10 Movie Sequels That Failed To Recapture The Magic
It's always a shame to see something that started so sweet, turn so sour.
Movie Sequels are a wonderful thing. They provide filmmakers an opportunity to expand on their creations, bringing them to new levels with bigger budgets, and allowing fans to see more of what the love.
When done well, sequels offer new ideas that keep franchises fresh, while also enriching what came before. Take The Godfather: Part II, for example. It's regarded as a cinematic masterpiece and often ranks above its predecessor. It's not the only sequel that does so either. The Empire Strikes Back, The Dark Knight, and Spider-Man 2 all serve as other notable examples that build upon what came first and exceed fans' high expectations.
Of course, this is not always the case. Sometimes sequels can be rushed through production in order to quickly capitalise on the first film's success. They could be shameless cash grabs made with no love for the source material. There's also the possibility that the original simply set the bar too high and nothing could ever quite reach those same heights.
Whatever the reason, it's always a shame to see a promising franchise stumble at the second step, failing to recapture the magic that drew so many eyes in the first place.
10. American Psycho 2
If you consider yourself a fan of cult classic American Psycho, don't feel too bad if you've never heard of its sequel. It's probably for the best you haven't.
American Psycho released in 2000, based on the 1991 novel by the same name. At the time of release, it was polarising, with many criticising its violent nature and glorification of the despicable acts, while others praised it and Christian Bale's performance. Now, it's a firm fan favourite, the flick seemingly ageing like fine wine.
The same can't be said for the sequel that released in 2002. The film was doomed from the start, largely because it wasn't even supposed to be a sequel. Lionsgate sought to capitalise on the success of the original and decided to resurrect an unused and unrelated script, and transform it in to a follow-up. The title was changed from The Girl Who Wouldn't Die to American Psycho 2, and references to Patrick Bateman were shoehorned in throughout. It's sloppy and feels brute-forced, while also flying in the face of the original.
It's revealed in the first film that Bateman's supposed murders were just his sick fantasies, but this film paints him as an actual killer, throwing continuity out the window. Not even the combined star power of Mila Kunis and William Shatner is enough to salvage this movie, and it's better viewing American Psycho as a standalone feature.
9. Mean Girls 2
Sometimes, bringing in a new writer for a sequel can be a breath of fresh air. They bring in new ideas while never losing sight of the core themes and values that should be present. Other times, it's a sign that a movie is heading for the bargain bins.
Mean Girls 2 fits nicely in to the latter category. Tina Fey weaves her wit and comedy throughout the original, which is genuinely funny, even if you aren't a 16-year-old high-schooler engaged in clique warfare. The dialogue is also sincere and stellar acting from the whole cast result in a timeless coming of age movie that remains a staple at sleepovers, and a must watch every October 3rd.
Fey's absence is sorely missed in the sequel. It doesn't even feel like a sequel, more of a shoddy attempt at a remake with a new cast and a reduced budget. It replaces the clever comedy with toilet humour and gross-out gags, which struggle to raise even a smirk. The plot retreads the first film in a much less engaging way, and it fails to make any reasonable additions to the Mean Girls Cinematic Universe. If that even exists.
8. Space Jam: A New Legacy
The original Space Jam may not be a critically acclaimed cinematic masterpiece, but you'd be hard pressed to find someone that grew up in the 1990s who doesn't have some fond memories of it. Nostalgia could be a big part of that, and some of the jokes might not hold up, but Space Jam will forever hold a place in many people's hearts.
Unfortunately, this makes it difficult for fans to view Space Jam: A New Legacy with the same fondness. The rose-tinted glasses are off and the sequel seems more like a giant marketing stunt for both Warner Bros. and its live-action star, Lebron James. The characters and the acting are forgettable on the live-action front, and the Tune Squad don't do enough to carry the film.
While this criticism may feel overly harsh as the picture is targeted at a younger audience who might not care about intricate character development or a thought-provoking plot, it's hard to imagine that the sequel will leave a lasting impact a couple decades down the line, the way that MJ and the Tune Squad did the first time around.
7. Basic Instinct 2
A lot of the entries here sound wrong. American Psycho 2, Mean Girls 2, and now Basic Instinct 2. The 2 looks unnatural and out of place. Almost as if there shouldn't have ever been a sequel to these films.
Basic Instinct 2 falls in to the trap relying too heavily on its star in Sharon Stone. That's not to say that Stone doesn't do well. Instead, she does too well that it shines a spotlight on how far ahead of everyone else she is.
Stone acts circles around co-star David Morrissey, and the supporting cast don't fare too well either. Production was supposedly plagued with casting issues, with both the studio and Stone being extra picky about who they were working with. Ewan McGregor, Jude Law, and Pierce Brosnan were all rejected, and it wasn't just actors either. Directors also came and went, being dismissed from production, and Stone even filed a lawsuit against the film's producers for delaying production because they couldn't agree on a male lead.
All the backstage drama surrounding the production, is actually more interesting than the movie itself.
6. Zoolander 2
A good sequel builds upon its predecessor, enriching the lore, characters, and the established universe. A bad sequel, like Zoolander 2, does the opposite.
Zoolander pokes fun at the absurdity of the fashion world and Ben Stiller delivers a performance leaving you wondering how anyone could be that dumb. Only a genius could pull that off.
The sequel fails to add anything new, however, and is a poor imitation job. It recycles the original's jokes while forgetting the funny parts, and even detracts from its own characters.
Ben Stiller's character is now washed up and out of touch, but instead of adapting and changing with the times, Derek Zoolander tries to drag his old schtick kicking and screaming in to the current times. It's almost metaphorical for the sequel itself, and while Derek does eventually succeed, the film does not.
