10 Movie Characters Killed In Reshoots

These characters met an unexpected end during post-production.

By Jack Pooley /

Reshoots are often seen as a dirty word among moviegoers, but if you know much about the film industry you'll appreciate that they're essentially baked into every blockbuster schedule these days, and rarely mean a production is doomed in and of itself.

Advertisement

A lot can change in reshoots after a film has been shown to ever-nebulous test audiences, whose feedback will decide whether or not the film needs re-edits or new material shot.

Reshoots have saved countless movies and characters over the years, but they've also been used to kill off characters who were originally intended to survive.

These 10 movie characters, whether hero or villain, were all written to survive in the original script and made it through principal photography in one piece, only to be killed off in post-production.

The possible reasons are endless: perhaps test audiences just straight-up hated the character and wished them dead, maybe the movie needed another death scene to spice things up a little, or the actor's unavailability for reshoots caused them to be killed off-screen.

In some cases it was definitely a good call, while in others it was absolutely a mistake to kill these great characters...

10. Dr. Susan McCallister - Deep Blue Sea

During the original shoot of classic shark B-movie Deep Blue Sea, apparent protagonist Dr. Susan McCallister (Saffron Burrows) made it to the end alive, but when Warner Bros. test-screened the film they discovered a surprising reaction they hadn't accounted for.

Advertisement

As it turns out, test audiences absolutely loathed Susan, seeing her as chiefly responsible for the genetically engineered sharks running amok throughout the underwater research facility.

These audiences desperately wanted to see Susan pay for her runaway ambition in the most ultimate way. According to director Renny Harlin, one of the test screening feedback forms simply said of Susan, "Kill the b*tch!"

And so a brief reshoot was conducted in which Susan is brutally devoured by a shark.

Harlin also claims that he cut some of Susan's more sympathetic moments throughout the film to make her seem even more icy and ensure her death was even more cathartic for the audience.

It's a genuinely shocking moment, honestly, and oh so satisfying.

9. Max Neurick - I Know What You Did Last Summer

Johnny Galecki has a small role in I Know What You Did Last Summer as protagonist Julie James' (Jennifer Love Hewitt) friend Max Neurick, who becomes an early suspect for the figure terrorising Julie and her ill-fated friends.

Advertisement

Originally this suspicion is as far as things went, but when the film was test screened director Jim Gillespie realised that there was a massive lack of violence in the movie's first half following the initial fatal car accident, and that the hook-wielding killer hadn't been established as a serious threat.

And so Gillespie decided to shoot an additional scene with Galecki where Max is brutally murdered in the first act, when the killer impales him through the throat with their hook.

Considering it's a further 35 minutes before the next death, it was most certainly a smart call, ensuring the gore-hounds didn't get too restless,

Gillespie further said that killing Max at the end of the first act bought him more time to tell a story and not worry about the long chasm of time without a death. You can't fault the logic.

8. Val - Solo: A Star Wars Story

This is an interesting one that's a little different than the other reshoots on this list.

Advertisement

Thandiwe Newton appears in Solo: A Star Wars Story as criminal Tobias Beckett's (Woody Harrelson) wife Val, and ends up sacrificing herself to help Tobias, Han (Alden Ehrenreich) and co. escape, blowing herself up during their botched coaxium heist.

Yet Val's death wasn't actually part of the script at all, and only came about due to an estimated 70% of the film being reshot by Ron Howard after Phil Lord and Chris Miller exited the project mid-production.

When Howard was speeding through the reshoots, it was decided that there wasn't time to film Val's original scene, where she would fall into the vacuum of space during the heist, leaving her fate ambiguous.

Instead, it was deemed simpler to just kill her off at the conclusion of the coaxium heist, and that was that.

Newton recently expressed vocal disapproval of the decision to kill off the first major Black female character in a Star Wars movie so hastily. Considering she signed up for a different final scene that would've allowed her to return in a sequel, can you really blame her?

7. Dr. Loomis - Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers

If you know anything at all about the sixth Halloween film, The Curse of Michael Myers, you'll be aware that its production was a big 'ol mess, with the original cut being received disastrously by test audiences.

Advertisement

The original version of the film, now referred to as the Producer's Cut, saw Michael Myers (George P. Wilbur) pass the Curse of Thorn - the curse which drives him to kill - to his long-time nemesis, Dr. Loomis (Donald Pleasence).

However, this cut of the movie was excoriated by test audiences, reportedly said to consist primarily of teenage boys, and so a round of extensive reshoots was conducted many months later.

Sadly by this time the great Donald Pleasence had passed away, and so the production was at something of a loss when deciding an alternate fate for his character.

As a result, Loomis semi-randomly disappears out of the film at regular intervals, and one of the new scenes concocted in reshoots was the very final scene, where we linger on a shot of Michael's mask as Loomis can be heard screaming in the background.

The implication is very clearly that Michael kills Loomis, even if it's unavoidably unsatisfying that we never actually see this due to Pleasence's passing. It's certainly a damn sight better than having him be possessed, though.

6. All The Remaining Survivors - Dawn Of The Dead (2004)

Zack Snyder's surprisingly great Dawn of the Dead remake originally ended with the survivors fleeing Milwaukee on a yacht as the infected Michael (Jake Weber) stays behind and shoots himself in the head.

