10 Reasons You're Wrong About Westerns
Seriously - how could anyone hate this genre?
The western genre has been getting a bit of a kicking lately.
In the last decade or so, it has become increasingly popular for modern film fans to simply write off the genre as 'boring' or 'outdated'. Even as properties in other forms of media, such as Red Dead Redemption, break records, the vast majority of western films these days seem to have been relegated to straight-to-DVD release.
But here's the thing - westerns are great.
It's no accident that they were so popular and so innovative for so many decades. They have been a vital part of filmmaking history since the very beginning, specifically because of their practically unparalleled ability to deliver spectacle and substance, hand-in-hand.
In short, westerns are fantastic, and there are a whole host of reasons why the genre's biggest detractors are just plain wrong.
10. Quintessential Good Vs. Evil Storytelling
Perhaps no genre has done as much for clearly defined, good versus evil storytelling as the western.
In classic western cinema, the lines are firmly drawn. The good guys wear white, the bad guys wear black, and there's little wiggle room in-between. Classic films like The Great Train Robbery, Stagecoach, or She Wore A Yellow Ribbon laid out these rules clearly and abided by them, creating some of the most classically-driven journeys of all time.
This is made all the more impressive by the fact that a great many of these classics came decades before Joseph Campbell's studies and publications about the hero's journey as audiences know it today even began.
Simplicity seems to often get a bad wrap in film these days and gets labeled as boring (see also any discussion revolving around the character of Superman). However, simplicity isn't always a bad thing; without these early western films, the three-act structure as we know it today might have never been laid out properly.
Most importantly of all, without the genre's clean-cut origins, it would have never been able to evolve in the way it has done.
9. The Brooding Anti-Hero
Westerns may have started as clean-cut fables of good versus evil, but they certainly didn't stay that way.
Considering that the western genre essentially remained a prominently successful genre of filmmaking for nearly sixty years, it was inevitable that films would eventually begin to offer meta-commentary on it.
The Searchers, for instance, is a 1956 film directed by the great John Ford and starring John Wayne. Yet, instead of simply reusing the mould of previous Wayne characters or archetypes, Ford casts him as Ethan Edwards. Edwards is a troubled hero, scarred by his time spent in the war and doomed to spend the rest of his life living with the horrors he's seen. He's still a hero, but certainly not the white-hat wearing do-gooders of the previous decades.
Similarly, later films such as Sergio Leone's Man With No Name trilogy would go on to cast frequent western star Clint Eastwood in a similarly troubled role. This kind of archetype became a new norm for the genre in its later years and no other genre has ever been able to do it quite as well.
8. They Preach Valuable Lessons
One of the most intriguing things about westerns is the fact that they are often set hundreds of years ago but still offer up some strikingly relevant thematic lessons, both in their form and in their narrative.
In other words, their stories and lessons still have value. There's a reason that a film like Shane was featured so heavily in last year's Logan, and that's because the western film had struck upon the same theme as Logan did, just decades earlier. It did it so well, in fact, that James Mangold couldn't help but sample it into his own film.
In many ways, classic westerns have become the equivalent of modern fables, teaching lessons of the past to modern audiences.
7. Some Of The Greatest Directors Of All Time Have Loved The Genre
Simply put, the western film is an auteur's genre.
Some of the most renowned directors of all time have made western films. From classic directors like Howard Hawks, John Ford, or Sergio Leone to more modern examples like James Mangold, Quentin Tarantino, or the Coen Bros. - great directors love working in the western genre.
This has resulted in some of the greatest films of all time being western films. Again, the genre has such a long and storied history that its kind of a natural fit for filmmakers looking to make a statement about the art of filmmaking itself. Films like The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly or even something more recent like The Revenant are revered as filmmaking classics because of the ability of great directors to utilize the genre to fit their needs. Even one of the greatest creators of comedy content of all time, Mel Brooks loved the genre and gave the world Blazing Saddles, regularly regarded as one of the funniest films of all time, as a result.
It's also important to note that even directors who haven't actually made a quote-unquote western film have publicly said that they owe their entire career to the genre. Big-hitters such as Martin Scorcese and David Fincher were both inspired to get into filmmaking by western films, with The Great Train Robbery and Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid, influencing their respective decisions.
So the next time your friend writes westerns off as 'boring', remind them that Oscar-winners like Martin Scorsese, Alejandro González Iñárritu, and Quentin Tarantino would beg to differ.
6. The Action Is Great
Even in bad classic western films, the action is absolutely incredible.
Perhaps more so than any other subgenre of action filmmaking, the western is rooted in gargantuan practical effects and stunts. In the genre's earliest days, these films were simply looking to entertain viewers any way they could, which meant offering up action sequences the likes-of-which had never been seen before.
This led to a lot of horseback-and-carriage-centric chase scenes, as well as shootouts at high noon. The limitations of the genre might initially sound stifling, but they're actually some of the action's greatest attributes. Filmmakers know what they can't do, so the question becomes how can they assemble the pieces they have in a new way.
