People tell us to question everything: reconsider the unbelievable. It's a mantra that keeps politicians in their place and audiences curious, but just how much should we believe about our favourite films? Because directors really could be deceiving us completely. When certain details don't add up, we put it down to human error, but a lot of the time, it would make more sense for our favourite scenes to have been concocted from the imaginations of our heroes. It adds hidden depths and intriguing layers to movies, often explaining a bizarre ending; if someone imagined the weirder bits, it can often make more sense. And if a few choice details were actually imagined, it can change the tone of a whole movie; a happy ending could in fact be reversed, and tricky spot that the hero survived could turn out to be the downfall of the character, only ten minutes into the film. If you really didn't like the ending, you might prefer to believe it was all a dream; it's a consolation of sorts. Here are ten films that could be partly imagined by characters. Got any more to add? Comment below!
10. The Hunger Games
Okay, so maybe not all of The Hunger Games is in Katniss's head; that would be one dark imagination. But when you rewatch the films, not everything adds up about Peeta Mellark, the introverted love interest who worked as a cake decorator back home in District 12. He's a lot more subdued than your average contestant, latching onto Katniss and Haymitch for guidance and support, but taking the whole "killing people" aspect of the competition in his stride: is he hiding something? Maybe he's suppressing something. I mean, why would a town of starving peasants need a cake decorator? Is it not wholly possible that Peeta's imagined much of his life, including his fancy occupation, because the horror of what's really happened to him is to much to live with day-to-day? It's not as if it's not a world in which something like that could happen, and we've seen glimpses of Katniss's post-traumatic stress disorder. In the first film, we saw Katniss starving in the rain; are there really people in her town who can not only afford a cake, but an intricately decorated one? A certain "let them eat cake" resonance comes to mind...
9. Minority Report
There's no denying that Steven Spielberg is one of the most idolised directors ever, but if there's one criticism you can level at him, it's that often, he can't end a film. Just look at Saving Private Ryan; it feels like Spielberg's making a grand statement about how nobody really won World War II, but can't resist giving it a good old patriotic twist. Minority Report, likewise, is another film that deals in such darkened hues, it hardly seems fitting for the characters to live happily ever after; Tom Cruise is on the run for a murder he's going to commit in the future, and eventually he persuades everyone that people can change. Some might argue that a 'Nineteen Eighty-Four'-esque ending would be more thought-provoking; an affirmation that no one can cheat the system is certainly a better way of warning us of the future we're heading towards, rather than suggesting one man can flip a dystopia. Funnily enough though, Spielberg has a Get Out of Jail Free card here; Cruise's character Anderton spent a little while in prison, while his mind was free to dream. If he was to have dreamt up the entire ending, we'd have a braver moral from Minority Report.
8. Taxi Driver
It's one of the greatest films of all time, from one of cinema's greatest directors, but the ending of Taxi Driver has confused just about everyone who's ever watched it. Because rather like Minority Report, it really doesn't seem right for the hero to escape the horrors of the world around him with a happy ending. Unlike Minority Report though, Martin Scorsese actually gives the film a final ten minutes that could suggest a dream sequence; Travis sustains gunshot wounds, runs out of bullets before he can kill himself, and waits for the police to arrive. What if he didn't actually run out of bullets, though? The idea that Travis escapes to see Betsy again has been one that many critics have questioned, but it certainly makes sense for Travis to live out a fantasy of being a hero, in his final breaths. Scorsese however notes that the ending, of Travis staring at something we can't actually see, suggests he could revert to the angry, reckless "ticking time-bomb" we know. Both De Niro and Scorsese have teased a sequel over the years; maybe Travis is a good man that imagined everything up to the ending, and the final shot that implies the rage within him is the starting point for the next film. Now that's a plot twist.
7. Vanilla Sky
When the closing lines of a film are "Open your eyes", it's understandable to wonder whether anything you watched actually happened. That's the case of Vanilla Sky, another Tom Cruise film that plays with your head and makes you question everything you're watching. The whole film revolves around perceptions of reality; Cruise's character David ends up disfigured after a car crash with his ex girlfriend, before killing her, eventually discovering he was cryogenically frozen 150 years ago, and that this is all a lucid dream. To escape, all he has to do is jump. Perhaps David really was frozen in time, and the lucid dream really was a lucid dream. Perhaps the dream occurs after the car crash, and everything before that is true. Or maybe the whole film is a dream. It's hard to tell exactly, but certainly some of it isn't real.
6. The Dark Knight Rises
It's fitting that Alfred should predict the end of The Dark Knight Rises when he tells Bruce, "I had this fantasy, that I would look across the tables and I'd see you there, with a wife and maybe a couple of kids. You wouldn't say anything to me, nor me to you. But we'd both know that you'd made it, that you were happy. I never wanted you to come back to Gotham." Alfred only ever wanted the best for Bruce, but when he is presumed dead, it seems like Alfred will never have this moment. Until the final moments of the movie of course, in which Alfred, back at the Florentine cafe, glances over and sees Wayne, with Selina Kyle. But there's a key word in Alfred's speech that you might have picked up on: "fantasy". What if this final encounter with Wayne is nothing more than a dream? The idea that Bruce Wayne is still alive and has given up protecting Gotham, could just be the dream of a grief-stricken old man who's lost the closest thing he had to a son. It's a lovely ending; it's a shame if it wasn't real, and certainly a sad twist.
