Even the most debased, ill-thought out movies will have some sort of message. That message may be "join the army" or "buy this toy", but at the very least a film will say something, no matter how simple. But while with the likes of Transformers what's going is painfully obvious from the studio logos, with better movies there's more room for debate. Certain movies have been out for decades and there's still major disagreement over what they actually mean. Obviously this leads to misreadings of films, with people somehow managing to miss the point. This isn't as strange an occurrence as you'd think; so often people read their own experiences into a movie's subtext, taking what they personally want from it. This is particularly true of films with unlikeable protagonists; often if a film is showing something, then it is assumed that it is also condoning it, which can sometimes be far from the truth. Then you have the movies that almost invite the controversy. Inception's cliff-hanger ending, with the question of whether Dom Cobb is awake or in a dream left teasingly unanswered, prompted much debate, but all that side-stepped the real point; he'd chosen this as his reality, whether it was or not is irrelevant. Whatever the reason and however the meaning was misconstrued, today we're going to take a look at ten movies that people took the wrong moral from.
10. Don't Let It Go - Frozen
Realising they were falling out of the animated movie game, the past few years has seen Disney really up their game. Instead of desperately trying to be hip and down with the kids, they've gone back to the roots of what made them so successful in the first place. Frozen is, thus far, the pinnacle of this new/old approach, boasting an updating of traditional Disney values (you can't marry a man you've just met). The standout element of the film were its songs. Simultaneously smart and subversive, they proved so potent that the soundtrack album went triple-platinum. Central to this was Let It Go, Elsa's ballad that sees her finally accept her ice powers, letting go (aha) of the parental-induced attempts to hide them from her subjects. Painfully catchy (good, because it was played on a loop for months after release), the song became an emblem of the movie, despite it working against what Frozen's actually trying to say. Let It Go is the unmasking of the repression put in motion in the prologue, but it's far from the overall moral of the film (it comes less than halfway through, after all). Elsa letting go of her inhibitions creates the whole endless winter issue and that lack of caring only makes things worse. It's only when she accepts her sister's love, understanding you can't just run from your troubles, that things really get back to normal. But don't tell that to the makers of the endless parody videos.
9. Greed Isn't Good - Wall Street
We'll see on this list that a lot of cautionary tales can taken all too literally, with satire lost on an audience. Wall Street is one of those, seeing Charlie Sheen's Bud Fox go through the usual "innocent guy is corrupted by the promise of power" storyline. What makes Oliver Stone's film, the most eighties movie ever made, stand out is who's promising that power. Gordon Gekko, Michael Douglas' defining role, is one of the biggest bankers on Wall Street and has a rather passing care for adhering to the law. Although the opulent lifestyle initially appears nice, Bud soon realises... oh, you know this all already - it's not as dandy as it seems. Bud ends up taking down Gekko, but not before dipping into the dark world of insider trading himself. You think it'd be the ultimate damning of bankers, highlight their flaws a decade or so before people really hated them. But here's the kicker; instead of leaving people aghast at the lives of bankers, the film actually inspired a new generation to take up jobs in the city, with the "greed is good" mantra Gekko spouts treated with pride rather than derision, much to Douglas and Stone's bemusement. Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps, the much belated sequel, had Gekko deliver a humerous rebuttal of earlier statement ("I once said greed is good, now it seems it's legal"), but that was overshadowed by a cameo from Bud Fox, who still appeared to be superficially motivated.
