10 Spectacularly Wrong Movie Reviews

What film is "a theme park ride masquerading as master's thesis"?

By Tom Baker /

As the saying goes, opinions are like bumholes. Everybody has one, most of them stink, and often you should keep them to yourself. Some of us, however, make exposing said bumhol-erm, opinions their career. So long as there has been art there have been people who have critiqued it, professionally. Some of the lucky devils even get paid for it. Said critics usually end up reaching some sort of a consensus about a piece of art, which is why we get, say, video games that are generally reviled or paintings that are held up as the pinnacle of human achievement. Most people will agree that something is really good, or utter tosh (or else consign it to be forgotten in the column of mediocrity).

Advertisement

But then there are the objectors, the contrarians, the reviewers who decide to break away from the herd. There are films that are part of the canon of classics, the indisputable top 10 (or 100, or 1000) sacred cows that nobody would even dream of slaughtering, because everybody knows they're perfect. Then there are the Ed Woods of the world, who make films that nobody will stand up to defend. They'll get laughed at. Imagine telling somebody that you thought that Adam Sandler was the best living actor, or Plan 9 From Outer Space is an overlooked masterpiece - you'd be a laughing stock. There are things that we've decided are infallibly great, and others undoubtedly !*$%.

Which is where the contrarians come in. The people who do stand up for the terrible films, or tear down the movies everybody else loves. They do it in video games, too, but there's something more galling about somebody singing the virtues of Eddie Murphy whilst taking pot shots at David Fincher. Another saying: everybody's entitled to their opinion. But we'll add the addendum: No matter how wrong they are. These are ten spectacularly wrong movie reviews.

Advertisement

10. Somebody Actually Liked Norbit

Norbit is not a good film. If anybody tells you otherwise, you should excommunicate them from your life. Even if they're related to you. Especially if they're related to you. Who knows what other dangerous actions they could commit to your person when suffering from such psychosis. Just when you thought Eddie Murphy had hit his career nadir (cardeer) with The Nutty Professor 2: The Klumps, but then he got even nadir...er with this 2007 excuse for a comedy. A comedy compared to other comedies in the same way that, say, a Big Mac found at the bottom of a rubbish tip is comparable to a three-course meal at the Ritz. Murphy plays a total of three characters in the film, including the shy title character, his massively overweight wife Rasputia Latimore, and his totally-not-racist Chinese foster father Mr Wong. Yep. It's that kind of film.

Advertisement

When it was released Norbit was rightfully pooped all over. Because that's what happens when you see something that looks like a toilet. It did somehow manage to swing an Academy Award nomination for best make-up, but really, you shouldn't be rewarded for making Eddie Murphy into a convincing fat woman, because that is not a good joke. It's not even a joke, really. The Rotten Tomatoes consensus rates the film at just 9%, based on 123 reviews - 11 of which were positive. One particularly effusive critic, Victoria Alexander, described it as "absolutely adorable...Murphy plays a big black woman who is not a victim of America's unrealistic ideal of beauty." So, er, we guess that's one positive thing about Norbit. Wonder why the review has mysteriously disappeared from her website...

9. Psycho Remake Better Than The Original

Gus Van Sant is as much an arty-farty type as a movie director. His best-known work is stuff like the Oscar-winning Good Will Hunting (it's not your fault etc), but he also helmed the pretentious likes of Gerry, where Matt Damon and Casey Affleck walk across a desert for an hour and a half talking, and then one of them strangles the other. It's a bit like 127 Hours without a happy ending. Or gratuitous violence. One of Van Sant's biggest "art" pieces was his remake of Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, which added literally nothing to the original. Which was absolutely intentional, as the director set out to perfectly replicate the film, frame-by-frame. The only differences are that it's in colour, and obviously the cast. Which includes Vince Vaughan as Patrick Bates, because we guess he's the modern-day equivalent of Anthony Perkins? You guys should see the sixties version of Dodgeball, it's a hot.

