10 Screenwriting Lessons You Can Learn From Prometheus

By T.J. Barnard /

Welcome to a new series of articles we€™re running here at WhatCulture, prior to a new section of the site that will be opening up soon €“ one which will focus entirely on the subject of screenwriting.Last week, I looked at screenwriting lessons we could take from The Dark Knight Rises. This week, it's Ridley Scott's sci-fi blockbuster Prometheus.
Back when the first trailer for Prometheus was unveiled online, most of us probably thought we were staring right into the big, beautiful eyes of a full-fledged sci-fi masterpiece. The movie contained within the frames of the trailer appeared to show something rich, dazzling, mind-blowing and perhaps even out of time. And it was Ridley Scott, going back to his roots with a huge, space-based blockbuster, one which starred Michael Fassbender and Idris Elba and... Alas, it was not to be. It's probably safe to say that most of us found ourselves largely disappointed come release day: Prometheus wasn't quite the sci-fi masterpiece we were all expecting, was it? Saying that, if you happen to be one of the very few people in this day and age who can watch a movie without any preconceptions, then you likely found Prometheus to be an enjoyable, visually-stunning blockbuster - one which was absolutely worth the price of admission. Visually arresting as Prometheus was, though, there was absolutely no way that anybody possessing even a passing interest in either movies or the screenwriting process could get past its bizarre and mis-guided screenplay, as penned by John Spaithis (The Darkest Hour) and later re-written (to its death) by Damon Lindelof (Lost). Confusing, convoluted, ambiguous in all the wrong ways, ridden with plot holes, it reeks of compromise, rushed scheduling, and a surprising lack of polish. For most sci-fi aficionados, the biggest disappoint came with the obvious shunning of the "harder" sci-fi elements that made movies like Alien feel intricate and fully-realised. This, accompanied with the fact that Prometheus would forcibly removed you from the experience time and time again thanks to a cast of highly questionable characters, made it near-impossible for audiences to suspend their disbelief. These fundamental flaws go all the way back to the script process, of course, and here I'd like to take a look at Prometheus and see which screenwriting lessons we can wrench from it...

10. "A Haunted House Movie... In Space!"

Here's an exercise that you can apply to practically any screenplay, and one which might've helped to better structure and define the script that Lindelof was trying for with Prometheus. Imagine that you're "pitching" your screenplay to a room full of movies executives. Imagine the words that you might use to instantly provide them with a snapshot of what your movie is about, preferably in a short, neat sentence. For Prometheus, then, when asked what it is, one might decide to say: "Well, it's a haunted house movie... in space!" There are no movie executives lingering around your place of writing, of course, but this is where conjuring up your pitch-line will help you to focus your storyline. The pitch-line reels you in, and gives you a chance to hone your ideas into a single place and set about your goal. In Prometheus' case, the movie eventually culminates in a kind of sci-fi haunted house scenario, so that's likely a good way to "sum" up the idea of the movie - "intellectual" subtext aside, that's all Prometheus really is when you strip it to its core. Executives and industry folk like to hear movie ideas compressed like this, so fitting your script around one of these pitch-lines (and making sure it sticks to it) is a good way to keep focused. You've probably heard a character in a movie pitching something dumb like "It's Jaws meets When Harry Met Sally," but thinking of your screenplay in these terms isn't a bad idea. It gives you successful, established properties to work from, and a better indication of your goals. It will also help you to weigh whether or not you think it sounds marketable.

9. Set Up Your Story In The First 20 Pages

Despite clinging to a plot that - in its second act - pretty much dwindles and dies, Prometheus does a good job of setting up its story with an admirable level of efficiency. This is achieved using one of the most basic screenwriting principles - have the main story set up by page 20 (at the latest). Here, we're introduced to the major players, the objective, the world that our characters inhabit, and are granted some Elizabeth Shaw-based backstory. That doesn't mean you have to stick with the original plot established on page 20 when you get further into your script (you're free to change things up anytime from there on), but you should aim to at least have the first "goal" set up and (hopefully) being explored by this point (page 20 will roughly translate as the 20th minute of your flick - about the length of time that audiences will tolerate a story set-up). Anything longer will give your movie a sense of aimlessness, and when it comes to the movies, aimlessness pretty much equals "boring."

