12 Incredible 2013 Performances That Definitely Won't Win An Oscar

Not everyone can win. Some won't even get nominated, no matter how good.

By Paul Sorrells /

The sad things about award shows is that there are only so many nominations available for all the great performances in a given year. Despite being integral parts of their respective movies and providing excellent examples of acting, some exceptional performances will still be left out for a multitude of reasons. Some will be shut out because they appear in movies that a lot of critics didn't care for, or in other cases were overshadowed by even better performances in the same movie. Other smaller or "less important," but no less impactful roles that weren't "major" enough to warrant awards consideration will also find themselves on the same heap, no matter how well executed. It also happens that actors and actresses who appear either in very small indie movies, or in massive blockbusters, generally have no shot at even a nomination, never mind a win. With the Oscar nominations announcement coming later today, and with a number of great performances that have no chance of winning again about to be forgotten during awards season, it's time to look back at some of the best performances that, for whatever reason, just weren't quite up to Oscar standards. Luckily, the Oscars aren't the final judgement of cinematic talent, and many of these performances will be looked upon fondly in the years to come, whether or not they end up with an gold statue.

12. Colin Farrell (Saving Mr. Banks)

Advertisement
Although Saving Mr. Banks was largely a dull, lifeless love letter from Disney to itself, there was a surprising number of likeable supporting characters that pop in and out of the movie. One of the most memorable was Travers Goff, the father of main character P.L Travers, who was played by Colin Farrell in another, typically excellent performance. Farrell has long been one of the most underrated actors in the business, and here he convincingly portrays a warm, loving father, who, despite being an essentially tragic character, is a role model for the young P.L Travers. Saving Mr. Banks wouldn't quite have worked if the audience couldn't understand Travers affection for her father, but Farrell knocks it out of the park. He makes his flawed character a poignant and memorable addition to a film that for the most part was particularly unmemorable. In many ways, he provides the movie the soul that it would have lacked otherwise, and although he won't receive a nomination, he might be the best part of Saving Mr. Banks.

11. Matthew McConaughey (Mud)

Matthew McConaughey's resurgence has been well documented, and it has come to full bloom this year with a Golden Globe win and a definite Oscar nomination on the way for his work in Dallas Buyer's Club. Sadly, his work in that film has kept one of his earlier performances this year a well-kept secret from the general public. In the fantastic Mud, McConaughey plays a character who feels like something out of a classic American novel. Mysterious and enigmatic, but oozing McConaughey's signature charm, his Mud would be an Academy Award nominated turn almost any other year. Dallas Buyer's Club's later release, and more politically-minded subject matter however, has eliminated any chance for a win in Supporting Actor for McConaughey. Still, it feels like a few years from now, Mud will be the movie people most associate with McConaughey's resurgence, even more so than Dallas Buyer's Club and his cameo in The Wolf Of Wall Street. Let's just hope he doesn't go back to making sterile rom-coms...

10. Ray McKinnon (Mud)

Probably the least heralded out of all the performances in Mud was Ray McKinnon's turn as Ellis's father, known in the credits as only Senior. While he doesn't receive very much screen time, McKinnon is very impressive as one of the central figures in the film, and the one who arguably has the most influence on Ellis. His impending separation from his wife and the mixed feelings it causes for his family mirrors much of what Ellis encounters elsewhere in the film with the other characters. Of course, Ray McKinnon is not nearly well-known enough to earn an Oscar nomination for anything less than a spectacular turn in a significant movie. McKinnon isn't quite as impressive as that, but he still turns in a fine performance in one of the year's best movies, and he deserves some kind of recognition for it, which sadly he's unlikely to see from the Academy.

