10 Most Unexpected Director Career Changes

When famous directors made a movie that was shockingly different to what went before.

By Adam Thompson /

Many would agree that, one sign of a great director, is the ability to identify a coherent style or theme that is present in all of their work. Some of the greatest directors of all time are known for doing just one thing really well, or at least, they become famous for one type of movie in particular. Woody Allen is known for a genre of cosmopolitan romantic comedies which focus on life in New York. Ingmar Bergman, a major influence on Allen, is forever associated with a religious-themed, meditative, psychological drama. Perhaps the director most tied to a single genre of film is John Ford - and it's almost impossible to imagine him involved in a film which is not a Western. While certain directors scratch out a critically-acclaimed niche for themselves, others prefer to beat a new path entirely. This desire doesn't necessarily make a great director - after all, Woody Allen and John Ford have some of the most impressive oeuvres going - but experimentation can be an indication. Often trying something new can be a true test of directorial mettle. But what are the most unexpected directorial detours of all time? Which films created a whole new vista of possibilities for the director that gambled on them, and which were brushed under the carpet at the earliest opportunity? Most of the career changes on this list led to the creation of some of the greatest films in the history of cinema. Read on to find out more.

10. M. Night Shyamalan - Signs

How They Became Famous In the early 00s Shyamalan was one of the hottest properties in Hollywood. His breakthrough,The Sixth Sense, starring Bruce Willis, was a commercial and critical hit, still revered for it's twist ending and spooky tone. The follow up, Unbreakable, again featuring Willis, turned the super-hero movie on it's head. Unusual for all sorts of reasons, it was perhaps too esoteric to become a major hit, but it did confirm to the world a major talent was on the rise. What They Did Next Signs isn't a bad film, only average. It is arguable The Village is the first truly stinking Shyamalan film, but this did mark a turning point in the director's career. It began his trajectory from the saviour of modern cinema, to washed-up, 'look where they are now' in just a few short-ish films. A trajectory he's still on now. Signs wasn't a departure due to tone or subject matter - it was another attempt at turning around a traditional concept, making the audience approach it in a new way - but it was the first time he failed in his ambitions. In this sense it was unexpected. What began with Signs ended in some of the most horrible movies to come out of Hollywood, each more baffling sub-par than the last. It seems he started to believe his own hype and the ultimate result was the wasting of a promising career.

9. Stanley Kubrick - Lolita

How They Became Famous One of the most famous and well-respected directors of all time, Stanley Kubrick really began making a name for himself with a realistic portrayal of the horrors of war in Paths of Glory. His next film, Spartacus, a gigantic historical epic, was again politically charged. The success of Spartacus at the Academy Awards and at the box office (it won 4 Oscars and became the highest grossing film of all time) might have lead critics to believe Kubrick was ready to get comfortable in mainstream Hollywood. It turned out that couldn't have been further from the truth. What They Did Next Following Spartacus in 1962 was Lolita, based on the controversial novel by Vladimir Nabokov. The story centres on a middle-aged man who falls in love with a 12 year old girl, effectively doing away with her mother, and taking her on a road trip across America until she is stolen from him and forced into the pornography industry. One of the most disturbing aspects of the subject matter, is that the child Lolita reciprocates with her lover. Ideal material to blow up a carefully built reputation and risk an entire career. To get it passed censors, the director had to make all sorts of concessions, and still it received an X rating. While the film was censored to the point Kubrick wished he never made it, and it received poor reviews on release, it has since become accepted as a fine, if difficult, piece of film-making. It can hardly be said a film which was followed by 2001, A Clockwork Orange and The Shining had a retrograde effect on this director's career either.

8. Steven Spielberg - The Colour Purple

How They Became Famous Spielberg burst onto the movie scene in 1975 with Jaws, arguably the first 'Summer Blockbuster'. The success of this and his subsequent films: ET, Third Encounters of the Close Kind and Raiders of the Lost Ark earned Spielberg the title of the biggest movie director in the world. Each of these films were stunningly well-made, could be enjoyed by audiences of all ages and backgrounds and were generally fantastical adventure movies. What They Did Next This all changed with The Colour Purple. While his reputation had been built on big-budget, family-friendly fun, here was a director engaging with grim social realities such as racism and incest. The Colour Purple urged people to think hard, and was politically charged. It was a success. Not the Jaws or ET sort of success, but it earned good money from theatre-goers and was nominated for 11 Academy Awards (winning none, incidentally). The acceptance of this change of direction urged Spielberg to try out new ideas. He didn't completely abandon the blockbuster, as Jurassic Park can attest, but the tone of his overall output changed to include more social themes. The release of Empire of the Sun, an adaptation of the JG Ballard novel soon appeared, and a run of films focusing specifically on the horrors of WWII would follow, including Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan. It all sprung from this.

