10 Most Embarrassing DVD Commentaries Ever
When commentaries go horribly, hilariously, embarrassingly wrong.
With the popularity of streaming video now far surpassing physical media, it's fair to say that DVD commentaries sadly aren't quite as in vogue as they once were.
But as we all know, commentaries from directors, writers, and cast members can be a valuable resource to learn more about film production, and also to glean some entertaining anecdotes at the same time.
Yet not all commentaries are created equal, because not all subjects come to the recording booth suitably prepared, and of course, not all movies are really worth learning about.
And so, for every brilliantly informative and truly useful DVD commentary, there's at least one that'll simply leave viewers biting their own fist in embarrassment.
These 10 commentaries, whether for light-hearted blockbusters or more serious-minded dramas, all activated the cringe reflex for a multitude of reasons: perhaps those recording the commentary were clearly ashamed of their work, or maybe they weren't ashamed enough.
Then there's the case of a certain tree-sized action hero who clearly never learned what a DVD commentary is actually supposed to be.
Though some of these commentaries are at least amusing to listen to, they're all tinged with a sure undercurrent of shame...
10. Joel Schumacher Actually Apologises To Fans - Batman & Robin
By most accounts, Joel Schumacher is a lovely man and a nice guy to work with, and you certainly get a sense of that while listening to his commentary for the widely maligned Batman & Robin.
However, it's also a frequently cringe-worthy commentary track given that Joel is incredibly matter-of-fact about discussing the film's failures, causing him to spend much of the commentary apologising to viewers for screwing things up.
Schumacher talks broadly about the pressure put upon him by the studio to make the film lighter and more mechandisable, and even throws his own godson under the bus by admitting that many of the film's eyebrow-raising ideas came from him.
Yet ultimately, he takes full responsibility himself for the end result, refusing to blame screenwriter Akiva Goldsman, resolving that if you don't like a movie you should blame the director.
Anyone who's seen one of the many quality movies Schumacher has made over his career knows that he has talent, but there's an unmistakable air of fatigue in his voice and tone during this commentary.
He acknowledges that Batman & Robin made him realise why sequels are so tough to make and why they disappoint so often, while adding that he actually wanted to adapt Frank Miller's Batman: Year One after Batman Forever, but Warner Bros. shot him down because the material was too dark.
Schumacher evidently has a sense of humour about the movie - joking about Uma Thurman's overacting, above all else - but listening to the commentary, it's still painfully clear that he's ashamed of how it all turned out.
He even ends the commentary early before the film's actually over. Oof.
9. Damon Lindelof Refuses To Accept He Ruined The Movie - Prometheus
If you've got two hours of your life to spare, the Prometheus commentary between original screenwriter Jon Spaihts and Damon Lindelof, who was hired to rework his script into the final product, makes for deliciously cringe-worthy viewing.
It's no secret that Spaihts' original script was decidedly more interesting before Lindelof came in and tinkered around with it, and the commentary perfectly reflects the creative bristling between the two.
Spaihts spends much of the commentary explaining how his original script would've sewn up various plot holes, while Lindelof flatly admits several times that he is, in his own words, "a very pretentious person."
Lindelof additionally offers up half-baked explanations for many of the movie's most divisive moments, ultimately telling his nay-sayers, "If you hated the movie, again, I apologise. And hopefully this made you hate me even more."
One imagines Fox knew exactly what they were doing when they sat these two together for this commentary. At least both Spaihts and Lindelof agreed that casting Guy Pearce to play an old man was a major mistake.
8. Guy Ritchie Thinks His Movie Is A Lot Smarter Than It Is - Revolver
Guy Ritchie's 2005 gangster flick Revolver is a textbook example of a movie made by a director who has started to believe their own hype and in turn gotten completely high off their own supply.
The DVD release of this insanely pretentious and scarcely coherent movie quite fittingly includes an outrageously pompous commentary from Ritchie himself.
For starters, the director implores audiences to watch the movie three times (without commentary, with commentary, and then without again), insisting that "each time you watch it, the concept becomes deeper and deeper." Right.
He also discusses the film's themes - particularly that chess is a metaphor for life - which he clearly believes are both deep and subtle, before launching off on an insane tangent about the film's three-pronged colour scheme mirroring how everything in nature occurs in threes.
Basically, it's toe-curlingly hilarious confirmation that Ritchie had disappeared entirely up himself at this point in his career, though at least the derisive general response to Revolver didn't validate his glue-sniffingly insane ideas any further.
7. Ben Affleck Relentlessly Mocks The Film - Armageddon
The DVD commentary for Michael Bay's Armageddon is infamous because a good portion of it is devoted to star Ben Affleck ceaselessly, hilariously ripping the movie to shreds.
Despite featuring Affleck alongside Bay, producer Jerry Bruckheimer, and co-star Bruce Willis, all four parts were recorded separately and spliced together, effectively allowing Affleck to let loose on the film consequence-free.
This results in the track fleeting between Affleck's sardonic put-downs and the more generous observations of Bay and Bruckheimer in particular.
Most notably, Affleck recalls how he mentioned the film's central plot hole - that it'd be more efficient to train astronauts to become drillers than the other way around - to Bay, who promptly told him to "shut the f**k up."
He also suggests that Bay is so adept at making films aimed at youngsters because he has the mind of one, and basically demonstrates he doesn't take the movie one bit seriously.
