must destroy mankind in order to save the planet, but then Connolly convinces him that people aren’t so bad and he reconsiders etc.
3. Lara Croft: Tomb Raider
Now that the dust has settled on Tomb Raider and its flashy effects have lost their lustre, we can appreciate the film for what it is – a Roger Corman movie writ large.
Despite all the money being thrown around, the movie runs barely 100 minutes (with a lengthy end credits sequence) and with the exception of Angelina Jolie, most of the cast look like they’d rather be elsewhere. The writing is flat, the direction is lifeless and overall there’s a certain heaviness to the movie, a feeling of sturm und drang that a big summer movie ought not to have.
Lara Croft is basically a female James Bond who’s placed in peril during her Indiana Jones-style adventures, but instead of providing two hours of no-think escapism, the movie goes about everything in the most convoluted way possible.
Consider the way that Lara’s father (played by Jon Voight, Angelina’s real-life father) is brought into the story: even though the source material doesn’t state that the character is dead, he’s established as such in the movie, so the filmmakers bring him back in the most unbelievable way possible, by having Lara communicate with him during a “crossing” of time and space.
2. Alone In The Dark
The Abkani, a race believed to have developed the ability to move between worlds, inexplicably vanished from the Earth ten thousand years ago. Then in 1969, one Professor Hudgens attempted to breed Abkani creatures with twenty orphans before being shut down by Bureau 713, a government paranormal investigation division.
Fast forward to the present and one of those orphans, Edward Carnby (Christian Slater), a former employee of Bureau 713, is attacked by a seemingly unkillable assailant after coming into possession of an Abkani artefact. The thug is of course under orders from Hudgens, who is preparing to unleash Xenos, Abkani creatures that can only exist in darkness.
Got that?
It doesn’t matter, because this dumpster fire was Uwe Boll’s follow-up to House Of The Dead and while it’s a slicker production, it’s arguably even more jaw droppingly, toe curlingly terrible. Throw in Stephen Dorff doing his best Kiefer Sutherland impression, add a badly miscast Tara Reid and sprinkle with rubbish digital effects and you’ve got a movie that must be seen to be disbelieved.
1. Terminator Genisys
Having learned nothing from Batman & Robin’s critical backlash, Arnold Schwarzenegger returned to the franchise that helped make him one of the biggest action stars in the world. Even after multiple viewings, though, questions persist: were they making a Terminator movie or a 1990s Batman sequel?
Like Batman & Robin, Terminator Genisys is so awkwardly contrived and crassly commercial that it deserves to lampooned as ruthlessly as possible. The plot refuses to make sense, the dialogue lands with a thud every few minutes and the campy approach means it will probably appear on Mystery Science Theater 3000 someday.
There’s so much rich material here: the groan-inducing attempts at humour, the characters who keep explaining their motivation to each other, the shameless attempts at fan service. Then there’s the alternate timeline that causes Kyle Reese to experience a live he never lived, where his younger self keeps repeating “Genisys is Skynet.” Erm, what?
Wading through it all is Arnie, whose metamorphosis into Mr Freeze is now complete: all his character does is make dreadful puns and smirk for the camera.