10 Movies That Would Work Better As Horror
We already have nightmares from Return to Oz, so why not make it an outright horror?
A horror movie is defined by its intent to evoke suspense or dread, often by highlighting a fear of the unknown, psychological torment, supernatural forces, or good old fashioned bloodshed. Of course, there are plenty of movies that evoke similar feelings, yet aren't classified this way.
But they could be. Certain dramas and thrillers could work better if they factored in more scares, especially if they already contain monsters, zombies, aliens, and things that go bump in the night.
Whether it's psychological tension, dark themes, or eerie visuals, a small shift here and there could turn these non-horrors into bloodcurdling experiences that are sure to haunt anybody. Science fiction and paranormal stories already deal with the unknown, so it wouldn't take much to revise such films into pure nightmare fuel.
Other times, a movie can have such a teeth-chattering premise, it's bewildering why the creators didn't make it into a full-blown frightfest in the first place. (It'd be like if The Fly or The Exorcist were packaged as a whimsical comedy.)
With some tweaks in tone, visuals, and storytelling, the ten entries on this list could easily become cinematic trauma.
10. Bull
The British crime drama follows a ruthless enforcer called Bull. After being left for dead by his former gang a decade earlier, Bull returns to his old town to exact revenge on them. He picks off each gang member one by one, before ultimately killing their leader, Bull's father-in-law, Norm.
In the final scene, a priest becomes horrified when Bull enters his church, accusing the gangster of being an abomination in the eyes of God. It's then revealed that Bull has pure black eyes, indicating he harbours demonic power.
Through a series of flashbacks, it's explained that Norm's gang shot Bull dead ten years ago and buried his corpse. With his soul unable to rest, Bull made a deal with the devil, allowing him to return and slaughter his killers.
Even though this is a harrowing revelation, throwing in this spooky element in the last two minutes of a grounded thriller feels out of place. The film could've avoided this by incorporating more grisly kills or referencing devilry and black magic.
If these horror aspects were sprinkled throughout, the last-minute twist wouldn't feel tacked on.
9. I Am Legend
Based on Richard Matheson's novel of the same name, Francis Lawrence's I Am Legend revolves around a scientist called Robert Neville, portrayed by Will Smith. After most of humanity turns into vampiric cannibals called Darkseekers, Neville desperately looks for a cure.
Despite the fact Matheson's book was very horror-oriented, this adaption is a blockbuster above all else.
However, the film would closer resemble the source material if one single thing was remedied - the Darkseekers. Though these creatures were meant to be brought to life with practical effects, they were replaced at the last-minute with atrocious CGI, eroding any potential scares.
Though the Darkseekers are cunning, and manipulative in the novel, the film turned them into mindless zombies. Also, the Darkseekers are significantly scarier when off-screen. As such, I Am Legend would've been nerve-shredding if these nocturnal beasts were implemented sparingly.
Also, the most hard-hitting part of the original story is when it's revealed the Darkseekers are intelligent and compassionate, meaning Neville had spent years killing innocent people. Although this ending was shot, it was switched out with a traditional climax.
If the film kept the practical effects and maintained the initial ending, I Am Legend would've been legitimately frightening.
8. Freeze Frame
Lee Evans may be renowned for his slapstick antics, but his performance in Freeze Frame proves the rubber-faced funnyman has a knack for drama.
John Simpson's directorial debut centres around a paranoid man called Sean Veil (Evans) who obsessively records every moment of his life to avoid being falsely incriminated. When he's accused of murder, he learns the tape that can exonerate him has disappeared, causing his life to spiral out of control.
Freeze Frame leans into themes of surveillance, paranoia, and wrongful accusations, but never takes the plunge into horror. This is a shame since Lee's unhinged character would fit the genre like a glove.
The movie could also dip into psychological horror, hinting that Sean isn't as innocent as he seems. Due to his delusional nature, what he sees on his surveillance footage may be different to what's going on, so viewers will be in the dark whether Sean is guilty or not until the end.
Though the mystery thriller is reasonably entertaining, it wastes its potential. With the benefit of hindsight, it's obvious Freeze Frame should've taken its creepy concept down a much darker path.
7. Polite Society
In Nida Manzoor's martial arts comedy, a defiant teen called Ria tries to stop her sister, Lena, from an arranged marriage, believing her groom-to-be, Salim, has ulterior motives.
For the first hour, Polite Society comes across as a delightful action comedy. However, things take a dark turn when Ria discovers a secret fertility lab in Salim's basement. On top of that, Lena starts having nightmares involving artificial insemination.
But that's just the tip of the iceberg. Ria eventually discovers Salim's mother, Shah, has orchestrated the marriage for her own nefarious schemes. Shah intends to (get ready for this) create a clone of herself and inseminate it inside Lena so her son can give her the life she always wanted. This means Salim would raise his cloned mother... as his own daughter.
Even though comedies have some real nutty villains, Shah's WTF plan would be more suited in Frankenstein, Don't Breathe, or Get Out. Nimra Bucha's performance as Shah is so utterly deranged, she comes across as a mad scientist or a serial killer (especially when she's torturing Ria with boiling hot wax).
Though Shah's scheme is way too dark for a light-hearted comedy, it's pitch-perfect for a horror flick.
6. Venom
Superhero blockbusters often contain dark elements, but there are few that fully embrace horror. It's understandable why, since it'd be difficult to market a horror-themed superhero.
But if there was any mainstream comic book film that should've indulged in gore and scares, it's Venom. Considering the titular symbiote feeds off human brains to keep its host, Eddie Brock, alive, it's no surprise to learn the Spider-Man spinoff was supposed to be R-rated.
Of course, Sony slapped the project with a PG-13 rating in the eleventh hour, hoping to make it as marketable as possible. Sony arguably made the right decision, since Venom banked over $850 million.