For decades, great filmmakers have been continuously finding inventive answers to that very question. Sequences like Butch and Sundance's final shootout in Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid, any number of showdowns in Silverado, or the final stand-off in The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly remain as some of the most thrilling action sequences ever committed to film.
They take the perceived limitations of the time period, such as the slower firing rate of the weapons or the need of horses for travel, and turn them into narrative strengths.
5. Spaghetti Westerns Are Phenomenal
Without the western, we would have never gotten the Italian equivalent, the Spaghetti Western, which may be one of the finest things to ever happen to cinema.
If you've ever found yourself unable to quite get into the traditional American western genre, for one reason or another, just watch a Spaghetti Western film and it will immediately change you. The most famous and iconic of the bunch has to be Sergio Leone's Man With No Name trilogy which is comprised of A Fistful of Dollars, A Few Dollars More, and The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.
These films are a pretty perfect embodiment of what's so wonderful about spaghetti westerns. The action and camerawork are kinetic, the music is bombastically over-the-top, and much like the Giallo Italian horror films of the time, they're typically drenched in technicolor red blood.
These are the films that filmmakers like Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez have returned to as reference points, not just for their westerns, but for their entire filmography.
And honestly, after seeing how the Spaghetti Western revolutionized and energized the genre, it gives you a whole new appreciation for the American western.
4. The Genre's Ties To Filmmaking History
Some of the earliest films ever constructed were what would later come to be considered the first western films. In 1903, Edwin S. Porter's groundbreaking film, The Great Train Robbery, was released and essentially pioneered a great many cinematic traditions that remain valuable to this day, such as parallel action montages, outdoor scenes, and narration.
The final shot of the film, a cowboy looking directly into camera and firing his gun, has remained so burned into the psyche of the audience since that Martin Scorsese recreated the shot verbatim for the end of Goodfellas.
Ever since The Great Train Robbery, the western genre has remained an active part of American cinema, in one way or another. You can literally track the entire history of filmmaking simply by watching westerns and, quite frankly, seeing how they've been able to evolve over time is simply staggering.
When people complain that westerns are 'boring', they typically seem to argue that the genre is just more of the same. Take the time to see how the genre's changed with each and every decade, however, and it only becomes clearer as to why that statement just isn't the case.
3. The Consistently Gorgeous Cinematography
If you love great cinematography, you love the western genre.
Western films worked wonders for the art of cinematography in the early days, simply because it was the first genre brave enough to venture outdoors. In doing so, filmmakers realized that they could capture those breathtaking vistas that were inherently part of the setting of their films anyway.
Suddenly, earlier films looked positively claustrophobic by comparison. This revolutionized the genre, obviously, but it also revolutionized film as a whole. As we moved into the 1920s, suddenly film was less about simply presenting a subject to an audience and more about how one presented the subject.
This has remained true ever since and it is all thanks to the western and its ability to get filmmakers of the early days to think about things in a more cinematic and visual manner.
In recent years, the western genre has remained the home of some of the most gorgeous cinematography you'll ever see. Incredible cinematographers like Roger Deakins, Emmanuel Lubezki, and Robert Richardson have upheld the genre's proud tradition and delivered consistently gorgeous cinematography.
2. They've Inspired All Of Your Favorite Films
Anyone who tells you they don't like westerns is kind of lying, at least a little bit.
Because whether they recognize it or not, they do like westerns. You see, from Star Wars to Blade Runner, some of the most highly revered films of all time have been explicitly inspired by the western.
George Lucas famously formed his sci-fi epic after not being able to acquire the rights to a Flash Gordon film but one of the biggest inspirations for the original film was none other than John Ford's The Searchers. Since then, pretty much the entire Star Wars saga has been inspired by westerns in one way or another, including its most recent additions in The Last Jedi or Solo.
Or take, for instance, the Marvel films. As more than a handful of people have pointed out over the years, the superhero genre now is essentially equivalent to what the western was decades ago. However, the MCU specifically seems to have an almost meta-textual awareness of this, with films like Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 playing out like love-letters to the western genre itself.
Outside of the MCU, you have films like James Mangold's Logan, which foregrounded the similarities between the genres in an even more overt way.
1. When They're Good, They're Unbeatable
When western films are good, it's hard to find anything that's more entertaining.
There are dozens of all-time classic films in the western genre, with any number of places to begin if you're attempting to get into the genre for the first time. From The Great Train Robbery, to Shane, The Searchers, A Fistful of Dollars, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, Unforgiven, No Country for Old Men and Django Unchained - the list of genre classics goes on and on.
Why? because westerns have the ability to deliver impactful cinema with a riveting narrative, jaw-dropping cinematography and incredibly well-staged and tension-filled action sequences, directed by some of the best directors of all time.
If you think westerns are boring, you must've been watching the wrong ones, because when a western's done right, it's unbeatable.