10 War Films That Were Basically Just Propaganda

What happens when you let a SEAL team make a movie?

By John Kerr /

Hollywood has manipulated you! I know, you’re shocked, dismayed, outraged. But, don’t worry. They have good reason to do it.

Advertisement

They want your money.

Ok, that’s not the only reason filmmakers manipulate you. Sometimes they want to push their political agenda. It’s been happening for decades. Often with the explicit help of governments, the military, or both!

Crazy right? It’s like rich and powerful people have decided to shape public discourse through the media...

One thing that's always hard to sell to the public is war, so governments often look to filmmakers to make war a little more fun and sexy. Sometimes a branch of the military, like the US Navy, will hire a director to churn out a two-hour long recruitment video.

And there are films where directors take it upon themselves to sell an unpopular war, like Vietnam. John Wayne tried this trick more than once. But, sometimes filmmakers crank out an effective piece of propaganda without even trying to.

At least one film on this list was meant to sell audiences on Armageddon. It won't be that bad, really. (As long as you get raptured.)

10. U-571

The 2000 film U-571 depicts the daring theft of a German Enigma machine by American soldiers. The Enigma was a, nearly, indecipherable encoder used by the Germans during World War II. In reality, the Germans used the Enigma to send coded messages to ships during the war.

Advertisement

For the Allies, managing to capture and reverse engineer one of these Enigmas represented a massive victory. Allied codebreakers were able to determine German ship movements and save countless lives.

The only problem with U-571 is that it’s a complete work of fiction. The film, however, fails to make this distinction clear. Many moviegoers left theaters assuming that American sailors were solely responsible for capturing the German code machine.

In truth, Allied forces captured fifteen Enigma machines during the war. British forces captured thirteen Enigmas, while the Canadian and US forces captured the other two. The fact that U-571 fails to even acknowledge the British contribution to capturing and deciphering the Enigma machine was, understandably, met with anger.

At the time of the film's release, British Labour MP Brian Jenkins said it was an "affront to the memories of the British sailors who lost their lives on this action." Prime Minister Tony Blair agreed with this sentiment saying,”... we hope that people realise these are people that, in many cases sacrificed their lives in order that this country remained free."

Filmmakers blamed their mistake on a desire to reach a wide audience. They decided that by Americanizing historical events it would make the film more broadly appealing. This is a pretty thin excuse, however.

Because of its glaring inaccuracies, U-571 ends up looking like the embodiment of American exceptionalism.

9. Black Hawk Down

Based on true events, the film follows the story of US special ops fighting in Somalia. They were tasked with protecting UN peace-keepers during a civil war that took place in the early 90s.

Advertisement

During the conflict, Somali forces gunned down two US helicopters. In the ensuing battle, 18 US soldiers were killed and 73 were wounded. The American public was further horrified by live CNN coverage of the event. After a few months of bad press, the Clinton administration pulled US troops out of Somalia.

Some may have seen this as a dark moment in US history, and Ridley Scott’s film could be viewed as a caution against US military intervention. In fact, this is how the film’s star, Josh Hartnett, described the movie.

But, top military brass in the country saw the film in a much more positive light. Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz called Black Hawk Down a “powerful film.”

The film was also praised by Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, and Oliver North, the mastermind behind the Iran-Contra Affair. That’s not to say these men are pro-war, but they’re not not pro-war.

8. Left Behind

Ok, this one might be a bit of a stretch. But, if you’re patiently awaiting the Battle of Megiddo then Left Behind is the war film for you.

Advertisement

This 2014 film is an adaptation of the popular 1995 novel of the same name. The original novel kicked off a very popular book series. The Left Behind series tracks the events happening in the aftermath of the rapture. These events include the war to end all wars - Armageddon.

For a film steeped in Christian religiosity, you’d expect a core theme to be one of forgiveness or love. What makes Left Behind propaganda is that its core message is one of fear: don’t believe in God because you want to do justice and love mercy. No way! You better fear God or your ass is getting... Left Behind!

...With Nic Cage. So, not all bad?

7. Forrest Gump

Since its release in 1994, Forrest Gump has taken on a surprising amount of controversy. The question surrounding the film is simple. Is Forrest Gump an example of conservative propaganda?

Advertisement

The film's producers, as well as Tom Hanks, have long argued that Forrest Gump is an apolitical film. Producer Steven Tisch once stated, “Forrest Gump isn't about politics or conservative values. It's about humanity. It's about respect, tolerance, and unconditional love.” But many conservatives have embraced Forrest Gump as an example of traditional American values.

Much of the argument stems from the way the film portrays both the Vietnam War and the 1960s counter-culture that accompanied it. During his time in the army, Forrest Gump is explicitly praised for following orders without questioning them. Gump’s blind respect for authority not only saves during combat but later catapults him into financial success.

Despite having an IQ of 75, by the end of the film, Gump is a millionaire enjoying early retirement.

The movie portrays the 1960s counter-culture through Gump's childhood girlfriend, Jenny. During the war, she is a true “flower child,” committed to anti-war demonstrations. By the seventies Jenny was suffering from severe drug addictions. And, as the film winds down in the eighties, Jenny dies from contracting AIDS.

It’s hard to view the stark contrast between these two characters and conclude that this film does not have an agenda.

6. The Great Dictator

The Great Dictator premiered back in 1940. It starred silent film star, Charlie Chaplin. He also directed and paid for the film. In it, Chaplin famously portrayed Adolf Hitler.

