10 Upcoming Horror Movies Facing ONE Big Problem

These horror movies all have to deal with one big issue.

By Jack Pooley /

The production of any movie is an utterly ludicrous undertaking that faces any number of hurdles on the path to screens both big and small. From behind-the-scenes issues before a single frame has been shot, to technical issues during shooting, and creative differences in post-production, it's truly miraculous that so many great or even good movies exist at all.

Advertisement

While horror is often regarded as the most fertile genre for filmmakers to make their start in the industry, making a horror film is still no picnic, as evidenced by the toils of these 10 upcoming films. These movies, though certainly touting the potential to be serious hits with audiences if not critics, also need to overcome one major problem.

From issues with the cast and crew to creative misgivings, and perhaps even the belief of many that there's no reason for them to actually exist, these movies simply can't triumph without addressing these problems head on. And while some of these films absolutely will figure things out, others are likely condemned to falling short of the mark just as many fans expect them to.

10. The Game Already Feels Like A Movie - Until Dawn

Though the upcoming adaptation of hit horror video game Until Dawn has some solid pedigree behind it with director David F. Sandberg (Lights Out) and writer Gary Dauberman (It), it's tough to discount the concern that the interactive drama game already feels like a movie.

Advertisement

With its emphasis on cinematic visuals over modest-at-best gameplay, Until Dawn basically splits the difference between a film and a video game, at which point you have to ask: why bother making it a movie at all?

More to the point, given that the game is itself already a loving homage to classic slasher movies, it would be incredibly easy for a film based on a game that's indebted to an entire genre of films to end up feeling like a tepid, lazy facsimile.

For Until Dawn to actually justify its own existence, it'll need to be more than a lukewarm nostalgia-fest, but at the same time, there are also sure to be those fans upset that it isn't directly adapting the game. And so, it'll be extremely tough to please everyone.

9. Nobody Wants To Release It - The Toxic Avenger Remake

After being shot in the summer of 2021, Macon Blair's remake of classic Troma film The Toxic Avenger had its belated premiere at Fantastic Fest 2023, where it scored predominantly positive reviews from critics. But over a year later, the film is still awaiting release and has only additionally screened at two other genre film festivals, the last of which was back in October 2023.

Advertisement

Despite solid reviews and starring Peter Dinklage in the lead role, reports state that distributors have dubbed the film "unreleasable" due to its niche subject matter and gory content, deeming it "too out there" for a theatrical release. And so, The Toxic Avenger is trapped in an awkward and frustrating state of limbo, with no distributors biting as of yet. 

While it's likely that the movie will end up on a streaming service at some point, it doesn't do the film's rep any favours at all that nobody's stepping up to support it. A sad fate for a film that, by most accounts, delivered on its promise.

8. The Franchise Can't Move Past John Kramer - Saw XI

It's nothing short of a miracle that Saw X turned out to be one of the very best Saw movies, slotting surprisingly neatly into the series' twisted chronology as an interquel taking place between the first and second films. And great though it was to see the legendary Tobin Bell give his most impactful and genuinely dramatic performance as killer John Kramer, it also illustrated an ongoing problem with the franchise - its inability to exist outside of Kramer's shadow.

Advertisement

The ninth Saw film, Spiral, tried and failed to shift the series away from focusing on Kramer, and its disappointing commercial performance led the producers to go back to Bell for another go-around. Saw X was a fun novelty for sure, but with Bell reportedly planning to return for the impending Saw XI, it doesn't indicate much of a willingness to address the simple fact that, sooner rather than later, the 82-year-old Bell is going to age out of the role one way or another.

The Saw series desperately needs to start thinking about its longer-term survival prospects without John Kramer by introducing a truly worthy successor to his mantle, whoever that might be.

7. The TERRIBLE Title - Final Destination: Bloodlines

Though there's much excitement about the sixth Final Destination film, it's tough not to hold it against the filmmakers for settling on such a wretched title - Final Destination: Bloodlines.

Advertisement

"Bloodlines" as a horror movie sequel subtitle feels like pure parody in 2024, considering the hilariously overused title has been lent to a long list of generally naff horror sequels in the Hellraiser, Pet Sematary, Wrong Turn, and Tremors franchises.

To call it played out is quite the understatement indeed, enough that it was even acknowledged by series producer Craig Perry. 

While a title isn't necessarily indicative of the end product's quality, it does nevertheless imply a patent lack of imagination on the part of those making the business decisions. Even if the title is actually relevant to the sequel's plot, can we really not do any better? There has to be a more interesting title out there that's still as marketable as "Bloodlines."

6. James Wan Isn't Directing (AGAIN) - The Conjuring: Last Rites

It's largely accepted by fans of The Conjuring movies that the third film, The Devil Made Me Do It, was by far the weakest of the original trilogy, an issue generally ascribed to original director James Wan's limited involvement, as he received only a "Story by" credit.

Advertisement

Sadly, the very same is true of what's said to be the final entry into the mainline Conjuring franchise, The Conjuring: Last Rites, with Wan again only taking a story credit while directing duties will once more be undertaken by Michael Chaves.

Given that Chaves not only delivered the disappointing third Conjuring film but also helmed two other underwhelming spin-off entries in the Conjuring Universe - The Curse of La Llorona and The Nun II - it's impossible to expect anything but mediocrity from this one.

