12 More Deleted Scenes That Explain Confusing Movie Moments

When editing goes very wrong.

By Simon Gallagher /

Warner Bros.

It's a fairly reasonable assumption in film-making that there are going to be deleted and alternate scenes. After all, it's part and parcel of the final editing stage - where the film is polished to its shiniest state - for directors to realise that some moments are self-indulgent, or ruin the film's pace, or are just completely superfluous. It's a good thing, really, and sometimes making cuts that remove something creative is a necessary evil.

Advertisement

What is less good is when those scenes are cut out without anyone realising that they actually played important roles elsewhere in the film's logic or plot. And because movie fans these days are primed to spot plot-holes, gaps in logic and mistakes, you just know that the lack of foresight to compensate for such cuts will come back to haunt the film-maker.

At least you can pin some of those stupid moments on an actual missing jigsaw piece, which can be found either on the home video release as an extra feature, or thanks to a quick frollic through the Internet archives. Because it would be even more embarrassing if all of these plot-holes and confusing moments existed solely because the film-makers were idiots...

Advertisement

12. Where Did Nero Go For 25 Years? - Star Trek (2009)

Paramount Pictures

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

In JJ Abrams' Star Trek reboot, the timeline is irreparably f*cked with when Eric Bana's furious Romulan cleverly manages to accidentally appear right next to the ship on which James T Kirk was born (and his father died). Then, after that initial, devastating skirmish, the villain promptly disappears for 25 years, waiting for Kirk to grow up into a douchebag, presumably.

The way the film paints it, Nero simply waited around, kicking his heels for two and a half decades.

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

Except he didn't do that. He was captured by Klingons and imprisoned on Rura Penthe, where he adopted a mysterious image, kept his past quiet (literally, as he had taken a vow of silence after Romulus was destroyed) and injured his ear.

Advertisement

He only escaped (and destroyed lots of Warbirds in the process) when the Klingons worked out what he was planning for Spock and threatened to interrogate him with a Centaurian slug. It was this escape that was the centre of the transmission Uhura heard regarding an attack on a Klingon prison planet, which stayed in the film.

Advertisement

11. Finn's Face Turn - Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Lucasfilm

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

Despite being raised to be a Stormtrooper and sent out into the field (presumably after some sort of testing of his mental condition), Finn turns his back on the First Order incredibly quickly. All it takes is for one of his buddies to be killed and he suddenly realises he's on the wrong team.

That's not sufficient explanation.

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

There's actually much more to Finn's betrayal of his first pay-masters than the final cut showed, but JJ Abrams decided to remove the scene that sees Finn stumbles across a local villager and her baby and is confronted by the evil of his orders (which would presumably have had him kill her). Her innocence is the catalyst to him realising the First Order are the villains.

Advertisement

That's far, far more believable as a trigger for his moment of realisation.

10. The Black Sleep Of Kali - Indiana Jones And The Temple Of Doom

LucasFilm

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

When Indiana Jones is taken prisoner and put under the Black Sleep Of Kali, Short Round somehow miraculously knows that the only way to get him out of his trance is to wave his flaming torch at him. That's some incredible foresight, given we don't see Short Round receive any of the necessary information to enact this plan, and can only assume he was legitimately trying to burn Indy.

The Deleted Scene:

Advertisement

There was actually a deleted scene set during Short Round's imprisonment, when he witnessed a Thuggee guard set aflame when a fissure spurts lava up out of the ground and is freed from the Black Sleep. So, that's how the resourceful little tyke worked it out.

Though there's no actual footage of this deleted scene, it definitely existed for a while, and a single shot exists showing the guard on fire.

Advertisement
Paramount Pictures

9. Boromir's Not A Bad Guy - The Lord Of The Rings

New Line Cinema

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

Though there's a rich thread in Lord Of The Rings suggesting that JRR Tolkein was a self-hating human (since he extols the evils of the world of Men lots), it's still slightly confusing that he paints Boromir to be a total dick, only to have him redeem himself heroically before death.

It's a nice moment, but up until that face-turn to protect the Hobbits, he just appears to be a bit of a grumpy sod who is easily led by the Ring's influence. It never quite sits well.

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

There was supposed to be a flash-back scene in The Two Towers that explained Boromir's whole motivation - and extended his father's malevolence in the process. The scene showed Boromir and Faramir celebrating a victory when their father Denethor comes to tell them about the Council at Rivendell and the One Ring, and to instruct Boromir to get the ring for Gondor.

Advertisement

That's why he's the way he is - he's driven by his father's corrupting will and his hope to protect Gondor and his people, and while he initially flatly refuses, he quickly changes his tune (though it's shown to be all in Gondor's honour).

Advertisement

8. What Octopus? - The Goonies

Warner Bros.

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

Right at the end of the movie, as The Goonies are celebrating their victory over the Fratellis and escape from certain death, they are interviewed by some gathered journalists. For some reason, during his interview, Data mentions that "the octopus was scary".

Perhaps because he'd been under so much pressure and through a lot of emotion, everyone just seemed to shrug it off. But what octopus, Data? WHAT OCTOPUS?!

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

Initially, there was a set-piece within the cave that included possibly the worst rubber octopus in the history of cinema. It actually made it into the initial TV version, but it was cut from all the others, making Data seem like he'd had some sort of catastrophic break from reality.

Advertisement

Watching the scene is all the justification needed for why it was cut...

Advertisement

7. The Ghost Ship - The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Universal

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

In the under-appreciated Jurassic Park sequel, the ship ferrying the T-Rex to San Diego, where it will meet up with its injured baby and become the centre-piece of the world's most ridiculous idea for a theme park - Jurassic Park San Diego, crashes into the dock. Everyone is dead, including the people hiding in the parts of the ship that are definitely too small for a T-Rex to navigate.