Hearing this juxtaposed against the more earnest musings of the other participants is as awkward as it is entertaining.
6. Robert Pattinson & Kristen Stewart Clearly Hate The Movie - Twilight
It's not much of a secret that Twilight stars Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart aren't huge fans of the movies, to the extent that they spent the majority of their time on the series' DVD commentaries unabashedly making fun of them.
This proved especially awkward during the commentary for the original film, where they're joined by director Catherine Hardwicke.
Though Hardwicke's mostly in on the joke, she nevertheless does attempt to defend the film when it feels like her filmmaking chops are being called into question.
For instance, when Pattinson debates the film's iffy physics during an action sequence, Hardwicke replies, "Those of us that are physics majors get it."
But for the most part the track is basically a Mystery Science Theatre 3000-style riff-off as the three, especially the two actors, crack jokes about the movie and demonstrate just how little regard they truly have for it.
5. Eli Roth Calls His Critics "Faggy" - Cabin Fever
For the DVD release of his low-budget horror hit Cabin Fever, writer-director Eli Roth recorded an insane five separate commentaries - four with various members of the cast, and then a final one solo.
That's almost eight hours of Roth talking about his film, and though the filmmaker does provide occasional insight, for the most part these commentaries rehash a lot of the same information and also reveal just how much of an exasperating Bro he actually is.
The most questionable moments include Roth discussing the film's use of the N-word and its exhausting abundance of homophobic slurs, which he sees no problem with whatsoever.
In fact, in a moment that hasn't aged well at all, Roth even "jokes" that calling the movie homophobic is a "faggy thing to say." See the offending clip for yourself at 14:15 in RedLetterMedia's recent review of the movie below.
All in all, despite Roth's clear love for the horror genre, he's an exhausting guy to listen to, and that lurches into obnoxiousness when he says embarrassingly juvenile things like this.
4. Arnie Doesn't Understand What A DVD Commentary Is - Total Recall
The commentary for Arnold Schwarzenegger's sci-fi action classic Total Recall is a sure thing of demented beauty.
Not because it provides any illuminating insight into the film's production, but because it's hilariously clear that nobody actually told Arnie what a movie commentary is supposed to be.
As a result, he spends the entirety of the track just describing what's happening on screen in the most basic, on-the-level way possible, while intermittently cracking bad jokes alongside director Paul Verhoeven.
There's certainly comedy value in it, for sure, and it's just one of several commentaries where Arnie obviously, hilariously misses the point, but for anyone hoping to glean some useful information about the making of the movie itself, there's very little to be found.
3. Uwe Boll Thinks He Made A Good Movie - House Of The Dead
Uwe Boll is one of the most infamous filmmakers to emerge over the last two decades, most "fondly" remembered for his so-bad-it's-good video game movies such as Alone in the Dark, Bloodrayne, and yes, 2003's House of the Dead.
Any feeling that Boll might be aware of how awful his movies are completely dissolves, then, by listening to his commentary for House of the Dead, which he largely spends singing his own praises and effectively demonstrating his planet-sized ego.
Actor Will Sanderson also appears on the commentary and makes it not-so-subtly clear that he's embarrassed by the film, spending much of the commentary picking apart its myriad issues while Boll thoroughly downplays them.
As a window into the mind of someone totally lacking in self-awareness, it's fascinating, but given that he's sat with people who aren't quite so blinkered, it's an undeniably awkward fit.
2. Jean-Claude Van Damme Clumsily "Discusses" The Movie's Themes - Replicant
Jean-Claude Van Damme is generally esteemed more for what he can do with his body than his mouth, and that's perhaps evidenced no better than in his rambling DVD commentary for the 2001 sci-fi trash-fest Replicant.
Van Damme appears on the commentary with co-star Michael Rooker, but because the two recorded their parts separately and the tracks were consequently spliced together, there's nobody sat with Van Damme to rein in his droning, verbose monologues about the movie's themes.
In particular, Van Damme goes off on several titanic tangents about DNA, the under-appreciated art of physical acting in cinema, and the importance of feeling in the world.
Though there's potentially something compelling there, without someone to actually discuss these concepts with, the martial arts legend comes off as doddering and only vaguely coherent.
1. Robert Durst's Commentary Gets Used As Evidence In His Own Murder Trial - All Good Things
Our final entry is embarrassing for a far more serious reason.
This Ryan Gosling-starring crime drama was inspired by the life of accused murderer Robert Durst and the disappearance of his wife Katie. Incredibly, Durst enjoyed the film enough that he agreed to record a commentary track for it with director Andrew Jarecki.
Jarecki and Durst discuss the accuracy of the film at various points, with Durst flatly accepting that his domestic abuse depicted was "close enough," even while keeping relatively mum on the details of his wife's "disappearance."
What makes this more than merely incredibly creepy, however, is that following Durst's eventual arrest in 2015 - after the airing of Jarecki's interview series with Durst, The Jinx - the prosecution then requested that Durst's DVD commentary be used as evidence against him.
Prosecutors stated that Durst's silence during certain portions of the movie's commentary implied a degree of guilt, and indeed, when the trial kicked off earlier this year, the jury were shown excerpts from the commentary track.
The outcome of the trial remains to be seen, and while every other commentary blunder on this list is comparatively harmless, Durst had the complacent gall to literally risk his own freedom because he couldn't keep his own ego in check.