10 Movie Murders That Were Utterly Impossible To Solve

Whodunit? Not a clue.

By Tom Baker /

The structure of the whodunit was cemented, if not entirely created, by Agatha Christie. The mystery writer par excellence penned 66 detective novels and twelve short stories in her lifetime, and regardless of whether they starred the deceptively doddering Miss Marple or the magnificently moustachioed Hercule Poirot, they tended to follow a similar formula: a murder, a murder scene, and a whole police line-up's worth of suspects, of which the sleuth at the centre had to accuse of the crime. The genius of Christie's work was that she gave the readers just enough to, potentially, solve the mystery themselves. It's an approach which has permeated murder mysteries in all forms since. Part of the fun is not just seeing the genius detective unravel the case, but also to try and figure things out yourself. Not quite in a "Choose Your Own Adventure" sort of way, but close. It's a fun extra level to the escapism afforded by fiction, as audiences get a chance at doing something they'd never get to in their real lives - namely, solving a homicide. Which is a pleasure that, increasingly, films are robbing people of. There are plenty of cinematic crimes that follow the Christie formula, and are similarly enjoyable. But there's been plenty of big screen deaths that viewers didn't have a chance of figuring out. Unforeseen twist endings, badly-plotted cases, or unanswered questions all figure into the ten movie murders that were impossible to solve.

10. The Life Of David Gale

When he's not screaming bloody murder at theatre-goers who forget to turn their phones off, Kevin Spacey has been carving out quite the niche as the go-to guy for creepy criminal types whose motives (or indeed, entire identities) are kept a secret until the final reel. Which is all well and good for a shocking twist ending, but can leave audiences feeling more than a little cheated when they've been following what was previously a fairly reasonable whodunit, only for them to have the rug pulled out from under them right at the end. That's what happened with The Life Of David Gale, a Spacey joint that had no less than Roger Ebert spitting with rage. The unfortunate swansong of veteran director Alan Parker (Bugsy Malone, Midnight Express - interesting dude), The Life Of David Gale sees the Kevster starring as the titular opponent of the death penalty who, rather ironically, ends up on death row after being framed for rape and then murder. Who was actually responsible for the murder of Laura Linney, though? Kate Winslet's curious journalist Bitsey Bloom discovers it was...suicide! Except Spacey already got executed. Whoops. End of film, right? Nope, turns out Spacey was responsible for the "suicide", and it was all a ploy to show how innocent men can get the death sentence. Both twists came from nowhere and made Ebert "want to throw something at the screen - maybe Spacey and Parker."

9. Se7en

Spacey is a bugger for this last minute twists. His appearance in David Fincher's first bonafide classic Se7en, that darkest of serial killer movies, was a surprise to everyone - the star actor's name wasn't included in any promotion for the film, and is absent from those haunting opening credits to boot. Which makes it all the more frustrating, watching the investigations of Brad Pitt's Detective Mills and Morgan Freeman's Somerset into a series of murders that follow the Biblical Seven Deadly Sins, and they don't actually solve it. The answer falls into their laps, as Spacey's John Doe surrenders to the police. It's all part of his plan... Obviously, you're not supposed to solve the mystery in Se7en. The film turns the traditional whodunit narrative on its head, because it isn't a whodunit - it's debatable as to what it actually is. A darker-than-dark thriller? A horror film? Some sort of psychological torture? The confusion that follows the investigation and the subsequent surrender is mirrored with the audience's reaction, since they can make as much sense of the murders and Doe's sudden appearance as Mills and Somerset do. There are barely even any suspects until he shows up, bleeding from the fingertips, at the police station. Se7en is about as far away from Miss Marple as you can get, in every conceivable way.

8. Taking Lives

The former part of the Braneglina couple doesn't get all the fun when it comes to impossible murder mysteries, mind. Angelina Jolie has appeared in her fair share of whodunits, too, and most of them are of the sort where nobody could possibly figure them out with the clues dropped throughout the films' running times. In fact, there are times in 2004's Taking Lives where it's not clear that the screenwriter necessarily knew what the eventual end to the mystery was, since he was busy imagining the steamy love scenes between Jolie's FBI profiler and Ethan Hawke's witness to a murder. Who, it turns out, might be the next victim. Gulp! Okay, so the big twist in this one might not be totally out of the blue. The film opens with a prologue where a couple of teenage hitchikers make pals on a bus, one comments on their similar height and then pushes the other into oncoming traffic, stealing his identity. The murderer is the same Jolie is later hunting, and whom Hawke's art collector claims to have seen doing another of his bad deeds, only for - wait! - Hawke to turn out to be the murderer all along! This one's different because the film is so clearly foreshadowing this reveal that, watching it, viewers assume it's a red herring. Surely they wouldn't signpost such an obvious twist? But they are. It's either a smart double bluff, or a stupid film. It's the latter.

