10 Smartest Decisions Made By Harry Potter Characters
It's important to pay attention while attending your classes at Hogwarts.
With seven books - or eight films - centred around a magical school, it’s no surprise that many of the characters manage to make some astute decisions. And that’s a good thing because the world of Harry Potter is a dangerous one. With a sinister threat looming each year at Hogwarts, it's imperative that some of these characters kept their wits about them.
Albeit good decisions or bad ones, the best choices are ones that have unforeseeable benefits later on. There are countless times in the franchise where things could have easily gone horribly for the characters.
However, they get by because of something they did earlier in the story. Whether it's Hermione’s need to take too many classes or Harry and Ron’s lack of thinking, planned or not, these decisions pay off in the end.
Whether it’s good planning, quick thinking, or just plain luck, the characters of the Harry Potter series tend to make sometimes intelligent and sometimes seemingly random choices that end up paying off. The characters may or may not have realized what they were throwing into motion, but because they did, the heroes prevailed.
Without these unforeseen consequences, Harry may never have made it through his second year of Hogwarts.
10. Dumbledore's Army Breaks Into The Ministry - The Order Of The Phoenix
Things did not go well for Harry and his friends when they broke into the Ministry of Magic.
While they managed to foil Voldermorte's plans and locked up some Death Eaters, the trip is hardly a success. Even though the break-in caused the tragic loss of Sirius Black and the demise of the Hall of Prophecy, there were a few unforeseen benefits in its destruction.
Aside from the destruction of Harry's prophecy, the accidental wrecking of Time-Turners was one of the most important events that could have happened.
The mess Harry and his friends cause in the Ministry prolonged Harry's life in more ways than one. The first is in delaying Voldemort from hearing the prophecy.
While Dumbledore could have shared the entirety of the prediction with Harry at any time. The loss of the sphere means Voldemort is left without essential knowledge. This allows Harry to grasp his duties and meet death as an Ally in the end.
The second and much less immediate consequence is in the continuation of Harry's story, The Cursed Child. The wizarding world is threatened by Voldemort's daughter and a single, illegal time-turner.
The loss of time turners not only keeps Voldemort's daughter at bay, but also any other loyalist that may try to go back in time and defeat Harry.
If Harry and his friends had not broken into the Ministry, the Death Eaters and any other Voldemort supporter would have been after one of the many time turners.
9. Narcissa Makes A Request - The Half-Blood Prince
The Malfoys are incontrovertibly horrible. They are cruel, manipulative, and act in their own interest, always. Throughout the series, we never see the family spend a shred of decency on anyone. Yet, no matter how unlikeable they may be, the Malfoy family cares ferociously for each other.
We see the family's protective nature several times throughout the series. It is evident when Draco seeks revenge against Harry for his father's arrest or when Narcissa lies that Harry is dead. However, the most brilliant idea comes from Narcissa's desire for Severus Snape to take an Unforgivable Vow.
Narcissa's need to protect her son inadvertently solidifies Snape's loyalty to Voldemort. Snape was able to secure information for the order both in Dumbledoors life and death in his choice to make the unbreakable vow.
It also allowed Snape to take the life of Dumbledore as he had promised to him and effectively end the line of the Elder Wand. While that's not exactly what happened, it ensured the elder wand never truly belonged to Voldemort.
8. Stealing A Car - The Chamber Of Secrets
Grand theft auto is never advisable. Very few times in history has someone stolen a car and greatly benefited from it in any way, shape, or form. But somehow, it worked out for Ron and Harry when they took the Weasley family car flying.
After being blocked from entry at platform nine and three-quarters and missing their train, waiting or at least trying to wait for Ron's parents would have been the wise choice. As fans know, Ron and Harry panic, and to avoid missing school, they steal the car and take it to Hogwarts.
After landing by way of smashing into the Whopming Willow, the spell-cast car seems to gain sentience and promptly kicks the children out of the car and hightails into the Forbidden Forest. But that carjacking ends up saving their and Hagrids' lives.
Hagrid's ever questionable advice and interesting choice of companionship lands Harry and Ron in trouble with some massive, hungry spiders. Thankfully for them, the stolen car comes to rescues them at the brink of a gruesome death.