Advertisement

Test audiences found this ending too jarringly abrupt, though, and so Snyder decided to shoot a found footage-style segment to be tacked onto the movie's end credits.

While principal photography took place in Toronto, this sequence was shot in California, and depicted the survivors running out of supplies, riding their yacht to an island, and being overrun by zombies.

At the end of the sequence the camcorder drops to the floor, and while we don't explicitly see the heroes die, the implication is incredibly clear.

It would've been nigh-on impossible for the resource-strapped survivors to fend off such a large horde of the undead, and so anyone who stuck around for the credits got a decidedly bleaker ending than those who booked it as soon as they started rolling.

5. Max & Elise - Suicide Kings

1997's cult crime comedy Suicide Kings follows a group of young men who kidnap a former mobster, Charlie Barret (Christopher Walken), in an attempt to fund the ransom for one of their kidnapper sisters, Elise (Laura Harris).

Advertisement

At the end of the movie, however, it's revealed that one of the young men, Max (Sean Patrick Flanery), was in on Elise's kidnap from the start, and better yet, both he and Elise set the whole thing up to claim her ransom for themselves.

The film ends with Charlie tracking the pair down and having his bodyguard, Lono (Denis Leary), shoot them both dead. This was actually a reshoot, however, as two previously shot endings didn't go down well at all with test audiences.

One ending saw Charlie let the couple live but taking most of their scammed money back, and in the other Lono shot holes in their boat, leaving it to sink.

Test audiences felt strongly that the couple deserved to perish for their sins, and so director Peter O'Fallon went back to shoot this more gratifying addendum.

4. Rick Johnson - A Nightmare On Elm Street 4: The Dream Master

The Nightmare on Elm Street franchise is full of creatively bizarre and disarming death scenes, though one of the low-key weirdest is that of Rick Johnson (Andras Jones) in the fourth movie, The Dream Master.

Advertisement

Later in the film, Rick has a dream where an invisible Freddy (Robert Englund) attacks him at a dojo. Rick, being a martial arts enthusiast, puts up a solid fight, though after knocking Freddy's glove off his hand the glove levitates and flies into his chest, stabbing him to death.

Fascinatingly, there's a very specific reason that Freddy is invisible in this scene - Rick's death was a last-minute decision added during reshoots, and because Robert Englund wasn't available, the creative call was made to have Freddy be invisible.

Thankfully the fantastical nature of the various dream sequences have always given the series a ton of latitude for improvisation, and so Rick's death actually fits perfectly into the fabric of the story, much as we might all miss Freddy's visible presence.

3. Fred Wilson - King Kong (1976)

In the 1976 King Kong remake, the primary antagonist is Fred Wilson, the greedy oil magnate ultimately responsible for Kong's rampage through New York City, as played so deliciously by the late, great Charles Grodin.

Advertisement

Wilson ends up getting his satisfying comeuppance when Kong breaks loose during the film's climax. Wilson trips over and is stepped on by Kong, killing him instantly.

However, Grodin has confirmed in interviews that Wilson was originally supposed to survive the events of the film, but once test audiences got their oar in and demanded justice, a small additional beat of him being stepped on was shot.

This is definitely a case where test audiences were right - seeing Wilson get stomped flat is enormously cathartic given his avaricious, selfish, and reckless actions throughout the movie.

2. El Diablo - Suicide Squad

It's no secret at all what a mess Suicide Squad's production was, with Warner Bros. heavily tinkering with the ensemble superhero epic during post-production.

Advertisement

Of the many head-scratching decisions made in post, though, the oddest might be killing off one of the more likeable and interesting lower-tier Squad members, El Diablo (Jay Hernandez).

Diablo perishes in the final battle against Incubus (Alain Chanoine) and his sister Enchantress (Cara Delevingne), sacrificing himself to keep Incubus in place when a bomb explodes, annihilating them both.

But back in 2020, director David Ayer confirmed on Twitter that Diablo originally survived the climax and his death was consequently added in reshoots.

Considering Diablo's tricky, intriguing character arc - having accidentally killed his family by losing control of his pyrokinetic powers - defeating Incubus could've been a much-needed moment of redemption for him.

And yet evidently somebody - whether Ayer or Warner Bros. - felt he needed to die for his prior sins. It's just one of Suicide Squad's many, many mistakes.

1. Robert Neville - I Am Legend

15 years later, this one still pisses a lot of people off.

Advertisement

I Am Legend is a mostly terrific post-apocalyptic thriller in which a virologist, Robert Neville (Will Smith), is apparently the only remaining human on Earth.

He's pursued throughout the film by cannibalistic mutants known as the Darkseekers, and at the end of the story Neville sacrifices himself, running towards the attacking Darkseekers while holding a live grenade in order to preserve a cure he thought they were about to destroy.

This was a reshoot, though, and deviated significantly from the ending of Richard Matheson's original book.

Test audiences hated the more source-faithful original ending, where Neville realises that the Darkseekers are more intelligent and emotionally engaged than he believed, and that they view him as a monster for his experiments upon them.

It's a brilliantly contemplative ending, and predictably one that unimaginative test audiences recoiled at for its thoughtfulness and moral ambiguity. Instead, they made poor Francis Lawrence shoot a new ending with more bang-bang 'splosions.

Advertisement