Given the lukewarm reception afforded to Iron Man 2 by both fans and critics alike, Iron Man 3 had a lot to live up to: now that the movie has been released worldwide and there's been some time allowed for the dust to settle, it's fairly plain to surmise that the reception for Tony Stark's third adventure has been mostly positive (albeit with a few minor gripes, of course). Iron Man 3 probably wasn't the movie people were expecting, though: in an age where movie-goers are willing to embrace the idea of a serious and (at times) terribly bombastic Batman, you might have expected Marvel to poise one of their most popular superheroes similarly. Not so: Iron Man 3 emerged as one of the silliest superhero movies for a long time, and - for once - I mean that as a genuine compliment. In the build-up to the release of Marvel 7th installment in its Cinematic Universe, the marketing department seemed intent on pushing this chapter as a darker, more existential outing - we were given a few glimpses of Tony taking a beating and dragging his broken armour through a bleak, snowing terrain. And yet Iron Man 3 is certainly the funniest Marvel movie yet, a sequel willing to embrace and subvert its comic book origins at once. And it's a blockbuster in every sense of the word. As for the angst? Not so much. Dark Knight Rises it ain't. All this falls to the movie's screenwriter (and director) Shane Black, whose trademark dialogue and action chops always seemed like a perfect fit for Robert Downey Jr.'s frantic verbal wit and ironic sensibilities. For this article, I'm going to delve into Black's screenplay for Iron Man 3 to see what handy tips we can take from it, both good and bad. Black, of course, was (and is once again) one of Hollywood's hottest screenwriters - he was paid record sums for his scripts for The Last Boy Scout and The Long Kiss Goodnight in the '90s. Here's a man who really, really knows how to write a spec. He's also happens to be one of my favourite screenwriters. Let's see what we can learn from him, shall we?
10. Shane Blackisms
Simple fact is: Hollywood bigshots don't read spec screenplays. Not to begin with, anyway. First of all, your spec will likely fall into the hands of a script reader, who, based on a few pages alone, will decide whether or not years of work will move up the chain or get thrown in the trash. It's harsh, but that's the way it works. Shane Black realised this depressing little notion when he was in his early 20s, and decided to do something about it: how else do you think he managed to sell the script for Lethal Weapon when he was just 22 years old? I'm cheating a bit here with this entry, because this doesn't relate directly to the script for Iron Man 3, but Shane Black's work in general. Still, it's invaluable advice. Faced with the fact that he desperately needed his script to jump off of the page and force somebody to read it all the way to the end, Shane developed a screenwriting style that appeared personal, honest and genuinely entertaining to read. He wrote his script with dashes of humour and little meta touches that spoke directly to whoever had it in their hands. Nowadays, these are known as Shane Blackisms. Take a look at what I mean. Here's a section of "action" from Black's original Lethal Weapon script:
"Okay. Okay. Let's stop for a moment. First off, to describe fully the mayhem which Riggs creates would not do it justice. Here, however, are a few pointers: He is not flashy. He is not Chuck Norris. Rather, he is like a sledgehammer hitting an egg. He does not knock people down. He does not injure them. He simply kills them. The whole room. Everyone standing."
See how much fun that is to read? That's practically inviting somebody to continue on through its sheer readability alone - if you've got a script that reads like that in a pile of a hundred, I know which one I'd want to spend a couple of hours with. I'm not saying that you should aim to replicate Black's style - that's his own. But don't be afraid to make your screenplay your own - inject it with your own flourishes. It's worth the risk. Don't go overboard of course, because you're still writing a screenplay, and some things you can't change. Black's approach made his scripts some of the highest selling in Hollywood history. Sure, it was probably easier to sell them going on the success of Lethal Weapon, but Black's approach (write the screenplay for the reader) is one of the most important lessons you can learn about screenwriting in general. Let your voice come through - make the screenplay as exciting to read on paper as it would be to watch on the big screen. View the writer/reader experience as a one-on-one conversation. You just happen to be out of the room.
