10 Overlooked Factors That Make Ben Affleck's Batman Casting Great

By E.F. Camacho /

There are a variety of lists for and against Ben Affleck as Batman, and by now most folks have probably relaxed to the notion a bit more. While a general chunk of fandom is still going (a bit) crazy and still are missing a few points as to why this is a good thing. When taking on this assignment I wanted to look at considerations most articles all over the net were not actually talking about, or not hitting, at the core of the argument. I also didn't want to touch on great points already talked about. There's another great article here on What Culture by Shaun Munro, 10 Reasons Ben Affleck Will Be An Awesome Batman, and I recommend you definitely give it a look. This piece focuses on more of the nuances of the argument and some of the big issues that are missing from the debate, are being ignored, or not really understood. It's hard to pinpoint in on topics we haven't talked about, and overlooked, but perhaps these 10 will help a few folks on the other end of the spectrum think a bit more about the subject. Perhaps it will at least relax to the point of hitting the "let's wait and see" column, and away from the raging "OMG WTF BATFLECK IS UNAMERICAN" column. Read on for these 10 overlooked factors that make Ben Affleck a great choice to play half of the eponymous roles in the upcoming Batman vs Superman film.

10. It's A Comic Book Movie, Not Shakespeare

In truth, I think any actor can pull off Batman, it's Bruce Wayne that requires the most work, and in truth he's pretty easy to figure out. What was just typed is not sacrilege, so don't have an aneurysm. We've all seen Batman as a dark, brooding, aloof, quick to reveal himself to the girl, self-sacrificing hero. We've seen this in strides. Bruce Wayne is in constant turmoil with his personal demons, and each film we've seen since Burton's entries have all dedicated screen time to Wayne's origins and the death of his parents. Wayne has trouble trusting anyone €“ which is part of his persona €“ yet every film we've seen he reveals his deepest secrets to the new girl in the leading role. This has forever been uncharacteristic and a frustrating state of plot portrayal to help us relate to the character and humanize the role. How about the Batman that is simply kept to himself, watches from a far, doesn't reveal himself until it's necessary; investigates, has intelligent insight on virtually everything going on. The same Batman that seemingly always has a backup plan. This is the type of Batman Affleck will be portraying. Knowing Snyder, and seeing Man of Steel and how differently he took the role. It's easy to see the direction we've always seen Batman take is not the same one that will be used in this film. Which means a straight forward Dark Knight, one that is possibly almost always in the cape and cowl.

9. Hollywood Thrives On All Publicity: The Good, The Bad And The Ugly

Advertisement
All the negative publicity that occurred within the earliest announcements of Affleck's casting actually helped the film gain more global notoriety than can ever be hoped for with a 7-figure marketing and PR campaign. If anything, more and more people are speaking about about the film €“ fans, mainstream movie-goers, their friends, family, and everyone in between. The media picks up and thrives on celebrity and film drama, it's what helps make the bulk of this industry run. Without it, 90 percent of all the blogs, websites; random boards, and social media sites wouldn't have things to talk about. All of this makes the entertainment world go round. What I have seen is a slow trickle of the naysayers fall away; whether it's lack of stamina for the course, or the trolls are dying out via attrition. More people are starting to either have faith, or have taken on the "If you can't beat them, join them!" or the less enthralling, "We'll wait and see" mentality.

8. Despite The Obvious Failures, Affleck's Career Has Been Very Solid

Advertisement
It's been said many times, the guy has two Oscars. It's hard to argue against this, but people still do. What is overlooked, is simply that every actor, every director, everyone in the industry has "Paying their dues" films on their resume. Even when they've "made it" in the industry (define that as you see fit), every great actor has films they wish they never made. Yet, those films are necessary! It helps the actor grow in their craft. Consider virtually all the successful work Affleck has done for the last 10 years (12, by the time Batman vs Superman releases); he'll have a few other films out in the market by then as well. We hear the arguments about Argo and The Town used often. Rightly so, he won Oscars for Argo. itself winning 33 total awards, 3 of which were said Oscars. The Town, had over 16 award nominations, 4 of them specifically for Affleck's work. Let's consider some of this future Bats' other work. Gone Baby Gone, The Company Men, State of Play, Extract; or better yet, To The Wonder. An intelligent love story, with so many spiritual undertones, there's no necessity for any other critique aside from this €“ it's a beautiful film, even if you're not into that sort of flick. Affleck has come a long way in his career to be ridiculed by fanboys that don't have a clue about this craft. Sure they know what they like and don't like in a comic movie, and that's respectable; the argument they simply don't like Affleck is fine. Trying to argue this accomplished Oscar winning director, and screenwriter, is not capable of acting is not respectable, and doesn't really make much sense. His bad films are deeply in his past, as lessons learned.

