Although Marvel currently rules the superhero cinema landscape with their stable of superheroes, DC keeps pumping out animated feature films based on popular graphic novels or storylines from the comics. Most, such as Batman: Under The Red Hood or Superman vs. The Elite, have been fairly loose adaptations of the source material while some others have been direct or close to direct adaptations, the most notable probably being Batman: Year One. With next year's slate of animated features already set, being Justice League: War, Son of Batman and Batman: Arkham Assualt, perhaps it is time to start speculating on what 2015's features will bring. Considering 2015 is the highly anticipated Batman/Superman film, no doubt DC will once again piggyback off that film to promote one or more of their new animated features. WhatCulture writer James Garcia wrote an article a few weeks ago titled 10 Batman Stories That Should Be Adapted Into Animated Films. He named some very good Batman stories that would make great animated features and inspired me to write my own piece regarding Superman, having wide range of stories to choose from that would make great animated features. In fact, many of these stories would make great full-length features themselves, but this piece will focus strictly on adapting these stories into animation. Without further ado, here are my 10 picks for what Superman stories should be adapted into an animated feature.
10. For The Man Who Has Everything
Batman, Robin and Wonder Woman take a trip to the Fortress of Solitude to celebrate Superman's birthday, but Batman finds it awkward because, as he says, "what do you get for the man who has everything?" The story goes on to show that as much as Superman has, he had to lose everything in order to get it. The alien tyrant Mongul has broken into the Fortress and placed the Black Mercy plant on Superman, trapping him in a deep hallucination of his innermost desires, revealed to be a life on a Krypton that did not face the apocalypse, even having a wife and young son. This is a great short story which examines everything Superman wants most. Like an adopted child, they may have loving parents and a great life, but there usually always is that lingering thought in their head of what could have been had their parents not given them up. It is quite a heartbreaking scene where Superman realizes everything is a hallucination and, teary eyed, tells his young son he has to let him go because he's not real. This story is also notable for having one of the few moments Superman gets really, really pissed and cuts loose on Mongul. Though the story is excellent, it is on the bottom of the list because it was adapted in the first season of Justice League Unlimited. Very few changes were made for the episode (Robin's exclusion was the most notable) and it retained the emotional beats of the story. Lengthening the story from a 22 minute episode into a 75 minute length feature may also prove to be a difficult task.
9. Last Son
Written by Geoff Johns with help by Richard Donner, a Kryptonian pod carrying a young child comes to Earth. Believing him to be another refugee from Krypton, Superman and Lois Lane take him in, adopting him as their son. Unknown to them though, he's the link between Earth and the Phantom Zone. Last Son reimagines, once again, the history between General Zod and the house of El as Zod and many other Phantom Zone convicts escape and wreak havoc on Earth. In order to defeat Zod, Superman must ally himself with several members of his rogues gallery, chief among them Lex Luthor. Last Son is an interesting story as it places Clark Kent and Lois Lane in the place of Jonathon and Martha Kent. Superman uses everything he was taught by his parents to help this child, Christopher Kent, adjust to a radical new world. The depictions of the villains, particularly of Zod and Luthor, are very well done as both are presented as more than maniacally laughing, moustache twirling villains, but as people with their own justifiable reasons. It also helps Richard Donner, the director of Superman and Superman II, was able to help craft the story. The only problem with adapting Last Son is using Zod as the main antagonist in a plot to rule over Earth as New Krypton, a plot with similarities to this summer's Man of Steel. Though it has huge differences with the inclusion of Chris Kent, Luthor and others, Last Son may be a bit redundant in the wake of Superman's latest big screen adventure.
8. For Tomorrow
Written by Brian Azzerallo, For Tomorrow is a bit of a hit-or-miss for some Superman fans because Azzerallo embraces a grittier take on the character. Nothing as dark as Batman, but mostly dark and gritty because of the story. A million people have simply vanished around the world, including Lois Lane, which makes Superman feel powerless because he didn't see it coming and can't seem to find who was responsible. It also asks the question of how far Superman will go to protect the world for tomorrow. Throughout For Tomorrow Superman befriends a priest to discuss his guilt and helplessness, having theological discussions on religion and the meaning of God. They are interesting discussions and one of the highlights of this story. After all, what does God mean for the people in the DC Universe when there is a 'god' flying around in a red cape? Can Superman really justify stepping in and changing the destiny of a planet, as a god might? Its subject matter may be too heavy for an animated feature, but most of these films aren't necessarily geared towards children.