How the hell did the T-Rex manage to kill them all off and then lock itself back in the cargo hold?

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

The scene that should have explained this whole moment was deleted from the original script and never filmed, which makes the fact that it left a gaping plot hole all the more idiotic.

Advertisement

In that early version, the ship was also ferrying a pod of velociraptors, who escaped and butchered the crew - including those in the control room. Which makes infinitely more sense.

6. Biff's Pain - Back To The Future Part II

Universal

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

In the excellent dystopian sequel to Back To The Future - which seems to be turning into the actual real-life world - Marty McFly unwittingly hands the keys to the world's destruction to Biff Tannen when he leaves not only a time machine but also the sports almanac in his reach.

He duly goes back in time and changes the past and returns to the exact same point in 2015 (creating a paradox that makes no sense). Weirdly though, he gets out of the time machine as if he's been kicked in the testicles - hunched over and in clear discomfort. Nothing more is said of it and he's never seen again.

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

The film actually initially showed some awareness of the issues of the paradox, as Biff's pain would have been explained by him fading out of existence in the future timeline. The deleted scene in question showed him literally disintegrating, as he'd been killed off in 1996 by Lorraine when she discovered he killed George (according to the official BTTF FAQ).

Advertisement

Robert Zemeckis revealed that it was cut because it was simply too confusing:

Advertisement
"...we actually filmed him falling onto the street and vanishing, and we previewed the movie this way. However, the vast majority of the audience did not understand it, so we decided to cut it out, leaving the answer ambiguous, and subject to various interpretations — besides the above explanation, you can believe that Old Biff had a heart attack from the shock of time travel of from flying the car, or from something that happened to him in 1955."

5. The Mac OS/Alien Mothership Debacle - Independence Day

20th Century Fox

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

It's pretty infamous by now, but how did David Levinson use Mac OS 7.6 to upload a virus to an alien mothership? The compatibility issues alone are staggering, considering you can't even get Android and iOS to play nice most of the time.

The Deleted Scene:

Advertisement

Levinson's virus was not an accidental discovery or a hack that came out of nowhere. In the original cut of the movie, he actually gets taken to see one of the alien crafts inside Area 51 by Dr. Brakish Okun, where they discuss the technology and David seemingly breaks their technological encryption (based on the same sequential reference point he used to decipher the countdown).

In this case, the deleted scene was actually the right cut to make, because it's horribly boring and kills the pace of the movie. It's just a shame that the whole plot point would then go on to become some sort of flag-bearer for idiotic movie plot-holes for decades.

Advertisement

The scene can be seen from the 05:58 point in this compilation...

Advertisement

4. The Submarine Conundrum - Raiders Of The Lost Ark

LucasFilm

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

He might be something of a superhero, but there's no way Indiana Jones could have clung onto a submarine underwater for the entire time he manages to in Raiders Of The Lost Ark. He would have been thrown off or drowned were it not for the unsatisfying explanation of his impenetrable plot armour.

The Deleted Scene:

Advertisement

Actually, he didn't just hold his breath for a superhuman amount of time. In Lawrence's Kasdan's original script, the submarine is only submerged to the point that its periscope sticks out of the water, which Indy clings to and then lashes himself to with his whip.

As any U-Boat historian would tell you, most of the time the vessels didn't submerge most of the time anyway, as their very design meant they were suited more to being on the surface.

Advertisement

3. The Most Expensive Day-Off Ever - Ferris Bueller's Day Off

Paramount Pictures

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

How on Earth did Ferris Bueller, a lay-about teenager who openly expresses the fact that he has no money at the start of his film, afford to go to a baseball game, a fancy restaurant and a museum without a dime to his name on his infamous day off?

Did he just steal it?

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

Yep, he stole it.

Advertisement

Because the earlier version of Ferris Bueller didn't realise that he had to be a loveable scamp and not a complete dick, there was initially a scene in there that showed Ferris discovering where his father keeps his precious bonds and then stealing them to pay for his good times.

Presumably, it was cut because it made Ferris look less like a hero and more like an ungrateful hooligan who audiences wouldn't have been able to get behind at all.

Advertisement

2. Lex Luthor's Weirdness - Batman v Superman

Warner Bros.

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

At the end of Batman v Superman, Lex Luthor is thrown into prison, but has a final barb for the visiting Batman that “the bell cannot be unrung. He’s hungry. He’s found us and he’s coming!”

Two things were unclear in this cut: firstly, why he was even in prison, and then who the hell he was talking about.

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

As the Ultimate Edition of Batman v Superman revealed later, Luthor was captured back inside the Kryptonian scout ship seemingly in communication with Steppenwolf - informing him of the presence of the Mother Boxes on Earth.

Advertisement

It's short, but it explained Luthor's final monologue to Batman, even if it posed a lot of questions in itself (like how he knew what Steppenwolf's phone number was, for instance).

Advertisement

1. Obi Wan Kenobi's Lies

Lucasfilm

The Confusing Moment:

Advertisement

Obi-Wan Kenobi is a big fat liar who consciously kept the truth from Luke Skywalker about his parents and then pretended to get away with it in Return Of The Jedi by claiming it was true "from a certain point of view" when really it wasn't.

This wasn't the only time Obi-Wan lied, but it was probably the most costly to Luke, and it sort of made the old man look like a bit of a dick.

Advertisement

The Deleted Scene:

Rejoice, Kenobites, for it wasn't his fault. In a deleted scene from Return Of The Jedi, it turned out that it was on Yoda's instruction that Obi-Wan hid the truth. An excised line from Yoda's dying scene confirmed as much:

Advertisement
"Obi-Wan would have told you long ago if I'd let him."

So maybe start blaming the little green guy for the deception, yeah?

Advertisement

Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.