7. Basic

John McTiernan has not made a film since this 2003 stinker. The director of such hits as Die Hard and Predator has been barred from taking another trip behind the camera, which is either something to do with the quality of this outing, or the fact that he was arrested on some complicated conspiracy charges by the FBI. Maybe a mix of both... Anyway, the film follows a very familiar whodunit structure, albeit in the form of a war movie instead of your usual crime thriller: a team of Army Rangers engage in a training exercise using live ammunition, and a bunch of them wind up dead. John Travolta is a DEA interrogator brought in to get to the bottom of things. From there, each suspect tells his story, Rashomon-style. Travolta - and by extension, the audience - has to decide how to believe. It's a daring attempt at updating the Christie approach, even down to a variation on the "gathering the suspects in the drawing room and revealing the identity of the killer" thing at the end. Except, well, that was all a total fake out. A bait-and-switch. Basic acts like you can figure out the mystery, before revealing at the end that the soldiers were actually a black-ops anti-drug unit, which involves faking a bunch of deaths, killing off some bad 'uns covertly, and the reveal that Travolta was in on the whole thing. Insultingly stupid, especially when the audience thinks they were on the level.

6. The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo

Stieg Laarson was, apparently, a big Agatha Christie fan. You can see why a man who dealt with actual right wing psychopaths in his day job as an investigative journalist would find reading fictional murder mysteries relaxing, let alone inspiring - published after his untimely death, the Millenium series of novels wound up being some of the most wildly popular whodunits of the modern era. Naturally they'd make the leap to the big screen, first in a series adapted in his native Sweden, and then in an English-language remake again helmed by that scamp David Fincher. Oh and the mystery at the heart of the first of those novels and subsequent big screen iteration is absolutely impossible for the audience to solve, since the books and films in question seem barely bothered about solving it themselves. Both versions of The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, but each also inherits a significant drawback from the source material. It's possible that audiences might've figured out the murderous secret of Martin, the brother of the missing girl Henrik Vanger hires antisocial hacker Lisbeth Salander and Mary Sue insert character Mikael Blomkvist to solve. There's absolutely no way they'd've pieced together what actually happened to Harriet, Henrik's grandniece, since even Martin doesn't know where she buggered off to. He's busy carrying on his father's legacy as a serial killer. And it seems that Laarson might've been more interested in that "mystery" instead of the one the story actually hang off.

5. The Million Dollar Hotel

It's not only your iTunes that U2 like to stick their noses into uninvited. Back in 1987 the bespectacled bellend Bono apparently had the bright idea for a murder mystery film and, over a decade later, he somehow managed to convince respected art house director Wim Wenders to make his dream a reality, the singer himself teaming with one Nicholas Klein on the script. The result is a movie that star and noted anti-Semite Mel Gibson referred to as "as boring as a dog's ass" whilst promoting it, and which involves Gibson's FBI agent being brought in to look into the mysterious death of the son of a billionaire media mogul, played by Tim Roth, at the titular hotel. And it is really boring. And stupid. Gibson's introduced to the colourful inhabitants of the hotel, whose name turns out to be ironic - it's a total skid row-style establishment, full of a bunch of weirdos, including Peter Stromare as a nutball who thinks he's the Fifth Beatle and has been awaiting a flurry of royalty payments since the end of the sixties. Whilst he looks into the death of Roth's Izzy the rest of the hotel plot to sell off a particularly valuable painting the victim owned, hopefully getting them out of the hellhole they call home. In fact the investigation takes a back seat to profiling the eccentricities of the residents, so when it turns out that Izzy killed himself at the end, you can barely bring yourself to care.

