12 Most Underrated Sci-Fi Movie Remakes Ever

The less loved Godzilla! The forgotten Kong! The Judge Dredd that isn't laughably awful!

By Cathal Gunning /

Alright look, no one likes remakes. We get it!

Advertisement

After all, remember when Halloween helmer John Carpenter tried to escape the grimy world of teenage chillers by remaking that much-loved fifties sci-fi classic The Thing From Another World?

The remake he directed in 1982 flopped hard at the box office, proving viewers never want to see classic sci-fi reheated for a new generation, and—wait hang on, the eighties remake of The Thing is roundly beloved for being a genius retelling of the original story. Harsher, darker, and smarter than its fifties inspiration, the film is widely considered a masterpiece of sci-fi horror and one of the genre’s most enduring influences.

Okay fine, so that’s one good remake. But what about say, Cronenberg’s eighties remake of the classic fifties sci-fi The Fly? Oh right, that’s also considered far superior to the original, and is also an undeniable masterpiece adored by critics and audiences alike, which has proven almost as influential as Carpenter’s flick.

Huh. We’re starting to think some sci-fi remakes might actually not be so bad. Okay, so there was admittedly a string of woeful Paul Verhoeven remakes circa 2012 which put us all off the idea of revisiting classic sci-fi. But that’s because Verhoeven and PG-13 ratings go together like Tom Hooper and felines.

So to prove a point, we’ve assembled a list of sci-fi remakes often written off by critics which are actually—whisper it—pretty decent.

12. Godzilla

Yes, alright, so Roland Emmerich’s 1998 iteration of Godzilla is rightly roasted for its less-than-convincing CGI, and there are times when the titular city-eater looks like he might be unintentionally smirking at the camera due to the limitations of the yet-to-be-perfected technology. But the ambitious monster movie was met with critical drubbing upon its 1998 release, with most complaining that the film took the “dumb fun” approach of the director’s earlier Independence Day too far and left audiences with a film too silly to take seriously.

Advertisement

Then 2014 brought us Gareth Edward’s Godzilla, and audiences were shown just how self-serious a creature feature could be. The Monsters director offered a more portentous take on the material, but it’s hard not to think of Roland Emmerich’s comment about how Godzilla was his most popular film amongst children when watching the darker 2010’s reboot.

The Matthew Broderick starring flick is quicker and sillier than Edward’s offering, and honestly there’s an argument to be made for its taxicab-chomping anarchy in this age of frowny, quasi-philosophical blockbusters.

11. Death Race

Start your engines folks, because we’re once again defending the controversial career of Resident Evil helmer Paul W.S Anderson (don’t worry, we tear apart Alien Vs Predator in an upcoming article). Yes, he may only be the second-best director with his name in this generation. But the Event Horizon director doesn’t deserve the hate piled on his offerings, as evidenced by the critical roasting heaped on this 2008 remake of Roger Corman’s 1975 grindhouse dystopia Death Race 2000.

Advertisement

Starring Guy Ritchie muse/ toughest Englishman alive Jason Statham, Death Race is a tense revenge flick, a gratifyingly gory and fast-paced action thriller unashamed of its R-rating, and even a pretty solid satirical indictment of reality TV culture in the twilight of Bush Jr-era America. Is it as daring as Corman’s original? Come on—no major studio will hit that level of shock value, but this remake is still worth a watch as a more mainstream remix of the same satirical targets.

10. Solaris

Well, the good news for Sex, Lies, and Videotape director Steven Soderbergh is that Stanislaw Lem, the author of the original source novel of the same name, disliked his version of Solaris as much as he disliked the original adaptation by Stalker director Andrei Tarkovsky. Technically this one is less of a direct remake and more a new reimagining of the same source material, a trippy and meditative journey through the mind of a lone space station-stationed psychologist orbiting the eponymous planet.

Advertisement

George Clooney puts in a more silent and sombre turn than usual in the central role and Cliff Martinez’s dreamy score provides a perfect aural accompaniment to the flick’s slow, strange tone. Critics and audiences were turned off by the film’s challenging ambiguity, but upon a revisit the film is as solid an exploration of this complex territory as the original Tarkovsky film, and its influence can be seen in more recent genre headf***s such as Duncan Jones’ Moon.