Advertisement

The general consensus is that the remade Psycho isn't very good. Or at least, it was totally unnecessary. Because it's exactly the same as the original. It'd make sense as an art installation for Van Sant to make in his own time, less so as a theatrically-released film. One enterprising critic, however, disagreed. In fact, Eugene Novikov's four-star review was quoted on the film's poster, as he noted his disinterest in Hitchcock's version before enthusing "to my absolute astonishment, I enjoyed the remake more." He admits that there isn't much difference between the two, except "because it€™s colorized it€™s about twice as effective, and twice as thrilling," and states that Perkins' "performance is in no way better than Vaughn€™s is here". Yeah, no, you're wrong. That's not how opinions work but, well, here it does.

8. And The Wicker Man, Too

Remakes, on the whole, tend to be a heck of a lot worse than the original. Psycho's actually an exception, since it's more just stunningly unimaginative and unnecessary; most modern redos of old films are simply naff, pale imitations of their source material that nobody should bother watching. That is 100% the case with noted playwright Neil LaBute's take on The Wicker Man, the cult classic British horror film from the seventies which traded more in a subtle, creeping sense of dread - along with a twist ending that everybody saw coming because of the poster - than on gore or shock value. Edward Woodward's repressed, virginial Catholic police man visiting a small Scottish island where a little girl had disappeared was swapped out for Nicolas Cage and bees. No, not the bees! They're in our eyes, and so on and so forth.

Advertisement

It made for a pretty good YouTube video, but not a good movie. Especially in comparison to he original, which was so restrained and disturbing, in favour of Nicolas Cage shouting a lot and some ham-handed political commentary on contemporary gender roles. Most reviewers agreed, making the new Wicker Man a pretty decisive critical failure - except in the eyes of Kyle Smith of the New York Post, who poo-pooed any controversy and labelled it a "profoundly disturbing, blood-chilling suspenser", thought that the feminist critique was pointed and smart (it's not), and claimed that LaBute had "matched" the original. It did not. It's is a load of rubbish.

7. Say Die To Goonies

Who doesn't like The Goonies? Nobody, that's who. Nobody who has a working heart or soul, at least. If you are devoid of those things, we guess you get a pass, and we hope that your journey into the underworld to retrieve these vital/metaphysical organs is successful. Not only will your life be back on track but, more importantly, you'll finally be able to extract the pure joy afforded by a viewing of The Goonies, the bonafide Richard Donner classic about a group of misfit kids who go looking for the mythical treasure of a long-dead pirate in order to stop their neighbourhood being flattened by a huge corporation. Also the pirate is called One-Eyed Willy, which is as hilarious to us now as it was when we first heard it.

Advertisement

It's a film with oodles of charm, thanks to a funny script - with a surprising amount of expletives - and the ensemble cast, including Corey Feldman before it all went wrong, and Sean Astin before it all went Gamgee. Plus Short Round from Indiana Jones And The Temple Of Doom, but he doesn't manage to ruin things as much here as he did then. It's a universally beloved film, which lives on as much in the hearts of critics as bored kids flicking through the channels on a rainy Sunday afternoon. Well, almost universally, as Jeffrey Westhoff was the one noted critic of the film, stating in his review for the Northwest Herald that "he find nothing entertaining about kids screaming for two hours." What a fuddy-duddy.

6. Factual Errors About Cabin In The Woods

It took a while to get released, having been finished off conclusively in 2009 but delayed from cinemas until 2012, but Joss Whedon and Drew Godard's fourth-wall-demolishing deconstruction of horror movies was well worth the wait. It was smart, funny, and made us collectively worry about mermen for the first time in our collective lives. The film was both a critical and financial success receiving positive reviews, as well it should - the script was clever, the performances were stellar, and never have we spent longer staring at a whiteboard. Like, not even at school. Which might explain a lot. A handful of audience members were disappointed that it wasn't quite the rote teen slasher flick they were expecting, but for the most part, people loved it. Rex Reed didn't, though.