9. Kristen Scott Thomas (Only God Forgives)

Only God Forgives is easily one of the most divisive films of 2013, despite being a daring, visually dazzling piece of moviemaking. One of the few things most people agreed on was that Kristen Scott Thomas turned in a particularly impressive performance, having one of the few roles that actually contained a fair amount of dialogue. Playing the diabolical matriarch of a mob family who comes to Thailand to avenge the death of her son, Thomas spews insults left and right and manipulates everyone around her. Her complicated relationship with her other son, played by Ryan Gosling, fuels many of the surreal and disturbing elements of the film. Only God Forgives won't earn any nominations on Thursday because of the mixed reception it received, but Scott Thomas will likely be more worthy of awards than many of the eventual nominees in the Best Supporting Actress category.

8. Benedict Cumberbatch (Star Trek: Into Darkness)

Although his character is a little misused and Star Trek: Into Darkness isn't the kind of movie to get much Oscar love (it's both too commercial and too "low-brow,") Benedict Cumberbatch continued his rise to the very top of Hollywood actors with one of the best blockbuster performances of the year. He elevates the mediocre dialogue given to him, and creates a truly compelling, and very nearly sympathetic villain. Although he was held back by the script, Cumberbatch creates one of the most intimidating villains of the year with "John Harrison," and although he won't sniff an Oscar nomination, it was one of the most impressive acting displays of the year. Khan, as he was revealed to be (without too much surprise,) was multi-layered, threatening and imposing, in both physical and mental terms: in his own words he was just better. Of course, the best may be yet to come for the character as there's little reason he can't return for the next instalment, and if the script is a bit better next time around, there's no limit to how good Cumberbatch could be.

7. Jake Gyllenhaal (Prisoners)

Despite getting a wide release in the U.S, Prisoners seems to have already been largely forgotten about, which is a travesty since it was easily one of the most unsettling movies of 2013. Bravely taking the audiences to progressively darker places, Prisoners asked compelling questions about what a parent will do for their children. The performance that had most people talking was that of Jake Gyllenhaal as the obsessive cop tasked with locating the children whose abduction is the central plot point of the film. Gyllenhaal adds nuance and subtlety to the character of Detective Loki: he is a loner, quite and reserved, who has solved every case he's been assigned to, and his world-weary gaze, and reserved mannerisms serve as the perfect foil for Hugh Jackman's wild, crazed performance. The dynamic between the characters provides the emotional core of the movie and Gyllenhaal more than does his share in bringing the movie to life. Loki is arguably Gyllenhaal's his best performance yet and proves once again that despite not attracting the same hyperbole as some of his contemporaries, he is one of the more talented actors working today.

6. Martin Freeman (The Hobbit: Desolation Of Smaug)

Like his Sherlock partner Benedict Cumberbatch, Martin Freeman is rapidly becoming one of the most in-demand talents out there, and like Cumberbatch, he will not even get a sniff of an Oscar nomination this year. However, after a strong start in An Unexpected Journey that confirmed for many that their suspicions about him being perfect for the role were right, Freeman continues to prove himself the perfect Bilbo Baggins, nailing the duelling emotions of fear and curiosity that drive the character. He might be easily suited to Bilbo's more relatable characteristics, such as his friendly nature and his everyman appeal that grounds the more fantastical feel of the dwarves, but The Desolation of Smaug challenges the British actor more than its predecessor. Here, Freeman is also tasked with showing the first signs of the ring's impact on his psyche, when Bilbo nearly loses the ring fighting off spiders in Mirkwood forest, and we are given a look into the darker side of the character. Overall, Freeman expertly displays the courage, kindness, and daring that made the character such a compelling figure in the book, and even though The Hobbit movies have been divisive so far, few would deny that Freeman has been anything but excellent

5. Ryan Gosling (The Place Beyond The Pines)

One of the great movies from the early part of the year that everyone seems to have forgotten about, The Place Beyond the Pines is a film with vast scope and ambition, which is anchored by some of the best performances of the year. Ryan Gosling and Bradley Cooper play the two main characters and although Cooper is likewise excellent, Gosling is the more compelling and interesting of the two characters. Following his mythology making performance as The Driver in Drive, here he plays an expert stunt motorcyclist who uses his abilities to rob banks in order to provide for his young son. Although his character is a ultimately a tragic one, Gosling infuses the role with likability, and the movie suffers somewhat in the second half when he is no longer on-screen. Despite some of the more venomous responses to his performance in Only God Forgives, Gosling is one of the best young actors working today, and it's probably only a matter of time before he wins an Oscar, though, unfortunately, it won't be for The Place Beyond the Pines. In all honesty, it would be massively surprising if he even god a nomination.

