10 Most Pointless CGI Movie Shots Ever

What a waste of money.

By Jack Pooley /

Dimension Films

CGI can be an incredible, immensely versatile tool in the hands of smart filmmakers who know when to use it, but as we've all seen countless times, it's too often used as a crutch or an indulgence, where the results can prove extremely offputting to audiences.

Advertisement

And though literally hundreds of movies can be ripped to shreds for their embarrassingly cheap visual effects, we're looking specifically at movies that needlessly employed VFX artists to work on scenes and shots that absolutely didn't need them.

Yes, some of these effects also happen to be bad, but a few of them are totally passable or even convincing - because the focus here is on CGI that was pointlessly injected into scenes that were doing just fine without them.

Advertisement

If nothing else, it's a testament to the thoughtless pervasiveness of CGI throughout Hollywood over the last two decades in particular, and that even enormously talented filmmakers aren't beyond overdoing it with the computerised flourishes and touch-ups...

10. $5000 Dog Poop - John Wick

Summit Entertainment

John Wick is an incredible action film which makes extremely minimal use of visual effects, though the producers did stump up a princely sum to include a wildly unnecessary pile of dog crap during one early scene.

Advertisement

Shortly after John (Keanu Reeves) has been gifted a puppy by his dead wife (Bridget Moynahan), the dog is seen leaving John's house to relieve itself, and the audience is "treated" to a shot of the healthy deposit the canine leaves behind.

And while you probably assumed this was a $2 plastic poop lobbed on the lawn, it was in fact a digital creation, rendered to the tune of a mind-boggling $5000.

Advertisement

With the production unable to feed a laxative to their dog performer to get a "practical" poop, there was apparently no other choice than to rely on VFX.

Given the utter pointlessness of the shot and the film's modest $25 million budget, it makes no sense at all to be so frivolous with...dog crap of all things.

Advertisement

And even if you're going to render a CGI poo, why would you make it so perfectly coiled, as though to look fake? That's irony for you.

9. Cold Breath - The Social Network

Columbia Pictures

Though David Fincher's 2010 masterpiece carried out a feat of sheer VFX necromancy by having Armie Hammer play two characters so convincingly, some more "subtle" CGI elsewhere unfortunately wasn't quite so precise.

Advertisement

During an early scene where Mark Zuckerberg (Jesse Eisenberg) and Eduardo Saverin (Andrew Garfield) are talking outside in the middle of a party, it's blindingly obvious that their cold breath has been digitally superimposed in post-production.

Rather than warm moisture faintly escaping from their mouths when they speak, they look closer to Superman deploying his ice breath like the fate of the world depends on it.

Advertisement

Though Fincher's commitment to the details is admirable, in this case the botched execution is distracting enough that he probably should've just ditched it entirely.

It's not like the temperature of the scene contributes in any way to the character or story beats we're watching unfold.

Advertisement

8. Johnny Depp's Face - Public Enemies

Warner Bros.

Michael Mann's Public Enemies largely focuses on good old-fashioned practical set-pieces, so Mann's decision to include one especially noticeable CGI stunt proves all the more jarring as a result.

Advertisement

During the focal bank robbery sequence, John Dillinger (Johnny Depp) is seen vaulting over a bank desk, and there's no two ways about it - it looks totally badass.

Or it would, if not for the fact that Depp's face is clearly just a crude digital mask pasted over that of a stuntman.

Advertisement

Apparently, the notoriously perfectionist Mann had a very specific idea of how the shot should look, and when Depp couldn't quite get it right, he brought in a stunt double to execute it with the correct physicality, while fixing the face in post.

The irony, of course, is that the entire shot is ruined by the distracting CGI, which resembles Depp only as though he were rendered in the cut-scene of a mid-budget PS1 game.

Advertisement

Given that the shot could've easily been captured from behind the stuntman and likely still looked just as cool, it's an utterly baffling act of stubbornness on Mann's part.

7. Green Screen Rooftop - The Room

TPW Films

It's fair to say that Tommy Wiseau's The Room is a film rife with questionable creative calls, though nothing quite raises the eyebrows like Wiseau's decision to use extensive - and totally unconvincing - green screen effects to shoot the film's rooftop scenes.

Advertisement

Wiseau had these scenes shot on a set hastily thrown together in a car park, with a green screen erected so he could composite a shot of the Los Angeles skyline in post-production.

But what makes this use of CGI truly pointless is that Wiseau actually had a rooftop available to shoot the scenes on, but for reasons that none of the film's crew members have ever been able to ascertain, he opted for gaudy chroma-key instead.

Advertisement

If James Franco's The Disaster Artist is to be believed, it's probably because Wiseau wanted to make a Real Hollywood Movie, and nothing says Hollywood like needlessly splashing cash on perfunctory CGI.

Given that the film's budget somehow ballooned to an absurd $6 million, it's fair to assume that this sequence ended up accounting for a sizeable chunk of that price tag.

Advertisement

6. Henry Cavill's "Digital Shave" - Justice League

Warner Bros.

Now, on the face of things (pardon the pun), you might protest that Warner Bros. spending roughly $3 million to digitally shave Henry Cavill's face for Justice League re-shoots was absolutely necessary.

Advertisement

After all, Cavill was contractually prevented from shaving his bushy 'tache until Mission: Impossible - Fallout had completed filming.

Except, there were several options that Warner Bros. had available to them here, and pretty much all of them were better than just pressing on and "fixing it in post", as the saying goes.

