10 Reasons Why Marvel Studios Fans Don't Like John Carter

By Ian Boucher /

Advertisement

There€™s no way around it. John Carter was a critical and commercial failure€”at least in the States, which is the only place that matters. The movie was condemned as a colossal flop before it even had a chance to perform. Common criticisms were its perceived similarity to other science fiction franchises, its lack of leading names in the cast, and its dense storyline.

Before its release, its reshoots and budget were regarded as delicious harbingers of failure. Upon the film€™s release, major critics led the way with their expertise, and most online entertainment venues jumped onto the anti-John Carter bandwagon. It became the movie to ridicule in 2012, despite the fact that to this day, if you ask casual moviegoers their opinions of the film (those who actually saw it anyway), many of those opinions are more positive than negative.

Advertisement
Regardless of whether or not you enjoyed the John Carter movie, I think most of us can agree that on paper, it had a lot going for it. John Carter came out at a perfect time. Science fiction and fantasy are now actually in the mainstream, with many €œnormal€ people being invested in superheroes, wizards, and aliens, whether they know it or not - I for one have a dear nonfan friend who was shocked to learn that the TV show Arrow is based on a comic book. While not perfect, John Carter€™s characters are for the most part pretty entertaining with some great performances distributed throughout. The teams behind John Carter poured their hearts and souls into the movie€™s rich world using the best resources Hollywood could muster. The John Carter books have a very peripheral but strong enough fanbase which should have been able to bring nonfans into theaters and quell comparisons to properties like Prince of Persia or Avatar. The expansive source material had great franchise potential. And Disney was, uh... backing it. The fact is, whether or not it was the greatest movie since Casablanca, John Carter should have leapt into many of our hearts like the titular hero from the dead sea bottoms of Barsoom. But it didn€™t. Why? I€™m going to look at Marvel Studios to try and figure it out. After all, it has been immensely successful with its movies, now merrily expanding into Phase Two of its business venture. Because of Marvel Studios€™s unwavering efficiency and its ability to market to wide audiences, Marvel fans are what currently drive the science fiction and fantasy film economy. They bring their uninitiated friends€”whether by word of mouth or by force€”into theater seats, and thus more than any other demographic, Marvel fans alert executives about new trends in blockbuster taste. And for the most part, fans of the source, Marvel Comics, support Marvel Studios both financially and emotionally. Contrary to what usually happens with comic book movies, Marvel or otherwise, Marvel Comics fans are generally pleased with the Marvel Studios-controlled adaptations of their favorite characters. And because there€™s nothing comparable on the table for fans who prefer DC Comics outside of Batman and Superman, DC fans don€™t really have a choice but to support the Marvel movies through their fundamental desires to support their inner nerd. Because of this financial foundation, Marvel€™s public relations team has something to stand on, and through business networking and the omnipresent need for readers and viewers, the industry and various entertainment news venues reinforce the seemingly wonderful quality of the films. Nonfan normal counterparts, thinking that the movies are something to be respected, further perpetuate the cycle. Perhaps there is indeed something inherently €œMarvel€ at the heart of Marvel Studios€™s success, something present within Marvel comics, films, and other methods of delivery which helps make Marvel Studios€™s films a cut above the rest, and helps make other film franchises successful as well. Marvel fans can€™t be blinded by or biased toward anything, can they? The answer is no. Not at all. So without further delay, here are 10 reasons why Marvel Studios fans don€™t like a movie like John Carter.

