10 Most Ridiculous Oscar Blunders Ever

Because we live in a world where Kevin Costner picked up a best Director gong before Martin Scorsese, and that's just sad.

By Daniel Rafacz /

With the Oscars fast approaching, this seems like the perfect time to review all the horrible mistakes the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences (AMPAS) has made in the past. The Academy Awards have long been a hotbed for controversial decisions both during and surrounding the ceremonies. Some winners have been swept up in a tidal wave of hype and emotion. Other wins were head-scratchers from the start. People have to understand that often these decisions have sometimes have little to do with the actual performances, people, or films that are nominated and much more to do with the politics, campaigning, and voter biases that happen behind the scenes. That is an unfortunate reality of the awards process. We, the film viewing community, have a much easier task: we are able to judge films with the benefit of hindsight. In that sense, perhaps we can forgive the choices in certain categories that were close races or which had many viable candidates. But there are some Oscar blunders so severe that retrospection only inflames the initial outrage. So, without further ado, these are the Oscar battles that totally perplex, flummox, and mystify the mind. These are the worst of the worst. This is the sour cream of the crop, so to speak.

10. Gwyneth Paltrow Robs The Queen (1998)

Gwyneth Paltrow€™s turn as Viola de Lesseps in Shakespeare in Love opposite Joseph Fiennes as Shakespeare was perfectly acceptable, much like the film itself. It just wasn€™t the best performance of the year by a leading actress. That honour belongs to Cate Blanchett, who completely owned the role of Elizabeth I, the Virgin Queen, in Shekar Kapur€™s underrated biographical film Elizabeth. Blanchett was totally captivating as the young queen of England who matures throughout the film into a force to be reckoned. It is arguably the best performance of her career, although her role in Blue Jasmine, which has her firmly in frontrunner status for this year€™s Oscar, may challenge that notion. This was the first instance of Shakespeare in Love stealing an Oscar, but it wasn€™t the last.

9. Judy Holliday Wins Best Actress (1950)

This Oscar race is an example of when the winner itself was perfectly fine in a vacuum, but in the context of the rest of the nominees, the win looks out of place. Judy Holliday turned in a fine performance in George Cukor€™s comedy Born Yesterday, but she beat out two actresses who had just given two of the best female performances of all time. The first was Bette Davis€™ stunning performance in All About Eve, and the second was Gloria Swanson€™s dazzling turn in Sunset Boulevard. This was almost certainly an instance of vote-splitting at its most devastating. Those two performances surely garnered scores of votes, but the result probably pushed the steadfast fans of Holliday and those who couldn€™t decide between Davis and Swanson to the forefront. It€™s a shame that neither of those historic dramatic performances would be recognised by the Academy. Instead, a safer comedy performance by Holliday pulled off the upset.

8. Shakespeare In Love Upsets Spielberg (1998)

The Weinstein brothers were and still are notorious for their Oscar campaigning and this year featured the most visible result of their campaign prowess. Shakespeare in Love was a fine film, but it may have been the worst out of the five nominations on offer in 1998. The heavy favourite that year was Steven Spielberg€™s harrowing World War II epic Saving Private Ryan. But people also forget that this year also included two other great films about World War II: Terrence Malick€™s beautiful and haunting The Thin Red Line and Roberto Beningi€™s heartbreaking Life is Beautiful. And don€™t forget the aforementioned Elizabeth, which is a good film in its own right. Regardless of which war film most deserved the honour, I think most of us can agree that Shakespeare in Love was an uninspired choice.

7. Art Carney Wins Best Actor (1974)

This Oscar race is a similar situation to the Holliday, Davis, Swanson Best Actress debate of 1950. In this case, Art Carney won for Harry and Tonto with a touching but understated performance. It is who he beat that ruffles some feathers. Also nominated in 1974 were Al Pacino, who played Michael Corleone in The Godfather: Part II, which won Best Picture, and Jack Nicholson, who played Jake Gittes in Roman Polanski€™s film noir mystery Chinatown. The magnitude of those two films and the actors who performed in them is staggering in retrospect. Again, I€™m sure that vote-splitting played a part here. Those two epic performances, along with Dustin Hoffman in Lenny, allowed Art Carney to swoop in for a remarkable surprise victory.

6. How Green Was My Valley Wins Best Picture (1941)

Back in 1941, Orson Welles made a film that many now consider to be the greatest film of all time: Citizen Kane. John Huston€™s directorial debut The Maltese Falcon has also become a cinematic legend. But it was John Ford€™s quaint coal country picture that wound up with the big prize. Ford also beat out Welles for Best Director. This one is a bit easier to forgive because Citizen Kane was decades ahead of its time; people today are still staggered by the technical prowess of that film. Similarly, The Maltese Falcon was a first film by a new director and voters tend to wait for people to pay their dues before getting rewarded. So while we may cut the Academy voters of 1941 some slack for their lack of forethought, this win looks severely out of place to contemporary critics when compared to the other two pillars of film history.