With that said, it was a shame to see the potentially dark story being revised into a wacky buddy comedy. What's more annoying is that Venom would easily fit into numerous sub-genres of horror. Eddie Brock is transformed into a monster against his will (body horror), is taunted by a disembodied voice (psychological horror), must face off against a psychotic alien (creature feature), and is compelled to kill (slasher).
Now, you could argue the studio didn't delve into horror, since Venom was intended to ultimately square off against Sony's kid-friendly cash-cow, Spider-Man.
But since Sony's Spider-Man Cinematic Universe has imploded, it's more frustrating how an R-rated Venom never saw the light of day.
5. Return To Oz
Despite The Wizard of Oz's legacy, it didn't receive a sequel for almost 50 years. Though Return to Oz received mixed reviews at the time, it has since developed a cult-following.
Even though Walter Murch's directorial debut has creative visuals and magnificent practical effects, it's best remembered for being absolutely terrifying. The Wheelers, the Nome King, and the princess with the "wearable heads" traumatised so many people, you could argue Return to Oz should've gone all the way with the horror angle.
Now, some people would be against this idea, since it would go against the source material.
But the Oz saga is filled with disturbing content, including lobotomies, Tin Man decapitating dozens of wolves, the Scarecrow murdering a hundred crows, and Toto eating townsfolk. If any of these scenes were adapted into a film, it would be classified as horror by default.
One key character in Return to Oz is the kind-hearted Jack Pumpkinhead. Even though he's a loveable hero in the film, he's freaky in the novels since his head keeps rotting and caving in, requiring him to regularly replace it with a fresh pumpkin.
Return to Oz is already on the verge of horror, so not much would have to be tweaked for it to be considered as such.
4. Fall
Fall follows an experienced climber called Becky, who falls into a depression when her husband dies. Hoping to get Becky out of her slump, her best friend, Hunter, convinces her to climb a 2,000ft radio tower in the desert.
After Becky and Hunter reach the top, the ladder collapses, leaving them with no way down. With limited supplies, no cell service, and a harsh environment working against them, the pair have to figure out a way to escape.
Though Fall is a survival thriller, there are moments where it veers into horror territory without fully committing to it. The film contains gory sequences, involving wild animals ripping their prey apart, vultures munching on Becky's infected wounds, and a human body being splattered across the desert.
When Hunter succumbs to her wounds, the story touches on the supernatural, with Becky hallucinating her friend into being. Due to Becky's delirium, it's hard to tell what's real and what isn't, making Fall feel like a psychological thriller at times.
Considering how unimaginably scary it would be to be stranded in the middle of nowhere over a mile in the air, it's bewildering why the filmmakers didn't lean into the horror more.
3. I, Robot
Hello again, Will Smith.
I, Robot started off as a collection of short stories by Isaac Asmiov that explores how a robot-centric society could be dangerous, even if they were programmed not to harm humans. Despite the fact I, Robot isn't deemed true horror, the stories are sure to shake readers to their core, especially when looked at through the lens of modern society.
Although Alex Proyas' I, Robot looks at the dangers of AI, it's a popcorn flick at the end of the day (with a ton of distracting product placement). The film itself is entertaining, but calling it an adaptation is a stretch, since its similarities to the source material are surface level at best.
There's a permeating sense of isolation, helplessness, and dread in Asimov's book, which the adaptation barely touches upon. Even when there's an unsettling moment, it's often diluted by one-liners and wisecracks.
Rather than "turning evil," the androids in the book often harm humans due to glitches or computational paradoxes, which is far more petrifying.
If you want to watch a horror version of Isaac Asimov's classic stories, check out Ex Machina rather than the I, Robot film adaptation.
2. In Time
In Time takes place in a future where people stop aging at 25 but must earn, borrow, or steal time to stay alive. Time has effectively become currency, allowing the wealthy to live indefinitely, while the poor struggle to survive day by day.
Even though the cyberpunk blockbuster has an ingenious premise, it barely explores the abject terror which most people must endure every waking moment. Rather than focusing on car chases and brainless action, In Time could've made the story more personal and introspective, highlighting how this flawed system turns ordinary folk into thieves and murderers.
As the expiry date approaches, the person in question could experience unimaginable pain, driving them to perform criminal activities or lewd acts to stave off death for a few days.
Rather than dropping dead, the clock running out could trigger a horrific change in their body, such as rapid aging or an agonising demise. If In Time took this approach, watching a person's last few moments run out wouldn't just be tense, but genuinely frightening. But instead, the countdown is played as an action-thriller mechanic, nothing more.
In Time is relatively enjoyable, but it could've been so much better.
1. Passengers
Passengers is set on a spaceship carrying 5,000 colonists in hibernation pods. Due to a malfunction, an engineer called Jim awakens 90 years early.
Terrified of living out his life in isolation, he wakes up a journalist called Aurora, condemning her to the same fate. Though he hopes to have a romance with Aurora, she berates and shuns him, telling Jim he ruined her life. But since this is Hollywood, the pair eventually fall in love.
Why Passengers was written as a sci-fi romantic blockbuster is a mystery, since the idea of being trapped in space with a stranger is beyond terrifying. And when Aurora discovered Jim deliberately woke her to fulfil a lovey-dovey fantasy, the movie should've transitioned to horror immediately. Passengers could've played out like The Shining in space, with an isolated man losing his grip on reality, driving him to violence and insanity.
If told from Aurora's viewpoint, Jim would come across as a nice guy initially. When Aurora uncovers the truth about Jim, her arc could shift from a forced love interest to a survivor.
Instead of going down this route, the filmmakers made Passengers into a run-of-the-mill blockbuster with a non-sensical love story.