7. Emperor Joker
This entry is probably going to raise a few eyebrows because of how out of place it will seem, but I actually think it would be a perfect fit for these DC Universe Original Animated Movies. Perhaps one of Jeph Loeb's lesser known storylines, Emperor Joker sees the Clown Prince gain Mxyzptlk's powers after the imp unwisely gives him a portion of it to cause Superman some trouble. Joker, instead, manages to steal all of Mxyzptlk's power and changes the world in his image. He turns the heroes into poor caricatures of themselves, makes Lois Lane his queen, Luthor his jester and every night kills Batman only to resurrect him the next day and kill him again in a new gruesome fashion. It's up to Superman to help the heroes remember who they were and put the world back to the way it was. It is rare you see Superman go up against one of Batman's rogues outside of a Batman/Superman title, but if there is one villain who could handle their own against Superman, its Joker. That may seem silly to say, but watch how Joker nearly kills Superman in the first Batman/Superman crossover of the DC Animated Universe, 'World's Finest', and you'll know what I mean. The fact he has a wide array of powers at his disposal makes this fight fun and unpredictable. One of the best aspects of this story though is how it examines the Batman/Joker relationship through Superman's eyes, ultimately using a well known truth of said relationship to save the day. Emperor Joker is a little weird and out there, but would make for a fun and entertaining film.
6. For All Seasons
Written by Jeph Loeb and drawn by Tim Sale, Superman: For All Seasons tells four stories which chronicle Superman's early days in Smallville and Metropolis, examining who he is mostly through the eyes of those closest to him. It explores why his character and not his powers are what should be remembered most. This book did so well it inspired the Smallville television series to be made, also created and produced by Jeph Loeb for most of its run. Each chapter is very well written, but the standout chapter for me is the very first one, from Jonathon Kent's point of view. Jonathon is a very underrated character and the relationship between him and his son is one of the best things in the Superman mythology. I'm always upset whenever a new take on Superman, like Man of Steel or The New 52 for instance, decides to kill him while Clark is still a teenager or young adult because there is a lot to be mined from that relationship when he becomes the famous superhero. For All Seasons is a very heart-warming tale which shows how Superman lives up to the Kent name and his affect on other people.
5. Red Son
What if Superman never landed in Kansas and was found by the Kent's? What if he never landed in America at all? What if, instead, he landed in Russia during the height of Cold War and become a hero of the Motherland? That is the intriguing premise behind Mark Millar's Superman: Red Son. What is so interesting about this world though is many of the characters are still the same; Superman still believes in doing the right thing, but only takes a more hands on approach to changing the world, Lex is still relatively evil, but believes he's the hero and Lois is the anchor for truth and integrity as always. Several other DC heroes have small roles or cameos, but one of the most fun aspects of Red Son is the tweaked history of the world. Aside from Superman succeeding Stalin and leading Russia into rich and prosperous times, Richard Nixon was assassinated while JFK lived a much longer life. It's very enjoyable to see how much history changed because of a course correction of one alien refugee. The changed dynamic between the characters is interesting as well, especially as you almost root for Lex Luthor to win. His checkmate move against Superman is also brilliant in its near simplicity while saying much about why our Superman wouldn't attempt to take over the world the way Soviet Superman does. It is a very well crafted alternate reality tale which, unlike Flashpoint, doesn't hinge on the actual DC continuity, giving Red Son a huge plus.
