10 Times The MCU Was Right To Forget The Source Material

There's no way Korg would've been a hit if he was just lifted from the comics.

By Scott Banner /

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has grown to become the biggest movie franchise in the history of the industry, but it certainly had a head start thanks to the decades of comic books that preceded it. Building from characters and stories that already had huge fanbases, Marvel Studios had a lot of source material to draw from.

Advertisement

However, the franchise has always taken certain creative liberties with these properties, often either adding new details or omitting important aspects from the original comics. This can either be a blessing or a curse, depending on how the audience perceives such a change.

Iron Man 3's Mandarin for example, was one of the most divisive aspects of the entire MCU so far, as it offered a radical departure from the source material, but there have been more than a few times such changes have been positively received almost unanimously by audiences.

From iconic story lines, to character histories and backstories, and even their design and costumes, there is seemingly little that Marvel Studios are not open to changing. At this point, it's pretty clear that the franchise knows what its doing, and most decisions to ignore the source material are made for very good reasons.

10. Changing Thanos' Motivation - Infinity War/Endgame

There can be no doubt that Thanos is the greatest villain that Marvel have ever brought to the screen. He was powerful, intelligent, and most importantly, had a strong motivation for doing what he was doing.

Advertisement

This was done expertly by all involved, as it could have gone in completely the other direction had the writers decided to keep closer to the source material.

Throughout his history in the comics, Thanos has always had close ties to the infinity stones. He searched the universe to find them and wanted to assemble them all in his gauntlet to snap half of the universe's population away, but it was his motivation that was different. While the MCU version was doing such an act to save the lives of those he didn't dust, the comic book version of Thanos simply wanted to impress Lady Death.

The personification of death became something of an obsession for the Mad Titan, and he wanted nothing more than her attention and affection. He sought to serve her by sentencing half of all life to death, a story arc that would have been far less compelling when translated on screen.

9. Hank Pym's Treatment Of His Wife - Ant-Man/Ant-Man & The Wasp

Hank Pym's MCU appearances so far have seen him act as a mentor in some capacity to both Scott Lang and Hope Van Dyne, in a similar way to how Tony Stark took Peter Parker under his wing. He was the original Ant-Man, and helped Scott and his daughter continue that legacy.

Advertisement

Even in the MCU, Hank isn't going to win father of the year any time soon, but he still a good man, and cares deeply for Hope, while trying everything to get his long lost wife back to him. In the comics however, he wasn't quite so loving towards Janet.

During Avengers #213, Hank had taken on the villainous Yellowjacket role, and attempted to build a murderous robot that only he could defeat. As Janet tried to reason with him, Hank struck his wife in the face, and continued on with his work.

In this single panel, with this irredeemable act, Marvel forever marked the character as a domestic abuser. Thankfully, this part of Hank Pym's history was left entirely out of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, allowing him a fresh start with a mainstream audience.

8. Korg's Personality - Thor: Ragnarok/Endgame

When Taika Waititi took over the reigns of the Thor franchise, he completely transformed it from one of the MCU's lesser properties, to one of its best. There is so much to love about Ragnarok, with one of the most entertaining aspects being Korg.

Advertisement

Played by the director himself, the Kronan instantly became a fan favourite, thanks to his hilarious one liners and general outlook on life on Sakaar, and was a more than welcome inclusion in Avengers: Endgame. As wonderful as he is, he is certainly a far cry from the comic book version of the character.

During the Planet Hulk storyline, one that inspired a big part of Ragnarok, Korg became an ally of the giant, green, rage monster. Far from comic relief, Korg was a seasoned warrior concerned with battle and survival, nothing more, similar to the Kronan that Thor destroyed at the beginning of The Dark World.

It certainly wouldn't have been the worst thing in the world had Waititi kept the character as he was, but without such a change he never would have become such an iconic character, and certainly wouldn't have had fans demanding his own movie or Disney+ series.

7. Star-Lord's Father - Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol. 2

From the very first scene of Guardians of the Galaxy, we see just how important Peter Quill's relationship with his mother is, but it took until Volume 2 to meet Star-Lord's father in the MCU. Not only did this introduce us to a wonderful new villain, it answered some big questions that had surrounded Quill since his MCU introduction.

Advertisement

In the source material, Peter's father is not Ego the Living Planet, but is J'son, a rather forgettable villain from outer space. The King of the Spartax system crash landed on Earth and was helped by Meredith Quill, but by the time he left, he had no idea that he was leaving her with child.

In many regards, their stories are similar. Both fathers sought out Peter after he became the famous Star-Lord, but only Ego was a Celestial looking to combine his powers with that of his son to expand his reach across the entire universe.

Thanks to Marvel Studios omitting J'Son from Star-Lord's lore, and replacing him with Ego, the Guardian of the Galaxy's legacy in the franchise became much richer, and the character himself far more powerful.

6. Donald Blake - Thor

After Iron Man and The Incredible Hulk had kept the Marvel Cinematic Universe relatively grounded, the Thor franchise brought to the table the fantastical elements of Asgard and its people, the Bifrost, and Laufi and the Frost Giants. The biggest game changer however, was Thor himself, and his mighty hammer.

Advertisement

The powers that the God of Thunder and Mjolnir bought to Earth was unprecedented, and was done slightly different to how the character was first shown in the comics.

When Thor was banished to Midgard by Odin in the source material, he was given an alter ego as something of a host. While on Earth, Thor took the form of a medical student by the name of Donald Blake to teach him humanity. Later, much like Billy Batson and Shazam, Thor was able to shed the form of Donald and transform into the God of Thunder.