10. John Carter Doesn€™t Cook Eggs For People

Even though neither Taylor Kitsch nor Chris Hemsworth were leading names at the times of John Carter€™s and Thor€™s respective releases, John Carter didn€™t make it while Thor did. After hours of experimentation, surveys, and being an expert, I€™ve determined that the reason for this has to be because John Carter doesn€™t cook eggs for people. John Carter€™s character arc in the movie just takes too long to resolve, because it actually develops. Andrew Stanton, Mark Andrews, and Michael Chabon should have learned from Thor€™s awe-inspiring example. Thor only had to get upset when he couldn€™t pick up his hammer. After that, all he had to do was decide to be nice, make eggs, and he was ready to sacrifice himself. What a solid way to get your powers back. Smooth, easy to digest, simple, cutting right to the chase. Why do we know this was the right way to go? Sure, the box office numbers gave an indication, but what is still even more of an indicator is the absolute seriousness and reverence Marvel Studios fans have about them when discussing Thor, holding the movie much in the same regard as Iron Man or Captain America: The First Avenger. Anyone can take a fantastical movie seriously. Anyone can be entertained by a popcorn movie. But this particular iteration of Thor, with an undernourished screenplay full of mostly by-the-numbers beats, is a genuinely special part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Why? Because it is, that€™s why. He swings his hammer and has cool friends. People generally say that Marvel Studios has yet to deliver a bad movie. Which is definitely true. A bad movie in Thor wasn€™t overlooked or ignored in the least€”it was fantastic, especially in the character of Darcy Lewis with her unique, categorically surprising quips about Thor being cute or taking a picture of Thor for Facebook or Thor not wearing a shirt. Marvel Studios used its creative independence and adapted the spectacular possibilities presented by the Thor character the right way, by sticking to basic Hollywood tropes. Not only did it keep them in the black, but the fans love it. So when John Carter tried to be a movie organically progressing its lead hero forward, that was the first nail in the coffin€”if Carter had requested a coffin, that is. John Carter isn€™t the only character in his movie guilty of this sin. If he were, the film may have been salvageable. Unfortunately, the movie is full of characters with multidimensional complexities. Dejah Thoris, the female lead, is already badass at the beginning, but the filmmakers just couldn€™t leave well enough alone. Badass is character definition enough these days, especially for females. All she had to do was be tough and fall in love with John Carter after talking to him in front of a campfire like Natalie Portman and we would have been happy. We know they€™re supposed to be star-crossed lovers, so why not just get it over with already? Instead, Dejah evolves organically almost as ridiculously much as Carter does. Yawn. Thor€™s Loki and John Carter€™s Matai Shang both have layers, but with Matai Shang, the viewer actually has to think about what Shang is saying and possibly wait for his larger motivations to be revealed in a sequel to truly see his whole arc, like a real trilogy. And on a related note, who needs Tars Tarkas€™s painful eyes so artfully rendered when we have Ray Stevenson€™s just as serviceable beard? Any real character development is better saved for a sequel anyway. Joss Whedon did some great work retroactively making Scarlett Johansson€™s Black Widow into a character pretending to be about more than fanboy fantasies. But if there€™s anything more immediate in my needs than a character getting to the end of the movie as conveniently as possible, it€™s my expectations for the next movie.

9. John Carter Isn€™t A Prequel Or Trailer For Something Else

Thanks for sticking with me on this True Believers. I don€™t know about you all, but when I watched John Carter, I had no idea what was coming next. It was so irritating to watch a movie that way. Sure, I could have been just watched it and taken it in, or read the books first, but even though they€™re mostly simple pulp narratives, it would have been way too time-consuming to get through what with their lack of pictures. Where is the expected buildup toward what I already know what they€™re building toward? I want to know the bigger picture, who John Carter will be fighting four years from now dammit! I don€™t want vague foundations for a sequel I have to actually see to fully know what they€™re talking about. With Captain America, I knew he was the first Avenger before I even had to see it while treading water to get through to the Avengers. The filmmakers were lucky I was watching a Marvel Studios movie, or I wouldn€™t have taken too kindly to their actually taking the time to make me care about the character of Steve Rogers. In Iron Man 2, I knew something big was brewing on the horizon outside of Tony€™s admittedly cool storyline, and with my years of comic book expertise, observant ear, and seeing that hammer, I was able to put things together, even though it wasn€™t really related to Iron Man. That€™s what I like. I want a movie with my Easter eggs. John Carter, on the other hand, wasn€™t just the first piece of a larger narrative, but also a self-contained story. I don€™t have time for that. And the actors didn€™t even bother to hold my attention visually€

