The characters actors play on screen are immortal, forever captured at a moment in time. The actors themselves are not. Be it because of ageing, calling the director a Nazi or generally not being bothered, sometimes their role needs to be recast. The most prolific recasting has to be the Bond franchise, which over its fifty year history has seen six different actors play 007. Originally brought about when Sean Connery tired of the spy adventures, the way the series shifts with each new face has made the habitual replacements of actors its calling card. The rules of the recasting, however, means that rather than playing the same character the six Bond actors are really just embodying the same archetype; Connery and Daniel Craig are clearly not the same person. It gets muddier when you're dealing with a new actor playing the same character. You can knowingly reference it (see the cringeworthy Oracle in The Matrix Revolutions), but its success can't really be swayed by how much you wink at the audience; it all stems from how good the replacement performance actually is. Ewan McGregor's Obi-Wan was one of the standout elements of the Star Wars prequels, channelling Alec Guinness but not to the extent his performance spiralled into imitation. One of the best recastings, however, has to be Maggie Gyllenhaal taking over Rachel Dawes from Katie Holmes; even thought the two actresses look alike the change does nothing to damage the continuity of The Dark Knight trilogy. And in that vein, today we're going to look at ten famous recastings of iconic characters that everybody thought would fail, but ended up being pretty damn awesome.
10. Dumbledore
The Original: Richard Harris The Recast: Michael Gambon When Harry Potter kicked off the most likely recast was going to be with the young leads. Child actors tend to grow faster than annual installments can be made, which had led Warner Bros. to originally suggest making J.K. Rowling's books into an animated franchise (she wasn't too hot on the idea). There have been various recasts throughout the gigantic film series - Lavender Brown got a new actress (and race) when she became a love interest and Crabbe was pushed out of events after his actor got sent to prison - but by far the most profile has to be Albus Dumbledore. Richard Harris has played the kindly-yet-powerful headmaster of Hogwarts in the original two films, but when he died in 2002 the producers had no option but to get someone else in. The replacement was Michael Gambon, who ended up giving us a more Gandalf-esque mage, which given the increasing seriousness of the series wasn't a bad thing. At first, however, it appeared the film-makers had made a big mistake. Some of his scenes in Prisoner Of Azkaban and Goblet Of Fire are decidedly un-Dumbledore; he really shouldn't have attacked Harry for his name coming out of the Goblet. Thankfully, as things got more epic, he settled down a little.
9. George McFly
The Original: Crispin Glover The Recast: Jeffrey Weissman Here's a character even the original actor thought would be impossible to recast, to a rather shocking result. Although everybody remembers Marty McFly and Doc Brown from Back To The Future, in the mind of Crispin Glover, who played Marty's father, George McFly, in both 1955 and 1985 form, he was the real star. When a sequel to the time-travel comedy was floated Glover not only demanded that his salary was increased to the same level as Michael J. Fox's, but also that he got approval on the script. Robert Zemekis wasn't ready to give all that up, called Glover's bluff and ended up not bringing the actor onto the project. George was instead played by a heavily make-upped Jeffrey Weissman, with a role in the story much smaller than originally intended. And, to be fair, it just about works; George doesn't have to play a big part in the film (his death in the alternate 1985 packs a real punch) and Weissman looks enough like Glover for it to not be obvious. Glover, however, wasn't impressed and sued Universal for using his likeness, a case that was settled out of court.
8. Spider-Man
The Original: Tobey Maguire The Recast: Andrew Garfield The Amazing Spider-Man has, from conception, been ruled by the studio. Sony needed to make another Spider-Man film quickly before the rights to the character reverted to Marvel and Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4 was taking too long; a reboot was their only option. There's a lot to be disappointed about in the two recent Spidey flicks, but that doesn't mean they're devoid of positives. On top of the improved web-swinging effects, the films boast a solid protagonist. Who out of Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield plays a better Peter Parker will be a contentious subject for years to come, but the fact the debate can exist at all shows that Garfield has done an admirable job. Audiences really connected to Maguire's performance - sure he's dopey, but that's the point of Peter Parker - and there was initial doubt anyone could fill the suit convincingly. Garfield isn't the conventional nerd from the comics (which Maguire very convincingly embodied), but he gets more opportunity to give Peter Parker depth (director Marc Webb's history with (500) Days Of Summer shining through). The script often leaves him lumbered with bland material, particularly on the superhero side of things, but when he's just being a regular teen, interacting with an equally brilliant Emma Stone as Gwen Stacey, he's a delight.
