12 Comic Book Film Adaptations Stuck In Development Hell

You'd have better luck getting a brick to fly than pushing these into the cinema.

By Chris OMalley /

Although we seem to be living in the golden age of comic book cinema and television, there are still those properties that have gestation periods so fraught with developmental problems, that they have thus far failed to make the transition to either the big or small screen. There is no singular determining factor as to why some properties are harder to realise than others. With some it is likely the complexity of the material itself, and its suitability for translation to another medium. With others the problems are clearly connected to the production and the creative teams behind those adaptations. Both of these explanations are valid. In terms of the material there is the notion that due to the popularity of the comic book film, Hollywood has optioned without prejudice anything that began life on the printed page. Regarding the creative teams, problems connected to development, pre-production and the ubiquitously cited "creative differences" are obviously not exclusive to comic adaptations, and a feature of a great number of unproduced projects. The following list details twelve key comic book properties that have resided in the fiery depths of development hell since they were first announced, a little background on what has put them there, and their chances of breaking out.

12. The Boys

It seems to be the law regarding Garth Ennis adaptations that they must serve their time in hell before being unleashed on the general public. A Preacher film has been discussed since 1996, and as is well documented, has been in the hands of various producers and directors, ranging from visionaries like Sam Mendes to comic adaptation terrorists like Mark Stephen Johnson. It may finally see the light of day via Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg's version for AMC, but this hasn't stopped history repeating itself with Ennis' other epic work: The Boys. The problem filmmakers are likely encountering when trying to tackle Ennis is that there is very little room for compromise, at least without sanitising the work beyond recognition. The Boys adaptation was optioned by Columbia Pictures in early 2008, to be produced by Fast and the Furious producer Neal H Moritz, with a screenplay by Phil Hay and Matt Manfredi. Two years later in August 2010 Adam McKay of Anchorman and Step Brothers fame was attached as director. Fast Forward six years after it was first announced, and the only developments have been it being dropped by Columbia and subsequently picked up by Paramount. As far as it is known McKay is still slated to direct and Hay and Manfredi are still writing the script. Somewhere in a waiting room in the dark recesses of Development Hell, Wee Hughie is having a pint with the Reverend Jesse Custer.

11. Rogue Trooper

Unfortunately, the poor box office performance of Dredd may have derailed the possibilities of other lesser-known 2000AD properties being made. This is a thoroughly frustrating scenario, especially when you realise that the marketing failures which damaged Dredd are not only having an impact on Dredd 2 but a whole universe of other properties. There is of course still hope that word-of-mouth, Blu-Ray and streaming figures will do enough to convince there is enough interest to make Dredd 2 a viable property. So in that regard there is also at least a slim hope that it could also prop up projects such as Rogue Trooper. The last time we heard anything official about the status of Rogue Trooper was when Grant Morrison said that he had written a treatment for Sam Worthington's Full Clip Productions in 2011. There has been no word since, and it would have to be presumed that if the producers can't find a way to make the epic-sci-fi-war piece budget friendly, then we are unlikely to see Rogue Trooper any time soon.

10. Transmetropolitan

Transmetropolitan was first announced during the comic's heyday in the late 90's. The late Pete Postlethwaite was reported by Coming Attractions as Warren Ellis's first choice for the role of cyber-gonzo-journalist Spider Jerusalem. Tim Roth was also suggested as a possible candidate, as well as Patrick Stewart, whose production company Flying Freehold attempted to option the rights in 2003. One of the problems with Transmet from a studio perspective is that the Blade Runner-esque, cyberpunk setting could be prohibitively expensive to put on screen, especially with a niche property, that isn't exactly well known outside of its small but passionate fanbase. Given that Ellis himself has said the movie isn't happening it seems highly unlikely there will be a Spider Jerusalem film any time soon. The entertainment world is a strange ever-shifting sea though, so there's nothing to say the property wont find its way onto TV or film as live-action or animation one day.