8. John Carter€™s Poses Aren€™t Alluring Enough

Regrettably, I€™ve noticed that John Carter isn€™t as distinct to any of us because he doesn€™t pose in a way that gets me turned on fast enough. Black Widow gets this respectably right, and don€™t get me started on the Hulk. Forget the magnificent sense of wonder the John Carter movie displayed in almost every shot as the story played out (after the opening sequence anyway). We got the point just as much in Iron Man 2 and The Avengers through Black Widow€™s poses. Because a good pose does wonders where lacking story or cinematography fail. Why should I care about what€™s happening on the screen if the characters aren€™t unnecessarily posing after their every action? The world is quicker these days. You have to bend over backwards to hold people€™s attention among the cacophony of the sound bite sphere, which is exactly what Black Widow does. Rather than playing out the story through aesthetically pleasing imagery that is relevant and augmentative, the shots€™ energy would be better spent by keeping me alert through vignettes of alluring poses, possibly related to one another, but it really doesn€™t matter. Dejah Thoris has some hot moments, sure, but we don€™t need them to fit seamlessly in the story. Just pose and put it in the foreground. Now that's composition! But believe it or not, the next point is even more important to every movie than poses.

7. John Carter Isn€™t Played By Robert Downey Jr.

A major drawback of John Carter is that the title character isn€™t played by Robert Downey Jr. I don€™t know what was wrong with Andrew Stanton on this one€”this factor had to have been obvious during the casting process. Maybe they did try to get him, I don€™t know; I wasn€™t able to find that information during my research. Robert Downey Jr. is an essential element of the success of any production. I mean, Robert Downey Jr. is a fantastic actor. Even when he pulls out his well-used witty, smart, and somewhat arrogant character template, it is legitimately very entertaining to watch every single time. Every movie can benefit from this, and Marvel Studios has. Robert Downey Jr. is arguably the core of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the reason why audiences have followed it so far. He really does have that much charisma, and the first Iron Man movie made him the star he has always been. Both John Carter and Tony Stark have personal battles that make them push people away. Both are incredibly difficult to get along with even when they€™re in good moods. Both know that in politics and government, lines are blurred and there are always more to things than we think. Both are interested in science and learning how things work. But John Carter isn€™t played by Robert Downey Jr. And like Tony€™s counterpart in the comics, John Carter is just too serious for his own good. But Robert Downey Jr. being in The Avengers was only the beginning of its greatness. The next point on the list caused me to overload.

6. John Carter Slashes, Not Smashes

This was almost Number One on the list, but I had to move it down. None of the jokes in John Carter, nor all of the amazing moments of the Marvel Cinematic Universe combined, nor any moment in any movie ever made in the history of the world got the same gleeful squeals in the theater as when Hulk Bamm-Bamm smashed Loki in The Avengers. A lot of things make the Hulk great, and a good smash helps carry his character€™s awesomeness home. So let€™s consider our priorities here, and what this moment really tells us. John Carter needs to rely less on his brain in general and more on Bamm-Bamm. No heart-wrenching emotional climax during Warhoons to progress and define the story. No cute Woolas. No evocation of hopelessness on Earth or desperation of John and Dejah. Just Bamm-Bamm smash. Don€™t even need a reason for Hulk controlling himself. Just get to Bamm-Bamm smash. Still. Even a Bamm-Bamm smash can€™t save a movie without€

5. John Carter Doesn€™t Have A Post-Credits Scene

Even John Carter€™s credits played out mediocre. Post-credits scenes should be a given in any movie we watch now. Even Green Lantern had one. The fact that John Carter€™s team didn€™t even try to put one in was just a letdown that made me feel like they didn€™t respect me as a viewer. I don€™t care if the plot details haven€™t even been worked out yet€”I want to see the sequel now, before it€™s even made, and a cool little post-credits scene always gets me hyped up for what I don€™t even know I€™m cheering for yet. Maybe not with John Carter. I wasn€™t even in the theater anymore by the time it reached the credits. I had to go read about The Avengers post-credits scenes. If I€™m going to read anything, there had better be a treat at the end. Or it had better be about a treat.