4. Greta Gerwig (Frances Ha)

Noah Bumbach's Frances Ha was one of the surprise movie of the year, premiering to raves at the Telluride Film Festival, and ending up one of the most acclaimed films of the year. And one of the biggest factors in the film's reception was the brilliant performance in the main role by breakout star, Greta Gerwig. She plays the archetypal twentysomething trying to find her way in New York City who moves in and out of apartments, alternates between jobs, and forms new circles of friends regularly. She bumbles her way through relationships with the people around her before finally learning how to accept herself for who she ends, and the movie ends with her finally beginning to enjoy life. Gerwig delivers one of the best performances of the year, carrying the movie over large portions. Although she was nominated for a Golden Globe in the role, and will likely earn an Oscar nomination, Frances Ha is too obscure of a movie for her to have a real chance at winning. Still, Gerwig's future is bright and Frances Ha will likely become something of a modern classic and her performance is a big reason why.

3. Michael B. Jordan (Fruitvale Station)

Another one of the breakout stars of the year was Michael B. Jordan, who surprised everyone with his heartbreaking turn in Ryan Coogler's Fruitvale Station. Playing the real life character of Oscar Grant, Jordan turns him into a flawed, fascinating figure, with his own particular set of motivations, dreams, hopes, fears, and longings. The best performances make their characters come to life, and Michael B. Jordan more than accomplishes that feat, and his Oscar Grant is one of the year's most interesting characters. The role was specifically written for Jordan, and it's easy to see why as he encapsulates so well the conflicting emotions that define the character. His performance ties the whole movie together, and few actors of any age could bring the same combination of charisma and pathos to the role as Jordan did. Although the competition is going to be too much for him this year, Jordan is one of the rising stars in Hollywood, and it's very likely that he'll eventually win an Oscar, just not this year.

2. Scarlett Johansson (Her)

One of the best performances of the year came from someone who never actually appeared on-screen. In Spike Jonze's brilliant Her, Scarlett Johansson turns in an incredible performances as the operating system Samantha, who falls in love with Joaquin Phoenix's Theodore Twombly. Using only her voice, Johansson manages to feel as real as any of the other characters in the movie, in what is easily her most memorable performance to date. She manages to be sensitive, kind, funny, sensual, smart, and a perfect companion for Theodore. Since the Oscar's have a bias against non-traditional performances, Johansson won't win a Oscar, or even get nominated for one. Just like the movie itself however, Johannson's performance will likely grow in stature over the next several years to the point that it will seem strange how the Academy managed to completely overlook her efforts.

1. James Franco (Spring Breakers)

Finally, the most impressive performance of the year with no chance at an Oscar because of its over the top subject matter, is James Franco as the completely bonkers drug dealer Alien in Harmony Korine's Spring Breakers. Franco holds nothing back in his performance, going above and beyond what most actors would agree to doing in both physical and psychological terms. Despite having a considerable amount of online support and a few critic wins under his belt so far, Franco has no real shot at an Oscar. Considering most of the Academy voters will have absolutely no idea what to make of Spring Breakers, Franco's excellent performance will fall on deaf eyes and ears. Although it's not clear how well Spring Breakers will fare over time, if it does end up being some kind of cult classic, Franco's performance will be a big reason why. It's an audacious, brilliant performance that elevates the rest of the film and provides it with it's most quotable and memorable moments. Without Franco, Spring Breakers would not have been as well-received as it was, and that is one of the marks of a great performance. Which great performances of 2013 do you think won't win an Oscar this year? Share your thoughts in the comments thread below.