Even though Wan's a busy man, bringing him back to give the Warrens a proper send-off would've been the smart play here.

5. Spoofs Are A Dead Genre - Scary Movie 6

Earlier this year, more than a decade after Scary Movie 5 was released, a sixth entry into the franchise was announced, and this past October it was further confirmed that the Wayans brothers - who wrote, directed, and starred in the first two films - were returning to develop this reboot.

Advertisement

But even accepting that the Scary Movie brand name is legitimately iconic in its own right, the spoof genre is completely dead. 

For one, the glut of low-effort parody movies produced by Jason Friedberg and Aaron Seltzer throughout the 2000s and 2010s - including Date Movie, Epic Movie, Meet the Spartans, and Disaster Movie - basically annihilated audience interest in spoofs as a whole. More than that, social media has allowed smart, talented creators to deliver bite-sized parodies of hit movies on platforms such as TikTok with an immediacy that a movie simply can't ever match.

And so, can audiences really be persuaded to leave their house and pay money to watch a new horror spoof movie when all the jokes it's inevitably going to make have probably already been done - and quite probably done better, even - by content creators online? 

4. Explaining Samara Weaving's Return - Ready or Not 2

Ready or Not was a terrifically entertaining horror romp, albeit one that seemed like a perfect one-off feature, enough that it was easy to assume the faint whispers of a possible sequel wouldn't ever amount to anything. But earlier this year, it was confirmed that a sequel was indeed in active development with a new director, Adam Robitel (Escape Room), and just recently, original star Samara Weaving was announced to be returning.

Advertisement

Yet for many, the most natural route for a Ready or Not sequel was a standalone follow-up focused on another person caught in the middle of a demonic ritual, rather than bringing Weaving's Grace back for an implausible second go-around. After all, on paper this has a lot of the same "gee golly, it's happening again!" energy that defined ridiculous sequels like Home Alone 2 and The Hangover Part II.

It'll require some seriously finessed writing to make audiences buy into this scenario befalling Grace once more, which isn't necessarily a great starting point creatively.

3. Nobody Asked For It - The Blair Witch Project Reboot

Perhaps the single toughest hurdle to any film's existence is total indifference from its own target audience, as is most certainly the case with the recently announced reboot of found footage masterpiece The Blair Witch Project.

Advertisement

Lionsgate and Blumhouse confirmed that the reboot was in development earlier this year, without the involvement of original filmmakers Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez or cast members Joshua Leonard, Heather Donahue, and Michael C. Williams.

The cast and crew have spoken extensively about their disappointment in being left out of the new film, but honestly, given how neither of the current cinematic follow-ups to the original 1999 film delivered worthy results, there's clearly minimal-at-best fan interest in another movie.

Not all horror movies were built to be franchises, and evidently The Blair Witch Project works just great as a single standalone entity. Couple this with the undeniable decline of the found footage subgenre in recent years, and the desire for a new Blair Witch just isn't there.

2. The Carpenter Sisters' Absence - Scream 7

To call development of the seventh Scream film awkward is quite the understatement, for though this should've been a slam dunk of a sequel to put together after the success of Scream VI, everything fell apart late last year.

Advertisement

It all began when lead Melissa Barrera was fired from Scream 7 after making pro-Palestine remarks on social media, and co-star Jenna Ortega departed the movie the very next day, allegedly over a salary dispute - though many naturally believe she really departed in solidarity with Barrera.

This led Scream 7 to be reworked, shuffling out the Carpenter sisters and bringing Neve Campbell back to reprise her role as original heroine Sidney Prescott, with franchise creator Kevin Williamson in the director's chair for the first time.

Given that Scream 7 was expected to be the trilogy-capping final chapter in the Carpenters' story, the sequel is in the uncomfortable position of either having to explain their absences or just... not mentioning them altogether, neither of which is likely to go down well with the fanbase.

Plus, with many feeling that Sidney's story was quite ably wrapped up in the fifth Scream, there are those lamenting that she's being pulled back into the fold at all.

1. The Law of Diminishing Returns - The Strangers: Chapters 2 & 3

This year's reboot of The Strangers wasn't a good movie at all, but to be completely fair to it, the slasher retread grossed almost $50 million worldwide against a tight $8.5 million budget.

Advertisement

While nowhere near as successful as the original Strangers - which grossed $82.4 million in 2008 - The Strangers: Chapter 1 was certainly a solid gain on sequel The Strangers: Prey at Night, which reaped a more modest $32.1 million in 2018.

All the same, Lionsgate quite ambitiously had director Renny Harlin film an entire trilogy of new Strangers movies back-to-back, with Chapter 2 set to drop next year and Chapter 3 at an unspecified date. Except, given that Chapter 1 landed a "C" CinemaScore, it doesn't exactly suggest there to be much audience interest in seeing this story develop into a trilogy. 

So, it's reasonable to expect the law of diminishing returns to swiftly kick in, with the second and third films likely grossing considerably less than Chapter 1.

Though the sequels are basically too low-budget to bomb outright, squeezing out a trio of mediocre movies in quick succession seems like an easy way to kill off overall interest in the horror brand in record time. They're not thinking about the long game here at all.

Advertisement