9. War Of The Worlds

This is a funny one, as critics weren’t actively unkind to Steven Spielberg’s War of the Worlds when it was first released in 2005—if anything, they were generous enough to overlook some pretty glaring plot holes when complimenting the flick’s propulsive action and surprisingly serious tone. Nonetheless, in the years since the flick has been written off as one of the Jaws helmer’s lesser offerings, and whilst it’s not perfect it is well worth revisiting with some historical context in mind.

Advertisement

Like the 1953 original, Spielberg’s film updates the action of the novel to the present, and in doing so produces one of the first “city under siege from faceless foes” blockbusters to be released in post 9/11 America. The film focuses less on the alien invaders and the military personnel fighting them and more on a single family, reducing the terror to a domestic sphere and reflecting the international fear of mass attacks effecting civilians curing the so-called War on Terror. It’s an effective and unsettling portal back to the paranoia of post-9/11 America, and for that alone the film is worth checking out.

8. The Wolfman

Long before the much-maligned Dark Universe was laughed out of theatres with Tom Cruise’s mega-budget version of The Mummy (only to be quickly rehabilitated with Leigh Wannell’s tense Elizabeth Moss vehicle The Invisible Man), Mighty Joe Young helmer Joe Johnson had offered us an early glimpse of the potential that big budget, gory re-imaginings of the classic movie monsters held.

Advertisement

Anchored by a typically great and underrated performance from Benicio del Toro, this atmospheric chiller benefits from a foggy Victorian London setting which brings to mind the likes of From Hell and Bram Stoker’s Dracula and some suitably over-the-top melodramatic theatrics from Emily Blunt and Anthony Hopkins. The film isn’t perfect—Rick Baker perfected the werewolf transformation pre-CGI, thank you very much—but it’s an effective slice of gory, action-packed horror drama which went largely unseen despite its massive budget.

7. The Day The Earth Stood Still

2008 may have been a bit too early for this sci-fi thriller remake—as Keanu Reeves’ emotionless Klaatu informs humanity at large that they’ve made a mess of their home planet and as such their time has come, it’s surprisingly reminiscent of the doomsaying we hear from climate scientists on a regular basis these days. Sure, global warming and climate change existed earlier than a decade or so ago (despite what Trey Parker and Matt Stone thought at the time), but the urgency of this remake’s eco-apocalypse is far more relevant and resonant when revisited now.

Advertisement

The film itself isn’t the dour affairs critics wrote it off as, with some dazzling special effects and inventive ideas injected into the existing template offered by the vintage fifties original. It’s a good thing director Scott Derrickson went on to helm the hugely successful Sinister after this flick was unfairly maligned—here’s hoping his career will be smooth-sailing from hereon out. Now to take a sip of coffee and read about the status of that Dr. Strange sequel…

6. Dredd

At this stage, it’s an open secret that 2012’s intense, gritty, and sometimes surprisingly psychedelic siege thriller Dredd is one of the most often-overlooked gems in recent sci-fi blockbuster history. Playing out like a dystopian remix of the same year’s brutal The Raid, Dredd benefits Karl Urban’s best performance as the titular officer and a sharp turn from Game of Thrones’ Lena Headey as a very different sort of villainous queen.

Advertisement

But the star of the show is Alex Garland’s unrelenting screenplay, blasted through with intense action sequences and gruesome, unsparing violence, with its many surprises harkening back to the meaner R-rated sci-fi thriller of the eighties. Before winning over critics with the comparatively cerebral Annihilation and Ex Machina, Garland obliterated any memory 1994’s misjudged Stallone vehicle Judge Dredd for good with this fast-paced, vicious thriller.

Sorry, Rob Schneider.

5. Dawn Of The Dead

Yes, alright, so Zack Snyder’s propulsive remake of George A. Romero’s 1978 original does jettison that flick’s dark anti-consumerism satire in favour of some gross-out black comedy moments, and the film wasn’t the first to bring fast zombies into the mainstream—that title goes to Danny Boyle’s 2002 hit 28 Days Later.

