Showdowns are a hugely important part of any film. They regularly depict the long-awaited clash between the protagonist and his nemesis to determine who will emerge victorious from their conflict, even though the end result is rarely ever in doubt. This being the case, it's essential to treat the audience to an exciting and gripping confrontation, complete with impressive physical action and enough swings of momentum back and forth to keep the viewer intrigued. The very best showdowns are occasions of high drama and emotion, and are worth many repeat viewings, even out of context of the film itself. But all too often a film spews forth a showdown that is is underwhelming. Maybe it's too short, maybe the special effects are unconvincing, maybe the antagonist isn't permitted a strong enough showing to demonstrate that it's actually a contest. Maybe too the battle fails to live up to expectations or to the legacy of its participating characters. What follows then are ten movie showdowns that rank amongst the most disappointing.
10. Optimus Prime vs. Megatron and other Decepticons
Oh Megatron. How did you go from being the ultimate movie badass in the first Transformers film who could tear Autobots aparts with his bare hands and easily outmatch Optimus Prime to becoming a coward who could barely hold a candle to him in the two sequels? The first film didn't show a great deal of the Decepticons until the very end. Most of them ended up dead but nonetheless caused enough chaos and destruction so as to establish their menacing presence. The sequels however, despite the increasingly grave predicaments that the earth was supposedly in, represented hardly any Deceptions as constituting much of a genuine threat. Let's look at some examples: Revenge of the Fallen started with a gigantic wheeled Decepticon who flattens half of Shanghai before before taken out by.....one shot to the head. Towards the end the similarly mammoth Devastator was introduced, who couldn't even digest the hugely irritating Mudflap and Skids, and then got taken out by.....one shot from a conveniently placed Navy railgun (which then lies forgotten for the rest of the battle). Then in Dark of the Moon Starscream, the only other Decepticon besides Megatron to make it through to the third film, gets taken out by.....Sam Witwicky of all people. Not to be outdone, the imposing new villain Shockwave, accompanied by his giant driller, soon both bite the dust as well, having achieved precisely nothing of significance in the film besides, well, looking flashy. As one army grunt exclaims as the driller tears down the skyscraper in which they've encamped, How come the bad guys get all the cool stuff? Come on, it's not as if all that cool stuff is going to do anything other than look pretty for the cameras. But it's Optimus Prime and his duels with Megatron over the course of the films which particularly bother me. As said, it was pretty clear in the first film that Megatron was the more powerful Transformer. He was only defeated once targeted by the US fighter jets and then when Sam pushed the All-Spark into his exposed chest (hang on, does this mean that technically Sam killed Megatron once as well?). When he was resurrected in RotF with new parts I fully expected to see him just as powerful as before and to represent more than a match for Optimus. True, he does kill Optimus in their first battle but only through the assistance of Starscream (who looses an arm) and a third Decepticon (who ends up getting his face ripped apart) after it's been made perfectly clear he can't take him on on his own. Fast-forward to the film's final battle in the desert, Megatron barks orders that Sam must not be allowed to reach the body of Optimus since he's carrying the matrix of leadership. It's odd that Megatron insists on a full-frontal assault on the Autobots' and soldiers' position when, being able to transform into a tank that also happens to fly, he could easily fly over them and attack from the rear. Anyway, once The Fallen shows up to nick the matrix and step on Optimus Prime a bit, the revived Autobot takes Jetfire's parts to become uber-powered and launch his own assault on Megatron and The Fallen. It's pretty clear that Megatron won't be able to put up much resistance here and accordingly gets half his face blown off. Optimus swiftly turns his attention to The Fallen, who despite having only a minute ago displayed supreme powers of teleportation and telekinesis, surprisingly doesn't think to use these same powers in the showdown, and accordingly finds Optimus' fist rammed right through his chest ten seconds later, after having literally given him his face. Fast forward to the climax of DotM and we're treated to a solid showdown between Optimus and the treacherous Sentinel Prime, who proves the superior fighter, cutting one of Optimus' arms clean off. Preparing to deliver the killer blow, Sentinel suddenly gets attacked from behind by Megatron, who has done almost nothing of note all film but now decides to stand up for himself, claiming that he won't concede leadership of the Decepticons so easily. Having saved Optimus' life and declaring that they need a truce, Optimus decides to let his old foe have it as well, and swiftly proceeds one-armed to rip his head and spine from his body in about 3 seconds, thus surely ending his life once and for all. I know the ethics of Optimus' actions have bothered a number of people; personally I'm just disappointed that the principal recurring villain of the series couldn't be granted a more befitting exit.