7. Manute
The Original: Michael Clarke Duncan The Recast: Dennis Haysbert You'd have imagined a Sin City sequel would have been an obvious thing. The film was not just a box office success but had a strong fan reaction with an entire generation falling in love with its comic-book-imitating visuals. Add on that the material for a sequel already existed in the form of Frank Miller's source graphic novels and it's flat-out ridiculous that it took nine years for one to arrive. With such a gap, A Dame To Kill For felt less like a follow-on striking while the iron was hot and more a throw-back to that film that was popular that one time. It didn't deserve the box office grubbing it got, but we won't dispute it felt a little irrelevant. One problem posed by the gap was the character of Manute. Played by Michael Clarke Duncan in the original, who died in 2012, the hulking bodyguard played a significant part in the story director's Miller and Robert Rodriguez wanted at the centre of their second film (probably because of something to do with Eva Green's boobs). Duncan had a pretty distinctive presence, making a recast incredibly difficult, although Dennis Haysbert did a strong job with the role. Hulking and feeling indestructible, he was one part the film got right.
6. Kyle Reese
The Original: Michael Biehn The Recast: Anton Yelchin Kyle Reese is a man who travels back in time to chase after a girl he's only seen in one grubby polaroid. And while that sounds obscenely creepy it's actually the biggest of romantic gestures and one that leads to the saviour of the whole human race. Only in the movies, eh. Michael Biehn made Kyle Reese, transforming what could have been a self-important soldier on a world-changing mission into a real man who had to deal with all the struggles you'd expect adjusting to a new time. It was a natural, down-to-Earth performance that presented Reese as a regular guy, making him a suitable adversary for the stoic Terminator (and that seedy side seem romantic). There was no need to recast the character until sequel-prequel-reboot Terminator Salvation, which had various characters from previous films in younger/older forms. Young versions of iconic performances are always a tricky gamble, with most lazily reverse-engineered to deliver a simple shadow of what made audiences like the character in the first place. Thankfully that wasn't the case with Kyle. Christian Bale wasn't overly suited to John Connor, who becomes a lot less interesting once he's actually in the robot war, but Anton Yelchin as Reese was spot on. Looking like a young Biehn (that's always a bonus), there was that same kindness present that had made the character so likeable in the first place.
5. Superman
The Original: Christopher Reeve The Recast: Brandon Routh In almost eight decades of existence Superman has been portrayed by a multitude of actors. The most prolific of these, without a shadow of a doubt, is Christopher Reeve, who played Clark Kent and his less unassuming alter ego in Supes' first major big screen outing (Superman And The Mole Man from 1951 was little more than a TV pilot, so doesn't count). Superman: The Movie has served as the definitive look at the Last Son of Krypton that all subsequent versions either draw from or willingly avoid. Even though the series quickly decreased in quality, Reeve remained an emblem of the character and while various other takes appeared over the years, they all looked at purposely different aspects to his; Smallville was his early days and Lois And Clark was geared towards the bespectacled ordinary guy. It was as if the straight take on Kal-El was locked away; the various failed attempts to bring the character back to the big screen in the nineties all tried different approaches. That is until Bryan Singer came on board with his nostalgic Superman Returns, led by Reeve-avatar Brandon Routh. Routh's performance wasn't as groundbreaking as Reeve's, but neither was it meant to be; he was very much the same character and as such stuck close to the earlier performance.
4. Slinky
The Original: Jim Varney The Recast: Blake Clark We know what you're thinking; was Slinky even recast? Well that's the pure beauty of what Pixar did with the character in Toy Story 3. Replacing a voice actor is a lot trickier than it sounds; although it'd be easy to dismiss their performances as just a funny voice, it's a very distinct and purposeful funny voice. When Robin Williams refused to return to play the Genie in The Return of Jafar, Disney got in Dan Castellaneta. A brilliant voice actor who found acclaim with his work on The Simpsons, Castellaneta just couldn't quite do the blue lamp-dweller justice. Jim Varney, who voiced the dog toy with an incredibly durable slinky, died shortly after the release of Toy Story 2, which posed a problem for the late-in-the-day third film. Slinky was too large a character to simply write out (Bo Peep wasn't as lucky), so Lee Unkrich and co. set about recasting. They settled on comedian Blake Clark who not only delivered a pitch-perfect voice for the character, but had actually been a good friend of Varney, making the whole recast rather respectful.