4. John Carter€™s World May Be Creative And Awesome To Look At, But Jack Kirby Didn€™t Draw It

A lot of love went into the world of John Carter, both in the books and the movie. It€™s beautiful to read about, look at, consider, and be a part of. But quite frankly, if fantastically crazy-looking images don€™t come from a Marvel artist€™s pen, I don€™t care. Marvel and no one else designs the vivid stuff of dreams€”the overwhelming, the wondrous, the ecstatic, and the terrifying. I can€™t wait to see Guardians of the Galaxy. That is an absolutely cool part of the Marvel Universe. But if anyone else from another company ever attempts to draw an airship or alien, they had better get it bought by Marvel. Everyone knows that Marvel can have its characters fight guns with swords, but when the John Carter movie tried to pull it off it was completely ridiculous and sundered what little suspension of disbelief I had left after the opening narration (also better in Thor). The characters and locales in each successive John Carter story become increasingly outlandishly awesome with wondrous images representing thought-provoking tones, but count me out. And this is because€

3. John Carter Wasn€™t Part Of My Childhood (Or Adulthood) Commercialism Indoctrination Processes

John Carter may be cool in theory, and the movie may have been adapted from somebody else€™s work instead of an original script, and the book series may have been near-plagiarized in countless ways over the 20th and 21st centuries to influence almost everything that I like, but I didn€™t see him on TV when I was a kid. No cartoons, no live action shows, no toys, no trading cards, no bubble gum, no toothbrushes, no macaroni, and let€™s not forget, the greatest travesty in a long line of travesties, no John Carter underwear to put over my non-existent John Carter pajamas. John Carter was a play in Hollywood€™s book I could never see, and that€™s what killed it. I hardly knew a thing about him before he came up on screen, and even worse, I didn€™t have cool nerd friends to explain all of his story and world to me (only lame John Carter nerd friends). I was totally lost and had to actually learn about the story in real-time, paying attention to the movie. Disney didn€™t need to just market John Carter. It needed to go back in time and make it a cornerstone of my childhood. But it€™s perfectly fine by me that almost every other popular story out there has already taken things from the John Carter books without me knowing. Ignorance is bliss. I might as well just not know about John Carter at this point, because it has become too much for me to be introduced to a new character all at once in a single movie. It needs to be gradual. Candy, video games, trailers, more video games, and then the movie. After the post-credits scene. This is the core of Marvel Studios€™s success. Because of its brand familiarity and its solid product and public relations infrastructure and influence, many of us know who is what in the Marvel Universes and will put our unwavering support behind them. And the constant whispering in our ears from ads and critics certainly help. A toy is a toy is a toy is€ hmm, this is awesome! But even more than being indoctrinated, another element keeps us watching Marvel Studios and not John Carter.

2. John Carter Overcomes His Curse

Many Marvel characters are burdened with a gift and a curse, and I think most of everyone ever born loves how Marvel Comics periodically erases everything from its characters to keep them fighting. It€™s like when mothers say, €œI wish they could stay like this forever€€”well, with Marvel Comics, you can do that! The status quo is dogma. It didn€™t always used to entirely be that way. We could somewhat grow with the characters we liked, but this relatively recent innovation is really much better. It has whittled our characters down to the basic traits we enjoy. Don€™t like Spider-Man continuing to learn new things? BAM! Have Mephisto erase everything. This philosophy is also being played out in Marvel€™s films. Don€™t like Tobey Maguire€™s Spider-Man learning about relationships past getting into one? BAM! Reboot the movie! Yes, that€™s not Marvel Studios, but don€™t worry. Their characters are pretty much going to stay the same as well€”friends, relationships, likes, and dislikes. Much like Professor Xavier and Magneto, Thor and Loki will be fighting until the end of time. Don€™t like Agent Coulson being dead? Not to worry! No action in this universe is prompted by true consequence! I mean, Iron Man evolving a little bit in his worldviews and in his relationship with Pepper is pushing it, but because it€™s Robert Downey Jr., I€™ll forgive him. Marvel has solid control over its product branding, keeping its characters in limbo instead of letting writers and artists build on what others have done. A living thing can€™t live in a package, and why buy a live puppy when I can get a toy one? Even DC has caught on to this with the New 52. John Carter, on the other hand, doesn€™t even stay the same through the first act, and somehow Andrew Stanton still had a movie on his hands. Every few minutes, Carter gets another insight on things. The movie even throws it in my face by adding something to his costume at every checkpoint! The Thark baby clothes. The medals. The Helium robes. The Jeddak furry shoulder pad. John Carter€™s status quo is constantly questioned. He has to learn something new in almost every scene, with the Tharks or the Red Martians or the Therns, until he even begins to realize things about his own world. And a significant character arc seems to be resolved in this movie alone, laying the groundwork for greater internal and external obstacles to come. John Carter is a character based around more than a gimmick; there is much for his character to develop from. No thank you, Edgar Rice Burroughs, even if that arc were told in comic book years. Give me the status quo any day. Marvel characters have more to offer too, but from the movies all the way back to the comic book origins, you don€™t hear me complaining. So that€™s a big part of John Carter€™s problems and a good fit for the Number Two spot. But there€™s something else fundamentally at the core of John Carter that keeps the Marvel fans away. It€™s not believable progress, and it's not a lacking of Jack Kirby. It€™s€

