10 Underrated Films From Great Directors

Steven Spielberg, Martin Scorsese and Christopher Nolan all have some fantastic hidden gems.

By Tyler Rigby /

There is so much media to consume right now that it is hard to keep up with it all. Exceptional films are bound to go under the radar and miss out on the attention that they both crave and deserve. If they're lucky, they'll gain a cult following but if not, they'll be lost in the annals of film history.

Advertisement

Regardless of the critical reception, industry accolades or general audience responses, these films have not been included enough in the general conversation concerning the greatest films out there. In particular, the directors attached to these movies have far more recognised and appreciated films in their career that has resulted in the cinematic achievements on this list being left in the dust.

From recent masterpieces to early works of genius, these films are all phenomenal in different ways and should be celebrated for it. There are a variety of reasons these films are not remembered as vividly as others directed by the same filmmakers but that doesn't mean they are any less deserving of being spotlighted. If you're a fan of these directors, or any of the films they have made then these movies are a must watch!

10. Spike Lee - 25th Hour

Spike Lee has made a career out of having his finger on the pulse of society with films that have a focus on his heritage and culture. Do the Right Thing and She's Gotta Have It are great examples and he's returned to the spotlight in recent years with his timely BlacKkKlansman and Da 5 Bloods. Lee's niche is this kind of social commentary that speaks to so many but that doesn't mean that he can't make a great film that doesn't fit this mould.

Advertisement

Enter 25th Hour, a sentimental drama about a drug dealer that is on the cusp of a seven year prison sentence. Edward Norton stars as the man in question who wishes to have one final night with his two best friends and girlfriend before he has to turn himself in.

Norton's character has become disillusioned by society and although the themes aren't linked to Lee's previous works, the film seems like it was a direct response to the feelings of many in the wake of 9/11. Lee is showing that he can make any character or story feel relevant to whoever is watching his movies.

9. Christopher Nolan - Insomnia

A contemporary thriller from director Christopher Nolan that is straightforward in its execution and uncomplicated in its narrative. Nolan has a reputation for playing with time in his films and experimenting with convoluted storytelling but there is none of that here.

Advertisement

After a Los Angeles detective, played by Al Pacino, is tasked with going to an Alaskan town were the sun never sets to solve the murder of a teenage girl, he begins to struggle with his inability to sleep while dealing with the case. Pacino's continuing exhaustion is infectious as his sleep deprivation becomes a larger obstacle than the killer himself played by Robin Williams.

Williams is the real standout here, starring in one of the few serious roles of his career, he manages to be surprisingly physical and even intimidating at times. The role is a great showcase for the kind of extensive range the late actor was capable of.

Despite the two popular leads, Insomnia did not receive the same critical reception as other Nolan films and it has also failed to achieve cult status compared to something like The Prestige. It may not be a mind bending adventure but it is still an example of a filmmaker at the top of his game.

8. Steven Spielberg - Munich

Munich opened to critical acclaim and awards attention acquiring five Oscar nominations including one for Steven Spielberg's direction, however it failed to resonate with audiences achieving only mild box office success. After the Munich Massacre at the Olympics in 1972, the Israeli government chooses five men to hunt down those that were responsible

Advertisement

The vengeance thriller has a star-studded cast lead by Eric Bana and is filled with intense and exciting moments of action to keep people on the edge of their seats. The bloated running time of just under three hours and the incredibly dark themes on moral goodness and justice is perhaps what kept this film as one of the worst performing domestic films in Spielberg's long and illustrious career.

With a filmography as long and enduring as Spielberg's, it is unsurprising that one of his films would slip through the cracks, it is just a shame it was a film as engaging as Munich. It's a film that feels both mature and developed and, like the characters, you'll end up questioning whether what you're seeing is really justice or not.

7. Alfred Hitchcock - Rope

Before 1917 and Birdman made famous the style of the uninterrupted take, Alfred Hitchcock did it first with Rope. A relatively simple tale of a murder of a boy by his fellow students who wish to show their superiority by having a dinner party with those who knew the deceased. James Stewart stars as the murderers' former teacher who would have philosophical discussions with them about killing in the past.

Advertisement

The film is well written enough and the performances are all strong but it is Hitchcock's direction here that is so significant. Taking place entirely in one apartment, Hitchcock uses the experimental style of the long takes with hidden cuts to make Rope feel like a real time play.

Yes, more recent films have done it better and more ambitiously but, that doesn't mean Hitchcock's efforts should be discredited. His cuts are far more obvious and blatant as he zooms into the back of characters to hide his edits but this is still an impressive feat for the time it was made. It will never be one of Hitchcock's greatest films but it is certainly his most underappreciated.

6. David Fincher - Zodiac

A lesson in suspense and tension, Zodiac is a methodically paced film that slowly builds up around the hunt for the Zodiac Killer in the late 60s and early 70s. The films has a fantastic cast lead by Jake Gyllenhaal, Mark Ruffalo and Robert Downey Jr. who all put in incredible performances as they all become slowly obsessed over the identity of the infamous murderer.

Advertisement

Before Zodiac, Fincher was known for more high tension films such as Fight Club and Se7en but this movies chooses a more deliberate lowkey narrative with a sense of increasing dread. Every frame lingers just long enough to make the audience uncomfortable and second guess the reason why it endures on the screen.

