10 So-Called Happy Endings That Absolutely Aren't
Richmond Valentine actually won.
Good filmmaking is the art of manipulating and tricking the audience. That's one of the keys to great Hollywood cinema - its ability to hijack viewers' mood and pull them right into a story's world.
A great example of this comes from 1996's Independence Day. There's a particular scene where a tunnel is being destroyed, and even though thousands of people have just died, audiences are likely to forget that because the focus is on the hero's dog. The dog makes it, everyone cheers! It should be a sad moment, but such is the power of Hollywood manipulation.
It's often like this with movie endings as well. If a picture uses cinematic techniques to successfully create a happy atmosphere, then viewers are likely to walk away thinking that they've just witnessed a happy ending. It might only be later, when they reflect further, that they realize it actually wasn't.
Just ask Whiplash. It took people a little while to realize that Whiplash's ending was miles away from the inspirational story that many, including the Rotten Tomatoes critics' consensus, described it as. People have come around to Whiplash, but there are plenty more stealth unhappy endings floating around out there, starting with...
10. Thunderbolts*
By the standards of post-Endgame MCU, Thunderbolts* wasn't bad at all. It ended up being a pretty fun time with a refreshing undercurrent of darkness layered in, most notably through its touching (if unsubtle) explorations of mental health and also a more cynical ending than normal for the MCU.
Throughout the movie, the titular team has been trying to survive the various efforts of Valentina de Fontaine (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) to kill them, and they've also come into conflict with Bob (Lewis Pullman), a young man who was experimented on by de Fontaine. She was trying to turn him into a new superhero, but only damaged him further, and he nearly destroyed New York by mistake.
Once the Thunderbolts help Bob regain control of his powers, they chase after de Fontaine, only to suddenly emerge onto a stage where she's holding an impromptu press conference. She introduces them as the New Avengers and takes credit for building the team and stopping Bob.
Though the film plays this ending in a somewhat optimistic light, with Yelena Belova (Florence Pugh) telling de Fontaine, "We own you now," it's actually a bit of a downer ending in all honesty. It's great that most of the characters made it through, but despite Belova's words, de Fontaine is the one who's in charge of them, not the other way around, and she's also got away with all of her appalling crimes.
9. Star Wars Episode I - The Phantom Menace
With this one, the clue is in the music.
When watching The Phantom Menace, the ending is heart-warming on the surface. Naboo has been freed from the Trade Federation, the humans and Gungans have formed a new friendship, and a more competent man has just become Supreme Chancellor. The joyful tone is buoyed by John Williams' exuberant score, but again, there's a hidden detail in there.
This score is actually the Emperor's theme from the Original Trilogy, just in a different key. That symbolizes what's really going on here. The freedom of Naboo is merely a temporary victory, as the real villain - new chancellor Sheev Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) - has just taken control of the Republic and is sowing the seeds of the downfall of the democracy and the Jedi Order.
Another neat little detail is in Qui-Gon Jinn's (Liam Neeson) funeral scene. Yoda and Mace Windu (Frank Oz and Samuel L. Jackson) acknowledge that Qui-Gon was killed by a Sith Lord and remember that there are always two, a master and an apprentice. As they ponder which one was destroyed, the camera slowly pans to Palpatine. Very clever indeed.
8. The Green Inferno
Eli Roth's The Green Inferno, which serves as a homage to cannibal horror films such as Cannibal Holocaust, is one of those horror movies that's arguably a bit too cruel for its own good. Though well-made and well-acted up to a point, it often feels overly sadistic, and the way it treats its ending as happy really leaves a bad taste behind.
In the end, protagonist Justine (Lorenza Izzo) does manage to escape the murderous tribe of cannibals who kill almost all of the other eco-activists she was travelling with, but, instead of warning other people about how dangerous the tribe is, she lies and says they were peaceful and benevolent. What?!
It seems she was doing this to protect the tribe from outsider aggressors... the same tribe who killed her companions and tried to mutilate her. Like, they weren't the good guys, you know! Thanks to her stupidity, someone else might've approached them and lost their life as a result.
Furthermore, a post-credits scene reveals that lead activist Alejandro (Ariel Levy), who is by far the most loathsome of the main group, has survived and is now a member of the tribe. Roth brutally killed off all the other characters but deprived viewers of any catharsis by denying them the one death they actually wanted to see.