9. The Bride vs. Bill (Kill Bill: Vol. 2)
This is a slightly difficult one as the long-awaited confrontation between Uma Thurman and David Carradine at the end of Kill Bill: Vol. 2 is about so much more than just how long and how impressively the pair can go at it with Hanzo swords. It's about The Bride's emotional state as she copes with the shock revelation of her daughter's survival, the brief glimpses of a potential happy family life, and her final conversations with Bill in which they eventually confirm that they cannot be reconciled, that they cannot forgive each other for their past deeds, and that, as Beatrix delicately puts it, they have unfinished business. Baby, you ain't kiddin'. As Tarantino fans would ardently declare, the man can do substance as well as style. I can respect that, but I still think this is a moment where the film would have benefitted from a bit more of that style. The sword duel really is one of those blink and you'll miss it moments, over in a matter of seconds. Don't get me wrong, what is there is very well choreographed and polished as expected, and the final revelation that Pai Mei taught Beatrix the Five Point Palm Exploding Heart Technique is hugely effective, making for an especially iconic exit for the Snake Charmer; I just wish that it had gone on a bit longer beforehand. In fact it almost did. It's hardly a secret that the film's climax was originally written as a sword-fight on a beach under the moonlight, with Beatrix clad in her wedding dress. Bill even suggests such a fight to Beatrix at the beginning of their final conversation, and one of the film's posters also showed Thurman in the dress brandishing her sword. But Tarantino was forced to cut the scene back upon Harvey Weinstein's insistence when the production ran long. It's a shame since we never get to see Bill display much of his skill with the blade, although there is one deleted scene showing the pair in their earlier happy days which goes a small way towards addressing this. Interesting fact however: every person killed on screen over both Kill Bill films, with the exception of those in the anime sequence in Vol. 1, is killed by a female character.
8. Barney Ross vs. Jean Vilain (The Expendables 2)
I'll start off by saying that The Expendables films have a clear target demographic audience for whom they probably work very well, and I'll be the first to admit that they do have a number of eye-catching action set-pieces. One problem I felt with the first film, not that it was the sole one, was the lack of a villain with real screen presence to match those of the Expendables crew, though perhaps with the exception of Stone Cold Steve Austin who I think can be said to have got the better of old Sly in their individual battle of fisticuffs. It's perhaps fitting that the former wrestler (i.e. fake sport) soon gets beaten in turn by the former mixed martial artist (i.e. real sport) in the form of Randy Couture, even if the latter wasn't half as entertaining in his prime. The sequel seemed to correct this issue perfectly through the casting of Jean-Claude Van Damme along with his own band of mercenaries as the principal antagonists. And for much of the film the Muscles from Brussels does an excellent job getting us to hate him, even going so far as kicking a knife into Liam Hemsworth's chest. I mean, he's even called Vilain for god's sake. Action-packed though the film is, the final showdown between Stallone and Van Damme does come off as something of a disappointment. It starts promisingly enough, with VD convincing Sly to drop his guns and confront him in a fistfight. After some intense but brief brawling, VD hits a couple of trademark spinning kicks and chucks Sly over a ledge, only for Stallone to go medieval on him with a length of chain and stab him with his reclaimed knife. Again, it's not terrible, but pretty anticlimactic after the huge build-up to the fight, not just in the course of the film itself but also throughout the film's publicity. Perhaps it was unreasonable to expect too much more from two ageing action-stars, but an underwhelming spectacle nonetheless. There have been far far superior fights committed to film. Who'd still be excited by the prospect of Sly finally taking on Arnie in a potential Expendables 3?
