10 Most Shamefully Lazy Plot Resolutions In Movie History
And they all lived lazily ever after.
Using the medium of film to tell a story is no easy task. For a story to work it requires a well-constructed plot, one that not only shows the audience how events in the story relate to one another but does so in an entertaining fashion. If a plot fails to hold an audience's interest while connecting all the dots, a filmmaker risks alienating the viewers or pulling them out of the story.
But constructing a logical plot is easier said than done: unlike other story telling mediums, filmmaking is a highly collaborative art. A director has to corral set designers, cinematographers, actors, FX specialists and scriptwriters like a ringmaster in a circus while keeping everything on budget and on schedule. On top of this, he or she has to make what appears onscreen seem effortless and fully realised.
With so many things juggling in the air at once, it's understandable if a filmmaker occasionally drops the ball and lets the odd plot hole through in the interest of getting the entire story onscreen. Other times filmmakers really half-arse it.
This typically happens near the climax when the story needs to be wrapped up. Sometimes you can almost see the filmmakers shrug and mutter whatever as they serve up an undercooked finale. A half-cooked plot resolution may be a deal breaker and other times a stumble at the finish line is forgivable because what came before it was so enjoyable. For your consideration, we have assembled a list of ten of the most half-baked movie resolutions of all time...
10. Superman Gets A Mulligan - Superman (1978)
The question facing all Superman writers since 1938 is how can you give a story believable stakes when your protagonist is a God-like being with near limitless powers? It seems that the team of screenwriters tasked with bringing Superman to the big screen for 1978's Superman failed to find a solution to this conundrum.
In the finale, Superman's arch-nemesis, Lex Luthor plans to create some prime Californian real estate by detonating a nuclear warhead along the San Andreas Fault line. Knowing Supes will take issue his plans for remodelling the west coast, Luthor traps Superman with the aid of Kryptonite before launching the missile. Supes manages to free himself but not before the warhead hits its target and uses his powers to clean up the nuclear fallout and repair the damage caused by the missile strike. While he has his hands full saving a bunch of innocent people, his love interest, Lois Lane, ends up dying.
It seems that even The Man of Steel can't win them all. Or can he? In a move that seems like a particularly lazy attempt to give the feature a happy ending, Superman reverses the rotation of the earth, turning back time, taking a mulligan to save his lady love. Supes' time traveling hijinks raise a bunch of questions that the film never answers like if Superman chose to save Lois did everyone else he saved before end up dying? Instead of answering these questions, the film ends with Superman depositing Luthor in prison and riding off into the sunset. The whole movie is such a grand old time it's hard to let niggling concerns like the half-cooked resolution ruin the fun.
9. Hermione Turns Back The Clock - Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban (2004)
As Superman illustrated, using time travel as a plot device is a tricky business; if a filmmaker suddenly introduces time travel without properly setting it up, it can make the story he or she is telling seem arbitrary and illogical. The third instalment of the Harry Potter film franchise, The Prisoner Of Azkaban, commits this cardinal sin.
Fans of the books might point out the following plot points are explained by the novel in depth but a film needs to stand on its own and what made it onscreen seems like a particularly unsatisfying attempt to wrap up the story. In the final act, Harry and his godfather, Sirius Black, are attacked by Dementors until an unseen wizard casts a spell that wards off Harry's foes at the last second. In the aftermath, Sirius is placed in lockdown and set to be executed at the stroke of midnight, and as the time comes it appears that Harry has no hope of saving Sirius until his friend, Hermione, pulls out a time turner - a device never mentioned before in the feature or in any of the previous films in the franchise.
Using a magical time amulet (which was never mentioned in the previous films) the kids rescue Sirius and Harry learns that he was the unseen wizard who cast the spell to ward off the Dementors. The movie makes it seem like the filmmakers wrote themselves into a corner and lazily pulled the time travel card to save their heroes from a tight spot.
8. An Unstoppable Alien Force Is Beaten By The Common Cold - War Of The Worlds
H.G. Wells' War Of The Worlds is one of the most influential literary works of all time. Almost all alien invasion movies from Independence Day to Avengers owes it at least a small debt for paving the way for tales about humanity's struggle to survive in the face of a seeming unstoppable alien force.
Wells' tale is a lot darker than its blockbuster progeny. In Wells' novel, humanity is truly helpless against the Martian invaders, and the only thing that saves us from complete annihilation is the fact that the aliens have no immunity to earthbound bacteria, which wipes them out. While this ending serves a thematic purpose by demonstrating humanity's ultimate helplessness on a universal scale, it's also an extremely poor way to wrap up the story.
Instead of having the protagonist save the day, or, following the story to its logical conclusion and having the aliens wipe humanity out, blind luck saves the earth. When adapting a literary work, filmmakers have the liberty to shore up any weakness in the source material, including the resolution of the plot.
