10 Precise Moments Horror Icons Stopped Being Scary
Scaring your pants off and laughing them right back on again.
It's fair to say that he big bads we've come to know and love don't really induce that instant vomit, crap your pants, cry until the sweet release of daylight fear that they used to. The 80s were a time of terrifying new turns in the horror genre, but since then, the legacy of slasher heroes has been dampened somewhat, priding campy sequels and illogical storylines over their original, simple, movie monster roots.
Whilst new and interesting creatures can try and fill the hole left behind, the attempts to get scarier with each new horror release only serve to remind us of what we've lost. More often than not, there's even an exacting, precise moment that can be pinpointed, where our favourite horror icons are pushed over the edge of reason and lose all sense of credibility.
Transforming from Pennywise to Ronald McDonald can happen over the course of an ill-advised sequel, or in some cases, during one unforgettably bad scene. All it takes is one slip up, and the fear is lost forever.
Looking at the history of horror and where exactly the S was taken out of slaughter then, we tip our hockey masks in respect. Rest in peace, monsters of old, as these are the moments that buried you.
10. The Cabin In The Woods - Sexy Wolf Kiss
The Cabin in the Woods is probably the best horror spoof movie of all time, purely for the fact that it functions perfectly well if you take the 'spoof' part out of it. Scary Movie, take some notes.
Breaking down genre tropes, cliches, and stereotypical characters, there's plenty of scenes that will stand out for their clever manipulation of horror films gone by - but only one that's just... well, a bit bizarre. Werewolves have been classic horror monsters for generations, and it's fair to say that their time is up. It's this moment that just solidified it, really.
Coming when the characters decide to play a game of truth or date, Jules, our sexy blonde lady who might as well have a target painted on her forehead, takes it upon herself to seduce a taxidermy wolf pinned to the wall. If you've ever been scared of a werewolf at any point in your life, watching her tongue punch the wall-mounts mouth is enough to eradicate any sort of fear and replace it with disgust, confusion, and a maybe some weird eroticism. Help?
Funnily enough, a werewolf appears later in the film, but is one of the least notably scary monsters on screen and relies on jump scares, potentially a reminder of the evolution of horror over the years that's forgotten our loveable hairy dog monsters. Good boys gone bad.
9. Friday The 13th - Jason Voorhees Returning From The Dead
Friday the 13th is a lucky day for some, but for those camping at Crystal Lake? Not so much. Any misguided teens looking for some fun will instead meet a grisly end, and in the first movie, it all made perfect sense.
Drowning due to ignorant camp counsellors, Jason Voorhees's legend still terrifies locals, who advise anyone against going there for fear of something terrible happening. Roughly 20 years after the accident and a brutal double homicide that caused the camp to close, Crystal Lake reopens for business, and brings back a deadly vengeance tale with it. As much as Jason is the heart of the Friday the 13th franchise, it's Pamela, his mother, that serves as the antagonist of the first movie: and this is the sole reason that causes him to stumble before ever gaining traction.
Pamela's revenge fitted well, served up some grisly deaths, and made a spooky legend come to life in an entirely real setting; her death should have been the end of it. Bringing Jason to life as a grown man in Friday the 13th Part II is never assimilated with his death as a child in the first movie, making his origin confusing and ineffective, and resulted in years of monster resurrection that removes all peril from the films.
Yes, they're good fun and provide plenty of wonderful horror genre fodder - but the disparity between its own timeline is the stumbling block for the scary.
8. The Blair Witch Project - Seeing The Witch
Now, this one is controversial as there's a clear cut argument for Blair Witch being a terrifying, appropriate sequel that utilities its source material and builds upon it carefully; creating something equally as scary as its predecessor with a modern, engaging twist.
However, in being so bold as to follow up to the seminal found footage film, there's always the risk that the original terror from the first movie will be filtered down and ultimately changed - which is what some would claim to be the case with Blair Witch.
Blair Witch is the film that gives the titular baddie a physical form in the woods. Unlike other horror films, it never reveals too much, showing a stretchy-limbed pasty woman running about just off screen instead of anything substantial. In giving the previously invisible monster a presence at all however; it creates a glass ceiling for just how scary the film can be - and an extended pause is all it takes to remove the bite from the creature we're shown.
Horror really has a thing for white skinned long people. Apply any other film that shows a little too much in bad CGI or misapplied makeup, and the Blair Witch shoots itself in the foot.
7. Halloween - Every Other Slasher Movie Ever... And His Mask
Halloween, whilst not the first slasher film to grace screens, was definitely one of the most impactful, spawning a template that horror movies for years to come adhered to. Whilst the movies have declined in quality since the first releases, Michael Myers has mostly followed the same character trope as ever, acting as the psychotic, silent killer knifing away at anyone that's unfortunate enough to get in his way.
The original film is one that stopped first viewers from sleeping, ingraining terror at the thought of a merciless intruder breaking into their house - but how many times have we seen this since? The one thing to Halloween's detriment is the sheer amount of copycat narratives it spawned, making any sort of attempt to watch it now fall flat in comparison to 1978's intense, gory thriller. It doesn't hold up any more as it's become a cliche: but at least it was for the solid reason that the first film defined the cliche itself.
To be honest, learning that Michael Myer's mask is actually a William Shatner face also ruins any scariness in the moment. Think of the spoken word covers, and a stab-tastic, pasty Shatner coming at you really doesn't do much.