9. The Invisibles

There are those (in accordance with Grant Morrison's belief) that would argue we've already seen an Invisibles adaptation back in 1999 when The Matrix first appeared in cinemas. The similarities between the properties are undeniable, and Morrison himself stated that he wouldn't want to see an Invisibles film recreate the shared elements that have already been sufficiently covered by The Matrix. However this hasn't stopped talk of developing the seminal series in other ways. Morrison has suggested he would like to see a videogame adaptation one day, and BBC Scotland were said to be collaborating with him on a TV adaptation as far back as 1995. In many respects it is easy to understand why a subversive, complex work like The Invisibles hasn't yet been made, but it also in the pantheon of highly influential 80s and 90s books that have left an indelible print on how comics have progressed since. In this regard there may always be creators who would wish to take a stab at the property, meaning it could one day bust its way out of development hell.

8. Powers

As fans of the comic will already know, Brian Michael Bendis and Michael Avon Oeming's Powers actually made it to a pilot starring Jason Patric and Lucy Punch in 2011. Very little footage exists of the failed pilot, but after increased delays, reshoots that were attributed to "tone and clarity" by Bendis himself, were eventually scrapped to allow for a completely new approach to the material. The property was actually first optioned for film development by Sony way back in 2001, before ending up at FX in a joint production deal with Sony in 2009. Given its roots in Bendis' love of the police procedural drama, an FX series seemed like the ideal platform for the Powers story to be told. The show remained in development at FX until it was announced in March 2014 that Powers would become the first original series to stream via the Playstation Network exclusively to Playstation consoles. Given Sony's long-standing attachment to the project, there is reason to be optimistic that this news will finally see Powers brought to life.

7. Chew

The culinary adventures of Cibopathic FDA Agent John Chu were first announced as a being adapted by Walking Dead production company: Circle of Confusion way back in 2010. Later in 2011 it was announced that Chew would be developed as a half-hour comedy series to be shown on Showtime. After that very little was heard about Chew, until creator John Layman confirmed via Facebook in February 2013, that the Showtime Chew series was no longer going forward. At the time this announcement came as something of a surprise, as Layman and co-creator Rob Guillory had intimated as little as a month earlier that the progress on the project was going well. Whether Showtime eventually balked at some of the comic's stomach churning subject matter is open to debate, but there has been no word as of yet whether Chew has been picked up by any other network, or whether or not a different, perhaps cinematic approach will be sought.

6. Justice League Dark

Guillermo Del Toro must have his own special warehouse in Development Hell. Nearly two years after his take on DC's stable of dark and supernatural characters was first mooted, there is still no sign of any significant move towards production. Having seemingly been superseded by the Constantine TV show and Zac Snyder's upcoming JLA: Light approach, Justice League Dark looks like it may be joining the ever-growing pile of Del Toro's other works stuck in Development Hell. However the director himself has said he feels that the Constantine show would have no bearing on the project, and that the two could co-exist. Furthermore It is possible that Snyder's DCCU kickstart will be a huge success and have a knock on effect, which sees projects like this come to fruition. In the meantime though Justice League Dark looks like it may be joining At The Mountains of Madness, Frankenstein, Hellboy 3, Slaughterhouse-Five and Beauty and the Beast locked away in the infernal Del Toro warehouse.

5. Green Arrow: Supermax

Although it seems to have been effectively and indefinitely cancelled, Supermax would still make a great premise for a tight, Dredd-by-way-of-Shawshank, superhero flick. With Arrow having established Oliver Queen more in the wider public consciousness, the opportunity to present the character on the big screen is arguably more valid than when the project was first announced. One approach would be to see how the burgeoning cinematic DCCU develops, specifically through JLA, then if Arrow is a part of the team, make the film a spin-off side project, or make it the focus of a future JLA story. It would be intriguing if Warner Bros were considering carrying over the TV versions of Flash and Green Arrow to the Affleck/Cavill/Gadot League. This has to be considered unlikely, but it would remove the need to introduce the characters in an in depth way, and without the demand for the oft-repeated origin story there could be scope for stories like Supermax to be told.

