10 Reasons Why Total Remake Sucks

Learn why Len Wiseman's update of the 1990 sci-fi classic doesn't make the cut.

By Shaun Munro /

Len Wiseman's remake of Total Recall hits cinemas this week, but if like most, you've found yourself dismayed at how poorly it follows the original film, you've probably found yourself thinking back to everything the original did so well. Below we list the 10 ways Len Wiseman and co. screwed up a remake that nobody wanted anyway!

10. "Get Your Ass to Mars"

Perhaps the defining aspect of the original Total Recall was its largely being "set" on Mars, with Schwarzenegger's Quaid opting for a memory implant of a luxurious vacation on Mars, which of course goes disastrously wrong. The entire aesthetic - soaked in gorgeously saturated reds and oranges - was defined by this setting, and it made the quirky, campy weirdness of the piece all that more endearing and entertaining. In Wiseman's update, the entire narrative is set on Earth, which in the wake of chemical warfare has been divided into two remaining factions - the United Federation of Britain and the Colony (essentially Australia). While it's understandable in both scenarios that Quaid would want to escape a humdrum life as a manual labour worker, isn't it more fantastical and thought-provoking that he ventures to another planet in the original, rather than simply live in near enough the same place, but as a secret agent? Furthermore, the aesthetic in Wiseman's film is just nowhere near as unique or original; its Chinatown-inspired, rain-drenched locales feel awfully derived from the likes of Blade Runner, and various other elements of the world are shamelessly pilfered from the style of films such as Minority Report (coincidentally also adapted from a Philip K. Dick book and starring Colin Farrell), and i, Robot. Furthermore, eliding Mars makes the three-breasted mutant character we see in the remake feel hugely tacked on, shoehorned in to provide a passing reference that would resonate with fans of the original. Verhoeven's version, set on Mars, can have a lot more fun with this idea, as we get to glimpse all manner of weird and wonderful mutants. And that's precisely the problem with the 2012 take; its tone.

9. Self-Seriousness

The 1990 Total Recall falls into that hugely entertaining pantheon of late 80s-early 90s films starring Arnold Schwarzenegger, including Commando, Predator, and The Running Man that did anything but take themselves too seriously; packed with one-liners that accentuated Arnie's goofy charm, alongside ridiculous action sequences, these films remain some of the most beloved of the action behemoth's career, and indeed, of the genre altogether. The 1990 Total Recall, with its bizarre mutant characters, talking, automated cabs, and sly sense of humour, became an instant box office smash, and has remained an indelible cult classic over time. As for Wiseman's take, one of the prime issues is that it takes itself far too seriously; aside from Quaid's brief interaction with the three-breasted hooker - derived from the original as it is - there is practically no attempt to play fast-and-loose with the premise. It is almost completely joyless and humourless, overly invested in its own import, and as such stripping away much of the personality that made the original film such a riotous hoot. This only further reflects the cynicism with which the project was concocted, more a business transaction than a concerted effort to pay due to the 1990 version, and it's reflected in the poor box office reciepts, having grosed a pitiful $134m in the three weeks since its release (against a $125m budget).

8. Casting

When a remake of Verhoeven's sci-fi classic was announced, the Internet was astir with rumours of not only who would be cast in Arnold's iconic spot, but also who would play both the antagonists and the femme fatale characters. While the likes of Bryan Cranston, Colin Farrell and Kate Beckinsale are cast well enough in underwritten roles that absolutely don't measure up to their talents, it is the casting of Jessica Biel that is perhaps most distracting, playing Melina, a resistance fighter who was played by Rachel Ticotin in the original film. They may as well have renamed Biel's character for all the resemblance that she bears to Ticotin's version; initially a gutsy prostitute who in fact turns out to be a gung-ho resistance fighter, here the more salacious elements of her character have been toned down - we don't meet her as a hooker - and she is merely a bland, uninspired quasi-love interest for Quaid, developed with no effort whatsoever. What's most problematic about Biel's casting, though, is that she's too young and fresh-faced for the part; watching her running and gunning is embarrassing, unconvincing and laughable. We need a member of the resistance who looks a little older, and a little more weathered - but still sexually appealing and interesting to watch - like Ticotin's Melina in the original.

7. Verhoeven's Violence

One of the prime tenets of Paul Verhoeven's filmography is his unique use of graphic violence; take his previous film Robocop, a gory action film that uses its violence to satirical ends, and in his own Total Recall, it helps to keep the tone gleefully off-kilter, and ensures that things never become too serious. Never do we feel that his gore, wild and cartoonish, is exploitative or legitimately gross - as compared to, say, a slasher film - because it makes us laugh; it has an amusingly morbid sense of humour, such as the notable scene when Quaid throws Richter's severed limbs from the elevator, while shouting "See you at the party, Richter!". One need only observe the BBFC's assessment of the new Recall's violence to see how toned down it is. According to them, and as is evident in watching the film, there is "little sight of blood or injury detail", and though one doesn't need blood to make a great film, the excessive gore and violence was so integral to the original film, generating several of its most original moments - after all, who can forget that human bullet shield on the escalator, the countless headshots, and yes, Richter's severed limbs? In the remake, violence is impactful, and fast-paced, but simply not memorable or entertaining; it is too serious and focused on slickness, when it should be more interested in staying true to the original film's vision of campy, over-the-top violence that made it such a success. The American PG-13 rating, of course, is to blame for this, and quite ironic it is that in attempting to recoup more box office receipts, they have damned themselves to a return best described as a flop.