7. Martin Scorsese - The King of Comedy

How They Became Famous There is a certain style of film-making viewers associate with Martin Scorsese, and it prevails to this day. Gangsters, anti-heroes, New York, extreme violence, a distinctive, retro sountrack. The list goes on. Scorsese is also know for his collaborations with Hollywood royalty such as Joe Pesci, Leonardo Di Caprio and most famously, Robert De Niro. His first big success, Mean Streets, included all of the above features: mobsters in New York, The Ronettes and De Niro all combining to make a distinctively Scorsese picture. This was followed by the gritty Taxi Driver and the abrasive Raging Bull, all dark, serious, dramatic films based around loner male-protagonists. What They Did Next Scorsese made a comedy. And to this day it stands out from his overall output. The King of Comedy was the director's first foray into an entirely new movie genre, and it was far from a complete success. While reasonably well-received by critics, it was a massive commercial failure. De Niro would blame this on the subject matter, but it was probably due to audience expectations. They didn't know what to do with a comedy directed by Martin Scorsese. Ultimately the film wasn't as big a departure as it may initially have seemed. Sure it was a comedy, but it was still based in New York. Robert De Niro continued his association with Scorsese, reprising the role of a psychopath once more only with a slightly different overall tone. It was very much a comedy made on the director's terms and how the director imagined it to be, rather than a pandering to convention.

6. James Whale - Frankenstein

How They Became Famous Whale made his name as a director on the London stage. His first major success came with the unknown RC Sheriff play Journey's End. Under the direction of Whale, the play became an instant classic and an important reflection on the futility of war and the needless loss of innocent lives. The director also introduced the world to a certain Laurence Olivier, as leading man Stanhope. Following the success of the play, it was expected Whale would continue in the vein of a well-respected theatrical director. What They Did Next His next move was one of the most unusual in the history of cinema. In the 1930s cinema was not a respected art form, certainly not in comparison to dramatic theatre. Surprisingly Whale left behind the West End for the cheap glamour of Hollywood. Even more unusual was his choice of first feature film. Frankenstein may have been taken from Mary Shelley's classic novel, but it was essentially a monster flick. An extremely successful one, but a monster flick all the same. A movie based on scaring its audience was the last thing expected of a respected man of the theatre, but it wasn't a one-off done for a quick buck. It turned out Whale had a talent for horror films, and it was a genre he would stick with for much of his career. He directed a number of Frankenstein sequels, including the acclaimed The Bride of Frankenstein, as well as The Invisible Man, before his career took a nose-dive in the 1940s.

5. Alfred Hitchcock - Frenzy

How They Became Famous Alfred Hitchcock will forever be tied to one particular type of cinema. The suspense thriller. But it is more than a film genre he has become associated with, it is a feeling or technique, a sense of dread that has since been termed 'Hitchcockian'. The term can be dropped into conversation with any film lover and they'll know basically what you're talking about. The effect depended on an editing technique which cut away from extreme violence in imaginative ways, leaving the true horror of what was happening in the film to play out in the viewer's imagination, rather than on screen. This was exemplified in Psycho, a horror movie which includes the murder of several different characters without technically showing any violence, while still leaving the audience in no doubt as to what had happened. What They Did Next Hitchcock had built a career on this technique, if not in Psycho, then in more suspenseful pieces such as Vertigo and Rear Window. Frenzy, however, was a complete departure, or rather, an abandonment of these principles. While Hitch had spent decades criticizing directors for gratuitous sex and violence this film released towards the end of his career in 1972 was gritty and brutal, as the title suggests. Every act of sex or violence appeared on screen for the first time in the director's career. It was by no means a bad movie, but it paled in comparison to Vertigo, North By Northwest and Psycho. Whether it was late-career experimentation, or a final effort to regain relevance in an increasingly violent, 70s cinematic landscape is difficult to say.