5. The Shining
Writers, we presume, have the wildest imaginations of any profession; they're the people most determined to prove the phrase "You couldn't have made it up" as being false. Jack Torrance from The Shining though is a struggling writer, who can't get a break. As his project stalls further, he becomes angrier, more violent, eventually finding out that he is in fact the caretaker of the hotel, and "always has been". It's implied that he's a new incarnation of an old caretaker, possibly the only caretaker ever of the hotel; but what if Jack, frustrated with his writers' block, imagined all of this as a story to write? The endless drafts all reading, "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy" could actually mean something to Jack. It's an intricate, twisted and thrilling plot that maybe only someone that angry could conceive, and it could all be born as a writing exercise to stimulate Jack's imagination.
4. Bruce Almighty
Jim Carrey runs around New York being silly, Morgan Freeman plays a cheeky deity and Steve Carell plays a nasty newsreader, who somehow, is actually a nice bloke come the sequel; it's fair to say Bruce Almighty is a film that isn't particularly thought-provoking. Unless, of course, it is. The film's going along fine, until Bruce has an argument with his girlfriend; he's driving along, minding his own business, when he bumps into a lamppost, and emerges from the car with a sore head. Suddenly he's contacted by God, who bestows all his power onto him. Skip forward all the cheating, the fame and the life lessons, Bruce is in another traffic accident, down the same stretch of road, this time hit by a truck. He wakes up, his girlfriend appears to want to forget everything that happened, and just go back to how they were. What if though, given that the prayer beads connect both accidents, Bruce imagined meeting God? The film would take a completely different message; it would be the story of a man who had a row with his girlfriend, hit his head in an accident and realised all by himself that his life wasn't as mediocre as he first thought. The only thing Grace would want to forget is their argument - something she's more likely to forgive than an infidelity - and even Carell's Evan Baxter is reasserted as the figure he was at the start of the film; the only thing that would need explaining is how Bruce got his job back. The homeless man at the end morphing into Freeman doesn't even need explaining. It's a metaphor for God being inside all of us, something that the film would definitely be endorsing if Bruce imagined the whole thing. Watch it again with this in mind. It's a much better film.
3. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
The fourth Indiana Jones film might have been a colossal disappointment for just about any fan of the franchise - aliens? Really? - but luckily, again similarly to Minority Report, Steven Spielberg was so kind to insert a tiny detail, should we wish to the retcon the bad stuff from our memories. Indy stumbles into a house. There's no one there, and it takes him a second to realise, but this is the model town at the Nevada Test Site. They're just about to launch an atomic bomb; there's no way that Jones can escape, so he hides in a fridge. "Bit far-fetched," you might say: "50-50 chance of survival", would be the response of creator George Lucas, who apparently compiled a huge dossier of meticulous research into how to survive an atomic attack from hiding in a lead-lined fridge. Of course, Indy survived. But what if he didn't? From Lucas's own research, it's just as plausible that Indiana Jones met his end hiding in a fridge; he could have imagined the rest of the largely mediocre movie in his final minutes, as he died of radiation poisoning. It's an elaborate, tongue-in-cheek fan theory - one probably concocted by a fan who wished Lucas would spend more time on the plot and not compiling fridge dossiers - but it's definitely a way to ensure there isn't another Indiana Jones movie.
2. Titanic
Titanic could have ended many ways, especially if Rose had only realised that there was room on that door for two. As it is though, Cameron ends the film with the elderly Rose dying in her sleep; Gloria Stuart was instructed to hold her breath when she filmed the scene. The final shot is of Rose, in her younger Kate Winslet form, reuniting with Leonardo DiCaprio's Jack in the afterlife. Everyone who died on the ship is there to applaud them, despite probably all having friends of their own to applaud. Where it becomes confusing, is that Rose mentions she married a man long after her brief romance on Titanic. Let's face it, it's good that she got over Jack: it's really sad to pine after someone for eighty years if you barely knew them. So why exactly would she meet Jack in the afterlife? Eighty years, a husband and no doubt some kids have passed, and yet the person who greets her is someone she knew for a few days? Taking the life expectancy into account and presuming her husband's already dead, shouldn't he be there to greet her in heaven? If her soul-mate was really Jack, why marry this other bloke? Just so he can have kids? That's a bit mean, isn't it? It would just make more sense for that final scene to be a dream, but the more you look at the film, the more you realise that it could all just be the fabrication of a very old woman. The important thing to remember though is that she could have saved Jack. There was room on that door for two.
1. The World's End
The much-anticipated end to the Three Flavours Cornetto trilogy, The World's End is perhaps the most surreal of the lot, as Simon Pegg, Nick Frost and the gang encounter alien life during a pub crawl. As more alcohol is consumed, the bizarreness increases, culminating in Frost and Pegg, drunkenly confronting the Network. As anyone who's ever been on a night out can testify, things can certainly get weirder the more you drink; it's perhaps no surprise that the pair get themselves into the mess they do. But how much of it is actually true? Gary King and his band of brothers only actually uncover alien activity after a couple of pints; convenient to say the least, as everything's more believable with a drink inside you. Continued fighting with robots breaks throughout, followed by frantic chases, a confrontation with Pierce Brosnan - they really must be trollied by now - and then at last, the face-off with the head of the alien robots; it all escalates from the first pint, so what if it's all the imagined tale of a night out? What perhaps makes this idea quite so beautiful is the apocalypse at the end of film, where modern technology is wiped out, and humanity heads back to the dark ages. If that's not the ultimate hangover metaphor, I don't know what is.