10 Sci-Fi Movies One Step From Perfection
Just one little change would have put The Faculty in the hall of fame...
Is there anything more frustrating than an almost-perfect movie?
You know the sort we mean—four star near-miss would-be classics which are one fatal flaw from being perfect, the sort of movie you’ll still champion to friends and family even as you stand there knowing they’ll leave the multiplex perplexed by the same small problem that’s still playing on your mind.
These aren’t bad films by any means—and if anything that’s what makes this phenomenon so uniquely annoying. Some of the flicks listed here are stone cold classics, but they’re nonetheless plagued by one persistent problem which we can’t help but wish away every time we sit down to a re-watch. Others are just solid genre efforts which deserve to be seen, but will always come accompanied by the addendum “Yeah it’s well worth a watch—I just really wish they hadn’t…”
Whether it’s a misjudged ending, a third act twist we wanted to write out, or a character who should have been jettisoned one draft before production began, here are ten science fiction films which were just one step from reaching genre nirvana.
10. Annihilation's Pointless Infidelity Sub-Plot
We’re well aware that calling 2018’s Annihilation anything other than an instant classic will result in some furious debates, but there is an issue with The Beach scribe Alex Garland’s sci-fi horror adaptation of Jeff VanderMeer’s novel of the same name, and like the helmer’s earlier Ex Machina, we refuse to avoid criticizing the flick just because it’s so close to perfection.
Okay so admittedly half of our staff here at WhatCulture HQ love the bleak ending of Ex Machina. But that half are, unfortunately, objectively wrong.
Early on in the moody, esoteric sci-fi thriller, we’re given glimpses of what seems to be a flashback to our protagonist’s affair during her marriage to soldier husband Oscar Isaacs. The plot hole isn’t the lack of explanation as to why anyone would cheat on Isaacs, though that’s also a fair question—he was Lewellyn Davis, no one would miss their chance.
No, the problem is—why does this subplot exist? It’s generous to call it a “subplot”, given that the momentary flashes don’t serve to flesh out the protagonist’s character, nor do they deepen the story or change its outcome. We’d understand if Portman’s heroine was plagued with guilt, but she seems to have forgotten any infidelity has happened—just like most of the movie has.
9. Event Horizon Cut Its Best Footage
Okay this one isn’t the director’s fault directly, and
in fact it’s only fair to give Resident Evil helmer Paul W.S Anderson some credit—he
did do all he could to try and avoid the issue plaguing Event Horizon. The
problem is with the producers, a refrain which should sound familiar to—well,
anyone who knows anything about how Hollywood works really.
Nonetheless, the finished flick still suffered from the studio deciding to go above the heads of the filmmakers and cut a significant portion of the movie’s more gruesome depictions of hellish alternate dimensions. The scenes owed more to Clive Barker’s dark Hellraiser imagery than anything from the director’s later, more conventional space-based horror Alien Vs. Predator.
As a result, the finished film is nowhere near as intense as its original cut is rumoured to be, with only very brief glimpses of the horrors of hyperspace travel remaining from the original cut’s lengthy depiction of the crewmember’s bloody fates. Worse yet, even though the atmospheric film is still widely considered Anderson’s best, the missing footage has since gone AWOL according to the embattled filmmaker, meaning the unedited cut is unlikely to ever see the light of day.
8. The Faculty Is Just Too Predictable
Desperado director Robert Rodriguez’s nineties remix
of Invasion of the Body Snatchers is a far better film than it has any right to
be, taking a script by Scream screenwriter Kevin Williamson and a game cast of
young stars ranging from 30 Days of Night’s Josh Hartnett to future Fast and Furious
star Jordana Brewster to create a wilder, funnier twist on the classic allegorical
tale. However, there is an underlying issue which holds the film back from full
blown greatness, and it’s not actually the corny tone which critics took issue
with upon the film’s release.