Neither the 1953 or 2005 adaptation of Wells' novel managed to improve on this unsatisfying resolution where, after conclusively showing humanity is no match against its otherworldly foe, the aliens just sort of keel over and die, rewarding human beings for our incompetence and inadequacy.
7. Zombies Make Healthy Diet Choices - World War Z (2013)
Paramount Pictures found out the hard way that bringing a book to the big screen can be a headache when the studio tried to adapt Max Brook's work of popular zombie fiction World War Z. Brook's novel chronicled a global war between humanity and legions of zombies through a series of interviews conducted years after the conflict ended. The movie adaptation tried to streamline the novel's plot by focusing on a single protagonist, survivalist Gerry Lane, and his attempts to find a cure for the zombie plague.
The film underwent a series of rewrites and reshoots because the original cut lacked a satisfying ending. Screenwriter Damon Lindelof was brought onboard to turn the hot mess of a conclusion into something palatable for general audiences. Unfortunately, the way he chose to resolve the plot comes across as extremely half-baked.
After trotting the globe and gathering clues on how to stop the zombie threat, Lane believes he's found the answer: the zombies don't attack terminally ill humans because they would be unsuitable hosts for the zombie virus. Lane visits a medical facility where he injects himself with a pathogen that effectively makes him invisible to zombies. The good news spreads and humanity turns the tide on the undead.
This nonsensical ending leaves the audience with a whole host of unanswered questions like: why did no one notice that the zombies ignore the terminally ill? Wouldn't there be entire hospital wings left untouched by the zombie apocalypse? Why would a virus that turned people into undead flesh eaters consider the soon to be dead unsuitable hosts? Despite the valiant efforts of Mr. Lindelof, the half-baked plot resolution he came up failed to provide a satisfying ending for such a large-scale story.
6. Khan's Magical Blood To The Rescue - Star Trek Into Darkness (2013)
1982's Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan pitted the crew of the starship Enterprise against its greatest adversary: the diabolical Khan Singh. During the film's climactic space battle the Enterprise's warp core is damaged, forcing Vulcan science officer Spock give his life to save the ship. A grief stricken Captain Kirk gives a heartfelt goodbye to his longtime friend in one of the most emotionally devastating moments in the franchise.
J.J. Abram's 2013 sequel to his wildly successful Star Trek reboot, Star Trek Into Darkness, lifted this iconic scene for its climax but put a fresh spin on it: instead of Spock, Kirk sacrifices himself to save his ship. The original film series waited until the sequel Star Trek III: The Search For Spock to resurrect the pointy-eared fan favourite but apparently Abrams and co wanted to save some time by bringing Kirk back before the credits roll.
Unfortunately, the way they chose to do so comes across as one of the laziest plot resolutions in recent memory. It turns out that Khan's blood has the ability to bring people back from the dead, somehow. When the Enterprise discovers this poorly explained phenomena, Spock promptly punches Khan out and the crew gives Kirk an infusion of the miracle serum. In the quickest resurrection scene in film history, Kirk wakes up in a hospital bed, alive and ready to get back in the captain's chair for Star Trek III.
5. God Helps Wrap Things Up - Raiders Of The Lost Ark (1981)
Steven Spielberg's classic adventure film is one of the greatest actions movies ever made. Raiders tells the story of Indiana Jones' quest to discover the lost Ark of the Covenant - a biblical relic that possesses devastating destructive powers - before the Nazis can use it as a tool for world domination.
Despite Indy's best efforts both he and the Ark fall into the hands of the Nazi menace. When Jones is tied to a pole and made to watch the Nazis open the Ark to harness its awesome power the audience is left wondering what ingenuous plan Indy will devise to save himself and stop the Nazi threat. It turns out he lets God sort it out.
Once the Nazis pop the Ark open demonic beings consume them in face-melting hellfire. The Ark seals itself and Indy is free to take it back to the states where it will be housed by the U.S. government. While this is a very good set piece, it really is a half-baked way for Indy to overcome his Nazi adversaries. It also takes away the onus on the hero to save the day; once the Nazis stole the Ark from Jones, he could have gone home, taken a load off and waited for God to resolve the plot without his help.
4. Ocean Pulls A Switcheroo - Ocean's Twelve (2004)
2001's Ocean's Eleven assembled an all star cast for a highly entertaining caper flick about a group of cons who rob a casino for 150 million dollars. In Ocean's Twelve, Terry Benedict, the casino owner the Oceans crew robbed in the first film, tracks the professional thieves down and demands his money back or else. Ocean is at a loss what to do until rival thief, the Night Fox, offers to pay Oceans debt if Ocean can steal a priceless Fabergé egg before the Fox can in a game of professional thieves poser. Ocean's crew tries their best to get their hands on the egg, going so far as creating a holographic facsimile to swap for the real egg, but fail in all their attempts.
