10 Movie Ratings IMDB Got Horribly Wrong

By Jacob Savill /

Whilst I admit I am a regular consultant to the IMDB website, I've always thought that several of its members don't always know what they're talking about when it comes to rating films. It seems like users frequently jump onto the bandwagon when writing their reviews, rather than voicing their own opinions on a film. As a result of this, the IMDB Top 250, a previously reliable list, is now inundated with a huge quantity of mediocre, run-of-the-mill movies which will long be forgotten in the annals of history. You may say that these ratings are down to nothing more than personal opinion and thus I am being harsh in criticizing them, however over the years this website has held host to a multitude of ridiculous movie ratings that only the minority agree with. I've particularly detected that the website tends to heavily overrate any movie made my Christopher Nolan or Quentin Tarantino, regardless of its stature, and as far as IMDB is concerned, this duo can do no wrong. The users of IMDB have also demonstrated the potential to completely disregard top quality films and modern greats, even though their brilliance is blindingly blatant to the masses. So in this list, I'm going to work my way through 10 movies in particular, which I believe to have been either completely overrated or underrated by the (at times) ignorant users of IMDB. Furthermore, for each movie I will state my own personal rating, so you can grasp how poorly I think these movies have been valued.

10. Titanic (7.6)

I don't know what it is about Titanic, but it's just one of those movies that everybody loves to hate. It's often overly critiqued for its excessive length, over sentimental plotline, and its historical inaccuracies. But it seems to me like everyone just wants to jump onto the "let's hate Titanic" bandwagon without providing any valid reasons as to why. Sadly these days, it is highly dangerous for any well-respected man to state in public that he "enjoyed Titanic," for he is at risk of being labelled a pathetic and mawkish loser. But, if we rewind the clocks back to 1997 and to the film's immediate release, I'm sure you'll recall it was welcomed with widespread critical acclaim and public support; In fact it swiftly became the most popular movie of all time. So why the change of heart? There has to be a reason as to why Titanic walked away with all those Oscars back in 1997. The reason? It is a great movie. Whilst I admit the storyline may be rather clichéd at points, the movie remains to this day one of only three that has ever made me reach for the tissue box in the cinema. (The others being Bambi and Castaway.) The story comes to life through two remarkable leading performances by Kate Winslet and Di Caprio, and these are given strong support by some of the most superb visual effects of the day. But, the real Tour-de-force of this movie has to be the music. Celine Dion's "My Heart Will Go On" is an absolute cinematic triumph and to this day, it should be considered the greatest film music of all time. As far as I'm concerned, it really is a titanic error on behalf of the IMDB users that this film isn't even represented on the IMDB Top 250 and is rated a measly 7.6. My Rating: 8.3

9. Inception (8.8)

I had only heard great things about this movie. In fact, a few weeks after its release, the IMDB users recognized Inception as the 3rd best movie ever made, with a rating of 9.0. The main reason behind this, was that it was released at the absolute zenith of Christopher Nolan hype (a year after the release of The Dark Knight) and so when I rented it on DVD last year, my expectations were about as high as they could be. Whilst I concede that the movie was a highy creative and inventive picture, and as much as I think Christopher Nolan deserves the utmost praise for his storyline and directing, I still believe it has been hyped beyond all proportion by Nolan fans. The simple problem with this movie, is that you have no idea what the hell is going on. The non linear structure and unbelievably convolated storyline had me confused from the get-go and I'm afraid to say, that never changed. And as much as I appreciated the spectacular visual effects and solid acting from the impressive cast, I have trouble enjoying a movie if I don't understand it. By the end, it left me with so many questions. Was it a dream? Was it a dream about a dream? Or was it a parallel universe where people dream they're dreaming about a parallel universe? I mean sooner or later you just cease to care about the plot whatsoever and just recline in your chair, devouring the iconic set pieces. Unfortunately, this is not the insignia of a great movie. But overall, I feel the movie and its director do deserve praise in abundance for its originality, that being why I feel it deserves an 8.0 rating. However at the moment, IMDB have this film rated on par with modern greats such as Goodfellas and One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest, and I'm afraid Inception isn't in the same league. My Rating: 8.0

8. Amelie (8.5)

I've never really had time for these style of films. Films that strive desperately to be as quirky and arty as possible have forever irritated me, and Amelie stands no different. After witnessing and just about coping with the first few minutes, it just becomes insufferably annoying to watch thereafter. Everything, from the exaggerated camera movements, pretentious interior monologues and over-grandiose cinematography, annoyed me to my very soul. I am of the belief that in cinema, there is a line between the stylish and the ridiculous and unfortunately, this movie crosses that line considerably. The main character Amelie, is chockfull of such artificial cuteness and humanity, that at times simply seeing her on the screen made me want to be physically sick. (No exaggeration). The ghastliest aspect of her character, has to be the creepy smiles she cracks to the camera from time to time. It's these uncessary features that make the movie come across as nothing but plain obnoxious. I know that as you read this, I may come across as a heartless chump and as a philistine to fine cinema, but I hope I'm not alone in the believe that to watch this histrionic piece of French cinema without cringing into the depths of your seat is an impossible task. It's hard to comprehend that the same users that gave Inception a ridiculous 8.8, can give this calamity of a movie an 8.5 and in the process, classify it as one of the top 50 films of all time, amongst the likes of Taxi Driver and Citizen Kane. My Rating: 7.2