8. Don't Go Over The Rainbow - The Wizard Of Oz
In one of the biggest examples of why studio meddling is a bad thing, Somewhere Over The Rainbow was almost cut from The Wizard Of Oz. Like the rather similar Part Of Your World from The Little Mermaid, the studio wasn't convinced about such a musing song's relevance to the bright plot, convinced only at the last minute to keep in something that has become an enduring part of the movie's legacy. While its exclusion would have negatively affected the film, it does at least show that MGM understood what The Wizard Of Oz was about, something that the song's inclusion has actually muddled. The Wizard Of Oz's general moral is that "there's no place like home". You can debate endlessly of whether that's a positive message to give to a new generation, but taking the film as it is it's essentially doubling back on the song. And yet there's a general feeling that wishfully dreaming of a better place is what the bright fantasy is all about; why else would the Land of Oz be so vibrant? The song's undying popularity has stretched beyond the film itself; Oz may now be regarded as a classic, but the general public are more likely to have come into contact with Over The Rainbow through Israel Kamakawiwoʻole than Judy Garland, meaning it's original relevance to the message has been misconstrued over time.
7. Greed Really Isn't Good - The Wolf Of Wall Street
If you thought Gordon Gekko was bad, wait until you see Jordan Belfort. Like his fictional counterpart, Belfort isn't above twisting the law to make a little more dough, although that's really only the tip of The Wolf Of Wall Street's hedonism. Belfort's Stratton Oakmont is home to raucous parties and institutionalised lying, while his private life involves so many drugs the film's production probably marked a significant boon in the icing sugar business. The film runs for 180 minutes and much of that time is spent in comedy mode, with extended sequences showing Leonardo DiCaprio and Jonah Hill act high. This probably played a part in making many mainstream critics dismiss the film as simply revelling in the luxurious lifestyles of its protagonist, a three hour drool over piles of cash. To view The Wolf Of Wall Street as that, however, misses the amount of emotional strife everyone's put through; the final act sees Belfort become an unstable, wife-beating rapist. As with Goodfellas and Casino before it, Martin Scorsese is showing the allure of the lifestyle, getting you wrapped in before revealing it's major downsides. That it's more extreme than those films only goes to show how much more extreme the world of banking is; starting only a couple of years after Goodfellas ended, the bankers make gangsters look well behaved.
6. Scarface
In terms of inspirational heroes you wouldn't expect Tony Montana to be a go-to example, but for some perplexing reason the drug-lord has become idolised (in a general sense, but particularly in crime circles). Initially poorly received for similar reasons to The Wolf Of Wall Street (clearly these sort of films promote people mentally blocking out the final twenty minutes), the modern misunderstanding of Scarface is a bizarre one. The rise and fall of Tony Montana is pretty detailed and while for much of the film things are on the up, when things do fall it's in spectacular fashion. Yet that hasn't stopped people from getting a little wrapped up in it all. Now we'd like to think that most viewers see that this is a two-sided coin; as with most staples of the gangster genre, there's a dethroning to counter the hedonistic rise. However, not only does the thrills of that first half dominate perceptions, but the final showdown is likewise idolised as a moment of cool. "Say hello to my little friend," is the moment from Scarface, encapsulating people's love of Tony Montana, ignoring that his death cry is a point of madness. Even if the pretty grim end to the protagonist sinks in, there's still a perception that the drive behind Montana is in some way positive.
5. The Partying Is Hollow - The Great Gatsby
In print The Great Gatsby has always been a story of dividing meanings. Some view it as a take-down of the crazed partying of the roaring twenties, while others think it's more than that, looking at the emptiness of the lives of those involved. Some would even go as far to insinuate it is actually a love story. Naturally all these ideas would be resurrected when the book everyone slogged through in English class became a big budget movie, with flashy visuals replacing those pesky words. The latest, and also biggest, adaptation came last year from Baz Luhrmann, with the pizzaz turned up to twelve, bringing this confusion of meaning into the internet age. By the end Jay Gatsby is dead in his pool, still pining for Daisy, which clearly seems to embody that money can't buy you love. And yet the bright CGI and modern music that gave this take on F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel such a unique feel blinded many people to that, with them only taking that partying is fun; in the months following the movie's release Gatsby-style parties sprung up over America. Which would be fine if Midnight In Paris hadn't itself highlighted how fruitless longing for the past it.