7. In Kevin Smith, He Has One Of The Industry's Biggest Comic Book Fans As A Resource

Advertisement
Affleck himself is a comic book fan. Consider the people with whom he started his career €“ Kevin Smith, Jason Lee, Jason Mewes, and Matt Damon. He doesn't get consideration as a fan, because fans are mostly prejudiced against people that don't look or match their social awkwardness, their ability to get women, and if they have upper body strength. This is a crude and stereotypical judgment made against people like Affleck by fanboys that usually separate themselves with this distinction. I'm not trying to be crude, this just happens. Truth is, he doesn't need to know anything about comics to figure out the character he is playing. He has plenty of references to figure out the character and a solid director that will guide him in the process. The fact that he is a comic book fan makes it that much better for his delivery, and for us knowing we'll get a pretty solid representation. Probably one that will be closer to the character than we've ever seen. Let me rephrase that last sentence. Probably closer to the version of the character we've always wanted to see.

6. He Has The Worst Batman In Film History As A Resource, George Clooney

Advertisement
Conversely to having Smith as one of his closest friends, he also has a friend and film making partner in George Clooney. While many will argue that Batman and Robin is one of the worst movies in comic book history, it actually sits ahead financially at #41 over Hellboy I-II and Blade I-II (Comic Book Adaptation), with over $238 Million in revenue at the box office, and the film made a ton of money merchandising toys. While I agree, it's an awful movie (as a comic book fan), I also understand and recognize this movie was not for me or for any of us "elder" fans. It was for little kids. I also boldly state that Clooney was a decent and vulnerable Bruce Wayne (despite what I wrote as my heading). Destined to fail in the role among comic book fans due to a hurricane of horribad decisions put together by the studio and those running the production. Take away the gimmicks, the stupid nipple suit, recast Freeze, get rid of the writers, and the film could have been pleasantly camp. That's a lot of change for any movie, it's far better to simply reboot the franchise (which took eight years). Clooney has a lot of insight, undoubtedly already, conveyed to Affleck in regards to his rendition of the character. Chances are he may even have a few revelations about "What if" situations he might've had if he would have stood his ground (hypothetically) on issues he saw with the writing, the direction, or perhaps how stupid he looked in the suit.

5. Zack Snyder Has Massive Experience In The Comic Book Adaptation Genre

Advertisement
I've read countless arguments about Affleck possibly helping Snyder direct the film, "He'll give him directorial 'pointers'" some say. Listen, that's a fantasy, and is nowhere near the truth. Sure, there are definite possibilities that a collaborative director, like Snyder, would listen to his actors (if they are asked); but he's not going to be led by them. If that was the case; Affleck would have been offered the directors seat on the film, not a starring role as Batman. Affleck's (solid) ability as a director will only add a better perspective in anticipating what Snyder is trying to do; once Snyder starts directing his principles during the films shoot. There's is a lot of speculation regarding Affleck gaining this role as a "Do this, and we'll let you do that" sort of scenario, which is probably a half truth. He has some latitude with others from the studio to give oversight on the script, whether or not he'll be credited as a Story Editor, or a Writer has yet to be substantially stated. The fact still remains that Snyder is a heavily capable director that undoubtedly has a specific vision for his next film, and knows how to deliver a new vision of these extremely beloved characters for a modern audience. He will still break all kind of rules as he goes along, but those will still be amazing to watch, especially in terms of what he has in store for Batman.