Basically, this one is a downer sequel-bait ending in disguise. A follow-up was planned but never materialized. Oh well, The Green Inferno isn't particularly good anyhow.
7. Old
M. Night Shyamalan's rock-solid horror-thriller Old focuses on a group of tourists who go onto a mysterious beach that causes them to begin rapidly aging. In the end, only Trent and Maddox, who went on the beach at the age of six and 11, respectively, are left alive. They have now aged up to adults in their 40s or 50s.
This particular ending is definitely one of the most unsettling 'happy endings' in any recent film. It turns out that the beach is a way for a pharmaceutical organisation to monitor the effects of various medicines and witness 'years' of progress in the space of a day or two. Trent and Maddox do manage to expose them, and as such, no-one else is going to suffer their horrible fate, but even so, how much of a life are these two going to have now?
At the end of the day, they're children stuck in adult bodies who've lost decades of their lives, and there doesn't appear to be any way to reverse the process. They really were dealt an awful hand here.
6. Peter Pan (Any Version)
The story of Peter Pan takes on new meanings as you get older. It stops being just an exciting adventure story and becomes something much more sobering as the full tragedy of Peter Pan's situation hits home. He's always going to be alone, unable to move on and get over his fear of growing up.
Well, he does manage to in 1990's Hook, but that's the sole exception. In every other version, the Darling Children are safely returned home to London, but Peter Pan is left back in Neverland. It's arguable that Wendy Darling is the real protagonist of this story, while Pan functions more as a cautionary tale of what happens when you cannot leave childhood behind. It's significant that the original source material is called Peter Pan & Wendy, rather than just Peter Pan. Also, Peter Pan is a massive jerk - that's another interesting thing you notice as you get older.
The most recent movie adaptation of Peter Pan was 2023's Peter Pan & Wendy, released on Disney+, and while that movie isn't particularly great on the whole, it does at least do more to acknowledge just what a sad figure Pan actually is, and it deserved kudos for that. This was in stark contrast to the 1953 Disney animation which, while a lovely film, didn't do much to explore the darkness of J.M. Barry's original novel and ends on a cheerful note.
5. Kingsman - The Secret Service
Kingsman: The Secret Service is a great movie, but its ending is one of those that gets worse and worse the more you think about it.
In this stylish spy comedy, main antagonist Richmond Valentine plans to activate a signal that will turn most of humanity (the exception being his allies, who have had safeguard chips installed) into violent savages and make them kill each other. This is his twisted solution to overpopulation and climate change.
Luckily, Valentine's signal is only active briefly, but so many people would've died even in that short space of time. Many will have even killed their own family members; the mother (Samantha Womack) of protagonist Eggsy (Taron Egerton) nearly kills her young daughter when affected by the signal, and only doesn't thanks to Eggsy warning her to lock her daughter in another room.
Additionally, all of Valentine's allies are killed when their chips are exploded. This appears to include leaders all over the world, so wouldn't the entire geopolitical system have been destabilized? The consequences of this are quite a lot to think about... which is probably why writer-director Matthew Vaughn and his team chose not to address the fallout in the movie's disappointing 2017 sequel, Kingsman: The Golden Circle.
4. Indiana Jones And The Dial Of Destiny
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull was a godawful movie, but at the very least, it gave Indiana Jones (Harrison Ford) a happy ending. He marries Marion Ravenwood (Karen Allen) and connects with the son (Shia LaBeouf) he didn't know he had. It would've been better to leave the story there, but alas, Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny cruelly undid this.
At the start of Dial of Destiny, Indy's son died in Vietnam, he and Marion are separated, and Indy is now a miserable alcoholic. He spends the majority of this adventure in a depressed stupor and playing second-fiddle to his goddaughter Helena Shaw (Phoebe Waller-Bridge), who's one of the most infuriating characters in recent memory.
During the film's finale - in which the characters travel back in time to Ancient Rome - Indy actually asks to be left behind in the past to die, and only returns to the present because Helena knocks him out and takes him back while unconscious. The closing scenes, in which Indy and Marion randomly reconcile, have a happy tone of sorts, and this felt grossly insulting.