7. Diamonds Are Forever
Bond showdowns can typically be relied upon to deliver exciting action set-pieces, though it's fair to say that some are of superior quality to others. 1971 saw the release of the seventh film in the series, Diamonds Are Forever, the sixth film to star Sean Connery as Bond who, after George Lazenby left the franchise, was tempted back to the role when United Artists offered him a then-record $1.25 million salary. It's perhaps the most disappointing of the Connery Bond films (I don't tend to include the non-Eon Never Say Never Again since it's essentially just a remake of Thunderball and Connery by this point looked far too old to be even remotely plausible in the role), and in keeping with this features one of the dullest showdowns of the entire series. By this point in the film series we'd become very accustomed to seeing Bond infiltrate the villain's lair and then later storm it at the film's climax, increasingly with the assistance of secret service special forces or regular army troops. You Only Live Twice had given us Blofeld's iconic and oft-parodied volcano base in Japan, coupled with invading ninja agents. On Her Majesty's Secret Service had treated us to stunning mountain vistas through Blofeld's research institute atop Piz Gloria in the Swiss Alps, where much of the film's action takes place, and culminates in a gripping bobsleigh chase between Bond and his nemesis. Compared with these two previous showdowns, the finale of Diamonds is anticlimactic to say the least, especially when Blofeld's base of operations is now revealed to be merely an oil rig off the Californian coast, a location that's also been completely absent for the entirety of the film, thus impeding any serious audience investment in it. The film has done relatively little thus far anyway to sustain much interest and it didn't help that Connery, though only 41, hadn't aged at all well during his decade spent as Bond. Coming back after four years' absence he no longer seemed as comfortable in the role and was certainly making far less effort to conceal his Scottish accent. Anyway, Bond gets captured only to promptly escape once the CIA begin a helicopter attack on the rig, but his contribution to the ensuing battle, though vital, is sorely lacking in excitement: Blofeld attempts to escape in what he calls a 'bathosub' and has a crane lower it down to the water. Bond gains control of the crane and crashes the sub into the control room, thus destroying the satellite control and foiling Blofeld's plan yet again, though leaving his fate ambiguous. And that's about it; no intense fistfight, no spectacular stunt, not even that much gunfire. Just sitting in a chair pulling some levers. You'd think Bond had morphed into one of his villains by the way he was behaving.
6. Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End
I still don't know quite what happened to the PotC franchise. The ending of the first film seemed to reaffirm the status quo that the pirates are the bad guys and that the soldiers hunting them down are the good guys. Then when it became clear just how popular Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow was the filmmakers slowly turned this equation on its head to make the pirates, the terror and menace of the seas, into good honest men and the forces of the East India Trading Company, the ones valiantly attempting to police said seas, into the worst thing since the Empire in Star Wars, presumably because they all wear smart uniforms and drink tea. (Ok, I know there's more to it than that, but still...) Anyway, the final showdown, the Battle of Calypso's Maelstrom as it's known in official Pirates lore, turns out to be a disappointment since it promises so much more. Much screen-time is devoted to establishing the alliance of the various pirate lords so that they can present a united front to meet the vast East India armada head on. They really needn't have bothered, since all they needed was the one ship. With two huge fleets ranged against each other and promising a tantalising encounter, it's just The Black Pearl and The Flying Dutchman who advance into battle. After shooting each other up for half an hour the Dutchman eventually gets swallowed up by a whirlpool, only to re-emerge and switch sides. The two ships, which you must imagine have taken quite a pounding from earlier, then flank Cutler Beckett's flagship The Endeavour, fresh into the action and arguably the most imposing ship of the entire franchise, and destroy it with one double broadside. Honestly. And you think how difficult it had been to sink even a smaller ship during the earlier films....Beckett doesn't even bother to fire his own cannons even with his lieutenants urging him so, such apparently is his shock at his business proposition having failed him. The rest of the East India armada swiftly disintegrates, and the pirate fleet raises a huge cheer, having contributed precisely nothing. I'm not saying it wasn't an impressive way to sink a ship; I just wish it had been allowed to do more beforehand and that battle had consisted of more than the activity of just three vessels. I really expected more of the film that stills holds the largest production budget of all time. Maybe they should have spent less time on the CGI that allows all those rocks to turn into crabs. I still find it hard to believe as well that anyone could have conceived that a frantic and storm-lashed naval battle was the best place to stage a wedding ceremony between Will and Elizabeth. I know this is a Disney production and that comic touches are to be expected throughout, but to undermine this serious occasion by such silliness seems to sabotage the sombre and dark tone that had been established for much of the film, especially through an opening sequence that had included child hanging.
5. Neo vs. Smith (The Matrix Revolutions)
Whatever anyone thought about the substance of the two Matrix sequels, it was still hard to deny the general impressiveness of their action set-pieces. In Revolutions I never get tired of seeing the Machines' spectacular assault on Zion and the increasing desperation of the human resistance. It's a battle that gets put on hold however as the combatants are made to await the outcome of the final showdown between Neo and Smith within the Matrix. It's by no means an unimpressive showdown but is quite a disappointing end to their conflict after several excellent fights in the previous two films: the first Matrix gave us their highly-polished wire-fu fight in the subway and culminated in Neo's eventual recognition of his status as 'the one'. Reloaded then exhibited the ludicrous yet still highly-entertaining rooftop fight between Neo and the increasing army of Smiths. After these two varieties the tactic adopted for Revolutions, making Smith into another flying Superman-like entity able to match Neo one-on-one, was certainly a logical choice. The scale of the confrontation is truly epic- quite literally earth-shattering but is excessive to the point of becoming risible, and in that you could include how slow-motion, the series' favourite action scene technique, is now employed in almost every other shot. At times it descends into near-pantomime, such as the shot from below of Smith posing maniacally against the stormy sky as lighting flashes behind him. Neo' super slo-mo punch to Smith's cheek during his brief resurgence near the fight's conclusion is also especially comedic. After all this, perhaps I still don't fully understand the film's ending, but frankly I don't care to.