Advertisement

8. Have A Clear Central Character

This may sound like obvious advice, but you won't believe how many screenplays (produced and unproduced) slowly wrench their protagonists out of pole position over the course of the story. Why does it happen? Usually, because the writer accidentally creates another secondary character who they find more interesting than their original protagonist. In an attempt to stick with a character who (in most cases) is more "fun" to write, the protagonist gets lost in the background. And that kind of happens in Prometheus, what with Dr. Elizabeth Shaw and David. But Prometheus suffers throughout because Dr. Shaw isn't much of a protagonist to begin with. Firstly, she makes it extremely difficult to identify with her, which is certainly something that you want to incorporate in the realm of sci-fi movies. She is constantly forced into situations that she never resolves, and ends up playing a victim, regardless of her status as a supposed scientific genius. The writers obviously had more fun writing David, the android character, something which likely emerged as a result of his moral ambiguity. He eventually emerges as the central protagonist (or it feels as though he does, at least), because he's better driving the events of the story. Elizabeth, relatively passive, falls out of our favour and relative interest. This choppiness makes the screenplay feel at odds with itself: it's almost as if, having written it, nobody could be bothered to go back, and define the protagonist. The result is a movie that feels conflicted, because - as audience members - we're not sure who to feel comfortable with. When writing your own script (of the blockbuster variety, at least), try to ensure that movie-goers have a character they can identify as the main protagonist.

7. Ensure That Your Characters Always Have A Goal

Ultimately, I think Prometheus is disappointing because - despite all its grandeur - it doesn't really have much of a plot. Hear me out. I mean, it has a loose story that emerges from an extremely intriguing premise, but our characters eventually find themselves trapped in a screenplay that spends much of its time subjecting them to a series of brutal events with no real motive or pay-off. And that's because the story is so frustratingly ambiguous. Wispy at best. When you're writing anything of the blockbuster variety, though, the most important thing is to ensure that we know what our characters are shooting for at every point in the story. The moment that a goal is completed or goes out of the window (in this case, once they've completed their first goal, which is landing on the planet and exploring the ruins), you've only got a short space of time to set-up the next goal. Whenever you find yourself growing "bored" whilst watching absolutely any kind of movie, it's almost always because the characters aren't actively doing anything at that moment - the next goal hasn't been set up and we're in the process of working towards it. Notice that whenever anybody says "Let's do this" (or some variation of), though, that you instantly perk up. Prometheus was crammed with ambiguous downtime. Ensure that your characters always have something to do, and that their agenda - whether actively pursued or not - is clear.

6. Your Audience Are Way Smarter Than You

Advertisement
Never stop thinking this when you're writing a screenplay: Your audience are way smarter than you. Even if it isn't true, it doesn't matter: it will help you to write a better screenplay, because you'll have the added fear that somebody will take your script up, read the first page, and call "bullshit." After months and months of hard work, it isn't worth taking that risk, is it? In any good movie, novel or television show, it's the extensive research process that writers carry out beforehand that ensures you're not constantly being pulled out of the experience, frowning and saying, "Uh, really?" As human beings, we have a great radar for knowing when something - even on subjects we're not well-versed in - don't ring true. We instinctively pick up on bullshit, and Prometheus is absolutely filled to the brim with questionable moments that feel like the stuff of vague speculation. That's to say, Prometheus is mostly dealing with scientific theories and concepts that just don't exist - a result of the movie being set in the distant future. Here's where we can happily except terms and words that we wouldn't ordinary hear - as long as the characters sound assured, we feel assured. But it's the characters themselves that don't ring true here: not a single one of the ship's crew feels like they're who they say there are. And that's because the scientific nature of their personalities has been dumbed down, likely due to a lack of research on the part of the writers. That aside, Prometheus took so much liberty with its plot, that it emerged as the most plot hole-addled movie of 2012. I won't go into all the "plot holes" here, because there are just too many to count and they've been covered extensively elsewhere - most of which are genuinely legitimate concerns. But the point is, never put anything into your script that you're unsure about, or know subconsciously that you haven't explained properly. The fact that the Prometheus crew are briefed on their mission hours before they reach the planet (and not before they sign up for the mission) is ludicrous: how did something like that make into this screenplay? In a sci-fi script, especially, audiences are actively looking for details like this - not because they want to find reasons to dislike the movie, but because sci-fi movies (especially Ridley Scott sci-fi movies) invite close scrutiny. It's the details and research that make movies like this, and Prometheus is bizarrely flat when it comes to the details. Research will make or break your script: it's arguably the most important factor. Simply watching other movies and using them as a guide will come back to bite you on the ass.

5. Got A Team? Give Them Conflicting Views

Here's something that, once again, might seem completely obvious if you're familiar with screenwriting principles, but I've read a seriously high number of unproduced screenplays that fail on this basic front: if you've got a movie about a team of people who share a common goal, give them all conflicting views. Conflict creates drama, after all, and that's precisely what a movie is all about. In Prometheus, we see a great realization of this. And the more characters you have, the more interesting dynamics you'll conjure up when writing. Setting up these "conflicting views" is important in the early stages. In the first act of your script, it might be a small gesture or comment that implants the idea of a potential conflict emerging between two characters in an audiences' subconscious. Later on, the pay off of said conflict will be greatly increased, because the tension has been building up slowly, as if natured from a tiny seed... Even if you've got two characters within a team that respect one another, give them conflicting views on something. Anything. Maybe one character wants to let a prisoner go, whilst the other one thinks that they should kill the prisoner to avoid trouble later. If these people are at odds with one another anyway, you've still got the potential for good drama. But what if they respect one another and are friends? Even better. The tension is ramped up because we hate to see friends bickering. We put ourselves in that position.

