10 Star Wars Scenes George Lucas Hated

Grumbling and dissatisfaction in a galaxy far, far away.

By Andrew Pollard /

It's now approaching ten years since George Lucas sold Lucasfilm to Disney for a staggering $4.05 billion, with that deal first announced on 30 October 2012.

Advertisement

In the time since that sale, there have been five Star Wars films released, plus two live-action TV shows, four new animated series, the return of The Clone Wars, and countless other ventures to a galaxy far, far away in various mediums. Added to that, there are also a slew of other Star Wars projects in development over at the House of Mouse.

For Lucas, he clearly has a whole lot of love for the Star Wars IP, with that first film back in 1977 skyrocketing the filmmaker to superstardom and helping to change the very face of cinema. It's not been entirely all sunshines and rainbows for George during his time crafting the Star Wars realm, mind, for there are certain moments and sequences that the California native has clearly not been happy with.

Whether it's mild disappointment or outright hatred, then, here are ten such Star Wars scenes that George Lucas absolutely was not satisfied with.

10. Killing Off Darth Maul - Episode I: The Phantom Menace

Did George Lucas regret killing off Darth Maul at the time? Not at all. In hindsight, the filmmaker clearly had some major regrets at the decision.

Advertisement

Of course, Maul was sliced in half by Obi-Wan Kenobi at the climax of The Phantom Menace. Despite being the greatest part of Episode I, this Sith was now off the chessboard as the franchise moved forward.

In the years since The Phantom Menace's 1999 release, Maul has famously risen from the dead, with him first resurfacing in The Clone Wars in 2008. And why was this Dathomirian Zabrak brought back from his apparent grave? That's because George Lucas realised what a great character he was and so wanted him back in the game.

As The Clone Wars co-creator Dave Filoni explained in the Star Wars Age of Republic: Villains book, Lucas told him that he wanted Darth Maul to be a part of this animated series. When Filoni asked how Maul survived the slice 'n' dice attack of Kenobi, George just told him to "figure it out". From there, Maul would make his return at the end of The Clone Wars' third season.

Going even further, Lucas wanted to position Darth Maul as the main villain of his planned movie sequel trilogy. That was before The Beard sold Lucasfilm to Disney, and thus plans clearly significantly changed by the time Episodes VII, VIII and IX hit the silver screen.

9. Yub Nub No More - Episode VI: Return Of The Jedi

For those whose first experience of Star Wars came with the original cuts of the Holy Trilogy, one of the most baffling changes later made by George Lucas was the removal of Return of the Jedi's Yub Nub song.

Advertisement

That tune played as the Ewoks and our heroes celebrated on Endor following the destruction of the second Death Star at Jedi's close. Sure, it was a little cheesy to hear this ditty while the Ewoks played drums with Stormtrooper helmets, but it was full of the charm that had Return of the Jedi appealing to so many.

To George Lucas, this was a scene that he wasn't happy with by the time he came to tweak those initial three Star Wars pictures in 1997.

Deciding that this scene didn't give the sense of galaxy-wide grandeur that Lucas now wanted, he replaced Yub Nub with a victory score composed by the legendary John Williams. It wasn't just the song that changed, though, for the entire final minute or two of Return of the Jedi changed. As this new song played out, the action took in celebrations on planets such as Coruscant, Naboo, Tatooine and Bespin.

As some have pointed out, this change made zero sense. The original Yub Nub celebration was one moment of victory in the larger battle of stopping the Empire. Death Star II had fallen, but the Empire still existed and still had plenty of numbers. So, to see the entire galaxy celebrating at the end of '97's Special Edition of Episode VI doesn't really work.

8. Who Shot First - Episode IV: A New Hope

While he may not have quite as much stock as Boba Fett when it comes to cult characters of the first set of Star Wars pictures, Greedo most certainly has his fair share of fans.

Advertisement

This Rodian was only on our screens for a matter of minutes in the opening act of A New Hope, but Greedo clearly made quite an impression as he butted heads with Han Solo in Mos Eisley. And by butting heads, that means taking a shot at Han. Or did Han shoot first? Or was it really Greedo getting off that very shot?

That is one of the great questions of the entire Star Wars franchise, and it's a topic that has often split the series' fanbase in some extremely, well, passionate ways across the decades.