Advertisement

Rex Reed is a terrible person. He's also a crummy film critic. Recently he's courted controversy for mentioning the weights of female movie stars in his reviews, because that's one of the most important aspects of film analysis, along with discussing the script or photography. He doesn't even have the decency to dress it up as, we don't know, a critique of the mise en scene. As he is a buffoon. Reed's review of Cabin In The Woods pegged it as so "stupid it makes trashy slash-and-burn epics like Humans Versus Zombies and I Spit on Your Grave seem like Molière and Proust", which are big words for a man who literally didn't understand the movie was a satire. Not only is his opinion wrong, but he also totally didn't get what the film was about. Or the ending. Or anything.

5. Everybody Hates On Fight Club

The film that made David Fincher, and the one that finally convinced people Brad Pitt was more than a pretty face, and the one which gave us yet another in our favourite sub-genre of modern cinema (Terrible Things Happening To Jared Leto; we're sure Netflix has come up with that one at some point). Fight Club is a relatively uncontested modern classic, a film which plays with genre, story and form conventions, with unreliable narrators, subliminal messages and the like. It far surpasses Chuck Palahniuk's novel, it has a kick-!*$% Pixies song over the end credits, it lets Helena Bonham Carter play a role other Tim Burton's stand in for his unrequited love for Johnny Depp. Everybody loves it now, right?

Advertisement

Well, yeah, but at the time of its release things were pretty different. In fact, when Fight Club came out in 1999, it was kind of a bomb. It made its money back and gained a following on DVD, but it earned sweet FA at the box office, owing partly to the bad reviews it received. Newsweek's David Ansen described it as puerile and pretentious, whilst no less an authority of films than Roger Ebert went in HAM on the film, characterising it as the "most frankly and cheerfully fascist big-star movie since Death Wish, a celebration of violence in which the heroes write themselves a license to drink, smoke, screw and beat one another up", and decried the appearances of talented actors like Pitt and Edward Norton. One of those opinions of the dear departed Ebert which nobody would agree with.

4. Same For Blue Velvet

Ebert and his cabal of critics are equal opportunity offenders, mind. They were similarly disenchanted with a similarly cult classic film, David Lynch's dark and perverse Blue Velvet. A surreal, nightmarish commentary on small-town American values and the darkness that lies beneath it (symbolised by the creeping insects that crawl beneath the white picket fences glimpsed at the film's start), the film follows the director's typical dream logic, with inexplicable plot twists and some troubling sexuality. By which we mean Dennis Hopper playing a gas-huffing mobster psychopath who blackmails Isabella Rossellini into have gross, kinky intercourse with her, where he pretends to be a baby. Yep. Pretty messed up.

Advertisement

Now, Blue Velvet has its rightful place at the top of modern American films, a strikingly unique and disturbing drama. Not so much on its 1986 release. Paul Attanasio of The Washington Post said that Lynch "isn't interested in communicating, he's interested in parading his personality. The movie doesn't progress or deepen, it just gets weirder, and to no good end." A major contingent was openly hostile towards the film as a whole, including Ebert, who would later admit he likes Lynch as a director but stands by his initial assessment that Blue Velvet has "a story that's marred by sophomoric satire and cheap shots", that the varying tone "is like the guy who drives you nuts by hinting at horrifying news and then saying, 'Never mind'", and that that was offensive towards Rossellini, who deserved "putting her in an important film."

3. Catwoman Is Actually The Best Superhero Movie

A recent, much-debated leaked memo from Warner Bros has revealed an interesting idea the studio have about the relative failure of their superhero films: there was too much humour in them. Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy of Batman movies, meanwhile, was stony-faced to a fault, and was the biggest success of any DC Comics adaptation so far. Especially compared to, say, Green Lantern, which had its tongue planted firmly in cheek and was a total box office bomb. Before all that, however, was the ill-fated Catwoman movie starring Halle Berry, Sharon Stone, and a campy attitude that had less in common with the sixties Caped Crusader TV series and more in common with, say, BBC One's Friday night hit Tumble. The one where Z-list celebrities put sparkly costumes on and do gymnastics poorly.