6. A Nightmare On Elm Street - Freddy Krueger The Catch Phrase King
Freddy Krueger has long been the epitome of horror movie icons. Heralding in waves of copycats, remakes, and reboots - he's had a long and hard existence at the top. We can definitely revoke his scary card at this point.
Starting out as a genuinely terrifying burned monster that skulks through the dreamworld, Freddy had both an original premise and a definitive look, both of which served to make him scarier than most. 1984's A Nightmare On Elm Street was the birth of something truly special for horror, and A Nightmare On Elm Street 2: Freddy's Revenge was the death of it.
Choosing to pursue a much more comedic slasher villain, Freddy became a wise-cracking master of the one-liner, dropping both painful and hilarious puns at every opportunity. After the release of Freddy's Revenge, the nightmare dwelling monster didn't seem so bad - at least you'd get a good laugh in before he brutally murders you.
5. Sharknado - A Tornado... Of Sharks...
If Jaws set the precedent for making the king of the oceans terrifying worldwide, then Sharknado is the film to undo it. With years of people being too scared to have a swim at the beach for fear of being dragged to their watery doom, all it took was a particularly strong bit of wind to make the sea a safe, enjoyable, relaxing place again. Really, we should be thanking whoever was insane enough to come up with it.
Sharknado is not the first shark spoof movie, and of course, it was definitely, definitely not the last. Spawning a franchise of six films with sharks not only flying through the skies of America but launched into space, the final film is set to feature 'time travel, Nazis, dinosaurs, knights, and Noah's ark.' It's everything you didn't know you needed.
If you thought the plastic shark took you out of the moment a bit upon re-watching Jaws, a taste of Sharknado will have you jumping in the sea, throwing some reigns on the toothy b*stards, and riding sharks like chariots through the ocean in no time. Sharks will literally never be scary again.
4. Hellraiser - Making Pinhead Human
Clive Barker's Pinhead is one of the most original horror movie monsters we've had on screen, with the director serving up a batsh*t crazy creature from another dimension obsessed with BDSM. Can't distinguish the line between pain and pleasure? Ram a load of pins in your face and see if that helps.
In the first Hellraiser movie, his ominous, gentlemanly presence was absolutely unsettling; Pinhead being the leader of a group of Cenobites who follow his dimension-exploring antics in pursuit of carnal experiences. The creepy clan of sex deviants soon suffered from sequelitis however, and Hellraiser: Hellbound offered up some backstory that nobody wanted.
Hellbound decided to make the Cenobites, and in turn Pinhead, human in nature - removing all supernatural and demonic assumptions attached to the characters. Whilst in films this works for realism, humanising these creatures made the Hellraiser series far less impactful, explaining away all mystery and intrigue that surrounded the original creations.
3. Aliens - Thinning Out The Horde
Originating as a tense, gritty little horror movie that pitted an unknowable and unkillable enemy against a practically defenseless spaceship crew: 1979's Alien was an exercise in creepy extra terrestrial horror unlike anything ever seen before.
James Cameron's Aliens took the formula and ran with it, transforming the skulking xenomorph into an army of angry bean-headed monsters: and whilst an excellent film, it can't be denied that it kills the scariness intrinsic to to the titular character.
By seeing the creature from the first movie mass produced and easily taken down by the colonial marines, we not only witness way more of the aliens than we've ever seen before, but how simple they are to kill. Take a flamethrower to the nest and you've got a xeno barbeque that's good for all the family.
The alien franchise is one rife with missteps, and Aliens is definitely not one of them - but it is the film that changed the genetic makeup of the alien into a battle-ready villain, rather than keeping its horrific roots.
2. Twilight - Attack Of The Sparkly Vampires
From Nosferatu to Dracula to all the fanged up bloodsuckers in between, vampires have terrified audiences for generations. Even when not quite hitting the mark, nothing has been quite unredeemable when it comes to the creatures of night. That is - and you all know what's coming here - until Twilight.
The first film of five that solidified movie vampires as a ghost of christmas past, Twilight threw the undead hordes back into their coffins and subsequently nailed them shut: and it was all with the unfolding of one fateful scene. Discovering the secretive high-school hunk is actually a vampire, our wooden leading lady Kristen Stewart is wooed by Edward Cullen, played by a moody Robert Pattinson. In doing so, he reveals he doesn't drink human blood, can read human minds, and best of all: freakin' sparkles when the sun comes out.
If looking like the aftermath of a lush bath bomb isn't enough to throw the whole vampire genre in the bin, the sickly love story that followed it is. Sexy seducers that steal your blood yes, sparkle-boys with powers to sniff out extra stinky blood, no.
1. The Babadook - Gay Pride Icon
Originating from the grisly Australian horror of the same name, the Babadook is half horrifying children's book monster, and half touching allegory for grief, representing the all consuming difficulties of moving on after losing a loved one. The Babadook itself is legitimately terrifying, manipulating the darkness around it and appearing only in shadowy recesses, almost one with blackness itself.
So if you dress it up in a feather boa, a few rainbows, and a dash of glitter, surely you've got nothing to worry about, right?
In all fairness, the B in LGBTQ+ does stand for Babadook, and he's served up some Baba-looks that got us Baba-shook throughout pride month. Accidentally adopted as a gay icon after Netflix categorised the horror movie in their LGBTQ+ section, parallels were drawn between the character and those that come out to their families, highlighting the struggles they go through.
Either way, the outright fabulousness and *clicks in Z shape* flamboyancy attributed to the character is particularly heartwarming - but completely devoids him of all spookiness instantly. Just don't confuse him with any death drops and we should all be fine.