10 Philip Seymour Hoffman Performances That Prove His Acting Genius

RIP Philip, and thanks for the brilliant work.

By Jack Pooley /

What a horrible loss for cinema. Philip Seymour Hoffman left us yesterday at the far too young age of 46, and it's certainly not mere sentiment to say that he was unquestionably one of the greatest actors of his generation, delivering four Oscar-nominated performances, the first of which won him the gong outright. Whether working for his long-time collaborator Paul Thomas Anderson or starring in a throwaway comedy like Ben Stiller's Along Came Polly, Hoffman always gave it his all and is distinguished as one actor who never gave a bad performance or phoned anything in. And what better way to honour the actor than to return to his greatest performances? Picking just 10 was quite a challenge indeed, so you'll have to forgive me if one or two of your favourites didn't quite make the cut (25th Hour and Charlie Wilson's War were particularly painful omissions), but we'll all agree that Hoffman demonstrated his range and flat-out brilliance in every single one of these turns. RIP Philip, and thanks for the brilliant work.

10. Scotty J - Boogie Nights

Boogie Nights may not have been the first collaboration between Hoffman and filmmaker Paul Thomas Anderson (Hoffman had a role in Anderson's debut, Hard Eight aka Sydney), but it was certainly the one that got heads turning towards the actor. Hoffman plays Scotty J, a gay boom mic handler who falls in love with Mark Wahlberg's well-endowed protagonist, Dirk Diggler. In a film full of hilarious performances, Hoffman's turn rises to the top, as perhaps evidenced no better than by a climactic scene in which he finally musters up the courage (thanks to plenty of alcohol) to make a move on Dirk and is promptly rejected, angrily shouting at himself in his car for his actions. It's a moment that's at the same time extremely funny and also pretty sad, and Hoffman captures that dichotomy perfectly. In part due to his work here, the film earned a Screen Actors Guild Award nomination for Outstanding Performance By a Cast, and rightly so. Quote: "I'm a f***in' idiot. I'm a f***in' idiot. f***in' idiot, f***in' idiot, f***in' idiot..."

9. Andy - Before The Devil Knows You're Dead

Easily one of the most under-appreciated films in Hoffman's filmography, Sidney Lumet's searing crime drama about two very twisted brothers and a robbery gone wrong benefits from outstanding performances at every turn (namely Ethan Hawke, Marisa Tomei and Albert Finney), and Hoffman is no exception. Watching the role right now is a little difficult (given that his character, Andy, is a drug addict), but there's a brilliant intensity to his work here, particularly as things get truly desperate in the movie's later portions. If Ethan Hawke's Hank is the sympathetic brother, Hoffman's Andy is meanwhile a total douche, and he makes us feel this unquestionably. We have no sympathy for him when the chips are down, and there's no doubt a little satisfaction on our part when Albert Finney (who plays his father) reaches for that pillow... Quote: "The thing about real estate accounting is that you can, you can, add down the page or across the page and everything works out. Everyday, everything adds up. The, the total is always the sum of its parts. It's, uh, clean. It's clear. Neat, absolute. But my life, it, uh, it doesn't add up. It, uh... Nothing connects to anything else. It's, uh... I'm not, I'm not the sum of my parts. All my parts don't add up to one... to one me, I guess."

8. Dean Trumbell - Punch Drunk Love

Though not one of the more prominent performances of Hoffman's career, his brief turn in Paul Thomas Anderson's Punch Drunk Love is, in my eyes, easily one of his funniest, and certainly one of his most brilliantly explosive. In the film, he plays the mastermind of the phone scam that Adam Sandler's protagonist Barry gets caught in, and over the course of a phone call, gets hilariously angry, telling Barry to "Shut the **** up!", before shouting "Shut up! Shut up! Shut, shut, shut, shut, shut up!", in easily one of cinema's all-time great put-downs. What more need be said? He may not have received the praise that Adam Sandler and Emily Watson did for their roles, but his small part is, for me, by far the most memorable scene in the movie, and something I'd love to act out in real life some day at a cold caller. Quote: "No, no. Shut up! Shut the f*** up! Shut up, will you, shut up! Shut up, shut, shut, shut, shut, shut up! ... Shut up! ... Now, are you threatening me, d***?"

7. Allen - Happiness

Without question the most difficult-to-watch film on this list, Todd Solondz's Happiness is a masterpiece of dark comedy, an extremely uncomfortable plunge into the ugliest, most eagerly repressed aspects of humanity, and Hoffman helps realise this through his character, Allen. Allen spends most of the movie making lewd phone calls to his neighbour, Helen (Lara Flynn Boyle), which requires Hoffman to enter an extremely unsavoury place, reciting lines that are both genuinely crude and hilariously desperate, particularly as he asks Helen about the state of her nether-regions while pleasuring himself down the phone to her. In a film boasting themes of rape, suicide and incest, Allen is practically a saint compared to what some of the other characters get up to, but like his role in Boogie Nights, he just about manages to imbue it with some sadness as well as car-crash hilarity. My love for this performance was renewed recently in the now-famous spoof trailer of Spike Jonze's Her (replacing Scarlett Johansson's voice with Hoffman's), which had several of Hoffman's quotes from this movie slotted in for good measure. Quote: "Are you wet? Is your p***y all wet?"