Zodiac manages to be an edge of your seat experience that never lets up as you become just as invested in the mystery as the characters. The film's distinctive style is a clear precursor to Fincher's later work on Netflix's Mindhunter which is another underrated piece of Fincher's work.

5. The Coen Brothers - Inside Llewyn Davis

The Coens are renowned for their whacky and oddball characters such as The Dude and Marge Gunderson, so when they decided to tackle a serious drama with a grounded protagonist, the reaction was hesitant. Even No country for Old Men has its fair share of bizarre characters roaming around that make it clear its a Coen picture. Inside Llewyn Davis is a mature and reserved portrayal of grief as Oscar Isaac's titular character struggles to break out on his own in the Folk singing circuit after his partner tragically commits suicide.

Advertisement

Davis is a realistic and angry man struggling with what he has lost as he moves through a world that seems crazy to him (the kind of crazy that reflects the Coens' usual stories) leaving him as the only person who sees things for how they really are.

Isaac is phenomenal in this character study going from place to place trying to find a reason to keep on living. The depression that the character feels is exceptionally developed and the empathy you feel for Davis is genuine. It being a Coen Brothers film, there are still some light moments of comedy sprinkled in, predominantly in the form of a ginger cat that Davis keeps misplacing.

The film is warm and beautifully written and stands as the Coens' most human film to date.

4. Darren Aronofsky - The Wrestler

Mickey Rourke gives the performance of his career in this brutally honest character study of an aging professional wrestler. Unless you're a fan of the medium, Pro Wrestling is often looked down on by society as something that's 'fake'. Aronofsky's authentic and visceral drama shows the destruction these wrestlers put their bodies through and the difficult lives they often live in order to entertain their fans.

Advertisement

The film doesn't rely on sweeping philosophical debates and eccentric editing like the rest of Aronofsky's filmography is known for. Instead, The Wrestler is a grounded examination of one man who is destroying himself and his relationships in order to continue doing what he loves the most. It is heart-breaking at times and incredibly truthful when it comes to a world that is rarely taken seriously.

Managing to be both touching and saddening, The Wrestler is Aronofsky's most personal and down to earth film. Its simple approach to showing the life of a complex man is one of its greatest strengths. Just because it doesn't feel like an emotional odyssey like has come to be expected from Aronofsky, doesn't mean it's any less powerful.

3. Yorgos Lanthimos - The Lobster

Greek filmmaker Yorgos Lanthimos, known for such works as the cult classic Dogtooth and the critically acclaimed The Favourite is rising fast in the mainstream as his quirky dark comedies continue to attract new audiences. By far, his most outlandish and wholly unique film The Lobster is what deserves the most praise.

Advertisement

Set in a world where you are required to have a romantic partner, single people are sent to a hotel where they will stay for a set period of time looking for a significant other. If they fail to find one in the allotted time then they are turned into an animal of their choosing. It's an original and ingenious premise that leans heavily into being weird and odd with all the characters speaking in an exaggerated monotonous voice.

Colin Farrell and Rachel Weisz lead an exceptional cast who fearlessly embrace the strange otherworldliness of Lanthimos' story which feels incredibly thought through and deliberate. The Lobster is one of the most enigmatic films in recent years and is superbly directed by Lanthimos in his English language debut. It is unashamedly strange and that is what makes it so special.

2. Denis Villeneuve - Incendies

Now a major Hollywood director with credits such as Sicario and Arrival to his name, Denis Villeneuve's best film is easily Incendies. A traumatising and unrelenting look at a woman's life in an unnamed Middle-Eastern country torn apart by war. After Nawal Marwan dies in Canada, her will instructs her two adult children to return to her home country and find their father who they thought was dead and their brother they never knew existed.

Advertisement

Told in both the present and during Nawal's time there, we see the brutality of Nawal's difficult life which will leave you emotionally exhausted. Unflinching in its approach, the film is utterly harrowing as it exhibits all the horrors that war can bring to a country. The film is hard to watch at times, but it never feels exploitative and every painful act you witness is there for a clear reason.

Incendies has one of the most heart-breaking and dark endings in all of cinema that will leave you shaken as the sad truth of Nawal's life is revealed. It is a haunting work which is exceptionally directed by the future Blade Runner 2049 director. Incendies is not light viewing but it is immensely powerful from start to finish.

1. Martin Scorsese - Silence

A recent film from one of the greatest directors of all time, Silence was a passion project for Martin Scorsese that took years to get to the big screen. The story follows two Portuguese missionaries who must travel to Japan in search of their former mentor who is rumoured to have apostatised and forsaken Christianity in a country where that religion is illegal.

Advertisement

Deeply personal and incredibly thought-provoking, Silence is a series of discussions and debates about the place religion has in this world and whether a God that remains silent during so much suffering is much of a god at all. Andrew Garfield gives a career best performance as the devout Jesuit priest and Adam Driver, Liam Neeson and Issei Ogata all provide stellar supporting work.

But, this is not a film about the characters, its focus is purely on the contemplative spirituality of everyone involved. The conversations that Garfield has with Ogata about Christian metaphors or that he has with Neeson about the Japanese worshipping him instead of God are all exceptionally written scenes and completely engaging.

Aside from the performances and writing, this is a film that looks gorgeous from start to finish. Predominantly shot in Taiwan, the whole film could be an advertisement for the country as the scenery is beautifully captured. This is one of Martin Scorsese's best films of his career and is a must watch for any of his fans.

Advertisement