4. Birthright
This spot was a toss-up between this title and Superman: Secret Origin. Both are reimaginings of Superman's origin in the modern day world and the introduction of several of the supporting characters. The difference between the two is Birthright was meant as a one-off tale whereas Secret Origin, written by Geoff Johns, was meant to be the new origin in DC's continuity, much in the same way his Green Lantern: Secret Origin became the established continuity for Hal Jordan. What is strange about that though is Superman: Secret Origin was written about a year or less before The New 52 started, completely making it null and void. Why I chose Mark Waid's Birthright over Secret Origin and even Grant Morrison's opening arc of The New 52 is because Birthright introduced several new ideas and concepts into the mythology, going so far as to influence this summer's Man of Steel. Introducing the S-shield as the Kryptonian symbol of hope, Clark's journeys before becoming Superman and Lois investigating him before his reveal to the world are only small things taken from this story. Birthright also goes very in-depth into the creation of Clark's bumbling reporter persona and into Lex Luthor's psyche, adding new layers to both characters. The realization that these enemies are both alone in their own way on Earth is a stunning one, but, as Superman rightly points out, it's the choices they each made rather the circumstances which led them to where they are.
3. Luthor
The old adage 'a hero is only as good as his villain' is well apt for Lex Luthor. He's one of the smartest men on Earth and believes the human spirit can accomplish anything. No goal cannot be accomplished when the mind is put to it is his philosophy. So why then is Luthor an enemy of Superman if he essentially holds the same beliefs? Brian Azzarello spends nearly 150 pages in Luthor (originally called Lex Luthor: Man of Steel) examining the Man of Steel's arch nemesis. Lex is a man who fully believes he's the good guy while acknowledging the evil within him, believing everything he does is for the greater good. To him, Superman is an alien waiting to take over while stripping away mankind's independence. What can you do if you have an alien who can and is willing to do anything after all? Lex believes people will stop looking up to the sky to imagine what is possible in place of a saviour instead and desperately wants to change that. The complexity Azzarello gives him is excellent and the fact you can sympathise with and understand Luthor to an extent is a testament to how in depth he goes into the mind of Superman's main villain. The sad irony though is if he spent even half his fortune and intellect actually saving the world rather than combating Superman, he might do more good than his rival.
2. Kingdom Come
Kingdom come was one of the most groundbreaking graphic novels of the 90s and, along with novels such as Watchmen and The Dark Knight Returns, gave further credibility to the graphic novel and comic book genre as legitimate pieces of literature which could tell serious stories. Kingdom Come wove together DC mythology and religious theology to tell a compelling story about humanity, courage and, above all, faith. Though Norman McKay is the central character of Kingdom Come, Mark Waid knew there would be a heavy focus on Superman's character once he drafted the storyline. Superman goes through quite an arc during Kingdom Come; disillusioned by Earth's want for a tougher breed of hero, he's rejected his Clark Kent identity and has withdrawn himself from the world for a decade. Urged to come back and stop the new generation of reckless superheroes rampaging across the globe, he has to rediscover his own humanity and place his faith back in the people he's sworn to protect. Kingdom Come is, however, a long graphic novel and it would be impossible tell it all in 75 minutes. Should DC ever decide to adapt this famous story into an animated feature I see them splitting it into two parts, much like they did with The Dark Knight Returns. What might be cut out of the film, however, is the religious aspects involving The Spectre and Norman McKay, as that may be too deep for the main children demographic, a similar problem I mentioned with For Tomorrow. That being said, however, these DC Original Animated Movies are meant for an older audience both in tone and violence, indicated by both The Dark Knight Returns and Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox. If any story should get a two part animated treatment, it should be Kingdom Come.
1. Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow?
Billed as the last Superman story before the Crisis of Infinite Earths event which launched a cross-wide reboot for DC (why does that sound familiar?), Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? was written by Alan Moore and explored the last days of Superman, utilizing many of the villains from his rogues gallery. One by one many of them act out in deadlier ways than before, killing civilians and putting the lives of Superman's loved ones at risk as he tries to figure out who is manipulating them all. A lot of Superman fans compare Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? to The Dark Knight Returns in that both stories revitalized a decades old character by doing something new to them. This story is constantly being named one of the best Superman stories written not only because of its place in the mythology, but because of the way it depicts Superman's inspiration in others and also examines the doubts he has during the story. There are also a number of significant deaths involving long-standing characters, creating an emotional investment into them as anyone can be killed. Alan Moore crafted a Superman story that honoured the long history of the character, giving a complete ending to the Silver Age interpretation of Superman. If any Superman story is deserving of an animated treatment, it is surely this one.