9. There's Always Room For A Joke
One of the reasons I think The Dark Knight Rises suffered was because it came out so bleak and bombastic - all the energy of the first two installments seemed to have vanished, and watching our protagonist dealing with so much angst felt, for an audience member, gruelling. Simply put, it was no fun, because all of the characters dealt with every moment in the same way: with a deadly seriousness But because it was supposed to be a blockbuster, and a movie about a popular comic book hero, it came across as far too ridiculous for its own good. One of the things that Iron Man 3 understands is that it's okay for its characters to make jokes, even at times when we might deem them to be somewhat inappropriate from a real world perspective. At first, it might appear strange for a character to make light of a dangerous situation - say, for example, somebody firing a gun at them in a shootout scene. But throwing out a funny comment, I think, can be a pretty realistic approach. Believe it or not, making light of a situation can help to imbue it with an added sense of humanity. I mean, you're not going to forget the moment in Iron Man 3 when that henchman drops his gun and says, "I hate working for these guys, they're so weird," are you? I remember once I watched a clip on YouTube of some American soldiers in Afganistan. They're just chilling out, waiting for orders, and then a bullet comes whizzing through the air and hits the wall behind them. Erk! They all freak out about it initially (as one would), but within seconds they're in position, laughing about it and cracking jokes about how one of them almost ended up dead. It seems bizarre, and it totally was, and I would have never expected any of them to react like that at all, but it did, and I'll never forget it. The fact that I've never forgotten that video, over five years later, proves my point entirely. Don't be afraid to play around with how you use humour in your script: no matter what you're writing, there's always room for you to pull back and see if it might be better to tackle the scene from a humorous point of view, or using a joke or two. It might seem kind of insane, but absolutely any situation can be mined for comedy purposes.
8. Sending Up Cliches Is A Good Way To Include Them
Iron Man 3 manages to be a massive studio movie that (somewhat surprisingly) still allows the voice of its writer to come through unharmed. That's to say, you can hear Shane Black working his magic for the entire runtime of the movie. And one of the best things that Black does as a writer is defy overused cliches by having his characters confront them directly. Seriously. By referring to these cliches or pointing them out or comparing their situation to something "they saw in a movie once" (and often marking how dumb or ridiculous they are), you're alluding to these common elements that we've all become so familiar with, whilst also factoring them into your screenplay. Audiences recognise the tropes and how frequently we see them, understand that you're aware of that, and yet the point of the cliche still stands: it's employed and defied at once. These moments are scattered throughout Shane Black's entire filmography - his 2005 movie Kiss Kiss Bang Bang was practically made up entirely of these moments. In Iron Man 3, his panache for cliche-defying is best realised during the "Tennessee" sequence, where Tony temporarily teams up with Harley, a precocious little kid who helps Tony when he's stranded in the middle of nowhere. Every time we think we're going to get a cutesy moment, Black pulls the rug out from under our feet. He employs a joke. Something happens we didn't expect etc. Amazingly, the "relationship" between these two characters is only strengthened because of this, which ultimately allows the audience to accept schmalzy moments like the one at the end of the movie, when Harley gets his shed made-over into a miniature Stark Industries. Given that the movies have seemingly worn themselves out with the same old cliches and tropes, it sometimes pays to confront these things face-on and try to find a clever way to show how aware you are that they exist.
7. Understand When To Use Voice-Over Narration
Iron Man 3 differs from its predecessors in the sense that the story is partly narrated by Tony Stark himself, which - at first - seems kind of odd, given that this trope hasn't been utilised before in any movie in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. There's a time and a place for a narration, though I think ultimately the idea makes sense here, given that Iron Man 3 is an very personal story, and one that deals with the whole "is it the man or the suit that makes Iron Man?" thing that comic book fans so often like to discuss. This is the movie where Tony is coming to grips with his entires career so far, after all, and is almost reflecting back on what has happened to him - if this is to be his swan song, the narration sure makes it feels like it. And the narration matches up, in the sense that it makes the movie feel more personal and intimate, as if Tony is finally ready to open up to us, the audience (a post-credits scene reveals that he is in fact talking to Dr. Bruce Banner of, you know, Hulk fame). So how do you know if a narration is right for your script? A lot of writers will advise against it totally (in the same way that they would advise against using flashbacks), deeming it lazy. If you want to give your movie a distinct voice, and you think it can work to enhance the action on-screen, you're probably okay. In this case, we've got Robert Downey Jr., which is a kind of failsafe narration device of sorts, so it's not a great example. But generally speaking, voice-over narration should never be used to tell the story, but only to comment on it. I like to use this rule: if you can remove the narration from the script when it's finished and the story still makes perfect sense without it, then you're fine. This begs the question, of course... if it works fine, do you need it all?