No, the campy schlockiness is one of the film’s strong suits upon reappraisal. Over-the-top lines like Hartnett’s resigned “alright f**k this, I’m outta here” on seeing his teacher pick up her own disembodied head give the film a bizarre charm, and the cheesiness is essential to its success. But the mystery central to the film’s plot—which one of the students is an alien interloper?—is shockingly predictable, with “the new kid” being both the most obvious answer and the correct one, thus sapping the story of any clever twist or surprising reveal.
7. Life Takes The Ending Too Far
With a far more impressive cast than most space-based sci-fi horrors, Life could have been an over-budgeted Alien clone but instead manages to emerge from the shadow of its famous inspirations with an identity of its own. This is down to the daring decision to kill off major cast members early and often despite the high wattage of their star power, leaving the audience unable to guess who—if anyone—is most likely to make it out alive.
Combine this
tense atmosphere with an inventive alien design and some surprisingly moving
character development and the resultant flick ends up far better than anticipated
and almost even justifies stealing its title from whatever uber-pretentious art
film could otherwise have used it.
So what’s it doing on this list?
Well, whilst Life might get a lot right, it misses the mark with a far-took-bleak ending which borders on silly in its over-the-top gloominess, with not only the entire cast dying, but the entire world now at risk of being painfully offed by the alien threat.
6. Signs' Invasion Motivation Is Too Silly
Yes, M Night Shyamalan’s 2002 alien invasion sci-fi
horror has been reconsidered by critics over the last decade or so, and many
have admitted that their initial distaste for the film was unfair in retrospect.
For what it’s worth we too think the film is a pretty superb flick, melding masterful
atmospheric scares with some stellar central performances and a moving story of
a family finding their faith again after a terrible grievance.
But that said—the alien’s weakness is water!
They’re attacking a planet whose surface is 70% water—hell, they’re attacking a species who are 70% water!
And yes, we’ve all heard the old “Gibson’s character is a priest who’s lost his faith, they’re not really aliens but rather demons disguised as aliens, that’s why his belief in Joaquin Phoenix’s character stops them and also that glass of water was holy” chestnut. But the thing is, the aliens were invading all over the world, as proven by the film’s most infamous jump scare. So… did these supposed demons need to go as far as Rio de Janeiro to test one American priest’s faith?
5. Slither Takes Too Long To Get Going
James Gunn’s 2006 horror comedy Slither flopped upon
release, leaving the former Troma director back making indie films such as 2010’s
low-budget Super until Marvel came calling with a little-known older property
for him in the form of 2014’s Guardians of the Galaxy. The Nathan Fillion-starring
throwback to the gory glory era of eighties horror comedies didn’t deserve to fail
at the box office, with the flick representing one of cinema’s last stands for
practical effects work until 2016’s The Void. So how did it end up on this
list?
Well, the film takes its time to populate the story with a believable, funny, and likeable cast of small-town characters before the gruesome infection which plagues Michael Rooker’s antagonist begins picking them off one-by-one. In fact, it takes a little too much time doing so, with the first third of the flick—the pre-gross out alien part—dragging, only for almost every character to end up dead before the credits roll regardless.
It’s not enough to ruin the film, but the movie rarely makes its way onto rundowns of the greatest horror comedies of all time and with its dragging opening act and bleak closer, it’s not hard to see why.
4. Alien: Covenant's Ending Is A Huge Let-Down
Unlike 2018’s Shane Black-directed flop The Predator, 2017’s latest instalment in the Alien franchise was widely quite well-regarded by fans of the franchise and newcomers alike. Returning director Ridley Scott made up for 2012’s pretentious prequel Prometheus with a return to form, crafting a scary, atmospheric, and inventive space-based horror to bring the franchise back on track, aided by a pair of impressive turns from newcomer Katherine Waterston and returning star Michael Fassbender.
Nonetheless, the film earns a place on this rundown for its misjudged ending, a bleak closer which renders the preceding film pointless as we learn that Fassbender’s android David is the true villain of the piece and his entire nefarious plan has gone off without a hitch, thus dooming the characters to an inevitable, painful fate.
