10 Terrible Films That Tricked Us With Awesome Posters

By Sydney Zink /

Face it, we've all judged a movie by its poster. Perhaps even before seeing its trailer, you may pass by an upcoming film's poster while exiting a movie theater or reading buzz in your Twitter feed. It gets your hopes up with a promising tagline or visual evocation of genre conventions. And the effect is no accident - the industry spends big bucks on this sort of advertising knowing full-well that a good poster can trick audiences into screens. For the following ten films, audiences are left wishing such memorable, admirable creativity evident in their posters would have been at least somewhat present in the equally paper-thin movies themselves. These films go to show that movies don€™t simply get better over the years (with titles from recent years to decades ago making the list), nor simply from having a higher budget. Sometimes, bad films are just a pretty promotional display that should have never turned into multiple frames.

10. Showgirls (1995)

Advertisement
Showgirls' provocative poster, like its titular subject, should have viewers aching to see beyond its teasers. However, considering the film€™s 14% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and seven nominations for 1995 Golden Raspberry awards, viewers hardly have their dollar bills out to throw at this movie. The final movie is a disappointment, but it keeps cult viewers coming back nonetheless. Its supporters have commended the movie as admirably daring, and its poster certainly speaks to that quality. The screenplay quality is as skimpy as the poster€™s showgirl, the onscreen romance as blank and flat as the black poster background. Though the poster is a creative use of space and an enticing attention-grabber, Showgirls€™ curtains are better left closed.

9. Volcano (1997)

The movie poster for Volcano could only be as strongly red as it is out of flushed embarrassment over how comically preposterous the film is. Admittedly, the poster, while visually great, flunks with the movie itself via some of its laughable taglines: €œthe coast is toast€ and €œit€™s hotter than hell.€ Sadly, the movie is far from €œhot€; when labeling it a disaster flick, disaster is right. This movie is a disaster in matters of discontinuity, absurd impracticalities, horrible characters, and a whole eruption of other issues. The poster creates a serious-looking scene of intense chaos by using a mid-eruption depiction of the volcano that serves justice to the action and thrill of the genre. Of course, to appreciate the poster, one must still look past the fact that there is somehow a hugely unlikely volcano pictured smack-dab in downtown Los Angeles. Despite the artistic poster contrast of red hues against black, the last thing this film will ever be called beyond its self proclaimed €œhotter than hell€ is €œred-hot.€

Advertisement

8 . I Know Who Killed Me (2007)

Advertisement
The poster for I Know Who Killed Me is beautiful, but upon recognizing the face as Lindsay Lohan in a post-2005 film, viewers will understand this film was toast from the get-go. However, for once, Lindsay Lohan is perhaps amongst the least of the film€™s problems. However, seeing two of Lohan really doesn€™t help. Yes, Lindsay has returned as twins, which is worth a shudder considering how lovely her previous performance as twins in The Parent Trap was in contrast to this new cinematic embarrassment (in a string of many for her). The poster for this movie is beautiful art depicting Lindsay€™s facial silhouette as the petals of a blue rose, but the film itself not only fails to bloom €“ it wilts.

7. The Happening (2008)

Advertisement
The poster promises apocalyptic suspense and visual style; the film awkwardly delivers Mark Wahlberg talking to a plant. Whether or not Wahlberg€™s character survives the movie's predicaments, the actor€™s one-sided conversation is just one more happening he (and we) won't ever want to relive. The poster, again, speaks for the movie, though to opposite effect: nothing is there, and that makes both the poster and movie discomforting. However, only the poster strategically pulls off such discomfort to its benefit; to the movie, such discomfort is not from the kind of fear the story would wish to illicit. Perhaps we viewers should have followed the car drivers€™ lead in the poster and abandoned the movie had we, too, seen the disaster ahead. Of course, those car drivers felt compelled to exit due to the unexpected, horrible troubles of a trance-like experience, but does this action not translate as well to theatergoers of this film?

6. Superman Returns (2006)

Advertisement
This film did not exactly face Superman-like expectations of astronomical feats and superhuman strengths of narrative or style, but viewers would expect at least a Clark Kent level of average quality. However, the ironically titled Superman Returns hardly puts out much return at all (for what was put into it), especially considering the famous franchise it follows. The poster is vibrant and classic with an image of high-flying ambition. It speaks the hope that superheroes and their movies promise us average folk. However, the poster image for Superman Returns reflects the outcome of the film itself in a quite different way after all: this superhero project clearly flew right over its filmmakers' heads.