Advertisement

Shutting down production for a few weeks was obviously the most sensible option. Though it wouldn't have been cheap, it ultimately would've prevented the film from becoming a laughing stock and perhaps even helped its box office in the long run.

Secondly, given how badass Cavill's facial hair actually was in Fallout, and that many fans expected to see a resurrected Superman with facial hair anyway, they could've leaned into it and re-shot Cavill's entire role with a full grizzled face of hair (even adding onto it with a false beard if need be).

Advertisement

Given that Supes' role is fairly small in the movie and it largely consists of material collected from re-shoots regardless, it likely would've been cheaper and certainly less embarrassing than the CGI beard removal.

When you've sunk $300 million into a project already, it really doesn't pay to skimp on the big picture stuff - and that's exactly what Warner Bros. did by over-relying on VFX.

Advertisement

5. The Rat - Daredevil

Fox

The Ben Affleck-starring 2003 Daredevil movie is a baffling production for many reasons, not least its general excess of frivolous, often unconvincing CGI.

Advertisement

And this much is made clear in the movie's very first shot, as a digital rat is shown scampering through the streets of Hell's Kitchen before being blasted by a steam grate.

Director Mark Steven Johnson originally intended to use a real rat for the shot, but when it didn't move across the scene as intended, the decision was made to move on and pass it off to the CGI artists.

Advertisement

The actual rendering of the rat isn't too bad, aided by the scene being extremely dark, but given the utter lack of storytelling necessity for the rat to even appear in the movie, it just feels like a daft, unnecessary indulgence.

But in the very least, it's emblematic of the film's entire misguided fascination with CGI, and lets audiences know early on what they're in for.

Advertisement

4. Replacing Practical Effects With Digital - The Thing (2011)

Universal Pictures

Now this one really hurts. While the 2011 The Thing was far from a good movie, it was at least shot with an emphasis on practical creature effects in tribute to John Carpenter's 1982 original, which remains one of the best-crafted creature features of all time.

Advertisement

And despite the film largely being shot with animatronics, during post-production the studio increasingly mandated use of CGI, ultimately replacing most of the original practical effects digitally through re-shoots and literally tracing over the original in-camera work.

Footage of the practical effects have since found their way online, and considering how great they looked, fans were left outraged by the utterly charmless nature of the final digital result.

Advertisement

There have been calls for Universal to release a "practical effects cut" of the film, though with the film's practical effects artists confirming that no such cut exists, it would require Paramount going back into the editing room and assembling it.

For a film that bombed at the box office and also reviewed badly, that doesn't seem terribly likely.

Advertisement

3. Digital Tyre Smoke - Ronin

MGM

John Frankenheimer's Ronin is a ludicrously entertaining action-thriller that boasts some of the most impressive car chases ever put to film, and Frankenheimer himself even boasted that the chases were all achieved in-camera, "not in green screens, not with computer tricks."

Advertisement

That's ultimately about 99.7% true, because while cars really were filmed hurtling through the streets of France, the legendary filmmaker peculiarly decided to inject some wildly unnecessary CGI into a Paris chase sequence.

As Sam (Robert De Niro) and Vincent (Jean Reno) burn rubber while making their escape, a ton of repulsive CGI smoke is layered over the top of the vehicle, intended to be imply an extremely severe tire burnout.

Advertisement

Unfortunately it looks laughably ugly and slightly undermines a sequence that's otherwise an epic triumph of technical filmmaking.

Frankenheimer probably should've asked himself what was more distracting - a car screeching away with minimal smoke, or a naff digital fog enveloping the screen?

Advertisement

2. Michael Myers' Mask - Halloween H20: 20 Years Later

Dimension Films

The seventh Halloween movie was actually a pretty decent return to form for the series for the most part, and given how little the franchise has relied on VFX over its tenure, few expected to see noticeable CGI in it.

Advertisement

Surprisingly, the filmmakers were still tinkering around with the new design of the Michael Myers mask even during shooting, and once post-production had been completed, a total of four masks had been used.

If you keep your eyes peeled, you can even pick out shots where earlier iterations of the mask appear - while most of them were replaced in re-shoots - and there's one especially obnoxious moment that occurs when poor Charlie Deveraux (Adam Hann-Byrd) comes face-to-face with Myers.

Advertisement

Because the production wasn't able to re-shoot this scene with the final mask design, a CGI model was instead pasted on top of the rejected practical one, the results of which are absolutely hideous.

Though the shot lasts just a merciful second or two, was this method of problem-solving really preferable to just sticking to the over-the-shoulder shot of Michael and avoiding all that fan outrage?

Advertisement

And no matter how rubbish that original mask looked, it surely wouldn't have been as distractingly bad as this.

1. The Prairie Dogs - Indiana Jones & The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull

Disney

The fourth Indiana Jones gets a ton of flak from fans for a number of reasons, and though nothing will ever quite top the "nuke the fridge" controversy, many were dismayed by the film's excessive reliance on low-rent visual effects.

Advertisement

Just like Daredevil, this is made apparent in the film's very first shot, and again like Daredevil, it involves a totally unconvincing and pointless digital rodent.

The film's opening shot shows a rough CGI prairie dog emerging from its mound, surveying the area and quickly scurrying off before a car runs over the mound.

Advertisement

And perhaps if this were a one-off, it might've been easy enough to tolerate. However, the awful digital abomination re-appears during the infamous fridge-nuking scene, popping out of its hole to stare gormlessly at Indy (Harrison Ford) for a moment before diving back in.

Do these moments add anything to the film? Audiences rightly expected better from Spielberg, and he really dropped the ball here.

Advertisement