10 Reasons The Flash Failed
You can't outrun this many bad decisions.
The Flash has failed. Opening to a weak 55 million dollars at the box office, the long-delayed DC superhero epic cratered in its second weekend, earning a paltry $15.3 million dollars, and dropping a staggering 73%.
After years of build-up, false starts, controversies and empty-promises, the much ballyhooed film tripped over its own feet before it crossed the starting line.
Pre-release, the current DC studios chief, James Gunn, and WB CEO, David Zaslav, proclaimed The Flash one of the greatest superhero epics of all-time, with luminaries like Stephen King and Tom Cruise seconding their opinion.
Michael Keaton stepped back into the cowl as Batman to bring the nostalgia factor, and DC aimed to cash-in on the multiverse craze. Hopes ran high that the Scarlet Speedster would zoom past the controversies surrounding its troubled star, Ezra Miller, and make a massive impression at the box office.
Unfortunately for the already-troubled DC cinematic universe, audiences soundly rejected the film, giving it a substandard 'B' cinemascore and putting a final nail in the coffin of the DCEU - at least as we knew it.
So, what went wrong? How could such a massively hyped film fall so flat? What cautionary example can future filmmakers draw from The Flash's example?
Let's catalogue the artistic hubris, poor decisions and bizarre events that made The Flash a total flameout at the box office.
10. Marvel Did It First
In the comics, Flash has been dealing with alternate versions of himself since 1961's "Flash of Two Worlds", but Marvel brought the idea of the multiverse to movie audiences first, with 2019's Avengers: Endgame, and set the ground rules for it in 2021's Disney Plus series, Loki. While these films hinted at the wild storytelling possibilities the multiverse offered, it wasn't until Spider-Man: No Way Home that the multiverse conceit realized it's full potential.
No Way Home took the unprecedented step of bringing in Spider-Men from previous iterations of the franchise to interact with the latest version of the character. The idea of seeing Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield donning their Spidey-suits one more time drove fans gaga, and powered No Way Home to a massive $260 million dollar opening weekend and a $1.9 billion dollar worldwide gross.
After that, any multiverse film that followed would have an uphill battle standing out.
Unfortunately for WB, No Way Home stole The Flash's thunder, and even the promise of Michael Keaton's return as Batman could not inspire the same kind of fan fervor as Marvel's record-breaking smash hit.
If The Flash crossed the finish line first, it might have faired better.
9. Studio Meddling
When Zack Snyder launched the DCEU with 2013's Man of Steel, WB was quick to announce a new slate of films that would fill out their shared universe, including a Flash movie starring Ezra Miller, set for a 2018 release date.
After Snyder's Man of Steel followup Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice divided fans, WB decided to change course, hiring Joss Whedon to rework Snyder's upcoming Justice League film after Snyder stepped away from the project.
Whedon's mangled movie failed at the box office, bringing about yet another course-correction for the DCEU. Walter Hamada stepped in as head of DC studios, and began retooling The Flash to fit in with his DC vision.
Hamada's controversial tenure saw him battling with Justice League star Ray Fisher, resulting in Fisher being written out of The Flash, which he was planned to costar in. More changes were to come.
In 2022, new WB CEO David Zaslav removed Hamada as head of DC studios. Zaslav tinkered with The Flash, ensuring that it would align with newly-minted DC head James Gunn's vision for the franchise.
Each new studio head tweaked the film, resulting in contrasting visions that muddled The Flash beyond repair.
8. Multiverses Are Already Stale
When WB first announced the film in 2014, making a Flash movie that involved alternate Earths was a no-brainer.
Flash first introduced the concept of alternate Earths in the DC comics, and Jim Lee's celebrated Flashpoint arc made Flash's manipulation of time via the speedforce a major plot point. If any character should introduce multiverses to the masses, The Flash was the logical choice.
However, almost a decade elapsed before The Flash finally landed in theatres, and in that time, the multiverse had not only become a familiar trope, it had already grown stale.
After Endgame, Marvel took the concept and ran with it.
By the time the Flash saw release, Loki, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness and Spider-Man: No Way Home had all dealt with the multiverse as a plot point. Beyond this, Best Picture winner Everything Everywhere All At Once and Best Animated Feature winner Spider-Man: Into the Spiderverse showed audiences what an elevated take on the subject looked like.
After these powerhouses dazzled moviegoers, The Flash had no hope of bringing something new to the table.
7. Snyder Fans Made Online Discussions Toxic
While Zack Snyder's vision for DC's most iconic heros rubbed movie critics the wrong way, a significant contingent of fans loved Snyder's dark, thematically-rich take on DC's biggest icons.
Once Whedon's Justice League tanked, a social media campaign dubbed #ReleasetheSnyderCut gained traction on Twitter and other social media platforms, resulting in the release of Zack Snyder's version of Justice League on streaming.
Even though they succeeded in their aim to have Snyder's vision for Justice League released, Snyderverse fans weren't satisfied. The Snyderverse faithful continued to insist that the director be allowed to finish the five film arc he planned before stepping away from DC films.
Their demands grew so loud that James Gunn addressed the backlash on two separate occasions, insisting that he will not be influenced by persistent social media campaigns.
Despite Gunn's pleas for fans to be openminded, The Flash's trailers were bombarded by negative comments from pro-Snyder accounts, poisoning the social media well, and further hamstringing a production already beset by numerous controversies.
6. James Gunn Turned The DCEU Into A Lameduck
Fans celebrated when David Zaslav picked James Gunn to replace Walter Hamada as DC studios new chief. Once he secured his position, Gunn took to social media, answering fan questions and teasing what the future might hold.