4. Affleck Deserves This Opportunity To Play Batman

Some of the loudest arguments against Affleck are the debates involving Daredevil. Fair enough, but with provisions. He wasn't actually what was bad in that movie. The script was terribad, the villains were pretty ridiculous and stupid. Even if Michael Clarke Duncan was interesting, he had his moments of exceedingly terrible acting. You can tell he was just having fun, and didn't take the role seriously. Colin Farrell was the epitome of suck, and quite possibly the worst villain portrayal next to Doug Hutchison's "Looney Bin Jim." On both occasions you'd rather watch Arnold's one liners in Batman and Robin, that is saying something. All in all, there was a director and producer that signed off on the dailies of that film, and deserve a large portion of the suck meter that Affleck is getting too much credit for. Affleck was actually pretty good as Matt Murdock. He looked great in the suit; the action was also pretty decent. We could have all lived without the fight scene in the park, and there are little words left for the level of cheese we all took on that film. Yet the fact still remains it was financially sound and did well enough to spawn the Elektra spinoff. A far worse film on the suck meter than Daredevil. Affleck deserves to be able to portray Batman in this film and silence any doubt that he can be a great Superhero character. Some folks say look at his portrayal of George Reeves in Hollywoodland which was a great film, but it's not really the same thing. He portrayed Reeves portraying the serial version of Superman, so he wasn't really Superman, per se, and it's a far cry from a comic book film. It was a wonderful indie film on the troubled life Reeve had, as a struggling actor. It did however reflect how Affleck can be a grandiose character that was considered beneath a good actor to play, bring it to life, and portray the man Reeves was in the real world. It was a wonderful exercise in acting. Especially for a person that never really wanted to play Superman in the first place. Consider other actors that time and time again are in Superhero roles that fail (whether it's their fault or not) and continue to return in some form to the Genre. Affleck only portrayed one Hero, a great hero, but not a top tier character like Wolverine, Hulk, Iron Man, etc. He didn't do a terrible job, he did well with what he had, and that's just being realistic. This will be a great franchise for Affleck to take on; he will be able to completely bring to life, what may very well end up being, the definitive Batman.

3. This Is Not Going To Be The Batman You'd Expect, Unlike Anything Before

Advertisement
The 60s had Adam West, what I'd regard as the campy Sherlock Holmes Batman. The late 80s (early 90s) started with a very dark and Gothic Batman. It was too dark (at least for the moms) and many folks still argue Michael Keaton wasn't right for the role. Schumacher took the property over and dumbed it down, added nipples, and made WB/DC a fortune in merchandising toys for young Batman fans. Nolan gave us the most realistic (we'll leave that colloquialism intact, why not) Batman. Snyder isn't trying to redo any of the above. He's not trying to reinvent the wheel, or even recreate the character. He's simply trying fit the character into Superman's world, the same world that will eventually have the rest of the Justice League in it. This is a very different kind of Batman, one we've yet to ever see on film. We've seen plenty in animated features and series. Never live. Affleck will be bringing this very specific type of Batman to life. Consider this argument: Bale, Kilmer, Keaton, Clooney, even West; let's be completists in this assessment. None of their takes on Batman would make sense standing next to Superman, Green Lantern, or Wonder Woman. Those "Batmen" might as well stick to saving cats from trees.

2. Snyder Specifically Wanted Affleck For The Role, Without Auditions

Advertisement
The talks between Affleck, Snyder, and the studio were so secretive early on; the agency was not aware of them. There are still a variety of details that have yet to be released by the studio in terms of all that encompass the deal. We only know Affleck has signed on for multiple films, and that he has a little bit of story-editing ability. While there are rumors about others being on a short list for the role, like Josh Brolin, Ryan Gosling, Michael Fassbender, etc. The bulk of the rumors were driven by fancasting on innumerable blogs across the internet. Other actors had been campaigning for the role, like True Blood's resident werewolf badass Joe Manganiello. When a director doesn't want you to test for something, wants you in one of the leading roles, and also agrees with the studio to have you help with the script, even in a limited capacity. That's a sign of trust, of respect for ability, and the studio getting behind the choice.

1. He Doesn't Actually Have To Carry The Film Alone

Advertisement
While the working title is still "Batman vs Superman", It is a sequel movie to Man of Steel, whether that title remains or is changed. It's a Superman movie after all, not a Batman film, so it doesn't need a bulk performance by Affleck. Even though we as an audience don't have much information about what this movie is going to contain, consider some basic observations. There is going to be at the very least, one villain. That means Superman, Batman, and a Villain have to share screen time. That's at the bare minimum 33% of the film being utilized to develop Batman as a character (this is an oversimplified example). What does this mean for direction? It means Snyder will most likely not be rebooting Batman's origin. Rather, he will be retelling it, likely giving subtle background through Superman's eyes as he learns about the Dark Knight. It means Snyder will likely not be flashing back as much to his parents death either. He'll likely be using existing material for a character we ALL know; which means most of Affleck's screen time will be deliberate and specific to his purpose in the film. What the deliberate and specific purpose is, we don't know yet!? However, the necessity for the ridiculous acting chops many arguments are citing are unfounded and unneeded. The bulk screen time for Batman may actually be the climax; rather, a dual climax. His expected battle with Superman, and both of their battles with one or more Supervillains. While the intention in this statement isn't "Don't worry, we won't see him so much on screen, which means he'll have little chance to suck!" No...It means he's not the only, or most important, aspect of the film; Batman's just part of the story; an important part, but not the only part. So much debate, so little time. Comment, share, tweet, pin, share your thoughts. Do you have a point to convey that no one has talked about? This is a good forum of discussion for it.