For George Lucas, he clearly wasn't happy with the scene that ended up costing Greedo his life. In the 1977 theatrical cut of the movie, it's Han who shoots and kills Greedo after the bounty hunter talks up how much he's looking forward to killing Solo. By the time of the 1997 Special Editions, Lucas had changed this so that Greedo takes the first shot, Han avoids it and swiftly, fatally fires back.

Once the 2004 DVD release of the Holy Trilogy came along, George had again changed things so that the pair shoot their blasters at nearly the exact same moment.

7. Luke Finally Sees His Father - Episode VI: Return Of The Jedi

The finale of Return of the Jedi famously saw Darth Vader step in and put a halt to The Emperor's assault on Luke Skywalker, with Vader throwing his master to his apparent doom. In the aftermath of this, the wounded, dying Vader asks Luke to remove his helmet so that he can look upon his son with his own eyes.

Advertisement

Here, franchise fans got their first glimpse of the real Anakin Skywalker, the man behind the mask and machine-addled outfit.

Why did George Lucas have an issue with this scene? Well, that was down to the eyebrows of original Anakin actor Sebastian Shaw.

By the time Lucas came to release the DVD versions of the Holy Trilogy in 2004, the filmmaker was eager to tidy up Shaw's eyebrows. Thus, the bushy, prominent eyebrows seen in the initial 1983 release of Return of the Jedi were nowhere to be seen. In fact, this version of Jedi left Ani with absolutely no eyebrows whatsoever.

In fairness, this would actually make a whole lot of sense once audiences got to see Episode III: Revenge of the Sith in 2005, for the drastic burns to Skywalker's body would've made it impossible for his 'brows to have grown back after he was decimated on Mustafar.

6. The Force Ghosts - Episode VI: Return Of The Jedi

Not content with removing the eyebrows of Sebastian Shaw's Anakin Skywalker at the end of Return of the Jedi, George Lucas ultimately ended up removing Shaw entirely from one of the film's key shots.

Advertisement

Said shot was the Force Ghost of Anakin joining the spirits of Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda, taking up his rightful place alongside his fellow Jedi Masters after righting his previous wrongs. Here, the original version of Episode VI had Shaw alongside Sir Alec Guinness and the Frank Oz-controlled Yoda.

This scene actually managed to remain intact throughout Lucas' 1997 Special Editions, but it was the 2004 DVD release of the Holy Trilogy that saw George decide he was no longer happy with this scene. Thus, Sebastian Shaw was out, and Hayden Christensen was in.

That replacement was literally just Christensen's head replacing Shaw's in the Force Ghosts shot. To justify this change, Lucas cited how he now felt that the Anakin seen in this moment should be representative of the last time Anakin was truly good - as in before he embraced the Dark Side.

One clear and obvious counterpoint to this, mind, is surely the last time Anakin was truly good, was in the final moments of his life where he saved Luke and banished the Emperor? In that case, that'd mean his ghostly visage should indeed be that of Sebastian Shaw, no?

5. The First Appearance Of Jabba - Episode IV: A New Hope

Much like some of the other scenes featured on this list, the first appearance of Jabba the Hutt is one that George Lucas was forever frustrated with. Well, until he was finally able to edit the scene accordingly decades later.

Advertisement

Played by Declan Mulholland, this first appearance of Jabba was filmed for A New Hope and had the character initially as a fur coat-wearing human. Lucas intended to replace Mulholland with a stop-motion character in post-production, but budget issues meant this wasn't possible. Unhappy with what he was left with, George cut the scene entirely.

With budget not being an issue by the time of the 1997 Special Editions of the Holy Trilogy, Lucas reinserted this scene and replaced Mulholland with a CGI Jabba the Hutt in the visage that we'd come to know and detest the sluggish creature.

This do-over itself was replaced in 2004, with a far superior quality CGI model of Jabba inserted for the DVD release of the original three Star Wars films. Even then, Lucas noted on the commentary track for the '04 version of A New Hope how he'd still debated cutting the scene out of the movie again.

4. The Phantom Menace's Finale - Episode I: The Phantom Menace

Taking shots at The Phantom Menace is pretty low-hanging fruit these days, with many quick to forever lambast the clear flaws in that movie and the impact it had on 'ruining their childhoods'.

