10 Reasons Why Lightyear Failed
Breaking down why Pixar's Toy Story spin-off failed to connect with audiences.
To say it's been a rough week for Pixar is quite the understatement.
This past weekend the beloved animation studio released their first theatrical animated film in over two years, with high hopes that Toy Story spin-off Lightyear would restore the company's standing on the big screen.
But alas, while Lightyear's reviews have been decent enough, it's already cratered catastrophically at the box office.
With a $200 million budget, the sci-fi adventure film needs to gross around $500 million to turn a profit theatrically, and yet following its disastrous opening weekend, it's going to struggle to make even $400 million.
It's a sad result for a film from the most critically acclaimed animation studio on the planet, and a spin-off movie from their most beloved IP no less.
Industry analysts and fans alike have been racking their brains ever since trying to make sense of why Lightyear failed to strike a chord with audiences, but there's really no single reason that can be pointed to.
Lightyear's failure is the result of a complex confluence of circumstances which, collectively, ensured it simply wasn't an appealing option for most viewers.
So, here are the 10 biggest reasons why Lightyear has struggled to connect with the mainstream...
10. It Wasn't About OUR Buzz Lightyear
One of the more blatant reasons that Lightyear didn't make a dent with the millions and millions of Toy Story fans is that it isn't about our Buzz Lightyear.
Fans of course love the character, but the version presented here - a human astronaut voiced by Chris Evans - is such a far cry from the charmingly neurotic toy we know and love that he's near-unrecognisable beyond the perfunctory invocations of the character's classic one-liners.
Knowing that the goofy Buzz Lightyear from the Toy Story films was inspired by a relatively po-faced version of the character from a 1995 movie isn't as appealing as Pixar thinks, and simply, fans are only really interested in the Buzz they've grown up with.
Had Lightyear been styled instead in the vein of the Star Command movie and TV show, with Buzz presented similarly to his Toy Story self, than it surely would've had an easier time getting people's attention.
As it stands, Disney and Pixar vastly overestimated the general audience's interest in a more realistic proto-Buzz.
9. Vague Marketing Turned Audiences Off
Misaimed marketing can cause even the best movie to flop, and in Lightyear's case it's a major reason for its failure to draw in larger audiences.
It didn't help that, until the final marketing push, Disney hadn't made it particularly clear what Lightyear actually was.
Many saw the first trailer and assumed it was a biopic of the real astronaut who inspired the Buzz Lightyear toys, only for later trailers to reveal that it's actually the film that Andy saw back in 1995.
Throw in confusion over its tone, torn between a more serious-minded sci-fi film and fluffy family comedy, and it wasn't easy for more casual audiences to get a handle on exactly what Lightyear was supposed to be.
More than anything, the trailers failed to cement the film as a must-see event, and that ambivalence over whether it was worth a trip to the multiplex surely prompted many millions to wait until it hits Disney+ in 45-or-so days.
8. The Story Was Too Generic For Adults, Too Confusing For Kids
One of the most common complaints about Lightyear from the moment its first trailer dropped was, "Who is this for?"
While the obvious answer might be Toy Story fans, the marketing largely underplayed its status as a spin-off, focusing instead on the gritty sci-fi elements and then, in later trailers, the goofy comedy.
Yet the final film is an awkward stew of elements that don't quite cohere: the sci-fi adventure story is too formulaic and familiar to make much of an impression with older viewers, while the time dilation mechanics will simply be too complex for younger viewers to make sense of.
And so Lightyear ends up a film powered by a relatively flat, underwhelming story that's unlikely to leave many completely satisfied or fully emotionally invested.
7. The Dumb "Controversy"
When discussing Lightyear's audience response it's tragically impossible to ignore the online conservative backlash to the film's more progressive themes.
Prior to release, Disney confirmed that the film would feature a kiss between two women, which turned out to be Buzz's (Chris Evans) Space Ranger partner Alisha Hawthorne (Uzo Aduba) and her wife.
It's an incredibly minor moment in the film, though a win for Pixar, as the company has reportedly had their attempts to feature LGBT characters and stories in the past censored by Disney executives. Yet beyond causing Lightyear to be banned in more than a dozen countries, the scene prompted the usual suspects to whine about Pixar injecting their "politics" into art aimed primarily at children, resulting in an influx of online media piling on the film before it had even dropped.
Homophobia has been not-so-subtly couched into much of the criticism levelled at Lightyear, with a lot being written online about it being a "woke" movie rather than, you know, a story that just so happens to fleetingly feature a gay couple.
All in all the fuss stirred up online about this tiny moment simply presented another obstacle that the film had to overcome with the masses, with this "controversy" dominating headlines.
It's a depressing result, though, given that it provides ammunition to many right-leaning bad actors to tout the inane "go woke, go broke" line once again.
6. Animation Is Generally Struggling At The Box Office
It's easy to overlook the fact that animation as a medium is struggling at the box office, and while many have been quick to cite audiences getting used to watching Pixar movies day-and-date on Disney+, that doesn't explain the bleak wider picture.
Since the pandemic started, the highest-grossing animated film has been Sing 2, which scored a relatively mediocre $407.5 million, putting it far behind the pandemic-era's biggest live-action hits.
