In 2007, Warner Bros. began production on a Justice League movie. This would have preempted the forthcoming announcement of Marvel's Avengers team-up. Fan reaction was loudly against it, especially considering that - at the time - Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy wasn't even halfway completed, and the idea of a competing Batman character (played by a then-unknown Armie Hammer) seemed disrespectful and boneheaded. The rest of the cast, including G.I. Joe Retaliation's D.J. Cotrona as Superman, inspired similar derision. When the movie collapsed due to a loss of tax breaks just as it was about to start filming in Australia, many breathed a sigh of relief. But the script recently leaked online, and it turns out to be far better than expected. While it probably wouldn't have been as good as Joss Whedon's Avengers, it's a lot better than early reactions claimed. The film, titled Justice League: Mortal, featured an already established Justice League clashing with Maxwell Lord and an army of cyborgs called O.M.A.C.s. So what can Warner Bros. learn from its aborted project? Well, let's delve right in and take a look, shall we? Please note: this post contains spoilers. If you haven't read the screenplay for Justice League: Mortal yet, I advise you do so before reading on...
10. Don't Cast Young Unknowns
The casting of unknown actors in their early to mid-twenties makes even less sense now than it did in 2007. These aren't new, inexperienced superheroes à la the Justice League of the New 52. These are seasoned champions that have already ushered in a time of "world peace." So a bunch of actors under 25 playing veterans would have been ridiculous, right? Even if the story had the heroes as rookies, a lot of the casting still seems shockingly bad. D.J. Cotrona, who showed absolutely no charisma or presence in G.I. Joe, would have made a terrible Superman. Likewise, the Australian model Meghan Gale was a poor choice for Wonder Woman. Her only role since the failure of Justice League: Mortal was in a minor Australian rom-com, suggesting that she didn't have the acting to chops to pull off one of the most iconic superheroes around. As an ensemble, the rumoured cast would have ruined what looked to be a really promising script. The actual Justice League movie needs actors that are already on their way to stardom. Think Henry Cavill or Christian Bale. Both had already proven themselves in smaller stuff before they took on their iconic roles.
9. The Flash Can Carry A Movie
The Flash is the heart of the movie and Barry Allen a very compelling character throughout. He's the newcomer to the League, and the audience encounters the other characters through his eyes for the first time. It's great decision that works really well. Though he was as written a bit annoying at times (and would've been even more so played by Adam Brody), a script rewrite could have taken care of that problem. Up until now, DC superhero movies have been totally reliant on Batman and Superman. They haven't been able to take advantage of their many other classic characters. The Flash is a great candidate for a new breakout superhero, and Justice League: Mortal shows how this can be done successfully, since a lot of time is spent developing his character. He's the only character whose supporting cast we see, including his wife Iris Allen and a young Wally West. This adds a lot more depth to the character, especially during those scenes with his wife. At the end of the script, when he sacrifices himself to save the world, it's a great moment that could have been one of the most emotional moments in a superhero movie ever filmed. And because of the aforementioned presence of Wally West, he has a natural successor for the sequel. If Warner Bros. is going to use a "new" character to focus on in a Justice League movie, the Flash is a great choice.
8. Superman & Batman Don't Need To Be Big Parts Of A Justice League Movie
While Batman drives the film's plot and gets a lot of solo screen time, his presence isn't too heavy in Mortal. He spends most of his time getting beaten up, and is constantly derided by the rest of the League for his mistakes. Batman is a strong enough character, though, that - given his various solo incarnations - his treatment in doesn't script doesn't diminish him. Superman, on the other hand, doesn't get much screen time at all, and there is little characterization for him. And that's fine. Like Batman, Superman is an extremely well-known character already. Both have already had more than their fair share of film outings already. A Justice League movie is a chance to let other DC superheroes shine, both to establish more franchises and build up the Justice League as something to rival The Avengers.
7. "Tower Of Babel" Is A Great Story...
Justice League: Mortal borrows a lot of elements from the classic Justin League story Tower of Babel. In it, Ra's al Ghul steals Batman's contingency plans to take down his friends in the League, should the need ever arise. The story was already adapted in the animated movie Justice League: Doom. The classic tale shows Batman at his tactical genius best and his paranoid worse. The ways in which Batman's plans ruthlessly exploits his teammate's weaknesses are ingenious, and remind us that while Batman may not have any superpowers, he's still the most dangerous being on Earth.
