Though rumours have been swirling for months that a new, all-female Ghostbusters movie was in the works, it was only earlier this month that director Paul Feig confirmed that it was actually happening, and that he would be taking the helm. Unsurprisingly, the reception to the news has been wildly mixed, with many expressing their disappointment, while less-articulate commentators have opted for the usual sexist mudslinging that does nobody any favours. An all-female Ghostbusters sequel-reboot is either going to completely blow or be a surprisingly refreshing take on a classic franchise, that much is sure. However, as much as women-centric comedies should be encouraged given the lack of movies (be it comedies or otherwise) topped by female casts in Hollywood, there is plenty of good reason to be skeptical about this decision. Outside of all the sexist reasons, there are plenty of legitimate answers as to why an all-female Ghostbusters movie shouldn't happen, tarnishing the legacy of the original that's already relatively tattered by the disappointing second film. Can't they just let the 2009 video game act as Ghostbusters 3 instead? At least that included the involvement of all four original Ghostbusters...
10. It Reeks Of Gimmicky Tokenism
The sad thing about this all-female Ghostbusters film is that its female-centric cast has been the key selling point, which can't help but make it seem like a gimmick. Why not talk up director Paul Feig or writer Kate Dippold instead? Though a female-only movie is not inherently a gimmick, of course, it just seems like a very deliberate and unnecessary attempt to tokenise the movie, to make it "Ghostbusters...but with girls", which is going to be a tough sell to anyone who grew up with the original line-up. Yes, the frequently-cited comparison to making a Sex and the City sequel with men doesn't really hold water (given that Ghostbusters has never really been about the gender of its characters), but why not make the cast a little more diverse, with a mixture of men and women? Sure, the same could be said of the original film, but if Feig and co. want to maximise their box office appeal, it's probably a smart idea not to completely cut out any and all male characters.
9. Ernie Hudson Thinks It's A Bad Idea
Hell, one of the original Ghostbusters, Winston Zeddemore himself, thinks it's a bad idea. In a recent interview with The Telegraph, Hudson put it perfectly: ""If it has nothing to do with the other two movies, and it's all female, then why are you calling it Ghostbusters?...All-female I think would be a bad idea. I don't think the fans want to see that...Maybe it will come out and be the most amazing thing, but in my opinion I think it would be wrong to do another movie that didn't include the guys. And that didn't include me!" Hudson did rather amusingly continue that "at least hopefully it'll be sexy", and despite his flippancy, he does make some pretty sensible, reasoned points as to why moving forward with this concept is a bad idea.
8. Movie Reboots Are Mostly Awful
The movie reboot is a rather dispiriting trend that has taken off hugely in the last few years, wherein there's apparently no shame anymore in restarting a franchise that's only been dead for even a few years, as in the case of the Spider-Man series. Whether talking about serious films or comedies, the list of recent reboots that actually worked is incredibly small (Star Trek, the Jump Street series), whereas most people have lost count of the number of flop reboots (more so critically than commercially). In terms of the sheer numbers game, the odds are heavily stacked against Feig and co. for producing a reboot that actually works. Only a small number of filmmakers have managed to pull off a reboot that actually made money and didn't anger fans of the original, and as such it's highly unlikely that a new Ghostbusters movie, even though sure to be financially successful, will go over well with fans of the original. Some of them will go see it, but more out of morbid curiosity than anything.
7. A New Ghostbusters Movie Is A Bad Idea. Period.
Even ignoring the idea of the series being rebooted, hasn't the boat kinda sailed on a new Ghostbusters movie anyway? There have been countless attempts to get Ghostbusters 3 made over the last 25 years, but due to various issues (namely Bill Murray being unhappy with the script), it's never come to fruition. Now, fans have to come to terms with the fact that even if a straight Ghostbusters sequel were made, it wouldn't feature writer-actor Harold Ramis (who died earlier this year), nor director Ivan Reitman (who stepped down from the director's chair after Ramis died, though will stay on as a producer), and Bill Murray likely wouldn't be involved either. Those complaining about an all-female Ghostbusters movie because they think it's somehow going to get in the way of a classic reunion movie are wrong: the best fans would ever get is one starring Dan Aykroyd and Ernie Hudson with a new group of younger Ghostbusters, so doesn't this pretty much ensure that a new Ghostbusters movie is a terrible idea regardless of which fresh new faces are in it?
6. Casting Will Be Incredibly Predictable
As well as showing his support for the all-female Ghostbusters movie, Bill Murray recently suggested his own casting picks for the movie, which included Melissa McCarthy, Kristen Wiig, Emma Stone and Linda Cardellini. They're all fine choices, no doubt, though given that pretty much every commentator on the Internet has come up with the same batch of women to star in the film, doesn't it all just feel a bit safe and predictable? While it's entirely possible that Paul Feig could surprise us and cast a few against-type actresses, it'd be a major shock if McCarthy (who will be discussed again later) and Wiig didn't make the cut given their previous success working with Feig. Still, there's the overwhelming fear that the cast could simply be "Bridesmaids Revisited" rather than something that stands on its own two feet. Even so, there's admittedly a fair question that follows: would people really be making the same complaint if, say, Michael Cera, Jonah Hill, Channing Tatum, Danny McBride and James Franco were cast in an all-male Ghostbusters movie? Quite possibly not, valid though the complaint would still be.