Advertisement

Actually, he played a character named Adenoid Hynkel, a dumb, autocratic dictator bent on world domination. So, yeah - Hitler.

In 1940 the US had not yet entered the war. However, the world was learning of the Nazis’ horrifying war crimes.

Chaplin almost scrapped his film, deciding it wasn’t right to parody the German atrocities. Chaplin didn’t want to make light of the horror that was Nazi occupation.

When Franklin D. Roosevelt heard of Chaplin’s intention to can the film, the US president intervened. FDR sent one of his aids to Chaplin with a simple message:

“Make this film.”

5. The Alamo

On its face, this is a film about the Battle of the Alamo. The Alamo was a Spanish church, turned fort, near San Antonio, Texas. In 1836, a small group of the fort’s defenders was wiped out by the Mexican Army.

Advertisement

In the aftermath, the Alamo became legendary in American folklore and history. The battle was viewed as a noble defeat where brave men died defending their freedom. All that aside, it’s not what John Wayne’s 1960 film is really about.

In what would be a trend for Wayne, The Alamo was a film made to support his staunchly anti-communist views.

While making the film Wayne said that Americans were living in “perilous times.” He stated, “the eyes of the world are on us,” and “we must sell America to countries threatened with Communist domination.”

In depicting the bloody massacre of the Alamo, Wayne hoped to show Americans his belief that freedom is costly. And that sometimes Americans need to invade southeast Asian countries to defend freedom.

It's a tortured metaphor, but if you look for it - it's there.

4. Top Gun

There’s really only one thing you need to know about the 1986 film Top Gun. Top Gun’s producers, Don Simpson and Jerry Bruckheimer had full cooperation from the US Navy while filming.

Advertisement

Director Tony Scott had unheard-of access to Naval ships and aircraft. And, it cost the producers practically nothing.

The only thing the Navy wanted in return was full script approval. With that, they changed some pivotal deaths in the movie, like Goose dying in an ejector seat accident. Originally Goose was going to die in a mid-air collision.

This cooperation netted massive benefits for the Navy. Top Gun made the career of a Navy fighter pilot look like the sexiest job ever. Ok, who are we kidding? It is the sexiest job ever.

All Top Gun did was put Tom Cruise behind the stick of an F-16 fighter jet. That’s the greatest combination since Saturday met Sunday.

Point me to the nearest recruiting office, please.

3. Act Of Valour

Top Gun was a fantastic investment for the US Navy. With Act of Valor, they took this formula one step further. Working with directors Mike McCoy and Scott Waugh, the Navy cast active-duty SEALs in the main roles of the film.

Advertisement

The Navy also let directors use Special Ops boats and equipment. With the help of the Navy, Act of Valor portrayed spectacular, realistic action set pieces. And there’s a plot in there somewhere.

While Act of Valor had less-than-stellar reviews it made a huge haul at the box office. One of the common complaints of the film was that the acting was a little stilted. While active-duty SEALs are some extremely impressive individuals, turns out they're not great actors. Who would've guessed?

The film ends with a dedication to every Navy SEAL killed in action since the 9/11 attacks. It’s truly a love letter to the Navy SEALs.

2. Red Dawn

Oh, the dreaded communists. According to Hollywood, they were the scourge of the globe during the 1980s. Even Rocky had to fight them!

Advertisement

Red Dawn begins with the collapse of NATO, expansion of the Warsaw Pact, and a communist-led coup in Mexico. It’s like something out of a John Wayne fever dream.

After all that, Cuban and Soviet paratroopers glide into Calumet, Colorado. Because of course, the Russians would spearhead their invasion by taking over a small town in the Colorado Rockies.

In response, a group of teenagers, calling themselves the Wolverines, escape into the mountains. They arm themselves and stage guerrilla-style attacks on the Soviet occupiers.

Who do these kids think they are? Ewoks?

This movie is rife with melodramatic nonsense meant to drum up a combination of existential fear, and sycophantic pride in the minds of American viewers. There’s even a scene where two brothers visit their father along the fence line of a Soviet death camp...

A Soviet death camp in the middle of the Rockies! What the hell?

This movie is pure, unadulterated insanity. And, pretty damn entertaining, actually.

1. The Green Berets

Guess who we’re pitted against in this movie? That’s right. Say it with me:

Advertisement

"The communists!"

Released in 1968, The Green Berets came at a point when anti-war sentiment was hitting its peak in the US. John Wayne was deeply concerned and set out to make a powerful pro-military, anti-communist film.

Wayne asked for and received full cooperation with the US military and government during filming.

In The Green Berets, John Wayne reduces a decades-long conflict into a simple game of cowboys and Indians, with the film being panned for oversimplifying what was in reality a much more complex conflict.

This is best represented in the young Vietnamese boy named Ham Chuck. Ham Chuck is a war orphan that the Green Berets unofficially adopt. Rather than acting as a fleshed-out character representing the human cost of the war, Ham Chuck acts as a mascot for the soldiers.

The film ends with Wayne’s character telling Ham Chuck that the whole war is being fought for him. This frames the Vietnam War in easy and favorable terms; the US saving the innocent Vietnamese from the evils of communism.

This sentiment also ignores the real issues at the heart of the Vietnam War. These include things like the US Containment Policy, wartime attrocities and decades of European colonization that led to the conflict in the region.

Advertisement