Barbara Wilson kind of feels like a third wheel. As Alfreds niece, shes an outsider to Wayne Manor and despite Bruce trusting her to an extent, hes not about to immediately divulge all of his secrets. Unfortunately, Bruce has that decision made for him when Alfred nearly dies and passes along all of their Bat-secrets. Gone was the independent Batgirl, operating opposite her oblivious father, Jim Gordon. Shes replaced with a rebellious loner who completely distrusts Bruce Wayne and believes that hes mistreating her uncle. Its infuriating to watch her, knowing the whole time just how wrong she is about everything. This characters on-screen persona was only tainted further by the goings on in real life. The press hounded actress Alicia Silverstone for a perceived weight gain during the film and the controversy and attention led to her part being cut down significantly. This might explain the lack of proper development and a more well-rounded personality. But regardless of the reasons why, the Batgirl we saw did not match the Batgirl we wanted.