6. Make Every Character Count
I was initially excited to see what the writers had planned for Maya Hansen, creator of the Extremis virus and a character we learn had a brief romantic fling with Tony in the movie's opening 1999 flashback. It turned out... well, that they didn't have much planned for Miss Hansen at all, which only ever feels like something of a cosmic shame. Maya is an interesting character on the surface, of course, and one with the potential to feel like a rightful part of the story. Sadly, it never pays off. For one reason or another, this character was underwritten and served primarily as a tool for exposition and to drive the plot in ways that didn't feel unique to her. Anybody could have done the things that she did. And if she had been taken out of the story entirely? Well, nothing much would have changed. Why does she come to Tony's house in the beginning, exactly? Is it just an opportunity for us to understand that she is going to feature in the story? There's no real point, and by the time Maya is killed, her death isn't really felt: she didn't do anything. Your goal as a screenwriter is to ensure that your story feels natural. The Maya Hansen character hinders this point, by introducing her and then not really knowing where to use her. Sure, she works with Killian, and she slept with Tony once, but these things don't have much to do with the bigger picture. Pepper Potts even isn't jealous of Maya, despite the fact that she knows Tony and her have been intimate once. That might've been one angle to explore as a result of her appearance, but it's not, so what's the point of having her in the first place? The whole "switching between sides" thing carries no weight, either, because we don't know Maya very well. That's to say, when writing your own screenplay, make sure that every one of your characters exists for a reason: don't conveniently conjure up somebody because you need a way to connect A to B, or you're struggling for something to bridge the gap between a couple of pages. When you create a character, you're playing God: you're creating an entire person, with feelings, their own personality, and history. When screenwriters just factor in a character to boringly connect the dots, audiences will pick up on it.
5. Make Your Hero Responsible For Your Villain
One of the best plot points in Iron Man 3 concerns the fact that Tony Stark is essentially the guy responsible for making Aldrich Killian into the Mandarin in the first place. In the movie's opening flashback, we see that Stark, still in full-on playboy mode in 1999, tells a younger, nerdier Killian to meet him up on the roof of their hotel so they can discuss the idea Killian approaches him with. Stark's just palming him off, of course, because he's about to get down and dirty with Maya Hansen. Still, Killian waits in vein in the freezing cold for 20 minutes. It's at this moment - as he's staring out over the city from high above - that Killan is inspired to carry out the evil plans that witness over the course of Iron Man 3. This adds a nice weight to the story, given that we know it was actually Stark's fault that Killian chose to go down an evil path (one that he probably wouldn't have, had Tony just took the time to listen to what he had to say back in '99). If you're writing a screenplay, it's not a bad idea to link your hero and villain in a way that gives them a sense of past history, or having previously associated. Better yet, make your hero directly responsible for why the villain of your movie has become the way he is and you open up a whole realm of creative possibilites. It's an old screenwriting trick, but it pays off in droves if you can get it right and make it work for the story at hand. And it works particularly well here because we've seen how Tony's old ways have come back to haunt him.
4. Your Protagonist Needs Inner Demons
Aside from having a central villain to battle against, it's important that protagonists have their own "inner demons" to face up against, too. It's the flaws that make protagonists interesting, after all, and watching how they deal with them over the course of a movie is what we're all ultimately drawn to, whether we realise it or not. It's the whole "how do they change?" thing that you hear over and over again when it comes to this craft. Nobody likes a perfect protagonist, because - just like in real life - a perfect person would be rather boring to be around. In the case of Iron Man 3, not only does Tony have to battle the Mandarin and his associates, but he's dealing with his own crippling anxiety attacks relating to the events we saw at the end of The Avengers, in which he strapped a nuclear bomb to his back and launched himself headfirst into an alien portal. Your own protagonist doesn't have to be dealing with events quite as heavy as that, but give them something - a mistake they made in the past, or a scar that reminds them of somebody they lost - that resonate throughout the narrative. Unfortunately, Iron Man 3 doesn't really tie up the idea of Tony's panic attacks in a particularly satisfying way. If you can directly tie your protagonist's inner demons to the plot problem at hand, and resolve them both simultaneously, then great. Once again, this is screenwriting 101, but I've read dozens of spec scripts over the past few years that feature main characters with nothing to define them but their quirky names. Pick any movie at random, though, and I guarantee the main character is dealing with something internal, as well as external - it's an essential component of any script.