4. Peter Jackson - Lord Of The Rings Trilogy

How They Became Famous Well technically, this director didn't become famous until Lord of the Rings. Before those films, he was perhaps best known for a handful of comedy-horror films which fitted very comfortably into the B-movie category. Bad Taste and Dead Alive, directed in 1987 and 1992 respectively, mixed cartoonish gore with dark comedy. Bad Taste revolves around a village invaded by aliens wearing massive prosthetic heads. What They Did Next Directed and produced one of the best known, highest-grossing, critically acclaimed movie franchises of all time. There was enormous buzz around the release of LOTRs at the time, but much confusion as to the history of its director. Prospective audiences and critics were confused that such a big budget had been handed over to a director with such a low profile. They needn't have worried so much. The films were praised throughout the film world and take their place today among the greatest films ever made. Jackson is yet to convincingly repeat the trick though. Since the LOTRs he has directed the bloated, disappointing King Kong, which again utilised CGI impressively, but failed in almost every other area. Perhaps more comfortable in the Lord of the Rings universe, he returned to familiar subject matter with The Hobbit trilogy, and though extremely popular, these films have not had the same impact as his previous work.

3. Robert Wise - West Side Story

How They Became Famous It might surprise readers to know Robert Wise had his first taste of success as a B-movie sci-fi director. He was originally best known for making the sci-fi classic The Day the Earth Stood Still, a movie which was a huge hit at drive-ins, revolving around the tale of an alien sent to Earth to warn mankind of his impending doom, due to his danger to other planets in the universe. After this film, Wise branched out, taking in a few film-noirs and a handful of comedies along the way, each receiving a relatively lukewarm reception. What They Did Next In 1961 Wise directed West Side Story, a musical, and a smash international hit. It's not that Wise had become especially known for one type of cinema, it's just that musicals are quite an esoteric genre, and the success of the film was huge. At the 1961 Academy Awards it picked up 10 Oscar's - still the most ever for a musical - including two for Wise as producer and director. He repeated the trick again with The Sound of Music just four years later. Another musical which remains one of the most successful and recognizable films of all time.

2. Charlie Chaplin - The Great Dictator

How They Became Famous Charlie Chaplin was born in England but made his most famous films in Hollywood, eventually becoming an American citizen. Chaplin was the highest earning and most recognizable actor in all of cinema from the 1910s through to the 1930s. His fame centred on a physical, slap-stick comedy style, and an uncanny ability to make us empathise with his characters without words. Comedy in silent cinema was quickly mastered by Chaplin, and though his popularity began to diminish into the 1930s after the advent of sound, his genius did not - City Lights and Modern Times two films which provide emphatic evidence of this. What They Did Next Though he clung on for as long as possible, the silent film had had its day by the late 1930s. A final swansong was planned to be The Great Dictator, a passionate critique of the Hitler-Germany regime in Europe and all dictators in general. Like all Chaplin films it was very good and very, very funny. What was an extraordinary departure in this movie, however, was that Chaplin actually spoke. Just once, and only briefly, but he looked into the camera and delivered lines. What's more remarkable is the content of his speech, now one of the most famous in cinema, as he rallies his audience against injustice and political despots. Totally sincere, and still memorable to this day.

1. Alfred Hitchcock - Psycho

How They Became Famous You might have that thought Hitchcock was covered earlier, but he deserves another entry on our list, and comes out at number 1 no less. In 1960 Hitchcock was among the most acclaimed directors in world cinema. An extremely talented technician who, importantly, could deliver his studio a profit. North By Northwest, Dial M for Murder and Rear Window had all come in under-budget, on time and delivered big profits. What's more they also included instantly recognizable Hollywood talent, such as James Stewart, Cary Grant and Grace Kelly. Hitchcock himself was a bankable star, and placing him in charge as director effectively guaranteed its success. What They Did Next Directing a horror movie was an extremely bold choice for all sorts of reasons. This was no by-the-numbers horror. It was dark, perverse and extremely violent. Unusually budget was a problem. Not because it was too big, but rather because it was too small. The studio refused to believe something created so cheaply could attract an audience. The film would have no major stars, save Janet Leigh. The director self-funded the project and placed his money and reputation on the line. In making the film he tore up the rule book. He killed off the main protagonist halfway through the film, included the sort of material reserved for B movies in a mainstream picture for the first time and created a new type of horror - the slasher. After all of this he was rewarded with one of the biggest film successes of all time - the movie earned more than fifty times its original expenditure. Film-making was changed forever, but it had been a risky undertaking.