6. Jon Savage - The Savages

Hoffman may not have received an Academy Award nomination like his on-screen sibling, Laura Linney, but he earned his fair share of plaudits on the awards circuit, most notably an Independent Spirit Award for his affecting performance as Jon Savage, a middle-aged theater professor who is struggling to get a book written and hold down a relationship, while also having to come to terms with the onset of his father's dementia. In a film that superbly melds its comic and dramatic elements, Hoffman similarly nails a complex part that's far away from the depraved roles we've already mentioned: he's not insanely likeable, but more importantly, he's relatable. Furthermore, the play-like quality of the movie no doubt lent itself extremely well to Hoffman's own sensibilities as a highly acclaimed Broadway actor. Quote: "We don't have to go after him Wendy; we're not in a Sam Shepard play."

5. Father Brendan Flynn - Doubt

But when talking about the theatrical movies Hoffman starred in, none fits that description better than John Patrick Shanley's Doubt, adapted from Shanley's own play, in which Hoffman plays a Priest who is accused of having an inappropriate relationship with a male student. The film's central conceit, that nobody knows for sure if Father Flynn did as he was accused (and at the end of the movie, we never find out for sure), required that Hoffman needed to employ some of his most subtle work in order to sell it to audiences: he couldn't play the part too villainous or too innocent. Hoffman's brilliantly restrained performance garnered him an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor, and though his slighter turn fell to the background compared to Meryl Streep's volcanic performance as the nun determined to bring him to justice, he was in many respects the springboard that Streep needed, the anchor without which her work would have meant nothing. Quote: "Doubt can be a bond as powerful and sustaining as certainty. When you are lost, you are not alone."

4. Brandt - The Big Lebowski

Another small role here for Hoffman, but an extremely memorable one, as the slimy, snotty, annoyingly self-satisfied lackey of The Big Lebowski, who serves as a middle-man of sorts between him and Jeff Bridges' The Dude. It's Hoffman's most straight-up comedic role on this list, one that allowed him to stick out despite the relatively minor nature of the role and the huge number of excellent actors that filled out the cast for the Coen Brothers' cult classic. Who could forget that ridiculous, amazing laugh? Much of the hilarity is in seeing Brandt try to maintain his dignity in the most undignified of situations, such as when The Big Lebowski's trophy wife, Bunny, offers to provide oral services to The Dude for $1000, all while Brandt tries to downplay the situation, declaring her to simply be "free-spirited". Quote: "You never went to college..."

3. Caden Cotard - Synecdoche, New York

Charlie Kaufman's immensely ambitious project may not be for everyone, but there's little denying how fervently Hoffman threw himself into the role of protagonist Caden Cotard, a terminally ill theater director who takes it upon himself to stage the most elaborate theatrical production in human history as his personal life crumbles around him. The film was a box office flop and the thoroughly bleak tone turned off some critics, but Hoffman's performance was almost universally singled out as truly the work of a master artist. Watching Caden slowly follow his fate to its untimely end is a mixture of dark amusement and sadness, a combination of emotions wrought through the actor's layered, nuanced performance, helping to anchor Kaufman's divisive vision. Quote: "My father died. They said his body was riddled with cancer and that he didn't know, he went in because his finger hurt. They said he suffered horribly, and that he called out for me before he died. They said that he said he regretted his life. They said he said a lot of things, too many to recount, and they said it was the longest and the saddest deathbed speech any of them had ever heard."

2. Truman Capote - Capote

Philip Seymour Hoffman's first Oscar-nominated performance (and his only one in a leading role) was also the nod that would lead to his first and only Oscar (as sad a phrase as I've ever written), playing In Cold Blood author Truman Capote in the process of writing said novel, as he forges a connection with one of the murder suspects, Perry Smith. Hoffman's transformative performance is a fantastic act of mimicry, nailing the physical intonations of the man, namely his high-pitched voice, while also emphasising his playful arrogance, making the banter between him and Harper Lee (Catherine Keener) especially fun to watch. At the same time, it would have been easy for Hoffman to overplay the role and make of Capote a campy caricature, but instead he employs respectful restraint, rightly netting him that Oscar. Quote: "Ever since I was a child, folks have thought they had me pegged, because of the way I am, the way I talk. And they're always wrong."

1. Lancaster Dodd - The Master

Though Capote won him the gong, for me his career-best performance was as the leader of the cult-like movement, The Cause, in Paul Thomas Anderson's challenging drama The Master. This film is an embarrassment of riches as far as performances are concerned: Joaquin Phoenix and Amy Adams were nominated alongside Hoffman, and frankly it's difficult to pick a best-of-show, but Hoffman's turn as the enigmatic, frustrating, quick-tempered Dodd is a fascinating window into the mind of a complex, ambiguous figure, one who may not be as powerful and wise as he at first seems. If Phoenix sits at front and center and Hoffman's appearances are more scattered throughout the beefy 144-minute run-time, Dodd is an endlessly fascinating character due to the unease of not knowing exactly what's going on in his head. Hoffman conveys that caginess, and ultimately, that desperation, like no other. Quote: "I am a writer, a doctor, a nuclear physicist and a theoretical philosopher. But above all, I am a man, a hopelessly inquisitive man, just like you."