3. Set Up/Pay Off
Another simple tip, and one that Shane Black has openly spoken about when discussing the screenwriting craft. It's the old set up/pay off method, which you've probably seen in, oh, every film ever made. But this one doesn't really get old, and it's a tried and tested way to bring back old plot points that seem relevant and allow the audience to go, "Oh, man, how did I forget about that?" Here's what Black had to say about this one:
"There's a great example of this in Face/Off. Near the start of the film John Travolta explains to his daughter how to defend herself with a knife: he says she should stab a guy in the leg and twist the knife once it's in there. By the end of the film, the audience has half-forgotten the scene. But when the daughter has a bad guy holding a gun to her head and pulls out a knife, everybody remembers."
And how does he write these moments? Well, he cheats.
"Sometimes I write a scene and I think to myself: "That would be even better if I'd somehow set it up earlier in the film." So I turn back to page 15, insert a set-up and wind up looking like a genius who had planned it like that all along."
And Black employed this technique in Iron Man 3, when Tony Stark gives Harley, the kid he befriends during the movie's "Tennessee" sequence, a deterrent gadget to use against a school bully. We make a note to remember this, of course, but straight away you forget, distracted by the rest of the movie. Harley later uses this gadget on a bad guy and saves Tony's life. It's a small, arguably meaningless touch, but when you're writing a blockbuster, moments like this count for a lot.
2. Ensure That Your Villain Has A Clear Motivation
On the whole, I thought that Killian/The Mandarin's motivations were way to muddled and confused for much of the movie, and that's because - simply put - they were. We know that Killian ultimately wanted to control both the President of the United States and his own Mandarin-led terrorist group via a decoy (Ben Kingsley), but why? His motivations aren't ever really laid out on the table in a way that makes sense to us. Sure, we understand what his plan is and what he's trying to do, but not what achieving it means to the guy. And things get a bit lost in the process of all this, because (like Bane in the Dark Knight Rises) we never really get a sense of purpose that we can go along with/root against. In the case of Iron Man 3, there's a lot of plot to distract you, but it's actually pretty thin going when you lay it out flat and try to piece it all together. That's to say, if your villain is planning on doing something, ensure that there's a reason for them to be doing it. There's nothing worse than a script with a character who ends up doing things for the the sake of it, or to cause problems for your protagonist, despite the fact that there's nothing in it for them. If you conjure up an extremely complicated plan (like the one here), it has to work for your villain as a human being. This is a person, and given the information you establish, they need to totally believe in what they're doing (whilst it really helps if we totally understand why they did what they did, at least by the end of the movie). In this case, Killian - who could have been a far more interesting character had they shown us more of his personality - is diluted by the fact that he simply wants to control the President and, uh... well, I'm not sure what else he wants to do. As Tony Stark's evil mirror image and a scientist of incredible talent and ability, that just seems so dated and lame. I never had a clear grasp on Killian's motivations, and he's rather forgettable as a result. At a time when villains are arguably more popular than heroes, that's a mistake you can't afford to make.
1. Don't Overdo Your Climax
There's something slightly strange about the overall structure of Iron Man 3, often with regards to the placement of its set-pieces. There isn't an overabundance of set-pieces in the film generally, which is fine, because it never feels overwhelmed by "too much action" - that is, until the end, when a couple of huge set-pieces follow on from one another without much of a break, the second of which goes on for far too long. I'm not sure it was written that way on paper, but it certainly feels stretched to its limits, perhaps at the studio's request. I'm referring to the set-piece with the plane and the falling passengers (excellent, in my opinion), followed by the overlong shipyard battle, which appears to exist to only ever go on and on and on. This thing could have been cut in half and still had exactly the same impact. We have the bad guy, Killian, constantly coming back to life like an enemy from a Resident Evil game - and for what reason? One "final battle" would have done nicely. Which is to say, "less is more." If you're writing a climax, don't feel pressured to top everything that came before it. Strangely, Black seems to have gone against his own advice when it comes to the ending battle of Iron Man 3:
"An action film can have too much action; picture an equaliser on a stereo, with all the knobs pegged at 10. It becomes a cacophony and is, ultimately, quite boring..."
No kidding, Shane. But his advice here is good advice that you should keep in mind when you're writing action. Change it up and don't be afraid to pitch your action sequences at different levels: the next explosion doesn't always have to be bigger than the last explosion. It also helps to know when to say when. If you find you've written a 10 page action scene at the end of your movie, see if you can achieve the same effect but cutting it down by half the size. Sometimes that's impossible, and fair enough if you can't make it work, but people will always remember a more honed and far slicker dose of action than a huge, muddled climax that goes on forever. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.