Indy hasn't dealt with any of his issues and basically tried to kill himself, but this is completely glossed over, while Helena doesn't seem to have grown and is still a hateful piece of work. Hearing the Raiders March during the end credits provoked an inevitable rush of joyous nostalgia, and even that couldn't wash away the horrible aftertaste this ending left behind.
3. Let The Right One In/Let Me In
Let the Right One In is a horror masterpiece that tells the strange, captivating tale of a romance between Oskar and Eli (Kare Hedebrant and Lina Leandersson, respectively). He's a viciously bullied schoolboy, she's a vampire who looks like a 12-year-old girl. The counterparts in the surprisingly great American remake are played by Kodi Smit-McPhee and Chloe Grace Moretz.
Let the Right One In is one hell of a journey that goes to many weird places, and it consummately blends different moods. Its ending very much plays into that, as it looks like a happy ending at first, but it's more complicated than that.
In the end, Eli kills Oskar's bullies when they try to drown him, and they leave together with Oskar set to act as Eli's new caretaker, as her previous caretaker (Per Ragnar) died earlier in the film. Well, it's nice that this pair can be together and Oskar's life was saved, but at the end of the day, he's going to age while Eli remains a child. Also, looking after her will likely mean he has to become a serial killer in order to get blood for her; this was what her previous caretaker was doing.
Let Me In explores the tragic Caretaker character further and also cast the great Richard Jenkins as him, so this ending perhaps feels even more bittersweet in that version. Having said that, this is a complicated ending whichever version you see, and it's not the straightforward romantic finish you might initially think it is.
2. Kick-Ass 2
Kick-Ass 2 isn't as bad as you remember, but the ending was a shocker.
So, at the end of Kick-Ass 2, Kick-Ass/Dave (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) and Hit Girl/Mindy (Chloe Grace Moretz) have defeated lead antagonist the Motherf**ker (Christopher Mintz-Plasse), Dave's team Justice Forever are taking a break but doing heroics in their everyday life, Mindy leaves New York in order to protect her guardian, and Dave continues to be Kick-Ass, training with more advanced equipment.
This was presented as a happy ending. It was anything but.
Both Dave and Mindy totally failed to move forward in everyday life without their superhero personas, especially Mindy, and both are still stuck in dangerous lives without having grown as people. Furthermore, the two nicest characters in the series are done so dirty.
Mindy's guardian (Morris Chestnut) not only has to deal with his adoptive daughter abandoning him to live a dangerous life alone, but he might be sent to prison because she used his gun to kill people. Worse still, Dave's dad (Garrett M. Brown) is murdered, and not only does Dave refuse to give up being Kick-Ass as he'd promised his father, but he ends the film still being friends with the guy (Augustus Prew) who sold his father out to the Motherf**er and co.
Over ten years later, Kick-Ass 3 hasn't materialized, and while that's disappointing - the first movie is a masterpiece, after all - it's not exactly surprising. How on earth do you follow up an ending this godawful?
1. 2012
Roland Emmerich's not-that-bad 2012 is notable for being the most 'Disaster' disaster movie to ever disaster, given that it features what is probably the most epic apocalypse ever committed to film. It also has one of the least-happy 'happy endings' of them all.
The ending scenes do have a refreshingly hopeful tone that might fool viewers at first. Protagonist Jackson Curtis (John Cusack), his family, and several of the film's other characters have survived by getting onboard one of the various arks constructed by the world's governments in order to survive the cataclysm. The three arcs that were completed are shown travelling together, and around 400,000 people are onboard in total.
Well, it's a miracle anyone made it at all, but that's still the majority of humankind dead. Furthermore, the arks weren't done in a fair way, as transport was only offered to the world's elite and also to the Chinese workforce that helped to build them. Africa is the one continent that wasn't submerged, so it's possible some people survived there, but most of the human race is gone whichever way you cut it, and that's pretty bloody depressing.
Furthermore, the many disasters that happened throughout the picture will continue to affect the Earth for years to come, such as the ash clouds from the super-volcano that erupts in Yellowstone. Really, the happiest thing one can take away from this ending is that 2012 was lambasted for its factual inaccuracies, and a disaster of this kind is scientifically impossible.