If Harry and Ron had waited for Ron's parents, the car wouldn't have been there to save them, and Voldemort would have been resurrected in Ginny's body.
7. Lupin Keeps His Secrets - The Prisoner Of Azkaban
A lot of characters in the Harry Potter series have secrets. Sometimes it pays off to keep things close to the chest, as in the case of Professor Dumbledore and his suspicion of Horcruxes, and other times it doesn't - like when James and Lily failed to divulge the change in secret keeper, from Sirius to Pettigrew.
In the case of Professor Lupin, he had selfish reasons for keeping his secret. Yet, that choice shifted the progression of Harry's life.
When Sirius broke out of Azkaban, Lupin could have revealed to the authorities that his old friend was an animagus. It would have made capturing Sirius a lot easier for the Ministry, and there would have been a much calmer third year for the trio at Hogwarts. But Lupin, too ashamed to betray the trust Dumbledore had always bestowed in him, decided to tell no one.
This saves the life of Buckbeak and Sirus. Moreover, it allows Harry and Lupin to understand the truth in the betrayal in Lily and James Potter. Without Sirius' prison break, no one would have known Peter Pettigrew was alive and should be considered a threat.
Sirius' escape also forces Harry to learn the Patrons charm, which, as fans know, saves many lives throughout the series. Hermione getting a time turner saved Sirius, but Lupin's decision to remain silent changes the fate of everyone.
6. Draco Plays Dumb - The Deathly Hallows
Draco Malfoy is many things. He's smug, arrogant, and a bully, but one thing he is not, is a fool.
He is very much a character who takes pride in being more intelligent than others, which is most likely why he surrounds himself with the likes of Crabbe and Goyle. But perhaps the most important decision he ever makes is to act stupid.
When Harry, Hermione, and Ron get caught by the snatchers and brought to the Malfoy Mansion, it seems like they are doomed. They're sure they have possession of Harry Potter, but fear of being wrong and the wrath of Voldemort to answer to leads them to ask for Draco Malfoy's confirmation.
Anyone who has been at Hogwarts for even a day knows that Harry, Hermione, and Ron are practically inseparable. Draco knows it's Harry. Everyone knows it's Harry, so why does Draco lie?
It would seem like a good idea to be the one who hands Harry to Voldemort, but Draco knows better. He knows their life would be worse if Voldemort rose to power. His hate for Harry was nothing compared to the fear of Voldemort.
Whether he did this to save his own life or Harry's, it allowed both to live full fear-free lives.
5. Harry Keeps An Old Textbook - The Half-Blood Prince
Very few people would choose an old, used textbook over a brand new version of the same one. Sometimes it's scribbled art in the margins, or more than the margins.
Usually, it's missing pages and contains a litany of rude words definitely not included in the original print. We can hope but, no one ever expects to find anything useful in it.
Harry keeping the Half-Blood Princes textbook seems like an obvious choice for this list because it is a significant plot point in the story, but it is nonetheless a brilliant move on his part.
The book gives Harry's the ability to perform in potions. Therefore he can do what Dumbledore asked of him, get close enough to pry information from Slughorn. However, getting in Slughorn's good graces isn't the only reason keeping the Prince's book was wise.
On the first day of Potions Class, Harry produces the best Draught of Living Death, winning the small vial of Felix Felices. Harry would have never procured the memory from Slughorn without the steady hand of Felix guiding him. And his friends who stayed behind at Hogwarts would not have survived the events at the end of the Half-Blood Prince without that lucky potion.
Harry can even thank his career as an Auror on Slughorn's post as Potions Professor and Harry's new skills from the Prince.
4. Hermione Takes Too Many Classes - The Prisoner Of Azkaban
It's never been said that Hermione is lazy. On the contrary, she is a classic overachiever, and when it comes to studying, there is no one better. Hermione's constant pursuit of educational excellence is the very thing that has saved Harry, Ron, and others countless times. But sometimes, her pursuit of learning yields other rewards.
In their third year at Hogwarts, Hermione takes her passion for learning, maybe a tad bit too far. She loads her schedule so thoroughly that many classes overlap. To attend each lesson, she must time travel. Hermione's ability to secure a time-turner kicks off a chain of events that has profound ramifications in the wizarding world.