7. Gone With The Wind (8.2)

Unfortunately I was forced upon this film by my Dad when it ill-fatedly appeared on Channel 4 over the Christmas period. After hearing all the flimflam that it's one of the best movies ever made, I was expecting/hoping to witness a classic movie. But regrettably, what I instead watched, was nothing of the sort. O.K I acknowledge, it was an alright movie. The acting was good, the sets, costumes and photography were all nicely done and to be fair, it had a decent story. However, I simply can't see past the fact that this is merely a chick flick of the '30s. And how it is considered today a timeless classic and one of the greatest cinematic achievements of all time I'll never know. As far as I'm concerned, it was dated, over melodramatic, extraordinarily dull and not to mention significantly too long. Fair enough, it did have a compelling storyline and did convey an important message about the devastation, hardship, and brutality of the Civil War, but for that, you can credit the novel not the film. In fact, the script definitely did its best to (and almost succeeded in) ruining this. You may think I'm being a little cruel seeing as it was released over 70 years ago, but in my opinion the true indication of a great film is that it is timeless. This film is by no means timeless. As I have already stated, it is no more than a mediocre and outdated chick flick of the 1930s, which has bizarrely been earmarked as one of the greatest movies ever made by the users of IMDB. My Rating: 7.0

6. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) (6.1)

The problem with this film is that it was always going to be compared to the 1974 original; a reputation there was no way it was ever going to live up to. However, despite falling short of the Tobe Hooper version, bad film this is not. One thing for sure is that it definitely does not warrant an exceedingly stingy 6.1 rating which it has been endowed by the IMDB users. People have criticized the movie for its over excessive use of gore and its weaker storyline in comparison to the original, but I always think it courageous for a relatively new filmmaker to remake a real classic film of the past, and I personally feel Marcus Nispel did a decent job in recapturing that suspense that made the 1974 version such a hit. The cast, lead by Jessica Biel, is a very convincing one, and this helps to form the chilling atmosphere which is not always present in the modern horror movie. As expected, the movie is dirty, brutal and gory; Not to mention the villain Leatherface is absolutely terrifying. (In fact, in my cinema two girls left the cinema in tears 2/3 of the way through because they couldn't stomach the gore.) Surely that is the reaction a horror movie is meant to provoke? So overall, Nispel could have done a lot worse with this remake, and by no means did he massacre the original. Obviously, he possessed the luxury of a much bigger budget and effects, but this didn't take away from the suspense or nightmarish atmosphere that was present under Hooper. Personally I believe that if this was a stand alone horror movie and not a remake, it would have been guaranteed at least a rating in the 7's by IMDB. My Rating: 7.4

5. War Of The Worlds (6.5)

I think the main rationale behind this low rating is simple. That is Steven Spielberg. Whilst this isn't a bad movie by any stretch, people were simply envisaging more from such an iconic filmmaker. People wanted something of the same calibre as E.T or Jurassic Park. People were expecting a revolutionary sci-fi epic that would transform the face of film forever. Spielberg didn't deliver on this. But what people fail to fathom is that The War Of The Worlds is still a highly engaging and impressive big-budget summer blockbuster, and it notably succeeds in avoiding every alien invasion cliché out there. This isn't easy to do. The greatest achievement of this film in my opinion, is that it never gets preoccupied by the alien invasion itself. Spielberg skilfully focuses the narrative on Ray Ferrier and his family, and whilst the destruction and invasion whir on in the background, it never dominates the screentime. In my view, this quality propels the movie above any other run-of-the-mill sci-fi picture out there. The brunt of the criticism has been aimed at the culmination of the film, and also at the physical appearance of the extra terrestrials themselves, but, whilst I confess the movie is not without its flaws, Spielberg still manages to deliver on the thrill and paranoia of HG Wells' classic novel and that definitely deserves some credit, of which he has not yet received. My Rating: 7.5