4. It's Not Summer's Fault - (500) Days Of Summer
If you want to hate something about (500) Days Of Summer, hate the fact that it reenforces The Smiths as a hipster band or that it serves as a reminder Marc Webb can actually direct. Don't hate Summer. She, unlike Jenny Beckman, is not a bitch. Tom immediately falls for Summer, believing her to be his ideal girl; the one he'll ride off into the sunset at the back of bus with. But he's not falling for Summer herself, but the idea of what he wants her to be to him. She repeatedly states she wants things to be casual between them and, while her definition of casual involves shower sex and going to Ikea, that's what she delivers. That's a rather simplistic summary of their relationship, cutting out the personal drama, but it's the general idea. Neither character is perfect, just like in real life; Summer didn't lead Tom on, but neither was he Sid vicious. They were two people who wanted different things, possibly on a fundamental level incompatible. Of course, that's not what a lot of people coming out of the rom-com think, finding the whole thing a cautionary tale against relationships in general, rather than simply an example of how inexact a science love is.
3. Hakuna Matata Is Wrong - The Lion King
When Frozen became a smash hit the immediate comparison point was The Lion King, the height of Disney's nineties renaissance. Both films created their own phenomenon, tearing up the box office and unleashing a barrage of merchandise. And, curiously enough, both feature an incredible soundtrack with a focal song that completely discolours the message of the movie; just like Let It Go works against Frozen's moral, Hakuna Matata is the exact opposite of the lesson Simba learns. When he runs away, believing he's responsible for his father's death, having an upbeat number that tells him to put his behind in his past is just what the lion prince needs. But that isn't a healthy way to deal with loss, hence why only a few minutes after the song is over the film starts to deal with the implications of this, culminating in Rafiki stating "run from it, or learn from it." But because that's not done in a catchy comedy number all people remember is "no worries". Hakuna Matata has become a massive ethos so overwhelming it looms large over the film. The original Swahili phrase itself is little more than a pleasantry, but having seen a meerkat and warthog live by its teachings it creates the illusion of big ideal.
2. The Theories Distract From The Point - The Shining
What exactly is up with The Shinning? Don't ask that question on the internet unless you want a barrage of increasingly crazed answers; it's about the genocide of the Native Americans; it's about the holocaust; it's Stanley Kubrick apologising for faking the Moon landing; watch it in reverse overlaid on the film playing forward and some creepy things match up. Or, you know, it's about a ghost story about a father going crazy and trying to kill his family. OK, we're not going to make the case that The Shining is just a horror film (with Kubrick a cigar is never just a cigar - it's probably a jump cut to space or something), but all these abstract theories and meanings get away from the film itself and what it's characters say about the human condition. Kubrick, the perfectionist that he is, no doubt put in elements of these various theories (particularly the Native American theme) but they're an added layer, not his overall goal. Whatever that goal is, of course, still up for debate. And, on a side note, Room 237, the film which puts forward these theories is equally guilty of gross misunderstanding; it's exploring the effects of obsession and fandom as well as just theories about The Shining.
1. It's Not About Fight Club - Fight Club
Fight Club has become one of those go-to machismo movies, a lad film whose posters are guaranteed to adorn student bedroom walls until the end of time. It's a kinetic, visually creative movie with a great story that the majority of the population has seen. Yet if you stop someone in the street and ask them what the film's about they'd probably start spouting something about "the first rule of Fight Club" or saying "my friend ruined the twist for me." Not all that in depth. David Fincher's attack on our dependence on consumerism (amongst other things) has become a defining film for a generation, despite much of what it's saying going over a general audience's heads. The biggest misnomer is the title. The last thing Fight Club is about is Fight Club. The topless men beating each other to a pulp is obviously important to the film, but what goes on outside Lou's is just as integral, forming its ultimate statement. That didn't stop people listening intently to Tyler Durden's teachings, with some actually forming their own Fight Clubs across America (thankfully things never got as far as Project Mayhem). Which other movie's morals have been misunderstood? Let us know in the comments below.