Fans know that Hermione and Harry use the time-turner to save Sirius Black and Buckbeak, but it almost seems like a letdown because, in life, Sirius could never prove his innocence. However, it's the unintended consequences that make this such a smart decision. The Order of the Phoenix was able to use Grimmauld Place as their headquarters.
While Harry and Sirius's time together was short, that relationship was significant to both of them. Even after death, Harry, Ron, and Hermione were able to use both the home and the assistance of Creature because Sirus cared for Harry.
Without Hermione taking all those classes, none of those things would have ever happened.
3. Harry Skips A Lesson - The Order Of The Phoenix
For the most part, Harry is a decent student. He's certainly no Hermione Granger, but he's also no Ronald Weasly. He is famously good in his defense against the dark arts classes but is also equally dreadful when it comes to History of Magic and Divination.
For the most part, Harry tries to be a good student, only really ignoring his studies when he's either fighting for his life or stuck in detention. However, there is one area of study that Harry actively dislikes and puts little effort into learning, and that's Occlumency.
As fans know, Dumbledore wanted Harry to learn to block his connection with Voldemort for fear that he would persuade Harry to act. While Dumbledore is correct, and Harry's actions result in Sirius's death, that connection ultimately gives Harry an advantage in the fight against Voldemort.
Harry's refusal to practice Occlumency allows them to know what Voldemort is doing in the final instalment. The flashes into Voldemort's mind confirm that there was a Horcrux hidden at Hogwarts.
Since Harry can see where Voldemort is when they set off the alarms at Hogsmead, ensuring their safety, without this ability, Harry and his friends would have never found Severus Snape. Aide from understanding the truth behind Snape's actions, Harry would have never understood what was required of him.
2. Dumbledore Leaves A Baby On A Doorstep - The Philosophers Stone
Most fans will ask upon watching or reading the series, "Why did Dumbledore leave Harry at his aunt and uncles?"
It is one of the more controversial decisions in the entire Harry Potter series, and it happens at the very beginning of the first book. It seems like an obvious choice to raise Harry in the wizarding world. He would have been surrounded by people like him, and he certainly wouldn't have suffered so much cruelty from whatever foster parents he might have ended up with.
That said, it turns out to be one of the wisest decisions made by a character in the series.
Fans will know that he is protected at his relative's house by magic because of Harry's mother's sacrifice. While that is a big reason why Dumbledore did what he did, it wasn't the only reason.
For one, attacks like the one orchestrated by Umbridge would be more challenging to cover up in the muggle world. Secondly, Dumbledore explains that he felt it best that Harry grow up away from the fame that would surround him his entire life.
His muggle upbringing ultimately works out because Harry grows up with a modest and kind personality, regardless of his tortured upbringing. It's precisely that disdain for his home that makes Harry care so deeply for the wizarding world.
Had he grown up rich and famous, there's a good chance Harry would have been more Malfoy than Potter.
1. Harry Gives A Sock Away - The Chamber Of Secrets
There are a lot of incredible moments throughout the Harry Potter series. Each story is full of memorable events and fantastic characters. It's why the series is such a hit. And one of the best characters in the entire series is the house-elf, Dobby.
When Harry freed Dobby, it was one of the best moments in the series. While Dobby has a small presence in the films, only showing up in the second and scarcely in Deathly Hallows part 1, he plays a much more significant role in the books.
Harry's act of freeing Dobby was one of the most intelligent decisions any character makes in the series.
The satisfaction felt by viewers and readers alike was palpable when Harry gave Lucious Malfoy a sock. Not only does it develop Harry as a caring character, but it introduces a unique character to the series, a free elf.
Dobby's freedom and subsequent employment at Hogwarts is why Moody can slip Harry Gilly weed in Goblet of Fire. Dobby acts as a spy for Harry, and he even went as far as cleaning the Gryffindor tower alone, while the other house-elves boycotted due to Hermione's SPEW initiative.
If Harry hadn't freed Dobby, it's likely Harry, and his friends would have never escaped the Malfoy manor.