5. Kevin Costner Wins Best Director (1990)

Ok, try not to fall out of your chair while I tell you a sad Oscar fact: Kevin Costner won an Oscar for directing before Martin Scorsese. Not only that, Costner beat Scorsese in 1990 with his direction of Dances with Wolves. Scorsese, of course, was nominated for Goodfellas. In fact, it took 16 more years for Marty to finally get that Oscar for The Departed. Let that sink in. Go on, let it fester. It seems one of the Academy€™s favorite pastimes had been repeatedly snubbing Martin Scorsese for some unfathomable reason, from Mean Streets to Taxi Driver to Raging Bull. Most people thought that this would finally be Marty€™s time. But it was not to be. Dances with Wolves€™ sweeping romanticism apparently resonated more with voters than Goodfellas€™ gritty charisma and it took both the Best Picture and Best Director statues. This one probably looks worse now than it did then, just because of how inexplicably long it took the Academy to finally reward Martin Scorsese.

4. John Williams Loses Best Score in 1978, 1980, and 1981

John Williams, the maestro of movie music, won his third Oscar for best music for scoring Star Wars in 1977. He had previously won for Jaws and Fiddler on the Roof. I suspect a bit of awards fatigue for the Academy may have set in at that point because no other sane reason could have explained what happened next. John Williams lost the Oscar in three of the next four years to the scores from Midnight Express, Fame, and Chariots of Fire. Outside of a mildly inspirational but slightly annoying Vangelis theme from Chariots of Fire, these three scores are mostly forgotten. Williams€™ three scores that lost? Oh, just three of his most iconic scores of all time: Superman, The Empire Strikes Back, and Raiders of the Lost Ark. The Academy must have realised their several mistakes because they gave Williams his fourth Oscar for E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial in 1982. Regardless, that amazing stretch of film scores should not have been ignored.

3. Ordinary People Beats Raging Bull (1980)

We could just make a separate list with how many times the Oscars have robbed Martin Scorsese. In addition to Robert Redford beating out Marty for the Best Director statue this year, Ordinary People somehow captured the attention of enough voters to award it the Best Picture prize over the monumental black and white slugfest that is Raging Bull, which many consider to be Scorsese€™s best film. This Oscar race never ceases to baffle me. I suppose the Academy was impressed by a successful actor€™s transition to the director€™s chair, but that certainly doesn€™t justify this result. Raging Bull is an incredible film that pulls no punches and features an astounding transformative (and Oscar winning) performance by Robert De Niro. Ordinary People is pretty standard Oscar bait that features the breakdown of a family after a tragedy. Whatever the reason for the snub, this category is a significant misstep in the annals of Oscar history.

2. Alfred Hitchcock Never Wins an Oscar for Best Director

This Oscar blunder is so infuriating that I couldn€™t narrow it down to just one year. Alfred Hitchcock was arguably the best director of all time, yet the Academy never saw fit to give him an Oscar for Best Director. In fact, he was only nominated five times for Rebecca, Lifeboat, Spellbound, Rear Window, and Psycho. These are some of the classic films for which he was not even nominated: The 39 Steps, Notorious, Rope, Strangers on a Train, Dial M for Murder, The Birds, and perhaps the most outrageous of all, Vertigo. As you can see, the Academy voters had a serious Hitchcock voting issue. Perhaps the genre of suspense was simply not taken seriously by many members of the voting body. The sheer volume of films that Hitchcock was not recognised for is truly staggering. To make matters worse, Oscar bestowed an honorary award upon Hitchcock in 1968, but this only magnified their many previous errors. The €œMaster of Suspense€ never won a competitive Oscar, and he showed his contempt with the shortest Oscar speech ever €“ 'thank you... very much indeed.'

1. Rocky Wins Best Picture (1976)

Here we go. This is the worst decision that Oscar ever made. Many of the blunders on this list have involved maybe two or three different parties, but this one includes almost the whole category. I don€™t know what the Academy voters were thinking this year, but they passed up three legitimate movie classics to award Sylvester Stallone€™s and John G. Avildsen€™s feel-good but massively overrated underdog story. What else was nominated? How about Martin Scorsese€™s momentous Taxi Driver, Sidney Lumet€™s prophetic Network, and Alan J. Pakula€™s illuminating All the President€™s Men? The complete and utter lack of both present-sight and foresight by Academy voters is mind-boggling to this day. The only explanation that makes any sense is that the vote-splitting between those three truly great films allowed Rocky to sneak in a take the prize. This unfortunate result was truly a shame because any one of the other three would have made a fantastic addition to the historic list of Best Picture winners. That€™s it, the worst Oscar blunders ever. What did I miss? Are there other bungles that merit a mention?