4. Wonder Woman

As with Green Arrow the status of an individual Wonder Woman flick would now seem to be inextricably linked to the fate of Snyder's Dawn of Justice and its JLA follow-up. The most noted previous attempt to bring the Amazonian to cinema was of course Joss Whedon's treatment, which was in development at Warners from 2005 to 2007 before finally being struck from their slate. Whedon isn't the only director to to encounter problems in adapting the material. In the wake of Tim Burton's Batman, Ivan Reitman was going to direct a Wonder Woman feature, but eventually dropped out in 1996. Several other writers and directors have had a crack at it, including Brett Strickland and Matthew Jennison's version, which was set during World War II. Of course David E. Kelley's TV version starring Adrianne Palicki made it to pilot in 2011, but the results were deemed so horrible it is still to see the light of day. Before Diana was announced as featuring in the Snyder-verse, Bronson and Drive director Nicholas Wending Refn had publicly expressed an interest in tackling the property, whether he is a candidate to further the cinematic life of Gal Gadot's version remains to be seen.

3. Aquaman

It's difficult to think of an Aquaman film nowadays without Entourage immediately springing to mind. Unfortunately for the King of Atlantis, attempts to bring him to the big screen in real-world Hollywood have been decidedly less successful than its fictional counterpart. Maybe someone should give James Cameron a call? Though he may be a little too busy with the next chapters of his "Dances with Space-Smurfs" saga. Much like the ecological symbiosis of the comic books, Aquaman is here dependent on his supra-terranean allies to determine the fate of his Atlantean kingdom. This is both a blessing and a curse, and sets up a similar situation to Dredd, whereby related properties are tied to the fate of another. Conversely like with Wonder Woman and Green Arrow, if Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice and JLA prove to be hits, then assuming he will be a part of the JLA film, there is every chance an Aquaman solo film will eventually be produced.

2. Flash Gordon

Flash Gordon has long been a problematic property. As is well known it took George Lucas failing to secure the rights to give the world Star Wars, and barring Mike Hodges's vibrant take, and the abortive Sci-Fi series, subsequent filmmakers have suffered similar fates. Like with the pay-off of receiving Star Wars though, this might not be an altogether bad thing. The closest the project came to fruition was when Steven Sommers the director of "Indiana Clones" flick The Mummy was attached. You only have to look at Sommers's Van Helsing, and the fact that he planned to cast Ashton Kutcher in the lead role, to realise we have dodged a laser bolt on that one. The latest status is that it is at Fox and currently being developed by Star Trek 3 writers J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay. It's anybody's bet whether or not this is the version that will finally make it to the big screen. One barrier could be the astronomical box office failure of similarly themed property John Carter, though it is arguable that Flash Gordon is a far more recognisable character to modern audiences. The enduring love that exists for the 1980 version could well contribute to it finally being realised.

1. Sandman

A project that has long languished in development hell, going through several iterations: from a 90s Roger Avery adaptation of the first Preludes and Nocturnes arc, to a James Mangold HBO series. This all seemed like it was about to change last December when Joseph Gordon Levitt announced via Twitter that he would be producing Sandman alongside Neil Gaiman and David Goyer. It's still early days but there has been surprisingly little news regarding the project since. Considering that Sandman has been here many times before, until there is more tangible development there is no reason to believe this version will get off the ground either. Having said that, news could be just around the corner regarding the project, and if Gordon-Levitt, Goyer and Gaiman (the three 'Gs') can get it moving, they will have succeeded where many have failed, and it will be an exciting time for fans of the comic. Dream isn't the only member of the Endless to suffer, his sister has also resided in development hell since Death: The High Cost of Living was first slated for production back in the 90s. It looked as if it would see the light of day in 2007 when Neil Gaiman announced he would direct and Guillermo Del Toro produce a version entitled Death and Me, but it would seem Del Toro's developmental curse struck again, and Warners closed the project in 2010. It has yet to be picked up or renewed anywhere else. Any thoughts or ideas on whether any of these properties will break out of production purgatory? Tell us below: