10 Questionable Reasons Why Actors Turned Down Big Roles

By Audrey Fox /

Actors may be prettier than us, richer than us, and more successful than us, but at least we can take solace in the fact that they make stupid decisions sometimes just like the rest of us. This is never more evident in the projects that they end up working on. In critiquing celebrities, we tend to focus on the roles they accept. But I can almost understand an actor taking part in a production that's really sort of beneath them. They've got bills to pay, after all. But I really struggle with the roles that some actors reject. Maybe they didn't realize that the part they passed on would become a cultural icon, but with some of these people it's like they turned their nose up at the material for seemingly arbitrary reasons. In most of these cases, I'm happier with the person that ended up in the role. But you have to wonder, what was going on in their heads to make them say no to this film?

10. Garth Brooks - Twister

Apparently back when Garth Brooks was at the height of his fame, he considered branching off into the acting world, only to be foiled by his own ego. He was considered for the role of the antagonist in Twister (the rival meteorologist played by Cary Elwes, if I'm remembering correctly) but turned it down. Why? Because he was concerned that the tornado would upstage him. I only wish I was joking. Other memorable moments from Garth Brooks' failed acting career include the time that he turned down a role in the critically-acclaimed Saving Private Ryan, because he didn't feel that he should have to play second fiddle to actors like Tom Hanks or Matt Damon. This is Garth Brooks, man. He's a big star. What business do actual, legitimate actors have getting billed above Garth? This sort of thing never would have happened to Chris Gaines.

9. Lindsay Lohan - The Hangover

This generation's Courtney Love was up for the role of Jade in The Hangover, but she rejected the project because she didn't believe that it had the potential to succeed. While this isn't necessarily a terrible reason to turn down a role, it comes off as a little too picky for someone who doesn't exactly have offers pouring in all the time. After all, beggars can't be choosers. The film went on to be a box office hit, spawning two sequels and single-handedly launching Mike Tyson's acting career. Had she accepted the project, it could have been that one role that launched her back into the realm of credibility as an actor. But what am I saying? That would just be the smart thing to do.

8. Gwyneth Paltrow - Titanic

James Cameron's production of Titanic was a world-wide phenomenon, launching the careers of Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet into the stratosphere (as well as creating a really adorable friendship between the two which has lasted over a decade and a half). But when the film was pitched to Paltrow, she declined, saying it simply wasn't her cup of tea. This is understandable. I too hate success and fame. Seriously, though, how could you look at the script for Titanic and not realize that it was going to be a blockbuster hit? Sure, you maybe wouldn't have anticipated it becoming quite as big as it was, grossing over 1.8 billion dollars, but it never looked like it was going to be a failure. I'm not saying that she was wasting her time filming Sliding Doors or Great Expectations, but Titanic will be remembered forever, and it's got to be hard not to kick yourself for failing to get your name on it.

7. Jack Nicholson - The Godfather

Back in the 1970s, Jack Nicholson was up for the iconic role of Michael Corleone in The Godfather, a character that has been immortalized by Al Pacino. The reason that he passed on the part was because at the time, he thought that only Italians should play Italians. While I can appreciate the desire for authenticity, I find this somewhat spurious logic -- surely the point of acting is to pretend to be something you're not? Oh well. Jack Nicholson has had more than enough career-defining roles to make up for missing out on The Godfather. And while Jack Nicholson, especially at his creative peak in the 70s, could be well trusted with pretty much any character, I'd be more than a little sad if I never got to see Al Pacino's version of the character.

6. Ralph Macchio - Back to the Future

Today, we remember Ralph Macchio almost exclusively for his work in The Karate Kid, but it's surprising to think how close he was to the other gigantic franchise of the 1980s. Most people know the story of how Eric Stoltz was originally cast as Marty McFly in Back to the Future. They shot part of the movie, it wasn't working, they recast the role with Michael J. Fox, and the rest is history. But before any of that happened, Ralph Macchio was a contender for the part. Or would have been, if he'd actually taken the time to read the script properly. He's gone on record saying that he turned down the role because at the time, he thought it was just about "a kid, a car, and plutonium pills". Uh...ok?

5. Johnny Depp - Ferris Bueller's Day Off

There's a pretty long list of high profile roles that Johnny Depp rejected during the 1980s and 1990s. Chief among them is the teen classic Ferris Bueller's Day Off, an irreverent hit that made Matthew Broderick a star. He also passed on the iconic role of Lestat in Interview With the Vampire (eventually played by Tom Cruise), and Brad Pitt's role in Legends of the Fall. Why was he against these roles? "I'm not a blockbuster boy," he said. Oh really? If 90s Johnny Depp could see himself now, he would cry his beautiful, soulful eyes out. Of course none of us can foresee the future, but it seems a bit rich for the guy who's about to start work on Pirates of the Caribbean 5 to be turning his nose up at high-profile roles like he's better than that.

4. Julia Roberts - The Proposal

The Proposal was a hugely successful and surprisingly enjoyable romantic comedy that starred Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds, doing the old pretending to be engaged for a green card bit. It could have starred Julia Roberts, but she reportedly turned down the role after being asked to take a pay cut. While she's a decent actress, she's a few years out of relevance to be demanding millions, especially while the film industry was hit by the same recession as everyone else and most A-List actors were being paid far less than their usual quote. I would argue that her last good film was Ocean's 11, which came out twelve years ago. Interestingly enough, she passed on The Blind Side, a role which also went to Bullock and even earned her an Oscar. It seems like she's learned her lesson, though -- her slate for the next year or so includes August: Osage County and The Normal Heart, two prestigious stage-to-film adaptations.

3. Tom Selleck - Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark

In my opinion, Tom Selleck does not understand why the medium of television exists for actors. It is a means to an end, a way to pay the bills while you're waiting for Hollywood to come calling. Because that's the ultimate dream, right? Movies. So when you get a once-in-a-lifetime offer to play Indiana Jones, but you're supposed to be filming Magnum PI, you bail like your life depends on it. Contracts are made to be broken. Having been forced to give up the role, he never quite got another big break to make up for the one he lost. Meanwhile, Harrison Ford has become one of the popular and highest grossing actors of the past 50 years. Them's the breaks.

2. Kevin Costner - The Shawshank Redemption

Let's face it, Kevin Costner is kind of the poster child of turning down juicy roles. But for the purposes of this article, I'd like to focus on his biggest and most egregious error in judgment. Back in the early 90s, Costner decided against taking the role of Andy Dufresne in The Shawshank Redemption, a character which Tim Robbins ended up playing in the Oscar-nominated modern classic. His reason? He was busy making Waterworld. As far as I'm concerned, "I'm busy making Waterworld" is one of the worst excuses I've ever heard of not to do something, right up there with "I'm having my carpets shampooed," or "I think I'm getting oral surgery that day." Because at least either of those excuses don't threaten to ruin your credibility as an actor/director. Seriously, Kevin...Waterworld?

1. Will Smith - Django Unchained

Word on the street is that Will Smith passed on Django Unchained because he felt that Django (despite his name being in the title) was not the main character of the film, and that he was only really available for leading roles at this point in his career. Uh-huh. First of all, let's check our star status for a minute. Tell me about all these offers for leading roles that you've been getting. Because all I see on your IMDB page is a bunch of sequels from back when you were a movie star. Face it, Will -- those days are nearing an end. You're not getting any younger, and getting a big role (sure, maybe not the lead) in a Quentin Tarantino film would have been a huge step towards the next stage in your career. You think you can keep playing the wise-cracking action hero forever? Django would have given you instant credibility at a crucial point in your career. Smart actors will take smaller roles in good films to stay relevant -- consider, for example, Tom Cruise in Tropic Thunder. I don't say this often, but you should sit down with your Scientology buddy and take some notes.