10 WORST Actor Replacements In Movies
Weaving, Connery, Furlong - sometimes it's impossible to step out of the last guy's shadow.
Franchise building has been big money in mainstream cinema for a long time, but the farther we get into this century the more sequels, prequels, reboots, and requels seem to spring up. This is all good and well when the best actor for the job is on a five-film contract that they'd have to kill their firstborn to get out of, but it hasn't always been like this.
There have been plenty of franchises that have come to make another installment and found that the talent has already jumped ship. Far from sinking the whole enterprise, however, this usually causes directors and producers to pivot to another choice, recasting the role and hoping the audience doesn't notice.
Well, sometimes we do. Agent Smith or 007, John Connor or George of the Jungle; sometimes the original is truly irreplaceable, sometimes the replacement isn't up to scratch and sometimes the casting manager has gone rogue.
Whether replacing icons or just not really understanding the part in question, the following ten actors found themselves being the worst replacement for characters in some pretty major film franchises.
10. George McFly - Back to the Future Part II (1989)
Back to the Future Part II took audiences to the actual future for the first time in the series, sling-shotting Marty (Michael J Fox), Doc (Christopher Lloyd), and the DeLorean forward into the space-age world of, uhh, 2015... Shenanigans abound as the pair attempt to prevent both Marty's son (also played by Fox) from sabotaging the McFly family's future, and bully extraordinaire Biff Tannen (Thomas F. Wilson) from altering their history, culminating in a wacky return to 1955.
While the film is fun enough, the production and release were laden with almost as much controversy as the first movie (which saw the mid-filming firing of original Marty, Eric Stoltz), thanks to producers' unwise decision to replace Crispin Glover's George McFly with another actor (Jeffrey Weissman) wearing a face mould of Glover taken during the filming of the first Back to the Future. A major lawsuit trailed Part II upon its release, with a reported $760,000 pay-out for Glover.
Weissman, while not a bad actor, is not a good likeness for Crispin Glover and couldn't exactly play well through some creepy prosthetics while also being side-lined to make up for the switcheroo. Still, all this could have been avoided simply by paying Glover the initially rather high sum of $1 million he demanded to return to the role.
9. Blob - X-Men: Apocalypse (2016)
The X-Men prequels managed to resurrect the mutant action franchise from several misfires and blunt endings, bringing in a new cast to breathe life into old characters. And, for two-point-five films at least, it succeeded.
While most of the recasts make sense, given that these are younger versions of the characters, there are a few that stick out. One in particular wound up being only a small part in X-Men: Apocalypse, Blob. Originally played by Kevin Durand in the unfortunate X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009), he shone through as one of the characters the film got right, embodying every ounce of the big guy in a ring fight with Hugh Jackman's Wolverine.
Fast forward to Apocalypse, and Durand was replaced by Giant Gustav Claude Ouimet for a brief scene in a cage match with Angel (Ben Hardy). Ouimet's performance is a bit-part, paying the barest lip service to the character in a scene designed only to highlight the fighting skills of his winged opponent.
But there was no need to recast him at all. The thing is, X-Men: Apocalypse is set in 1983, and the bulk of the action in Origins takes place in 1979, just four years prior. Durand could have returned for another round in the ring, slapped us with some more of the sassy slob's star power and given the scene some spice.
8. Clarice Starling - Hannibal (2001)
Anthony Hopkins' is the performance everyone remembers from The Silence of the Lambs (1991), in which he took over the role of intellectual cannibal Hannibal Lecter from Brian Cox. And yet the whole film turns on its lead, Jodie Foster, as junior FBI agent Clarice Starling. Her sharp yet doe-eyed performance provides not only the perfect counterpoint to Hopkins' charming psychopath but a seamless audience surrogate for dealing with material - cannibalism, flaying, weaponised projectile semen - that could otherwise be quite alienating.
Despite initial interest, both Foster and Lambs' director Jonathan Demme departed from the series because of the significant increase of violence and gore proposed for sequel Hannibal, with producers wanting to push away from the psychological aspects that made the original so, well, original, and tack closer to the horror norm. Thus, Julianne Moore was drafted in to take over.
