Criticisms come from being unfamiliar with the source material. Those who are versed in the literary counterpart will realise that Peter Jacksons filmic interpretation delivers the true nature of the book, and therein lies its ultimate value. Imagine the outrage of literary fans if what Jacksons trilogy had showcased wasnt what was promised in the novel. Many people protested about not only the length, but the inclusion of the supper scene in the trilogys first installment. However, as one of the weightiest scenes of the novel, spanning several pages and showing-off Tolkiens poetical prowess with Misty Mountains Cold, Journeys sequence was in fact not long enough.Jackson has successfully conveyed the tone and the atmosphere that is anchored within Tolkiens writings and the bottom line is, fans of The Hobbit get The Hobbit. On a similar note, fans of The Lord Of The Rings still get The Hobbit See how it works?