4. The Godfather (9.2)

Like many others, I've grown up hearing nothing but veneration for the Godfather. It is widely considered the best film of all time and currently sits second on the IMDB Top 250 behind The Shawshank Redemption. With a ridiculously high rating of 9.2, it was very difficult for me to watch this movie with an open mind. The glowing reviews it recieves pretty much everywhere, gives one extremely high expectations that you're about to watch one of the best movies ever made. I think its safe to say, I was expecting perfection. However sadly, after reflection I thought the Godfather to be nothing more than a "good" movie. It was worth watching. I was glad I'd seen it. But the greatest movie ever made? No. not by a long shot. The portrayal of mob life in post-war New York was very well presented by Coppola, and the performance of Marlon Brando as Don Corleone I have to say was nothing short of outstanding. Al Pacino and Robert Duvall were equally impressive in their more supportive roles and provided great backing to Brando. However, for all its positives, I thought the film went on far too long than was necessary and the fact that the pacing was so deliberately protracted, meant that I frequently found myself yawning and glancing at my watch. But as I said, it was not a bad movie, in fact it was enjoyable for the most part. Evidently, Coppola injected a great volume of skill and dedication into its making. And with good results. However in my opinion, a 9.2 rating it is not. I have definitely seen better and as much as people won't want to admit it, I'm sure many can agree with me on that. My Rating: 8.3

3. Million Dollar Baby (8.2)

If ever there was ever a movie "made-for-the-Oscars, " then this was it. I knew as soon it was released, that it was going to be the major Oscar contender of 2004. It features everything that the Academy has on its Oscar checklist; and in abundance: Clichés, patriotism, influential women and of course...it has Clint Eastwood. But, as history as proven, being Hollywood's Best Picture doesn't necessarily guarantee a great movie. In fact in my opinion, this will be the latest in a long line of Oscar winners that are bound to be forgotten in the annals of film history, (along with the likes of The Hurt Locker and Chicago.) The script was mediocre and over-clichéd, the acting was lethargic, (especially from Eastwood it has to be said), and the plot at times bordered on the ludicrious. I don't understand all the praise it has been recieving by renowned critics and IMDB users alike. It seems to me that people are too afraid to give it a bad review because Clint Eastwood is the Director and Star. What I found hilarious about the movie was how Maggie miraculously transforms from someone who doesn't know how to hit a speedbag, to someone who is suddenly ready for a shot at the world title after about half an hour screentime. In fact, I reckon if you combine all boxing sequences throughout, they'd probably only make up 15-20 minutes of the whole movie. The fact that it is considered a sports movie at all is indeed laughable, and so is its 8.2 rating! My Rating: 7.4

2. Castaway (7.6)

Castaway is a terribly misunderstood movie. Ever since I saw it last year it has immediately become one of my favourite movies of all time. I think it is a great triumph on the part of Robert Zemeckis that he successfully creates a timeless classic, with only one character on screen for the best part of 80 minutes. He efficaciously manages to elude all the survival movie clichés in the book and still effectively enthralls the audience for 2 and a half hours, with very little dialogue whatsoever. The film is centred upon two very impressive performances. One from Tom Hanks and the other, of course, from Wilson the Volleyball. (A stroke of genius on the part of Zemeckis for the inclusion of that character.) In fact, the scene in which Hanks loses Wilson to the ocean, moved me to tears more than any other. As many critics have suggested, the scenes of just Hanks on the island were by far the best scenes of the movie, but I feel that the last section of the film, much reviled by many, is still immensely touching. The premise of the ending was that Hanks had survived 5 years of utter isolation and solitude, he hopes finally to be reunited with his true love, his fiancé, only to find out that she has resigned him to death and that she is happily married. This was a much misunderstood section of the movie and a highly effectual finale in my view. I don't understand how this movie, the greatest survival movie of all time, can be considered a mere 7.6 on IMDB. For some reason, it's recognized as a lesser movie than the likes of Shaun of the Dead, Iron Man and The Terminator! Surely there's something wrong about that. My Rating: 8.5

1. The Dark Knight Rises (8.7)

Yet more Christopher Nolan hype. I personally found this movie extremely disappointing compared to the previous two installments. After the global success of the Dark Knight, (a movie I believe to be one of the best of all time,) I and a lot of others, were expecting another masterpiece from Nolan and a great conclusion to what has been an epic trilogy. But this we did not get. Batman Begins and The Dark Knight were essentiallly intricate works of genius, but this movie lacks everything that made these movies great. The only reason why everyone is waxing lyrical about it, is simply because they can't dare to criticize Christopher Nolan and his beloved Batman trilogy. For a start, the villain (Bane) is the most pathetic villain of any comic book film I've ever seen. He is a cardboard, unexplored character, and the scene at the end when he actually CRIES is just laughable. Can you imagine the Joker crying? Also, Bane's one on one encounters with The Batman were poorly choreographed and undramatic and they hardly involved anything but a few punches being swung. The introduction of Catwoman was a highly pointless inclusion by Nolan as she added nothing to the story whatsoever; her insertion seemed almost forced and weak. But for me, the worst aspect of this movie was that for a film that lasted nearly 3 hours, and I'd wager that there was less than 20 minutes of Bruce Wayne as Batman. Admittedly there are some impressive set pieces, (the American Football one springs to mind in particular,) but these aren't enough to save this movies from "massive disappointment" status. The 8.6 out of 10 rating seems laughable considering it is such an unoriginal, uninspiring blockbuster, that fails to deliver on almost every level. Again: I think the IMDB users are guilty of some serious bandwagoning when it came to rating this... My Rating: 7.8Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.