Unfortunately for DCEU films that had yet to be released, Gunn made it clear that the upcoming roster of DC films would not have a significant impact on the Gunnverse. While this gambit might have benefited Gunn's impending slate, it rendered the remaining DCEU movies lame ducks. Any future crossovers, plot points or characters teased in DCEU films would be meaningless after DC's change of guard.
This lack of connection to a larger storyline undoubtedly hurt the DCEU's box office tallies. This was no more apparent than in 2021, when Black Adam ended with a much-hyped cameo featuring the return of Henry Cavill's Superman, only to have Gunn announce Cavill's departure from the franchise before Black Adam left theatres.
Gunn's antics let fans know that The Flash's story would not impact the larger DC narrative, making the film a footnote from DC's past before it was even released.
5. A Genuine Production Hell
The Flash will go down in history as one of the most troubled productions in recent memory. As early as 2007, Warner Brothers had tried to bring a version of The Flash to the big screen, though none had ever managed to get off the ground and once the DCEU kicked off, production on The Flash became troubled almost immediately.
A veritable revolving-door of directors and screenwriters became associated with the property over the years, as it struggled to reach completion.
At one point, Phil Lord and Christopher Miller of Into the Spiderverse fame began developing a script for The Flash, only to leave the project over creative differences.
King Arthur: Legend of the Sword screenwriter Joby Harold began a complete rewrite, which was then rewritten again by Game Night directors John Daley and Jonathan Goldstein. Goldstein and Daley's reworked version of Harold's script eventually served as the wider story for The Flash, with Birds of Prey scribe Christina Hodson receiving screenwriting credit.
This mishmash of screenwriting voices resulted in a muddied final product and contrasting tones, which did The Flash no favors at the box office.
4. Ezra's Barry Allen Isn't For Everyone
WB's shifting studio heads led to a tonal inconsistency across the DCEU.
Wishing to steer clear of the grim tone of the divisive Snyderverse, WB's post-Snyder output became lighter in tone, bringing it more in line with MCU's approach.
This push and pull of styles is apparent in the version of The Flash audiences saw in theatres. In the film, alternate reality Millers portray a younger and older version of the character, with the younger iteration of Barry doubling down on the goofy tone established in Whedon's Justice League, turning this Allen into an annoying slacker.
While the Scarlet Speedster has always been a motor-mouthed quip-machine, younger Barry leans so heavily on goofy humor that the character is robbed of any gravitas whatsoever. Miller's comedy-heavy portrayal of younger Barry deadens the film's impact during its climax, where younger Barry is expected to do considerable dramatic heavy-lifting.
In the comics, Flash could be funny, but he was never goofy. This deviation from the source material ultimately hurt the film, undoubtedly contributing to the lacklustre word-of-mouth and minimal repeat business.
3. Ezra Miller's Controversies
Back in 2020, on the heels of appearing in multiple DC projects, Ezra Miller seemed poised to become a massive star. Unfortunately, things soon went awry when Miller found themselves at the centre of numerous legal troubles.
A video showing the star choke a female fan blew up on social media, leading to many fans calling for Miller to be removed from any upcoming DC projects.
However, WB decided to stick with the troubled actor amid the controversy. The incident appeared to largely blow over. In 2021, Miller won the Oscar's Favorite Cheer Moment poll (thanks in part a social media campaign led by the Snyderverse fandom) and all seemed well enough.
But the notorious choking incident wasn't Miller's only brush with controversy. In 2022, Miller became the centre of numerous viral clashes with the law, including alleged assaults. Ultimately, Miller issued an apology for their behaviour, pled guilty an unlawful trespassing charge and entered treatment for mental health issues.
This about-face from the contrite star failed to sway moviegoers, which likely contributed to the audience for The Flash skewing heavily male in its opening weekend, seeing men comprise 73% of tickets sales, much higher than average.
2. A Non-Existent Marketing Campaign
With Ezra Miller's off-air antics making them persona non grata for many viewers, WB found itself with a predicament:
How do you market a movie without its star?
The studio decided that the best way to sidestep the Ezra issue would be to focus The Flash's trailers on the return of Michael Keaton's Batman. Keaton had not donned the cowl since 1992 and, with the mammoth success of Spider-Man: No Way Home, WB banked on Keaton-nostalgia to make up the difference at the box office. While Keaton acquitted himself well in the role, audiences at large greeted his return with a shrug.
James Gunn and David Zaslav also attempted to juice the box office by publicly proclaiming The Flash to be among the greatest superhero movies ever made - a claim that created unrealistic expectations.
When The Flash didn't match the hype, fans immediately called foul.
Further compounding these miscalculations, WB presented numerous free screenings of The Flash to fans in the hope to build hype. This gambit had the opposite effect of what they intended, eating away at the opening weekend box office and further contributing to the image of The Flash as a dud.
1. No Zack Snyder
The source of The Flash's many productions-related travails can be traced back to the second film in the DCEU, Batman V Superman.
Even though Snyder appeared to be on the right track with BvS outgrossing Man of Steel and making nearly 900 million at the box office, BvS' reception instigated a period of reactive business decision from WB, effectively derailing their extended universe plans.
After Snyder's departure, WB threw out the multi-film arc Snyder had set the groundwork for. This arc would have included a solo Flash film, and while there is no way to tell how successful it would have been, being part of a coherent multi-film narrative would've likely made it more intriguing for general audiences.
With WB's game plan in constant flux, The Flash never had a chance to realize its potential.
The Flash has concluded the DCEU, and the Gunnverse will now take DC films into the future. If WB wishes to avoid another Flash-level bomb, they need to allow Gunn to fulfil his DC vision, and avoid knee-jerk decisions made to appease shareholders over film fans.