The Night Fox manages to scoop Ocean and gets a hold of the egg first. It seems all is lost for Ocean until the God of plot contrivance allows him to escape his predicament far, far too easily. Ocean reveals that the Fox's mentor, master thief LeMarc, tipped Ocean off ahead of time that he could intercept the Fabergé egg while it was being transported between museums. LeMarc intended for the Fox to steal a fake egg as a means to humiliate his protégé.
This way too convenient set of circumstances zaps the haphazardly paced feature of any tension, giving the impression that Clooney and his cronies wanted an excuse to hang out and whipped the plot together almost as an afterthought.
3. Deus Ex Machina Saves The Day - The Matrix Revolutions (2003)
The Wachowski siblings' 1999 smash hit The Matrix introduced audiences to a tantalising fictional world where malevolent machines enslaved humanity via a virtual reality program known as the Matrix. Fans clamoured for a deeper exploration of the mythology hinted at in the first Matrix film and the Wachowskis obliged them by filming two sequels back-to-back.
The first sequel, The Matrix Reloaded, ended on several cliffhangers including the imminent destruction of Zion and the potential destruction of the Matrix by an ever-multiplying Agent Smith. The Matrix Revolutions, released a scant six months after Reloaded, gave fans a lazy cop-out ending instead of providing a satisfactory conclusion to these plot threads.
With the machines threatening to annihilate humanity's last surviving city, our hero Neo breaks into the machine stronghold to speak with the machine leader: the Deus Ex Machina. In ancient Greek theatre when a play used the deus ex machina, an actor playing a God would intervene in the plot to rescue a hero from an impossible situation.
The Wachowskis didn't even try to hide the fact The Matrix saga would end with a lazy, miraculous plot device. Neo cuts a deal with Deus Ex Machina to leave humanity alone if Neo rids the Matrix of the pesky Agent Smith virus. Neo bests Smith, sacrificing himself in the process, and the machines retreat from Zion. The Wachowskis' shameless admission they will end their hours-long story with an unearned resolution lands them at number 3 on our list.
2. Batman Survives A Neutron Bomb - The Dark Knight Rises (2012)
After the titanic success of Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight, fans eagerly anticipated the release of his concluding chapter in his Batman saga, The Dark Knight Rises. Nolan's follow-up met with critical and commercial success upon its release with many critics lauding the ending as a fitting and deeply moving end to the Caped Crusader's story.
Despite the acclaim, some fans voiced their dissatisfaction with a few questionable plot choices Nolan made to get to the end of the story. In the climax of the feature, Batman must use his flying machine The Bat to transport a neutron bomb out of Gotham City. The Bat's broken autopilot system means it's a one way ticket for the Caped Crusader and Batman gets exploded along with the bomb. Or so audiences thought. It turns out Batman repaired the autopilot beforehand (somehow) and faked his own death so he could live a normal life free from his secret identity.
While this conclusion hit many audiences members square in the feels, others wondered how Batman managed to fix the autopilot when the challenge had stumped tech genius Lucius Fox. On top of this Batman had spent the preceding months trapped in a prison on the far side of the world so when did he get the time to orchestrate his fake death, rewrite his will, and leave clues for his protege John Blake to find the bat cave? The majority of fans seemed to be okay with minor plot quibbles and enjoyed the larger story Nolan told with his trilogy but others found the inconsistent plotting a disappointing way to end the stellar film series.
1. An Invincible Ghost Army Sweeps Up The Mess - The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King (2003)
J.R.R. Tolkiens massive work of fantasy fiction The Lord Of The Rings is comprised of three volumes that total over 1,000 pages, not including the appendices and supplementary material. This mammoth book contained so much story that many considered it un-filmable. When director Peter Jackson finally brought Tolkien's tale to the big screen in a wildly successful trilogy, each instalment clocked in at well over two hours and large parts of Tolkiens vision still didn't make the cut.
Jackson's need to half-arse some plot points to get the entire story on screen is never more apparent than in his trilogy-capping epic The Return Of The King. In the climactic battle of Pelennor Fields, the forces of good face insurmountable odds as the armies of Mordor close in for the kill. It seems all is lost until the heroic Aragon some reinforcements: an army of invincible undead ghost warriors who eradicate the bad guys in a matter of minutes without breaking a sweat.
The audience is left wondering why Aragorn didn't enlist the aid of this ghostly blitzkrieg before the battle even began. In Tolkien's novel Aragorn only enlists the ghost warriors to help him pave the way to bring human reinforcements to the battlefield so the heroes must win the day without a supernatural assist. Jackson decided that having the ghost army simply wipe out the bad guys would cut down on the runtime of the already bloated flick. Unfortunately, he makes the resolution seem more tossed-off then it could have been.
Did we miss any features that limped across the finish line? Let us know in the comments.