Advertisement

But given how widely derided Snyder’s more recent cinematic outings have been, it’s hard to recall just how intense and undeniably cool this remake was when it first hit screens in 2004. Starring a pretty impressive cast including future Modern Family dad Ty Burrell and Ving Rhames, the film offers one of cinema’s most impressive opening sequences and the pace of the following film rarely lets up. Re-watch 2005’s canon, Romero-directed sequel Land of the Dead if you’re looking for a more thoughtful spin on the living dead—this one is perfect for adrenaline junkies looking for a shock of dystopian sci-fi horror action thrills.

4. Kong: Skull Island

When Kings of Summer helmer Jordan Vogt-Roberts was announced as the director for an upcoming King Kong instalment, the indie kid probably didn’t seem like the most obvious choice for the action-packed reboot. But as his storied personal life proves (check out GQ’s fascinating into his near fatal assault for more), the director is no stranger to the wild side of life.

Advertisement

And 2017’s Kong Skull Island did an incredible job of showcasing the director’s more un-restrained side, eschewing the typical melodrama of the story in favour of an intense and unrelenting thrill ride. With an eclectic cast including Brie Larson and John C Reilly and a touch of humour to lighten its intense action sequences, Skull Island may have little in common with the flicks it is ostensibly remaking but it serves as an impressive calling card for the now A-list Hollywood director to prove his action chops.

Not that, you know, a handful of kids having a nostalgic summer in the woods wasn’t enough to prove how awesome his action skills were.

3. The Thing

Okay, before anyone comes for our heads—it’s not as good as Carpenter’s original (well, Carpenter’s remake, but the film which this one is clearly meant to be remaking). With that out of the way, is this Mary Elizabeth Winstead starring action horror sci-fi thriller really as flat and lifeless as critics claimed upon its 2011 release?

Advertisement

Or is it possible that, in all of the “practical effects vs CGI”, we all missed out on a pretty solid, if admittedly far from superior, body-swapping chiller?

The flick boasts a pretty solid cast including a typically stoic Joel Edgerton and its CGI assisted transformations may be disappointingly lifeless, but for the opening half of the film their limited onscreen exposure means that a nicely creepy atmosphere is developed. And yes, the denouement may go over the top in its explanations of the enigmatic titular Thing, but Winstead makes for a resilient and likeable heroine and a few gory sequences make this one worth a watch.

Also, it is technically a prequel, so the whole “not as good” argument isn’t totally fair here.

2. Body Snatchers

To clarify, we don’t mean that 1978’s super bleak and well-regarded re-imagining of 1956’s Invasion of the Body Snatchers is an underrated remake. Yes, the Donald Sutherland-starring seventies version does a great job of updating the somewhat corny fifties original, dropping the film noir style narration in favour of a more realistic and gritty take on the material. But it’s pretty well-loved critically speaking, so not great material for this list.

Advertisement

The Driller Killer helmer Abel Ferrara’s gorier 1993 revisiting of this material, however, is rarely mentioned in discussions of the definitive screen portrayals of pod people, and the more horror-oriented retelling deserves its own moment in the spotlight. Critics wrote the film off as an emotionless re-tread, but by transporting the action to a military base Ferrara adds a dark satirical edge to proceedings and elevates the material to darker, grittier territory than either of his cinematic predecessors.

Add in an ensemble cast including R Lee Erney, Meg Tilly, and Forest Whitaker, and you’ve got a wildly underrated iteration of the iconic source material.

1. The Blob

It’s rare to see the name Chuck Russell amongst the best genre directors out there, but the helmer spent the eighties and nineties producing solid, often exceptional flicks to little fanfare, and many of his offerings have gone on to become fondly remembered cult classics in their own regard. Maybe he’s no Wes Craven, but there’s a case to be made that the man who brought us Nightmare on Elm Street 3 Dream Warriors and The Mask should be as well-remembered as say, Joe Dante—or at very least John Landis.

Advertisement

Just look at his gory, gruesome late eighties remake of infamous fifties vintage sci-fi The Blob. This R-rated body horror takes a corny original suitable for family viewing and stoned riffing and turns it into an ultraviolent, deeply creepy Cronenbergian horrorshow. Reimagining the eponymous Blob as a mass consuming the denizens of a small American suburb piece by painful piece, the film is a blatant influence on James Gunn’s later Slither, and remains criminally underrated amongst splatter flick aficionados.

Advertisement