The reason for this? Families are struggling to justify a trip to the cinema - which, factoring in petrol, parking, and snacks, can easily exceed $100 for five people - when they can wait no more than six weeks and watch the movie at home for a fraction of the price.
With the current global inflation crisis causing families around the world to tighten their belts, such a large expense for a mere two hours at the movies is an easy one to cut.
In Lightyear's specific case it certainly didn't help that it was going up against Top Gun: Maverick and Jurassic World Dominion - both of which were far more appealing to the Father's Day crowd - but the prevailing fact is that animation as a whole is continuing to stumble theatrically.
The industry's eyes are now very much looking towards the upcoming Minions: The Rise of Gru, praying that it can finally lure families back to the multiplex en masse. As ever, we'll have to wait and see.
5. The Absence Of Tim Allen As Buzz
Many have also pointed to the absence of original Buzz Lightyear actor Tim Allen as contributing to Lightyear flopping.
While it's not inherently nonsensical to cast a younger actor as a more virile version of Buzz - given that Allen is almost 70 years old today - many were disappointed that Allen wasn't involved in some way.
Some felt that Disney opted not to cast Allen in the part due to his controversial political comments, yet considering that Allen just recently wrapped shooting a Santa Clause series for Disney+, that doesn't seem likely.
It certainly would've made sense for Allen to play the older Buzz we meet later in the film, though.
As good as Chris Evans was voicing Buzz, it's admittedly hard not to view his casting as a little cynical, that Disney just had to put an Avenger in the role. Some meanwhile suggested that Pixar should've hired Patrick Warburton instead, who voiced Buzz in the Buzz Lightyear of Star Command TV series.
Given that Tim Allen is Buzz Lightyear, his presence was sorely missed by a lot of fans, regardless of the fact that this wasn't the toy version of Buzz.
4. The Hugely Divisive Plot Twist
By far the most divisive aspect of Lightyear's story is its big mid-film plot twist, where it's revealed that Zurg is in fact none other than an older Buzz Lightyear (James Brolin) from an alternate timeline.
This naturally rankled many fans due it directly contradicting the twist in Toy Story 2, where Zurg was revealed to be Buzz's father.
Many felt it was little more than an attempt at shock value, to change things up because everybody of course knows Zurg's identity from the Toy Story movies.
Despite James Brolin's solid performance in the role, fans aren't thrilled at having existing lore rewritten.
Though it's probable that Old Buzz isn't the "real" Zurg and simply appropriated his identity, it was still a poorly executed rug-pull that never fully justified itself beyond "Hey, surprise!"
The vitriolic response to the big reveal helped dampen Lightyear's word-of-mouth on release weekend, no doubt contributing to its poor box office performance in the process.
3. It Felt Like A Disney+ Film
It's somewhat ironic that Lightyear is the first Pixar film in over two years to get a theatrical release, and yet for the most part it actually feels like a straight-to-Disney+ film.
Now, that's not really a slight against Disney+ movies at all, but simply that Lightyear lacks the finesse that defines almost all of their work - including their three prior films, Soul, Luca, and Turning Red, which were sent straight to Disney+.
Despite its stonking $200 million budget - more than any of those three movies - Lightyear feels in its bones like an amusing little Toy Story spin-off that isn't quite theatrical caliber, no matter how gorgeous its visuals might often be.
Again, there's no shade intended against the films Disney releases direct to their streaming service, but since the pandemic audiences have generally become far more discerning about what they leave the house to watch.
As a piece of storytelling, Lightyear simply lacks that attention-grabbing spark or zeitgeist-capturing sense of FOMO.
2. The Underwhelming Critical Reception
Now, it would be silly to say that Lightyear was negatively received by critics, but its current Rotten Tomatoes score - 76% with a 6.8/10 average - does place it firmly on the lower end for Pixar.
Considering that the movie's aforementioned marketing woes left a lot of potential audience members on the fence, broadly positive reviews mostly in the three-star range didn't exactly persuade many that it was worth rushing to the cinema for.
Had Lightyear received rave reviews on par with, say, Top Gun: Maverick, it surely would've performed considerably better.
While the critically panned Jurassic World Dominion managed to stave off its poor reviews due to the inherent appeal of both dinosaurs and its legacy cast, Lightyear had neither luxury, and so the reviews did little to encourage anyone who was already ambivalent about it.
1. It's A Spin-Off Nobody Asked For
And yet, perhaps the primary reason that Lightyear failed? It's a spin-off that nobody asked for or was particularly interested in even once it was revealed.
Again, a Buzz Lightyear spin-off featuring the real Tim Allen Buzz toy, either within the Toy Story universe or as part of the Star Command franchise that inspired the toys, might've actually gotten fans interested.
But given that Toy Story 4 only came out a few years ago and just barely managed to justify its existence, a tangential movie about a different version of Buzz was always going to be a relatively tough sell.
In a present where media companies are circling their branding wagons and trying to milk their existing IP for every drop, Lightyear should be seen as a cautionary tale. If you drop $200 million on a spin-off from a beloved IP, be absolutely sure it's what people are actually interested in seeing.