5. It's Exploiting The Ghostbusters Legacy
As with pretty much any reboot by their sheer nature, this new Ghostbusters movie is blatantly exploiting the lucrative Ghostbusters license and fanbase, and as Ernie Hudson himself said: if there's none of the original guys in it, how exactly is it a Ghostbusters movie? Why not just make this all-female ghost-hunting movie, keep the script mostly the same but remove the Ghostbusters name? That way they'll avoid annoying the fanbase of the original movie if it sucks, and they'll be more likely to give it a chance as it's not piggy-backing on what came before in order to make money. Hell, they can even market it as "Ghostbusters for a new generation!", but just don't call it Ghostbusters. Still, money ultimately talks, and the Ghostbusters name accounts for huge brand recognition, and therefore doesn't represent the same financial gamble as a new franchise, similar though it might be. Using the Ghostbusters name when the end result is likely to be so different from what's come before, though, seems tacky and crass, a commercial calculation rather than an artistic necessity.
4. The Internet Has Already Pre-Hated It Into Oblivion
Yes, articles such as this probably aren't helping stem the flow of negativity, but as soon as the idea was released into the wild, there were plenty of detractors online ready to flame the movie into oblivion before it even began production. While many of them are misogynistic "neckbeards" simply touting an ignorant sexist agenda, there are also those more reasoned skeptics who cite genuine reasons for concern about an all-female Ghostbusters flick. The point is that so many have already made their minds up about the new movie and simply aren't prepared to give it a chance, even if the trailer ends up looking not-awful. Though some might go see it out of morbid curiosity, plenty will likely boycott a film with no involvement from the original actors or creative minds, even if the all-girl cast could easily open the film up to a wider new audience (namely teenage girls). There's absolutely no way all this Internet bile will result in the movie bombing, but it doesn't exactly set a great precedent right out of the gate.
3. Melissa McCarthy
Of all the casting choices to expect in the new Ghostbusters, the dead-cert you can count on is Melissa McCarthy. Not only is she pure box office dynamite at the moment, she's an Academy Award-nominated actress, and has worked with director Paul Feig on his last two movies, Bridesmaids and The Heat. If she doesn't end up as one of the main characters in Ghostbusters, it would be a huge shock. A lot of the early comments about the new movie were critical of McCarthy's casting, that the humour would lean too heavily on jokes about the actress's weight and her tendency to fall over in most of her films. Even ignoring that, her obnoxiousness is off-putting to many (though not enough to deny her box office success, apparently), who suspect her loud, boisterous brand of comedy will result in a film vastly inferior to the hilarious wit of the original. If McCarthy tones down her shtick a little and is perhaps kept to a minimal role (with no defecation in a sink and less fat jokes), then she might fit in fine, though that won't stop many groaning at her probable inclusion.
2. Paul Feig's Involvement
Paul Feig seems like a cool guy, and it's hard to hold much against the guy who not only created Freaks and Geeks, but has directed episodes for hit shows such as Arrested Development, 30 Rock, Mad Men, Weeds, Parks and Recreation, Nurse Jackie and The Office (U.S.). His cinematic work, however? Not so great. His first notable efforts, I Am David and Unaccompanied Minors, were both rinsed by critics, and though Bridesmaids went on to be a critical and commercial hit, was it really all that great? Amiable to a point for sure, it just doesn't really hold up on repeat viewings, and is far from the hilarity of the original Ghostbusters. As for Feig's follow-up The Heat, the less said about it the better... Though Feig is definitely a talented director when given the right material, he just doesn't seem like a good fit for Ghostbusters (radically different though it will likely be to the original). Filmmakers like Chris Miller and Phil Lord, who have experience relaunching a classic property (21 Jump Street) and somehow made The Lego Movie work, would be a great pick, and other solid choices are Evan Goldberg (This Is the End) and Adam McKay (Anchorman).
1. It Probably Won't Happen Anyway
Even considering Feig's insistence that the movie will be happening in spite of a huge tide of negativity, a third Ghostbusters movie, in whatever form it takes, is still something most people won't believe until they're actually sat in a cinema watching it. It's taken so long to get the film off the ground that it almost seems as though it's just not meant to be, as though fate itself knows another Ghostbusters isn't part of the plan, and wants to stop it. Perhaps without any of the principal cast attached it will be much easier to get the ball rolling, but even so, it's such a controversial idea, and ensuring both the right script and cast are in place will be a Herculean feat that could easily crumble before production begins. What do you make of the planned Ghostbusters reboot? Shout it out in the comments!