Advertisement

While there are a handful of bright spots in Episode I, George Lucas himself clearly had some issues with the final moments of the picture. As shown in the excellent The Beginning: Making Star Wars Episode I documentary, a first watch of the initial cut of The Phantom Menace had Lucas questioning whether or not he'd done too much too quickly in the moments after the death of Qui-Gon Jinn.

As pointed out by editor Ben Burtt at the time, Episode I shifts way too frantically from mourning the loss of a hero, to a big escape sequence, to comedy with Jar Jar Binks, to the return of young Anakin Skywalker. It's absolutely fascinating to watch this documentary footage of George Lucas almost wincing his way through this sequence, realising that he may have done f**ked up the grand return of cinema's greatest franchise.

How much of The Phantom Menace's finale was ultimately changed after this, we'll never know for sure. Either way, it was clear that George Lucas wasn't at all happy with what he'd initially put together for the film's final few minutes.

3. The Whole Of The Force Awakens - Episode VII: The Force Awakens

Not a scene and not one of his Star Wars movies, but George Lucas was not impressed at all by J.J. Abrams' Episode VII: The Force Awakens.

Advertisement

As detailed by former Disney CEO Bob Iger in his The Ride of a Lifetime book, Lucas didn't even attempt to hide his disappointment after Kathleen Kennedy screened The Force Awakens for him ahead of the film's 2015 release. Of course, this was the first Star Wars picture to be released following the House of Mouse's purchase of Lucasfilm three years prior. As such, Lucasfilm President Kennedy wanted to get George's thoughts on this new venture to a galaxy far, far away.

Unhappy at what he had just watched, Lucas bluntly told Kennedy how "there's nothing new" in Episode VII, lambasting it for being a carbon copy of his original 1977 Star Wars movie, and explaining how he always viewed each new film as a way to introduce new worlds, new key characters, and bring something fresh to the table.

Not just that, but George slammed The Force Awakens for not having enough "visual or technical leaps forward" in what the finished product brought to the screen.

2. Stopping The Star Destroyer - The Force Unleashed

Not a scene from any of the Star Wars movies, but this entry instead revolves around a scene in 2008's incredibly fun The Force Unleashed video game.

Advertisement

George Lucas had given his okay for the story of this game - players taking control of Darth Vader's apprentice as he ponders the morality of his role and responsibilities - yet he wasn't exactly enthused with the end result. While gamers ate up the intricate storytelling, the use of familiar faces, and the ability to do all kinds of crazy sh*t with the Force, George was not so impressed.

In particular, the one moment that really irked The Beard was the sequence where Galen Marek, aka Starkiller, uses his Force powers to bring down a giant Star Destroyer. As a video game scene, it was pretty darn badass to witness one person wield so much sheer power. Lucas, though, did not agree.

To George, this was seen as way too over-the-top, even for a game in which he encouraged the creators to do what they saw fit. After all, the legendary filmmaker has never been shy about commenting on how he sees everything other than his movies and The Clone Wars as being its own separate world and canon. As Lucasfilm's Pablo Hidalgo has detailed in since deleted tweets, Lucas himself wasn't as directly involved in The Force Unleashed as some fans originally thought, and the Star Destroyer scene in particular wasn't to George's liking.

1. The Kissing Siblings - Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back

This is partly educated guesswork here, but one has to think that George Lucas really isn't keen on the scene where Luke and Leia share a kiss in The Empire Strikes Back.

Advertisement

Of course, Return of the Jedi would reveal that Luke and Leia were actually siblings. Not just siblings, mind, for the two would be twins. Neither character was aware of this at the time of Empire's smooch, and likewise neither was Lucas.

As detailed in Laurent Bouzereau's Star Wars: The Annotated Screenplays, the original plan was oh so very different where these Skywalker siblings were concerned. Originally, Lucas had zero plans to have Luke and Leia be brother and sister, and instead the pair were intended to be two parts of a love triangle involving Han Solo.

When Yoda spouts "there is another" in The Empire Strikes Back, that was in reference to Luke's sister, but this sister was not Leia and was a character who Lucas intended to introduce in his planned sequel trilogy. It was only when he got to Return of the Jedi that George decided to combine Leia and this mystery sister.

In hindsight, surely George Lucas must look back on Empire's big kiss scene and slap his head in regret? After all, incest is never cool, kids. Not even in a galaxy far, far away.

Advertisement