In the end, the satire element is lost and instead of adding to what made Zoolander so good, the sequel takes away. There are some good laughs to be found throughout its runtime and it's not completely unwatchable, but it feels hollow, devoid of the satirical spirit that imbued the original outing.
5. Halloween II
It cannot be overstated how significant Halloween (1978) is, and it has established a legacy of being one of the most important films in horror, and cinema as a whole. It is the perfect slasher movie, and Michael Myers is an icon.
There have been countless sequels to the original, a Rob Zombie reboot, and we're currently in the season of another reboot trilogy which, for the most part, does a good job of continuing the tale of Myers and Laurie Strode. The current reboots serve as direct continuations of the 1978 original, and completely omit the plot of the sequels.
The sequels of course began with Halloween II, releasing a couple years after audiences were first introduced to The Shape. It begins right where the last left off, and sees Myers stalking Laurie Strode to a local hospital, with Dr. Loomis in hot pursuit. It's eventually revealed that Michael and Laurie are in fact siblings, and the Michael may have ties to the occult, granting him supernatural abilities. Why did they have to make it so complicated?
It's messy. The sequel lacks the suspense and restraint the original had. It ups the violence and doubles the kill count, but that isn't necessarily a good thing. It seems to misinterpret everything that made the original so good, while introducing plot threads that detract from the mystery of Michael Myers. We don't know anything about him, and it should have been kept that way.
Subsequent sequels doubled down on these new plot lines and expanded them further, resulting in sequels that are even worse than this one. Whoever's idea it was to ignore all but the 1978 film for the 2018 reboot, Halloween fans owe them big time.
4. Book Of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
A good sequel needs to bring new ideas to the table, expanding on its predecessor in new ways, while also not straying too far that it's unrecognisable. It's a fine line to walk, a line that Blair Witch 2 fails to stick to.
The Blair Witch Project is an independent gem. It's a guidebook on how to do found footage well and its horror aspects aren't lacking either. It's claustrophobic and evokes fear through the unknown, rather than bearing all like so many films do. It's so inventive that big studios must still be kicking themselves for not thinking of the idea first.
The success of The Blair Witch Project prompted its distributor to greenlight a sequel, but the original filmmakers, Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sanchez, wanted more time than they were given to fully develop one. Instead, Artisan Entertainment pressed ahead with a new director, and a much bigger budget. What could go wrong?
Director Joe Berlinger has since disowned the film, citing constant producer meddling and forced reshoots as the main reasons for the movie being such a disappointment. There are other factors like god-awful dialogue and characters with less personality than a wet noodle that make Book Of Shadows as bad as it is, and it's clear it was intended as a shameless cash grab hoping to capitalise on the success of the original. It's not a labour of love and almost single-handedly destroyed the franchise.
3. Son Of The Mask
The Mask has a lot going for it. Jim Carrey's physical comedy is top notch, Cameron Diaz is introduced to audiences for the first time, and there's just enough depth to the plot with hints at darker undertones to make it an enjoyable watch.
Son Of The Mask has none of these things. In fact, it really doesn't have much going for it at all. The comedy just feels obnoxious without Carrey spearheading the project, and many of its moments fall flat. It relies heavily on its CGI effects, which leave the movie feeling more like a slideshow of cartoon gags, rather than having a proper narrative.
Despite its PG rating and being geared towards a younger audience, some of the jokes in the film verge on inappropriate and just plain gross. Is a scene with green cartoon sperm swimming to an egg really necessary? It's probably best to avert your kids' eyes from this disaster, not just because it's inappropriate, but also because it's only best watched as a form of cruel punishment.
2. Speed 2: Cruise Control
Speed. It's in the name, With a name like that, you'd have to expect a breakneck pace, non-stop action, and a level of intensity higher that refuses to let up.
Speed 2: Cruise Control. What does that sound like? On one hand, Speed 2 sounds even faster and even more relentless than the first, right? On the other hand, Cruise Control sounds more like its meandering at a steady pace, slow even. Refusing to go any faster and hands at ten and two at all times. So which is it? Spoiler alert, it wouldn't be on this list if it fell in to the first category.
Sandra Bullock returns and this time the (lack of) action takes place aboard a cruise ship that's been hijacked and programmed to head right towards an oil tanker. This is the most glaringly obvious issue. Cruise ships are not fast. The fact that no one questioned the setting during production is a mystery. That being said, of course they couldn't just rip off the original and rehash that on a train for example, but other than Sandra Bullock's character, what ties this to Speed and makes it a sequel?
It's not the only issue though however. Uninteresting characters, a serious lack of fun action sequences, and camera work so choppy and frantic it seems like it was shot with the intention of giving the viewer seasickness, all add up to a boring, pedestrian ride.
1. CaddyShack II
Caddyshack is widely regarded as one of the best comedies of all time. Chevy Chase is a joy to watch, the writing and directing are phenomenal, and everything combines to create a perfect storm.
Thanks to its success, its easy to see why everyone involved would want to try once more to catch lightning in a bottle, but the sequel is proof that lightning definitely doesn't strike twice. Chevy Chase reprises his role and Harold Ramis also takes on writing duties once again, but it's not enough to save Caddyshack II.
The choice to go for a PG rating hinders this sequel, and it feels like a watered down version of the original. The comedy is clumsy, and a lack of any depth in the material contributes to this, with newcomers to the project coming in at a disadvantage. The cast tries their best but they really aren't given much to work with.
The sequel failed to recoup its blown-up budget, and managed to pick up two Razzie awards. For those unaware, that is definitely not a good thing. It won the awards for Worst Supporting Actor, and Worst Original Song, while also being nominated for the dreaded Worst Picture.