4. Throw A Wrench In The Works

Let's imagine that you've written a good, solid screenplay, but it's missing that "oomph" factor - one which helps to differentiate it from other good, solid screenplays (which there are, like, a million of). Your best bet, then, is to take a long, hard look at your finished screenplay and see if there's room for you to factor in another unique story aspect. It might mean that you're going to have to re-write lots of the script, but "throwing a metaphorical wrench" in the works can a) mark your screenplay as something special b) inspire brand new ideas. In the case of Prometheus, the "wrench in the works" is the android David, who exists purely to create a mayhem and force the other characters into the movie's situations and set-pieces. Despite being played excellently by Michael Fassbender, Davis is a great writers' tool because his motives are all over the place. This doesn't work quite as well as it might've because Prometheus is all over the place, but the movie would have been rather dull without him. Factor in your "own" David - it doesn't necessarily have to be a character, but could be an item or a new plot twist - and see what happens. It might not pay off every time, but it's certainly worth the risk.

3. Go Easy On The Symbolism

There's nothing wrong with imbuing your screenplay with symbolism - many of the greatest screenplays of all time are built around subtext and symbolism. Thing is, though, the symbolism inherent in these screenplays is subtle and carefully weighed. Prometheus is a movie constructed out of the most ham-fisted movie symbolism I've seen in a long time: worst of all, it doesn't make much sense, as if it's stretching to be complex for the sake of it, despite the fact that the movie doesn't even have a properly developed storyline. So what, you say? Isn't it better to have some degree of symbolism, anyway? I'd argue not: it doesn't work because doesn't have a plot to attach itself to: good movies work as symbolism, because the symbolism is derived from the plot - how can Prometheus hope to have symbolism when the symbolism doesn't have anything firm to cling to? Instead, it becomes a movie that is relentlessly trying to have "ideas" larded into it. The key to layering your own screenplay with symbolism? Just write it. If you've got a good story, the symbolism will fall into place by itself. You shouldn't be trying too hard to make your script more intelligent than it actually is: that will come through in your writing anyway. The point is, symbolism shouldn't be at the forefront of your script. Prometheus makes this mistake over and over again: jamming it in our faces is just obnoxious, especially when its "big ideas" are just a means of distracting from a lack of plot.

2. Don't Write For The Sequel

Advertisement

Lots of writers (myself included) like to write in the knowledge that they're saving "added" material (and a few answers) for a sequel to whatever project we're working on. There's nothing better than trying to imagine a full-on mythology or expanded universe for your own works. After all, it leaves you with an imaginary safety net that means - should you find writing success - you've got some good ideas saved away should you need to revisit your work.

But this isn't such a great idea, and Prometheus is proof of that. In fact, the entire movie could've easily been condensed into a kind of prologue or opening crawl, given that we don't learn barely anything that the movie sets out to teach us. It is a movie in search of its own idea, and it shows.

Advertisement

Thankfully, there's a Prometheus sequel in the works as this moment, and maybe the first film will be improved through the answers that a follow-up can provide us with. But as it goes: write every screenplay as if it's your last, or as if it's the only work that will ever be made in the universe you've created. That way, you're not stashing away important plot points for the sake of forced ambiguity, and your movie won't be reduced to a succession of messy interludes and unresolved narrative threads.

Advertisement

Advertisement

1. Know Exactly Why Everything Happens

So many screenplays nowadays rely on ambiguous endings and audience interpretation. That's fine - it makes movies interesting, and gives them a longer shelf-life. The fact that we're still talking about Prometheus now means that - to some extent - its vagueness has paid off (from a marketing point of view, anyway). But try to remember that, whilst writing your screenplay, you know why things are happening, even if you don't plan of letting the audience know the full extent. In the case of Prometheus, you can tell that Damon Lindelof was working in the shadows of the screenplay: he attempted to pass off certain plot elements as purposely ambiguous, but it came off like he was making it up as he went along (which he likely was, if his work on Lost is anything to go by). But consider that if you, at least, know the reasons why the events in your screenplay are occurring, you will ultimately write a better movie. That way, you can't defy the logic that you have set up, and plot holes won't reveal themselves in the way they did with Prometheus. Again, this isn't advising you to spell out everything for your audience. That's even more of an insult, and can even prove more frustrating. But making sure that you're confident in your ideas will make you feel better about every single word you put down. Then the fun comes in working out exactly the right amount of information to reveal to audiences. Like this article? What lessons did you take? Let us know in the comments section below.