Advertisement

Not only was Catwoman as unsuccessful financially as Green Lantern, but it's also considered one of the worst films ever made by most reviewers and audiences alike. Which it is. It's undeniably dreadful. Unless you're Mick LaSalle, in which case you will deny that charge stringently and at length. In fact, not only did LaSalle deny that the film was rubbish, or stupid, revealing that "rather, it's an odd, idiosyncratic movie - dark in look and dark in spirit - that plays as a kind of pop culture investigation into the meaning of feminism and the options open to women in the modern world." Reminder that this is a film where Halle Berry gets murdered for discovering a murderous secret of a make-up producer, comes back to life and fights crime whilst wearing cat ears and a leather bra.

2. Schindler's List=A Theme Park

Who would criticise Schindler's List? It would be an even greater sacrilege than dumping on The Goonies. It's the one inarguably brilliant film that Steven Spielberg has made. We'd argue he's made a bunch but, well, there's plenty of people arguing otherwise. Schindler's List, meanwhile, is a rightfully sacred cow, an intensely personal yet sweepingly epic true story of the eponymous doctor (played by Liam Neeson), who managed to get hundreds of Jewish people out of the German concentration camps during World War II. It's a pretty grim film - as, duh, a film about the Holocaust would and should be - but ultimately a hopeful one, a story of human triumph over horrible, terrible adversity and, well, mass genocide. It's never trite, however, with Spielberg sticking to the facts rather than going full saccharine.

Advertisement

"A theme park ride masquerading as master's thesis" is how Luke Y Thompson of the New Times described it. Yeah. That's a pretty damning indictment and a snappy line, but does it actually mean anything? Non-committal shrug from us. Jeremy Heilman went even further, labeling Schindler's List "a misguided failure that aims to please where it should instead be challenging and confronting", disappointed that the film doesn't go for any more complex morality than "Nazis bad, everyone else good". In which case we don't think he should ever watch Inglourious Basterds. He's really missing out, mind.

1. Everything Armond White Writes

A self-described "pedigreed film scholar", the characterisation most give to Armond White is that the guy's a troll. Not the kind that lives under bridges and asks you questions three (although we've noticed his Wikipedia entry lacks a "personal life" section...), but the internet neologism used to signify a person who has awful, contrary opinions specifically to wind people up. To upset them. And we have plenty of evidence that White has such opinions, because the dude's been writing film reviews for decades, even acting as the lead critic and arts editors for a number of prestigious publications. All whilst extolling the virtues of Paul WS Anderson and being fiercely critical of acclaimed directors like Darren Aronofsky.

Advertisement

One time he actually heckled Steve McQueen. Y'know, the guy who won an Oscar for Twelve Years A Slave. White doesn't just blindly follow the opinions of his fellow critics, which we suppose is something to be commended. But also his dissenting opinions are usually terrible and wrong. And not consistent. He hated Toy Story 3 because he thought it was a crass celebration of consumerism, but bloody loves the Transformers films, which are based on and designed to sell toys? Eh? He also hated The Dark Knight Rises for similar reasons, and reviewed GI Joe positively in comparison to "such utter banality as Iron Man and Star Trek and Harry Potter's Half-Blooded Chintz".

He found Bridesmaids contrived, and called Adam Sandler's Grown Ups "cheerful and surprisingly heartfelt". I Now Pronounce You Chuck And Larry is preferable to the "laughable Brokeback Mountain". He even went so far as to suggest the Clash Of The Titans remake "shows a better sense of meaningful, economic narrative than the mess that Peter Jackson made of the interminable, incoherent Lord of the Rings trilogy". Armond White is a crazy person. And pretty much every movie review he's written has been spectacularly wrong.

Advertisement