It’s a disappointing twist and one which the film didn’t need, particularly after establishing a protagonist as resourceful and likeable as Waterston’s Ripley replacement, and whilst it may not be enough to derail the film entirely, it’s certainly sufficient to keep it from the perfection embodied in the original film.
3. The Fly's Third Wheel Is Never Resolved Properly
We get it, fingertips are bound to start pounding keyboards once anyone suggests that David Cronenberg’s 1986 body horror classic is anything short of flawless. The visionary director’s tragic love story is a bona fide brilliant horror film, and unlike some of the director’s earlier efforts it doesn’t suffer from focusing more on effective gore and gruesome scares than its cast of characters (hello there, Shivers).
Like John Carpenter earlier also extremely effects heavy and also deeply bleak sci-fi horror The Thing, Cronenberg’s fifties sci-fi remake is a rare case of the reimagining improving upon its original in every way, with a career best central performance from Jeff Goldblum adding gravitas to its heart breaking plot.
However the film isn’t entirely without its flaws, and the one which its story never really finds a way to work around is bizarrely named third wheel Stathis Borans. As on-again-off-again love interest to Geena Davis’ Ronnie, Stathis has little to offer the film’s plot beyond embodying Seth’s seething undercurrent of jealousy, and whilst John Getz handles the role admirably, there’s just not much purpose to it.
In such a dark and unremittingly bleak tale there’s little room for spare characters, and poor Borans could have been sent to the cutting floor without much loss.
2. Gamer Fails To Make ANYONE Likeable
Okay, so first things first, Gamer may have never been
destined for true “greatness”. Compared to a few other titles on this list,
2009’s grisly sci-fi thriller offering from the directorial duo behind the
bats*** crazy Crank franchise Neveldine/ Taylor probably isn’t as close to
classic status as say, The Fly. But there’s plenty of potential in this R-rated
satire of everything from reality TV to gaming culture, and it remains one of
the better offerings from the late 2000’s brief revival of gory sci-fi action (sorry,
Daybreakers and Repo Men).
However, despite a clever premise and an impressively kinetic visual style, the film fails for the same reason the Crank franchise succeeded; there are just no likeable characters here, whether it’s Gerard Butler’s scowling personality-free protagonist or Milo Ventimiglia’s charming minor villain, Rick, er, Rape.
Yeah, it’s that sort of film, tonally speaking, which makes it hard to root for anyone when their bloody demise is almost always around the corner and mean-spirited wanton cruelty reigns supreme. There’s nothing wrong with a dark tone, but Gamer has little levity, making it a slog to get through and not one worth saving your progress in when you inevitably give up early.
1. The Crazies Fudges The End Twist
2010 saw Hollywood try its hand at remaking George A. Romero’s 1973 sci-fi horror The Crazies, revamping the thoughtful, dark epidemic thriller into a mile-a-minute action spectacle. However despite this new style, a mash up of Zack Snyder’s then-recent Dawn of the Dead remake and the Bourne trilogy’s edgy, propulsive handheld action, the film managed to maintain the original film’s devastating critique of US policy both domestic and foreign.
Much like in 2002’s Danny Boyle zombie flick 28 Days Later, in this iteration of The Crazies the military and police are as formidable a force of fear as the titular infected, and the characters struggle both with the governmental response to an outbreak and the epidemic itself. Add a stellar pair of central turns from Timothy Olyphant and Radha Mitchell and you’ve got a recipe for greatness, right?
Sure—or almost greatness, given the film’s ending. Cribbing its conclusion from 1995’s Jurassic Park rip off Carnosaur (never a good sign), the film sees its pair of survivors seemingly escape—only for an aerial view satellite shot to show that the military plan to bomb the next town they arrive in and continue quarantining, a process which has already proven lethally ineffective. It's a needlessly bleak and predictable conclusion to an otherwise surprisingly solid offering.