Now, don't get your writer wrong, Moore is a fantastic talent, and she has put her stamp on countless top-tier films, but she didn't quite have the right approach for Clarice. Even if we put aside the fact that none of the stylistic and aesthetic choices for the character ring true, she still feels like an entirely different person - though not in the ten-years-later, sustained character development kind of way. More than this though, she lacks the chemistry that the original Clarice shared with Lecter, which is the key to the whole thing.
7. George - George of the Jungle 2 (2003)
Pretty much anyone who grew up in the '90s with a pair of eyes and a TV knows the Tarzan rip-off George of Jungle (1997). It's not perfect, but there are plenty of laughs and an all-star cast, which includes Brendan Fraser as George, alongside John Cleese, Leslie Mann, and Thomas Haden Church, who sustain the hackneyed fish-out-of-water premise for the full 90 minutes. Job done.
Or so we thought.
If ever a film didn't need a sequel - never mind one released six years later, after all the pop culture capital had dried up and young audiences had moved on - it was this. And Brendan Fraser agreed. To replace him, studio execs brought in Christopher Showerman, who swung, hollered, and goofy-grinned his way through a serious slog of a film in which the new George attempts to save Ape Mountain from his nemesis Lyle Van de Groot (Church).
The part isn't exactly Shakespeare, but it seems as though it was written for Fraser, relying on his brand of dopey optimism and charisma to sell it. Showerman instead seems like a frat boy who has wandered onto the set and been told to do his best. And while it may indeed be his best, it's not nearly good enough.
6. Evie - The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor (2008)
While George of the Jungle may have helped make Brendan Fraser's name in mainstream cinema, the Mummy franchise cemented it. Starring as rollicking adventurer Rick O'Connell, Fraser teamed up with John Hannah's Jonathan and Rachel Weisz's Evie to unearth some sarcophagi and deliver us some campy and fun, if critically disappointing, Universal monster magic (and whatever this is).
But the dream team wasn't to last, and come time for the late third entry in the main series - Tomb of the Dragon Emperor - Weisz bailed on account of a bad script. Drafted in to replace her was Maria Bello who, while a fine actor in her own right, was all kinds of wrong for the part.
Firstly, she's American, and Evie is a Queen's English-Brit, meaning that her accent, while perfectly serviceable, never quite hits the spot. Secondly, she has a different physicality to her predecessor, jettisoning some of Evie's more delicate sensibilities in order to match her on-screen husband. But, thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, she doesn't have the same delivery and repartee with Rick and Jonathan. Maybe it's the years of watching Weisz that colours this, but it just feels like there's something missing.
5. John Connor - Terminator 3: Rise of The Machines (2003)
Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines has aged surprisingly well in the years since release. While it was criticised at the time for being a bit too glossy and shiny and, y'know, 2000s, the slew of Terminator misfires that have followed in the 20 years since have almost served to canonise it. But there's one detail about the film that cannot be overlooked, and that's the casting of Nick Stahl as John Connor.
Rise of the Machines' predecessor, Terminator 2: Judgment Day (1991), is widely regarded as one of the best action and sci-fi movies of all time. And the definitive element of this is not Arnie swinging in as an unexpected good guy, or Robert Patrick's shapeshifting T-1000, but Edward Furlong providing the relatable human core as an immature, rebellious John Connor. Furlong's punk attitude gives the film its flavour, and he bounces off his hulking android protector (Schwarzenegger's T-800) in the most entertaining ways, delivering iconic scenes and catchphrases like "Hasta la vista, baby".
While Stahl is perfectly fine as an actor, he has none of the spunk and deep character qualities that Furlong brought to the role. He also doesn't really click with this T-800, leaving several emotional and character gaps in the film. Unfortunately, Furlong was too washed up to participate, lost in a haze of drugs, and unable to meet the studio's demands.
4. Batman - Batman & Robin (1997)
Despite his tongue-in-cheek return at the end of The Flash (2023), George Clooney has been banned (by fans, producers, and himself) from the role of the Caped Crusader ever since the series-ending disaster that was Joel Schumacher's Batman & Robin.
Schumacher took the reins from Tim Burton in the mid-'90s, ditching some of the gothic influence and realising a brighter, neon-inflected Gotham that paralleled the growing rave scene of the time. It was fitting, then, that for a new-look Gotham, the film deserved a new-look Bat, and in Schumacher's first film, Batman Forever (1995), Val Kilmer replaced Michael Keaton in the lead role. Now, Kilmer wasn't perfect but he played a more convincing billionaire playboy than Keaton, and what he lost in the suit was made up for with some seriously OTT villains.