4. The Avengers
The Avengers is a hugely entertaining film with a great script containing plenty of tongue-in-cheek humour, but I'm not convinced that an awful lot actually happens. Loki threatens Earth though his acquisition of the Tesseract and his alliance with the Chitauri. The Avengers are assembled to combat this threat. They argue, bicker, and squabble for most of the film but eventually put aside their differences. The Chitauri then finally make their long-awaited appearance with half an hour left to go and start causing a nuisance in Manhattan. Their ensuing battle with the united group of superheroes is mightily fun and visually spectacular, yet distinctly more amusing than gripping, since it readily becomes clear that none of the Chitauri forces can hold a candle to any of the Avengers, even the two with no superpowers whatsoever, Black Widow and Hawkeye. The final climax of the battle isn't even about which side will prevail, rather whether or not a nuclear missile will be allowed to hit Manhattan, thus nullifying the Chitauri invasion of Earth at the expense of a single city. The issue is not who will win, but rather the extent of the human casualties in the victory. Ever the ingenious one, Tony Stark intercepts the missile and guides it through the portal toward the remaining Chitauri fleet. The missile destroys the invaders' mothership, conveniently leaving their forces disabled on Earth Phantom Menace-style. So why the disappointment? I think it had something to do with the way the movie was marketed. So much of the promotional material, and the trailers especially, focused on the threat that Loki and the Chitauri posed to the world, with the emphasis on lines such as Tony Stark's If we can't protect the Earth, you can be damn sure we'll avenge it really suggesting that something near-apocalyptic was going to happen onscreen. But we never got that. As said, the Chitauri's presence is established at the very start of the film but then they're largely forgotten about as the majority of the screen-time is devoted to the world's mightiest heroes' in-fighting. Their eventual appearance seems almost an afterthought (even Stark's words echo this), a hastily-tacked-on segment to provide the physical test of the Avengers' newfound teamwork and co-operation, and the fulfilment of the obligatory action-heavy finale. But the Chitauri do not convincingly live up to their potential of constituting a genuine threat to Earth; ultimately they come across as something of a joke. Here's hoping that the sequel supposedly starring Thanos as the new principal antagonist can promise a battle of more cosmic proportions.
3. Rocky Balboa vs Tommy Gunn (Rocky V)
As movie street fights go, the confrontation between Rocky and his former protégé Tommy at the end of Rocky V isn't terrible per se, but it's a whimper of an end to a film that has already been struggling to avoid the label of most disappointing Rocky sequel, and pales in comparison to the epic (albeit highly ridiculous in true Rocky spirit) clash with Ivan Drago at the end of Rocky IV five years previously. Sequels are tricky things to get right. To an extent they need to adhere to the same formula that made the movie(s) popular in the first place so as to succeed in bringing fans back into cinemas. Yet you can also understand why filmmakers on occasion seek a break from tradition and attempt to do something new with the characters. But an integral part of justifying sequels, and certainly as advertising would make us believe, has always lain in increasing the scope and scale of the film beyond that of its predecessor(s), and the Rocky films proved highly successful in this. Rocky IV turned the match with Drago into a microcosm of the American struggle against Russian communism for goodness sake. Each of the first three Rocky sequels proved more commercially successful than its predecessor, with IV most notably becoming the second highest-grossing film worldwide of 1985. No film sequel would buck this trend more emphatically than Rocky V however, which grossed almost $200 million less than IV. Let's imagine for an instant that a boxer such as Rocky Balboa did exist in real life. It's perfectly plausible that after his victory over Drago he'd be keen to retire on account of the number of injuries he'd sustained and the sense that he had nothing left to achieve. It's entirely possible that his accountant would be found out to have squandered all of his money on bad business deals, and it's highly likely that Rocky would consequently have to start training boxers at his old gym to make ends meet. Whether you'd actually want to see all this in a film however is another matter entirely. You wouldn't be alone in arguing that Stallone made it out of greed, cashing in on the popularity of the character as much as was feasibly possible. Whichever way you look at it, Rocky V is an underwhelming film, a fact underlined by its final showdown. I wouldn't go so far as some critics in claiming that a Rocky film that doesn't feature Rocky in an actual in-ring boxing match can't be counted as an official entry into franchise, but the bare-knuckle street fight is a strange encounter nonetheless. There's something about it that just doesn't feel right, a sense that it doesn't belong in a Rocky movie. It doesn't help either that it's given virtually no build-up (though how could it?) and happens quite out-of-the blue, thus denying the audience the opportunity to anticipate it over the course of the film and, naturally, to experience yet another of Rocky's famous training montages. As said, there's nothing obviously wrong with the actual fighting, but the lack of the big-fight arena atmosphere that we'd become accustomed to is detrimental. The moment when Rocky, beaten down and seemingly out for the count, suddenly hears the voice of Mickey urging him to get up, get back in the fight, and to go just "one more round, is also one cliché too many. Stallone himself over time made no secret of his dissatisfaction with the film and sixteen years later made a final sequel in the form of Rocky Balboa. It more or less succeeded in finishing the series on the high and emotional note that he had always desired and, most crucially, put Rocky back in the ring where he belonged.