6. ...But For A Sequel, Not The First Movie
We need to know more about the characters before we see them neutralised: simple as that. Martian Manhunter is defeated at the start of the movie before we even know who he is or what his powers are. The first Justice League movie needs to tell the origin of the team (if not the origins of the Leaguers themselves in some cases). If Warner Bros. had launched their franchise with this movie, it would be like if Marvel skipped all of its solo movies and the first Avengers film and began with Age of Ultron. Tower of Babel is a great idea to build a plot around, but for Justice League II or III - not to launch the franchise.
5. The Justice League Needs To Face Huge Villain(s)
The villain in the movie is Maxwell Lord and an army of cyborg O.M.A.Cs under his control. In the comic books, Lord was a one-time ally of the League, before going bad and being killed by Wonder Woman in a controversial story from a few years ago. He isn't exactly the kind of villain that would need the whole Justice League to defeat him. The fact that Jay Buchrarel (yes really), was cast as Maxwell Lord, means the villain in the movie would have been extremely weak. The Avengers dealt with a souped-up Loki and a whole army of inter-dimensional aliens. In their first outing, the Justice League would have fought Seth Rogen's skinny mate from Knocked Up. There are plenty of options for villains that would pose a serious threat to the League.
4. Hopeful Superhero Movies Are More Fun
The tone of the script is much closer to the lighter Avengers than the dour Man of Steel. And that's a good thing. While I loved the Dark Knight Trilogy, Rises was a bit too grim. Justice League: Mortal is a lot more positive and optimistic than the more cynical and dark Man of Steel. At the end, as an army of O.M.A.C.s approaches New York, the League prioritises protecting civilians. This was missing at the end of Man of Steel, where Superman gave little thought to saving the countless people caught in the crosshairs as he battled Zod. Similarly, Batman is rebuked for his cynicism about the rest of the League for coming up with plans to take them out. His isolation is also touched on. By the end of the movie, Batman realizes that he can't go it alone all the time, and can work with and count on the rest of the team. The Batman of the Justice League needs to be different from his previous incarnations. Making him a team player, as this script sets-up by the end, is a great way to differentiate him and grants audiences a fresh take on the character.
3. You Can Introduce A Load Of Superheroes In One Movie (But Please Don't)
The script does a surprisingly effective job of introducing a lot of characters. By the end, you get a sense of who each character is and what makes them tick. The only characters that get the Hawkeye treatment of being under-utilised are Superman and Martian Manhunter. But everyone else is given the chance to shine at one point or another. But the Marvel model of introducing the characters in solo movies first, before bringing them together as a team, is much more exciting. As a viewer, the cross-over movie is such a great concept that it's silly not to take advantage of it. 10 years ago, most fans would have said that a Justice League movie would have been a bigger deal than The Avengers. But Marvel did a great job building the anticipation of seeing their superheroes (who had previously been relatively unknown) sharing the screen for the first time. Warner Bros. needs to take its time in building towards a Justice League movie, introducing each character on their own terms, and not just throwing them all into a Justice League movie right off the bat.
2. Give Green Lantern Another Chance
The casting of Common as John Stewart was just about the only bright casting choice in the project. In his few solo scenes, we're shown more imaginative uses of his ring than two hours of the 2011 Green Lantern movie. Perhaps most excitingly, in the film's climax, he uses it create ring projection of Superman to fight the real thing. John Stewart would also make a great new Green Lantern. That doesn't mean giving up on Hal Jordan (Geoff Johns has produced too much great Hal-centric material to draw from), but Stewart would do fine as the team's Green Lantern. So would Kyle Rayner (but please no Guy Gardner!), in fact. Using Jon Stewart as the team's Green Lantern allows Warner Bros. to move on from the failure of the Ryan Reynolds movie, anyway. Jon Stewart would also add some much needed diversity to the JL roster, and comic book movies in general, being one of the few non-white superheroes and all.
1. Wonder Woman Kicks Ass
After Flash, the other standout character of the script is Wonder Woman. Reading it, it's hard to believe that Warner Bros. has failed so many times to bring the character to screen, be it on film or television. The character has so much breakout potential, especially given the dearth of female superheroes. The script does a fantastic job of establishing her as a fearsome warrior. She is the only hero that Maxwell Lord isn't able to defeat, even when he uses a mind-controlled Superman against her. My favorite bit reading the script was at the end, when after withstanding Superman's attacks, Lord tells her: "Not even Superman could take you out. Amazing." Wonder Woman, along with the Flash, has the potential to be a huge character. Along with the Scarlet Speedster, she could become a cornerstone of the Justice League and carry a franchise of her own, if only she given the chance to do so. Well, here's hoping that something materialises in the future. So what do you think? Would Justice League: Mortal have made a good movie or should Warner Bros. start from scratch? Sound off in the comment section.