6. Poor Villains

Though the names Lori and Cohagen are there, Wiseman's Recall doesn't have anywhere near as good a grasp on its villains as the original pic. While Richter has been omitted entirely - and we'll get to that later - there's still enough to work with here to make compelling foes for Farrell's Quaid. Bryan Cranston is a superb actor and well-cast in the role of primary antagonist Cohagen - though it's odd to see him sporting hair after working so long on Breaking Bad - but his character is poorly-written and underdeveloped; he only makes his presence truly felt in the later stages of the film, giving us little time to appreciate his menace, and the final showdown against Quaid is completely unmemorable, despite having only seen the film three days ago. The eye-popping Mars finale of the original is reduced to a boring, forgettable mano-y-mano fight, and frankly, it's difficult to even remember how Cohagen kicks it (he is incinerated). Kate Beckinsale is more compelling as a re-purposed version of Lori, played by Sharon Stone in the original. Though she fills out the requirement of Quaid's pseudo-wife well enough, she is essentially Lori and Richter from the original film conflated into one character, a more menacing and physically imposing antagonist than Cranston's Cohagen, though again, her demise is not particularly memorable, and one can't escape the feeling that Wiseman through Beckinsale in there primarily because she's his wife, and he has a weird fascination with watching her make out with other guys.

5. Too. Much. Lens. Flare.

Perhaps the most pernickety entry on this list, but a valid complaint nonetheless. CGI-infused lens flare has been overused throughout the last decade of science fiction films in particular; take the new Star Trek reboot which, while a surprisingly excellent film, suffers from slight over-stylisation, resulting in some jarring moments as the crew members dart around the ship, with lens flare obscuring much of the screen. It's an odd choice as it would purport to give the films a more verite-esque aesthetic, despite the fact that they are obviously incredibly realistic; who are they trying to fool? While the style of this new Total Recall might be one of its few good points, Wiseman goes overboard as usual, and drowns the action sequences in particular amid abusive employing of these flares. What's most bothersome is how these flares appear to be added even when the scene does not feature a strong light source; it is purely stylistic, and quite nonsensical in this stead.

4. Overuse of CGI

Following on from the above, Wiseman further over-exerts himself from a stylistic perspective by glossing just about every shot in this film in some sort of visual effect, be it a lens flare or a floating hover-car. Now, we're not going to knock the hover-car sequence too much, because it was probably the most entertaining set-piece in the film, but Wiseman's reliance on CGI reaches an exhausting, tiresome, even boring apex by film's end; the various explosions and crashes feel overly mechanical and have no emotional or visceral impact. Compare this to the original film, which employed stunning practical effects for the large part, and is as a result much more impressive for the startling result that these effects created. Like too many sci-fi films these days, filmmakers think that rendering shiny, bright objects is sufficient for depicting the sleek, technologically advanced future, but rather, it better resembles a current-gen video game than anything approaching progress. While it would be immature and churlish to decry CGI as anything but progress, it's all about how you use it, and here it feels synthetic and lifeless.

3. No Richter

One of my biggest gripes with the remake is the absence of Richter, who was in the original a far more memorable antagonist than the head honcho himself, Cohagen. Gifted character actor Michael Ironside brought a tenacity and very real menace to the character, that made the thrill of the chase all that more exciting, while Cohagen and Lori had their own separate agendas with Quaid. In this remake, he is nowhere to be seen, and as mentioned before, his character has essentially been combined with Lori's, giving Kate Beckinsale double-duty as the duplicitous "wife" and the ruthless killing machine. One struggles to imagine why Wiseman would elide such an iconic and important character, except for giving his wife the opportunity for more screen time. And depressingly, her death in the new film isn't a might as memorable as the deaths of either Lori or Richter in the original.

2. Real or Rekall?

One of the best attributes of the original film's script is how well it deals with the concept of memory vs. reality, pondering whether or not Quaid is actually on Mars, or is in fact still back at Rekall. Even as the film concludes, we're unsure as to what is reality, and this ambiguity has kept people debating the ending for the two decades since. The marketing for Wiseman's remake heavily implied that this would also be a core concern of the narrative, but in the film itself, it is severely toned down compared to the original, and only very rarely does it at all become a concern for the viewer. In fact, only one instance - a brief flash of a blur during one scene - at all hints to this, and Wiseman delivers a final shot of ambiguity to bring this theme crudely back to the surface. However, the plot is so murky and inconsistent in his remake that one could be forgiven for just not caring whether Quaid is back in reality or is in fact still living through Rekall, whereas the original, with its likable characters and smarter execution, actually made us emotionally and intellectually engaged in what was taking place.

1. No Arnie, No Sale

And of course, is there any bigger argument for this film's failure than the absence of Arnie himself? That's not to say that we would have preferred Arnie to do the remake himself, but simply that recasting such an iconic actor in a memorable performance such as this is extremely difficult. With the hilarious script and zany premise, Arnie brings a lot of charm to the table that helps us believe this universe, whereas Wiseman's version, deafeningly self-serious as it is, feels bland and joyless. Colin Farrell, while cast well enough for a film like this, suffers because the script doesn't even give him a chance to live up to the statuesque presence set by Arnie in the original. It is as though Farrell is playing a shadow, a shade of Quaid, and he is powerless against the debilitatingly dull script, and Wiseman's own over-stylised, mechanical direction. What did you think of the Total Recall remake? Give us your feedback below, and let us know how you think it stacks up against the 1990 original.