2. Superman vs Nuclear Man (Superman IV: The Quest For Peace)
Superman showdowns are another thing that are tricky to get right, partly because Kal-El is already so frickin' powerful that all conventional villains are immediately ruled out of the equation. The Superman films have thus generally followed one of two routes: either have the villain weaken him with Kryptonite so as to bring him down to their level (which I found slightly underwhelming since you always knew Supes was eventually going to regain the same godlike powers that had already been on display for much of the film), or range him against a similarly super-powered entity, and just hope that your special effects budget is sizeable enough to create a convincing fight. Superman II had managed this pretty successfully in the encounters with General Zod, Ursa, and Non, but the less said about Superman IV's showdown the better. Gene Hackman returned once again as Lex Luthor, one of the few positives of this mostly terrible third sequel, but Superman's principal physical clash is against Nuclear Man, an evil solar-powered clone of himself. His appearance, for starters, is just ridiculous, looking like he'd be far more at home in a Thundercats movie. Credit where it's due, their battle is given plenty of screen-time but it's all largely awful. Superman IV had a production budget of a meagre $17 million (the first film nine years earlier had $55 million) and by god it shows. It joins the fairly small list of official sequels that suffered from both inferior story and special effects to their original predecessors. At one point their battle even takes the pair to the Moon, whereupon Nuclear Man seems to think that driving Superman into the Moon's surface and covering him with a thin layer of space dust will be sufficient to permanently eliminate him. Supes promptly escapes, succeeds in nullifying his opponent's powers, and disposes of him by dropping him, fittingly, into the core of a nuclear power plant. Nineteen years on Bryan Singer wisely chose to disregard the events of Supermans III and IV in the backstory to his Superman Returns, though that film's showdown too left many feeling distinctly unimpressed. Signs so far look promising though that this year's reboot, Man of Steel, will be delivering in spades on the action front.
1. Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Count Dooku (Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith)
I'm under no illusions, a lot had to happen in Star Wars Episode III: a lot of loose ends to be tied up so as to set up the situation at the start of A New Hope. Included amongst these was Anakin supplanting Count Dooku as Darth Sidious' Sith apprentice. Everyone knew it was going to happen at some point, but I'd rather it had formed much more of an integral part of the story rather than just have Dooku killed off in the first ten minutes and then gradually wait for Anakin to become more and more tempted by the Dark Side. Perhaps you could even ask why Palpatine orders Anakin to execute Dooku at this point when he can't yet be 100 per cent that Anakin will definitely be swayed from the Jedi order. All that aside, it's a pretty anticlimactic end for Dooku anyway. One of the problems with the prequels for me was, aside from Sidious, the lack of longevity for any of the villains. Too many weren't allowed to survive beyond one film, thus preventing them, exciting though they were, from establishing a screen presence and iconic status that came even remotely close to matching that of Darth Vader in the original trilogy, and you can definitely attribute that at least partly to George Lucas' desire to introduce more new characters to the franchise so as to sell more toys and merchandise and thus get even more stinking rich. But Dooku seemed to buck that trend. Whatever its faults Attack of the Clones did succeed in presenting him as, if nothing else, a wholly credible antagonist capable of besting both Anakin and Obi-Wan and even holding his own against Yoda. But after this impressive build-up and subsequently great anticipation of his future actions in Episode III he goes out, like many others on this list, with a whimper, not being allowed to last any longer than the first major action sequence and only delivering a handful of lines in the process. The role of secondary antagonist for much of the film is then given to that far less-interesting quadruple-lightsaber-wielding droid who is cool and all, but no Christopher Lee, whose talents are largely wasted this time around.