5. Lady in the Water (2006)

Advertisement
€œFantasy€ is too flattering a word to describe Lady in the Water, despite its genre label. The most blatant relevant fantasy is the belief that this movie would ever serve its promotional art justice, not to mention Shyamalan€™s blinding ego that wrongfully drove this film. The poster is overwhelming and coldly blue, plus saturated with tangles and harsh eyes€™ gaze; so, too, describes the movie€™s colossal letdown. The difference is how pleasingly intricate, engrossing, and busy the images appear in the poster in stark contrast to how offensively passive the actual movie and its developers come off as in treating viewers. The poster for Lady in the Water is prettily abstract and artsy to the point of inspiring a poem, but don't consider it fan material: The screenplay is read. Its poster is blue -- but the movie's so bad that its viewers are, too.

4. 2012 (2009)

Advertisement
Nothing calms the distressed viewer like a good laugh. On December 21 of this year when people worldwide waited to see if the supposed Mayan prediction of the end of the world came true on its set day, many friends of mine watched the film 2012 in the day€™s honor. The humor certainly settled some hesitant, superstitious people; too bad the movie wasn€™t meant to be funny. The horrendously constructed characters, bad dialogue, unconvincing developments, and so forth sent this movie hurtling into mayhem, but not the kind desired of the action sci-fi plot. Believability and retention of attention crumble away at an earthquake€™s strength like that crumbling the city in the movie poster. The poster is intriguing in how hopeless, wasted, and insignificant it makes individual victims in those high-rises out to be in the face of catastrophe, but the movie unappealingly matches those same dismal descriptions. 2012's poster evokes thrill and fear regarding a predicted worldwide disaster, but even viewers couldn't predict the real disaster to face them in the movie: its dialogue, which, like the poster city, sinks quickly.

3. Poseidon (2006)

Advertisement
The movie is about a wreck. Eliminate "about" in that last sentence and the statement will be just as accurate. The poster is a beautiful one of a capsized ship, but as the quality of this terrible film goes to show, it's hard to recover potential treasures once they've already sunken. The one thing that the movie and poster share in terms of praises is stunning visuals. The poster is eerie but elegant with creatively integrated title text, and the movie has some costly but admirable CGI that earned it an Academy Award nomination for visual effects. The characters and cast, however, were odd at best. For one, the film should have done away with casting Fergie in a cameo, giving €œcastaway€ a whole new meaning. Beyond that remedy, Poseidon still has so many weak spots that even its CGI cannot patch it up enough to save it from drowning.

2. Heaven's Gate (1980)

Advertisement
The multiple posters advertising Heaven's Gate commendably adhere to the epic western genre of the film. The posters are classic expressions of American patriotism, old-timey trimmings, and quintessential Western quirks. From aged-looking texture to Eastwood-looking depictions of male characters, ever poster appears a detail-focused, well-worked charm of western movies and style. However, with posters€™ theme of patriotism comes that of pride, and director Michael Cimino unfortunately seems to have sported more of it towards Heaven€™s Gate than the project was worth. The film is not nearly as epic as its classification would have it. For a western, surprisingly little justice is won -- that is, from this film towards the western genre itself.

1. Max Payne (2008)

Advertisement
The poster for Max Payne draws upon the style, and likewise, all the positive reactions to Banksy's kind of street art: rebellious, cool, creative, independent, and uncompromising. However, comparing Max Payne's stellar video game to its following let-down film is like comparing such street art to poor crayon replications. Inspiringly bold material led only to a drab, practically insulting knockoff. I would almost rather idly watch a friend play the videogame for hours on end than have to face its film again. The poster is modern, appealing to teenage demographics, and brilliantly direct due to its superb artistic simplicity. Max Payne, given the hype that both its high-quality poster and its video game fame would warrant, was prime for success. It elaborately failed to its own notable degree of disappointment amongst other films that have made this list.

Did we miss any great posters for films that turned out to be terrible? Share your own picks below.