4. Mindhunters

John McTiernan hasn't made films in a decade because he was locked up in an actual prison. Renny Harlin, who helmed Die Hard 2: Die Harder, spent about as long in the metaphorical "Hollywood Jail" after his big budget gamble Cuthroat Island was a total bust, and studios didn't wanna take another chance on the risky filmmaker for a good long while. Finally he made his comeback at the turn of the new millennium, principally with the ridiculous psychological thriller Mindhunters, which was blessed with an interesting cast - Johnny Lee Miller, Val Kilmer, erm, LL Cool J - with one of the most ridiculous whodunit plots ever committed to paper. By a writer who was presumably, later, committed. Mindhunters sees a bunch of wannabe FBI profilers fresh out of the academy put on a deserted island, with a mock town, where they have to figure out the identity of a fictional serial killer. Except then somebody starts to actually bump off the rookies! There's an actual murderer on the island! And it has to be one of them, because the island is otherwise empty! There are any number of ridiculous methods of death throughout the film - seriously, Jigaw should be taking notes - but worst of all is the eventual reveal of the killer, which makes no sense based on...like, basic logic.

3. The Bone Collector

Angelina Jolie, as promised, makes her second appearance on the list with a film that actually has an interesting premise on the surface. Denzel Washington plays a brilliant forensic scientist rendered bed bound by a car accident, who guides Jolie's rookie cop as they try to solve a string of murders all connected one thing: a single shard of bone is removed from each of the victims. The Bone Collector is the eponymous killer, and the dynamic of Denzel safe and sound in his bed, with Queen Latifah's nurse looking after him, whilst Jolie throws her into constant danger at every turn is a fun one. Shame the actual mystery that they're solving doesn't make any sense. There are a handful of clues presented to the audience throughout the film hinting at the killer's identity, including the fact that he poses for a while as a taxi driver to select his victims. Ah, but what if he's actually a taxi driver all along? Double bluff! Nope, turns out that all along he was a character that was barely seen on screen until the last minute twist, where it turns out he's the medical technician who cares for Washington's medical equipment, who also used to work in forensics but was struck off because Denzel testified against him for faking evidence. Yep: not that that explains why he killed all those other people, or was possible for audiences to figure out themselves...

2. Identity

The grand daddy of cheap twist endings in whodunits absolutely has to be this 2003 film which purported to be a loose adaptation of Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None (the one that used to have a super racist title before cooler, less prejudiced heads prevailed), except instead of taking the incredibly complex but compelling explanation of that murdery mystery, Identity came up with its own. And it was terrible. And it made audiences wonder why John Cusack would possibly agree to be involved in such an idiotic film. Ray Liotta, less surprising. Ten strangers find themselves stranded in the middle of a torrential rainstorm at a remote Nevada motel, and weird stuff starts happening. Concurrently, convicted murderer Malcolm Rivers awaits execution on death row. Throughout the plot of the ten strangers being slowly but surely bumped off you keep expecting it to somehow get tied into the Rivers story and, eventually, it does - albeit in the worst way possible. For the majority of the running time it genuinely seems like any of the characters could be the killer, as Identity constantly keeps audiences on their toes; only to squander that whole thing by revealing that all the stuff with the motel is happening in the head of Rivers. He has multiple personalities, you see. So you just wasted ninety minutes trying to figure out the killer, and he never existed. Bleh.

1. Zodiac

At this point we're getting a little sick of David Fincher's shenanigans. The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo was an adaptation of a novel and Se7en came from a script by Andrew Kevin Walker, but Zodiac was his baby. This time he was entirely responsible for crafting a movie murder mystery that was absolutely impossible to solve, because whilst the audience certainly got a lot of evidence with which to figure out who the titular killer was, they never get to find out if their pet theory was correct €“ because, at the film's end, it's not revealed who the Zodiac killer is. What a cop out! Obviously, like Se7en, that's kind of the point. And it's also just in keeping with the real-life story of the Zodiac killer, who is still at large for all we know. That's pretty scary. Along with being incredibly frustrating because, after investing an epic three hours in Fincher's painstaking recreation of the investigations carried out by both the police and amateur sleuth/crossword composer Robert Graysmith, you want answers. But they're not forthcoming. Which, again, does a pretty good job of emulating the feelings of Graysmith and co themselves. They never got closure, so why should you? Because you paid good money, dammit, and a whodunit is supposed to not only give audiences a chance at unravelling it, but also have an ending. Except life doesn't work that way, does it? Which other impossible movie murder do you think deserve mention on this list? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.