Fast forward two years and the notoriously difficult-to-work-with Kilmer was out on his ass, and '90s heartthrob George Clooney was stepping into the spandex. On paper, Clooney should have been right for the role; handsome, witty, in-demand, and with the kind of chin that really rounds out a cowl. Unfortunately, the results were quite the opposite. His boyish nature took the punch out of both Bruce and Batman, who are meant to be dark and brooding, but which he played like a smarmy tech bro. His performance is hammy as hell, and as for his line delivery, well, Adam West could have done better.
3. Kevin McCallister - Home Alone 4 (2002)
The first two Home Alone movies (1990/1991) are cherished family Christmas classics, and may they reign forevermore. The rest of the series, however... there’s a reason they don’t get aired too often.
It may be hard to believe, but there are in fact six(!) Home Alone movies, of declining quality, with the most recent franchise instalment dropping like a Yule log in 2021.
While most of us may have assumed that Kevin McCallister (originally played by Macaulay Culkin) ended his adventures with Lost in New York, the character was actually resurrected for a third outing in 2002 for Home Alone 4, with Mike Weinberg taking the role. Taking place a year or two after Kevin’s Big Apple adventure, 4 finds the McCallister family in turbulent times, with Kevin having to choose which divorced parent to spend Christmas with.
Weinberg fails to capture the instant likability and whip-smart attitude that made the role so iconic in the first place. Add this to the fact he looks nothing like Macaulay Culkin, and the result is a character totally devoid of any essential Kevin-ness. As Culkin was way too old to play McCallister (without severely altering the plot), it makes sense that producers had to replace him with younger talent. But, really, it would have made even more sense just to not bother at all.
2. James Bond - On Her Majesty's Secret Service (1969)
One of the most scandalous actor replacements of all time came in the late '60s when, after an era-defining run as British superspy James Bond, Sean Connery stepped down, leaving producers Albert R. Broccoli and Harry Saltzman in the lurch, struggling to find a suitable replacement.
Rather than the straightforward replace-and-reboot formula we are used to seeing now, this first change of guard for 007 was guided by an attempt to retain the exact same character and provide direct continuity with the existing films, as if nothing out of the ordinary had happened. While Australian model George Lazenby had no acting experience, he did bear more than a passing resemblance to Connery, and on this basis made it his mission to ingratiate himself with the producers.
And it worked! Through persistence and the chance acquisition of one of Connery's own Savile Row suits, Lazenby dressed for the job he wanted, and he got it. But neither clothes nor manners maketh an actor, and his lack of talent came through loud and clear once he was on film - but by then it was too late.
What George Lazenby possessed in terms of physical presence, he lacked in charisma and skill, failing to make the part his own and coming off as a cheap imitation of his mighty Scottish forebearer.
1. Agent Smith - The Matrix Resurrections (2021)
It is difficult to think of The Matrix (1999) without Hugo Weaving's 'Mr. Aaaaaaanderson' echoing in your mind. As Agent Smith, Weaving frequently stole scenes from the chronically bland Keanu Reeves, whose everyman-Jesus Neo left plenty of room for more colourful characters to enter the frame.
Given Smith was destroyed in The Matrix Revolutions (2003), it would have made total sense to leave him out of the 20-years-later soft reboot, The Matrix Resurrections. But no, Smith survived because Neo survived, and on the tumbling chaos goes.
Fair enough, we may say, for what is a high-concept sci-fi action thriller without its snarling villain? But when Weaving turned the role down, owing to an unworthy script and scheduling conflicts, this may have been the time to rethink including the character at all. Instead, writer-director-producer Lana Wachowski and her team decided it was time to recast. Enter musical theatre wunderkind Jonathan Groff.
It's not just that Groff was a poor fit for the role to begin with, it's that he was stuck trying to balance the essence of the character with a desire to make the part his own and not just do a Hugo Weaving impression. The outcome is a character that feels like a bad imitation of the original and at the same time not like the character at all. He's not elastic enough, not sinister enough, and it would have been so much better if Smith had just sat this one out.