1. John Carter Subconsciously Reminds Marvel Fans Of Superman

Yep. €™Nuff said. No? More explanation needed? Okay. This point is better read keeping in mind that John Williams€™s score is playing in the background. Although John Carter has influenced many things, one of the first properties he helped significantly inspire was Superman, the greatest superhero of all time€”make no mistake, even if he isn€™t one of your favorite superheroes, he is nevertheless the greatest. John Carter is very much a proto-Superman, a Willow of sorts to Superman€™s Star Wars. Like Superman, John Carter has great powers. Like Superman, John Carter is an alien outsider. Like Superman, John Carter solves problems based on his intelligence and bravery, which are in turn based on his origins. Like Superman, John Carter is a beacon of hope for his adopted homeworld. And also, like Superman, despite his longevity, John Carter is widely, whether ignorantly, obstinately, or sensationally, misunderstood. Although a fan of one comic book character cannot with good conscience dismiss another without first reading every book about the latter, this is a huge norm when it comes to Superman. There seems to be something in comic book fans, especially nonfans of DC Comics, which is threatened by Superman, something which makes Kal-El the brunt of vicious comments, something that passionately stamps over his heartfelt, inspiring story. Not realistic? No. Not identifiable? No. An uncracked story code? Arguable. DC€™s marketing? Possibly. Mostly, it€™s pessimism and the steady, pressuring call of the all-knowing status quo, wrought from our especially darker moments. The same sensibility which can get us thinking, yet also led past scientists to say that humanity would never fly. Marvel is lauded for its identifiable characters with real-world problems. Superman has them too. They€™re just of a different kind and a different scope, one that requires a different sort of effort, or fortitude, which isn€™t always easy to lift yourself into. Where most of the pantheon of superheroes is Ray Bradbury, Superman is Isaac Asimov. In short, Superman, like John Carter, is not easy. Some of Marvel Studios€™s films, like the Iron Man Trilogy, have pioneering souls, but they are packaged in a way where you can gloss over their underlying ideas if you so choose. John Carter, on the other hand, puts a theme of the futility of war at the forefront, which doesn€™t go down easy for anyone. Hopefully the upcoming Man of Steel will help more of us rethink things, and more movies, science fiction, fantasy, or otherwise, can build on what John Carter tried to stir. Click €œnext" to read my conclusion...

Conclusion

If John Carter came from Marvel Studios, critics and audiences would like it. It€™s an established property that has influenced other things. Its fanbase knows it€™s awesome. Its female lead is €œbadass€ while actually being a good character. Its science fiction and fantasy themes, world, and effects are frequently beautiful. Its title character is both gifted and cursed, albeit differently than in the books, with an interesting larger arc playing out behind his own. Sure, it€™s not always smoothly put together, but neither are most first films. You can€™t fool us, Disney. Not that you tried to (Marvel did try to help with some marketing). But it€™s just not Marvel Studios. Maybe it would have helped the movie if there were more prophecies or people getting captured on purpose. Or less overt questioning toward the concept of war. But mostly, John Carter just isn€™t Marvel, and that is something that can never change. Well wait€”Disney did make the movie, Disney owns Marvel, and Marvel does have a history with John Carter comic books€ Marvel technically doesn€™t even need to get the rights back! Maybe they could merge them together into one universe! John Carter fans need to change the semantics of their petitions if they ever want that sequel to happen. Well. LucasFilm wouldn€™t like that anyway. If you haven€™t already noticed, I€™m a fan of characters from Marvel, DC, and John Carter. But we need to think about and be vocal in our standards of why we like what we like. Do we like something because it€™s good, or because it€™s from a certain company? Fans of those franchises that make it have a responsibility for the franchises that follow. Otherwise, we€™ll get Finding Dory. Which is the best thing ever. Right? Agree? Disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.