For the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the mortal character's role was reduced to an easter egg on a name tag, and the narrative was better off for the omission. This would have potentially overcomplicated an already strong origin story with an unnecessary new layer and dimension.

5. The Original Guardians Of The Galaxy - Guardians Of The Galaxy

Before 2014, the Guardians of the Galaxy were a very obscure property, unknown to even some of the most die hard Marvel comic fans. While the team is now one of the most popular in the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe, the original team from the comics would still be unrecognisable to a mainstream audience.

Advertisement

When the team was first introduced in 1969, there was no Star-Lord, no Gamora, no Drax, and no Rocket or Groot. Instead, the Guardians were made up of Charlie-27 and Martinex, two characters who ultimately cameoed in Volume 2, Major Vance Astro, and Yondu Udonta.

The team operated in an alternate Marvel timeline, 1000 years into the future, and while this may have been a fun world to explore in the MCU, it would have been much more difficult to bring the Guardians together with the Avengers for the eventual Infinity War.

While there's no doubt that James Gunn could have worked wonders with just about any character he chose to pull from the very depths of Marvel obscurity, we could have been robbed of some of the greatest characters to ever grace the MCU.

4. Helmut Zemo's Origin - Captain America: Civil War

After the Red Skull and HYDRA in the first two Captain America movies, Helmut Zemo entered the MCU for Civil War and began the trend of phase three villains being a cut above what we'd seen previously. His plan may have been too convoluted, but the character himself was both sympathetic and compelling.

Advertisement

It would have been easy for the franchise to use the character to continue the villainous thread from The First Avenger and The Winter Soldier, as Zemo has strong ties to HYDRA and was a protégé of Johann Schmidt in the comics. However, his origin story was modified to better suit the history of the MCU.

Rather than coming from a German background, following closely to the ideals put forward by the Nazis, Helmut Zemo instead hailed from Sokovia, and his personal motivation tied into the events of Age of Ultron rather than a wider, more generic philosophy.

Allowing Helmut Zemo a real reason to hate the Avengers, and giving him a personal and emotional vendetta against the heroes of the franchise allowed us to relate and connect to the character in a way that a comic accurate origin story never could have.

3. Erik Killmonger's Heritage - Black Panther

Thanos may be the best villain in the MCU to date, but Michael B. Jordan's Erik Killmonger is in a close race with Loki for second. The Wakandan, cousin of T'Challa, questioned the King's rule, and believed the great nation's resources would be better used shared with the millions of oppressed people across the planet.

Advertisement

He may have gone about it in the wrong way, but the theory behind Killmonger's motivation was something that every single audience member could understand and sympathise with. The character was made even better in the MCU by his relation to the King.

In the comics, N'Jadaka was exiled after his father helped Ulysses Klaue attack Wakanda, and became obsessed with vengeance against T'Challa. This ultimately brought him toe to toe with the King, but their relationship and the character's altered history in the MCU lent Killmonger a far more compelling story.

Family has been a key theme throughout much of the MCU, and Black Panther was no different. Instead of being exiled, N'Jadaka saw his father killed by T'Challa's father, and made sure the need for revenge lived on for his cousin. The villain's story and overall arc were certainly bettered with his closer relationship to the King.

2. Certain Comic Accurate Costumes

Thanks to the pre-existing loyal fan base that Marvel Comics have established for themselves, there is always a certain degree of expectation from audiences with regards to the characters of the MCU. Such heroes have been around for sometimes decades, and demand to be done to justice on the big screen.

Advertisement

Some of this comes down to the characters' costumes. Often iconic outfits, such as the Iron Spider are anticipated by fans for years, while others are completely left out altogether. When the MCU does this, it is usually for the best.

As popular as some costumes are, many just wouldn't translate to the big screen effectively, or haven't aged particularly well. Scarlet Witch's costume in the comics, for example, has been little more than a corset in the past, something far too revealing and nowhere near suitable for a Disney movie. Similarly, the likes of Vision, Zemo, and the majority of the Guardians have been given new outfits and aesthetics to work with, far superior to that of the comics.

Many of these comic accurate costumes have been used by the MCU, but in a satirical way, rather than seriously. Luke Cage and Captain America were both given their original costumes as something of a joke and an easter egg for a scene or two, and WandaVision has teased a similar situation for its titular characters. Often the MCU's designers have been able to come up with something far better than the comics of many, many years ago.

1. The Spider Bite - Spider-Man: Homecoming

After Marvel struck a deal with Sony to bring Spider-Man into the MCU, the announcement that they would be continuing with a new iteration of the character rather than Andrew Garfield's sparked some concern. This would make three completely separate Peter Parkers within the space of less than ten years.

Advertisement

Of course, Marvel Studios and Tom Holland have gone on to create arguably the best live action version of Spidey, and managed to do so without boring the audience by retelling the origin story we all know off by heart at this point.

Even just the typical, mainstream audiences know Peter's backstory by now, thanks to having it told by both Sam Raimi and Marc Webb, let alone fans of the comics themselves. Instead of a third retelling of how Peter was bitten by a radioactive spider, the MCU cleverly accepted that this was already common knowledge, and old ground that simply didn't need revisiting.

The same can be said about the death of Uncle Ben. Though integral to the character, the MCU was able to make do with a couple of subtle hints to these two big moments in Peter's life, saving precious time and allowing for a much fuller Spider-Man movie. We simply didn't need another origin story, and Marvel Studios appreciated that.

Advertisement