3. Spock
The Original: Leonard Nimoy The Recast: Zachary Qunito Leonard Nimoy is Spock. He wrote a book about it and everything. On top of playing him in all three seasons of the original series, Nimoy has become the half-vulcan, half-human First Officer of the Enterprise in The Animated Series, The Next Generation, multiple video games and all the original films. It's just one of those character's who's so iconic because of the performance; Nimoy's take on Spock has become the embodiment of Star Trek in the eyes of the general public. That's a shadow you can't imagine any other acting wanting to stand in. So you can imagine the unrest when it was announced Star Trek XI was going to be a prequel, bringing a younger version of the Enterprise's crew. There were worries for all character, but particularly Spock; who could do him justice? The answer is Zachary Quinto, who did a brilliant job of capturing Nimoy while also offering a greater sense of conflict that felt in keeping with the skewed approach of Star Trek and its sequel, Into Darkness. The real masterstroke, however, was using a sneaky bit of time travel to allow both versions of Spock could exist in the same reality; Quinto wasn't replacing Nimoy, rather showing a new take on his iconic character.
2. The Joker
The Original: Jack Nicholson The Recast: Heath Ledger Given how universally praised Heath Ledger's performance as the Joker in superhero-crime epic The Dark Knight was, it's hard to remember that when he was first cast as the Clown Prince of Crime there was a massive backlash; how could an actor whose biggest recent role was a gay cowboy do this villain justice? The closest comparison is... well, actually the casting of Ben Affleck as Bruce Wayne. Gee, what is wrong with Batman fans? As glimpses of his performance began to be released people began to be less dismissive of Ledger, although any praise was always uttered with the caveat, "he won't be better than Jack Nicholson though." Nicholson was a much more typical actor to fill the Joker's shoes, winning an Oscar for his ability to dip into psychosis. His take had been central to Tim Burton's Batman, with the caped crusader taking a backseat to Jack Napier (that film gave the character with an unknown past a backstory). It's a fine take on the character and stood out against all the scenery chewing that followed from the likes of Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey. It was, for a long time, believed that it was the definitive version of the Joker, with anyone else who touched him on the big screen destined for second-best. How wrong we were. Little more needs to be said about Ledger's performance - if you're like us you've watched The Dark Knight more times than is healthy - which has totally replaced Nicholson's as an untoppable stroke of brilliance.
1. Hannibal Lecter
The Original: Anthony Hopkins The Recast: Mads Mikkelsen Although Hannibal had already been seen on screen before (played by Brian Cox in Manhunter, with the surname Lecktor), it was Anthony Hopkins' performance as the part-time psychiatrist, part-time cannibal that proved so icon-making. Appearing as Lecter for a meagre sixteen minutes, Hopkins' was so utterly unnerving on screen that Hannibal won him the Oscar for Best Actor (not supporting) and has come to dominate his legacy. Things got a little hammy in Hannibal and Red Dragon (particularly the latter, which boasted a boosted screen-time for Hannibal compared to the source novel), but even then it was still an actor having a lot of fun with a morally diverged character. He was first recast in prequel Hannibal Rising, a generic horror film whose only link to the earlier movies was the title, with the casting of Gaspard Ulliel falling into the usual pitfalls of making a character younger. It was always assumed any new Hannibal would exist in Hopkins shadow, so expectations were middling for NBC's drama looking at the psychopath pre-Lambs. Betraying its network TV origins, Hannibal is a cracking piece of brilliantly made television, elevated from a crime procedural by some lushious cinematography and and ever developing plot. The cast is equally brilliant, with Mads Mikkelsen as Hannibal being particularly noteworthy. And here's the big whammy; he's better than Hopkins. Given much more time to present a nuanced performance of Lecter and placed central to the plot (rather than as a bystander like in Silence Of The Lambs or Red Dragon), Mikkelsen has matched and bettered the Oscar winner. Which other famous recasts were expected to fail? Let us know in the comments below.